← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/205/2023allowed

Nirdosh Kumar v. Punjab And Haryana High Court, Chd. And ORS.

2023-10-19Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan8 pages



                  



           

   

   

       ! "          #      

   

       ! $           %     

   

       ! 

!"!#$!%&'( ) ) !*+%!%&'( ,) ) ( - ) .).)./    -.) .

0

/  & '(

  ) *  +  ,-"./-"."$ '0

(

1  ) * +  ,-$.-"."$ '( (

) * +  ,-234-"."$ '0  ) * +    55555 ).).1'%21314+15)  *        +          +   , (  %   .3.""."$ 7  7 

LPA-205, 310 & 476-2023 (O&M) 2- * 8-$39 ::: "44:"$93-".".  )707 )   + * +7*  ;   *   +  *+* )    7 *   +7   *  6 +   *+  *   +      +( (*(     

 + 7 * "  , (  %  7  +   *    7  ** 

 +* + 

 *

   *   7       *      )  +  *  ++ ) *+* )+ * - ++7  *     7 +   *6 * - ++  + *     7       ; 7    7  ) 7 ,( %  $    +    0 7     

7      7     $..3".97    +**   + * 7 +  $$)*  +( (*(      

 +

   * 6 * - ++

* + )   <    :./".3 ;

 - 7 "3.4".3      +       +  *  7 7"-$.   "3.4".3 7 ;   )  

* * =;- )* 2/ & >2  

< < +*    *  ++ "3.4".3  &- /    

    +  *     )* +

?

 

"     $.   +   

LPA-205, 310 & 476-2023 (O&M) 3- "3.4".3  7)      ;  +  

*

*  =;-()*  @ ) =     &- 

* *.   )  *

  "=;-()*    +  <    +* )* $   $A 7;  .  +  *     7 0   @ )  ? ( @ ) ?    ?1   6  +     )   

 7       *  * B 2 < +* +   #  +1*   +    (**  < )    +   * C A)   

)    +**     + *    8   *

  ((   4 )+   +   +  

          * +   * - ++   "3.4".3      2      3  )  *   

 * +  +7 ;

     <  +    9  )   * 

  * )  +       *  *  7   9

& >9   * 

  * )  +   + # =   * ?  *     

     *   *      7  B / (    ""  )     

 +  *  *  

*   +*  +    +    * *  

 < 

 ""  &

LPA-205, 310 & 476-2023 (O&M) 4- >"" 6  

  +   *      +  *   *

 7      )   

*  

 +    *   *      + + 

  *   )* 

    + D+  )+*         +   +   *   *

 +   *   + +  +   *   ?

 * 

  ** 7

    *  6  *

   *    *  

  +   *    ?+  

) * +   )*-) D+  

) * +   + +  *   * *     * 

 < 

7*  B 4   * ,( %  *  + * *   + +  +  **  +*  + *  

 *  ,( % D * 8-$39- ".".7  *   7- )**   + + 7   )* 7 

*  +   * +*   *   +  *  +

!

  * 7 )  ; 7  

6  "".".". & > * +     """.". A   0  +    ' 0     0  *+  7) +   *   + * +*     -

)**     7 * 

)*  + +  +     *   - )**

 +

)7  )*   )     *    +    D )  +    *

 +   * +* *        

LPA-205, 310 & 476-2023 (O&M) 5-  ; +          *   ; 6 

**  *        )             +  ;      "".".""".".+ 

*     +   *    *   + *  0

  )  * +  B 3           D    *    < +   "3)** )+  @ 7 7 7* * ) 0 + +  D7 +   *)   .2.3"."$   ")** +4 )** 7 )    7    *    )     7      

*  *

7   ++  *    +    !

 7 * *

 ++)+*+ +* 6 ++) +(       E++*  (* #  ,     +  +*     ) 9      * *       

 ; &446221'%17")21+#81'55  

 .   7   *   , (  %      ) 7 *    * *    * )7     *  + ) 6 ; # 

 

    +*   7   ) ) 

      *

       )   <  *+*  7      * 

*+* D +    * *

 

LPA-205, 310 & 476-2023 (O&M) 67

 7     7  *  

 +    +; : D   *      *         

 +   +   *     < +*   7 *

   D 7    +*         *

 *+*   + + +   *  + 7  **  + )    6 ; 

 ; *    +



  + +7           *           +  *  !)  ) # 



 & >36   7  +  *  +     

 < +*    +;+ 

    

  *

  * +   *    

 ;

 )    *  6 * ;      +  <  < +*    +; 6      

     * *

 *+*    0

 (    ) +   + +  )   7

  * *

 *+* )      * 6    *      + + +   +* < +*  * + 0 *    +  + +  )  #   +*  +*   * ;    +



  + +7       *     + *  =) +*  +    



  + +  *

 

*  +* B . ()7 +  7 *  + 180981# +:#&617")!42+.9;&#%+'1<!.!#$+*!".!4!*<+&'&1#%5 

.   7   7      ! )   * 7

LPA-205, 310 & 476-2023 (O&M) 7-

 E1*+*+ * - ++

  *   *  ( )7     0  2!!#!'%!# .+'=2

14+314 7")

.5   

 .   7   7   7     + 6 7      *  *+*   + + F 

    *  

*    0  )     < +*   *  )  *     *   <  *+*   + +

 

 < +*    D 7  **    *  )*  7 )

  -  *  +< +*  " D &&%&#>&#1<+&'&?'%+17") +8:2+85 , . ,   +  7  

7   7   ++ *+* +;*    *  7 *   *   ) + +     7  *  *        # 



 $ ( )7 7    0    -  1*   ,-::-".:  

 

!

"# # # $* "2.$"."$ 7 7  *   

  *  < +*        *  * - ++ =1@*+*

7

 <    7  

 7 + *    +  **    + ,( % 7

 6 *7    2 D

**  * 7 + *     * 7    + +   

LPA-205, 310 & 476-2023 (O&M) 8- < +*      ) 0 7  *       +* *  + *+*  7 * 

      +  *     D       *  +   7 7   +"3-$.   "3.4".3   +             7

 +* 6     * + 

         <   + 

    A)  7 7     * +     +  * 7 *    <   +  -

 < +*  +  * - ++7   *  / D

**  * 7 + *         7 + +        + (  (* (                7) 

*    + * * 0   4     7     )-     +     7  +  70  +       *      + ).)./    

,) )    

0

/   #          0 ? & G 8  ! &