High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/2482/2017disposed of

Ram Gopal Gupta v. M/S Avon Steel And ANR

2025-10-30Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel3 pages

!1 !1 !1 !1

' & ' & ' & ' &A A A A *

4444A A A AC 0 C

D!!!!%#

;%$

!"#

!"# ####'

%% 4 #-/+/#-8$*< '

%% 4 #-/+/#-8$*< # *%$ # *%$ # *%$ # *%$ D! % #-%#

! % #-%#

& :(

! ' :(

! ''

(

( ====

$% %# &

$!+*/ *%>'*$4-"

$!;/ * 4-". . %,$ ,$ *%%# ! #%,$$% #-%# ! ==== '

( ( ( (4! 4! 4! 4!2 $3 2 $3 2 $3 2 $3 )! *% + # /"% $9%$ - -% /# *% $% %# % $%- 4

& ? / 4 *%$%,$%4 $% % %.

, 9 $9%- *% $% %#

% 9 >/#-9 +% 6%- #- *% 7 -8%# - %- )@!A1!A)0 %- +9 '

+ /"/ /# -/./ 8/ $ %4 *49>/#-9+% % / /-%/# *%/# %$% ,7

/.%!E #86/ *#%4# /. /#,$8$# ,%"%* +%%# $%,%$$%- #-%$'%.

/#0123 $!

!!4)50 ! *"% *%$- %$#%- . % ,$ *% %# #- *"% %$ *%%$+> %%#8 *! ! %,$% $.%%-/#8 *%$

*% /. /# 2,$ 8$# , %./% "% %3%#%$/

*%$%,4/ 6 -+% / $%,%$ *%$% %/# 7 -8%# %- +9 */ /#

1@ 1@ 1@ 1@AC AC AC AC C

7 B $ " ! 7%#-%$ & A

7 B $ " ! 7%#-%$ & A AC& &A050A AC& &A050A AC& &A050A AC& &A050A 6*%$%/#4 46* */%$%9/#8 # *%-/.

, %#:+%'

$%% /#

!1 !1 !1 !1

,A)0 -2- %% %% %% %% /##./" !!

/##./" !!

/##./" !!## %>$# ## %>$# ## %>$# ## %>$# # .!AC'1A&AC23 # .!AC'1A&AC23 # .!AC'1A&AC23 # .!AC'1A&AC23 3333

2$/

2$/ //#3A1 //#3A1 //#3A1 //#3A14* *%- # %8/# #$-%$,.F

/# $.

.%%-/#8 #-%$ '%.

/# )1 , *% %8 /+% # %# .

)11)$%, ,%$$%-+9 *%./## 4, $%96/ */# *% $"/%6, $"/ '%.

/# 0 , $!

!!) , ''4 A! */ 7 -/./ %# #./ / #6 $%-/. # *%/# %$ $$% /"% #-%$ #-/#8 4,$ $

*% $ % , ./# #-%$ '

/# )1 , *% %8 /+% # %# .

4 )11)4 *% ./## / %#. %- 6/ */# %G# /"% %-%,/#/ /#,H"/.

/: -%/#% %-/# *%$!

!!4)50''4 A! # %F %# 94 *% ./## / # .# $/#%- $% $/# #8%# $.%- $%, %%>/#8 %./ /%"% % #-%$'%.

/# # 0123, ,$!

!!4)50)523,''

'4A!*/ #-%$ .$%-

*% .

.%#-+/ ,$"/ '%.

/#0$!

!!)''$% /#*%$%# 9 9+$-%$#-$%..- /#86*%#7 %-6/ * .$ /"%9 #$$6%$ .#,/#% , '%.

/# 0123 , $!

!!4 )50)52 23,''4A46*/.*#- - % *%$.

$%%# , %./ %"% ,$ *% /8* ,$ # % 8/# # .F

/# ./#

. %! 6%"%$4 -%# $ /#8 $, #- ./ %# "%$$.*/# #8 $/#./% , 7

/.% #- - -% %$/# /# $%. -% %$% $.%- $ %.*#/./ /% ,$ %./ /#8

*% + # /"% -7 -/. /# ,

*%. %4

*/ 4/# %-, $/ 9-/ / /#8 *%%#

%.*#/. /#,/$/ 947 -/./ 9 $%%8 *%%4#86/ * ..# #9/#8/. /#2 34 *%.#.% %$#%-'% /# ! ! $8I/#"/%6, *%-/.

, *%#:+%'

$%% /# #

%% % /##./

/##./ % /##./

/##./2 $3

*%$# #.%%# , */

!1 !1 !1 !1

,A)0 -3- /# 7

7 B $ $ $ $ 2 $3I *% $% %# %4 #8 6/ * ..#9/#8 8 /. / #2 34/ -/ %-, *%$% #-%$ $& 2/3 *%$% %# %4#86/ *..#9/#8/. /#2 34 / $%/

% *% %$#%- '% /#

-8%4 %*8$* '*/+ 6/ * -/$%.

$% *% % *"/#8 +% %%# ,/%- #-%$ '%.

/# 0 , $!

!!4 ) )50'%.

/# ) , ''4 A A! *% /- %$#%- '% /# -8% 9%#

*%% */ %, $ /8#/ # *%$ , .% %# 7 $/ -/.

/#,$/ -/ 4 %$6! 2//3 %%-% .$/,9 * # -%"%- /# %$/ ,

*%% #86/ *.

..#9/#8/. /#2 3I#-

*% % / %, %#,$.# /-%$ /#, *%.#.%$#%-%$#%-'% /# 4 6 6*/.* * /#- +/ +9 -7 -/.

. *% % 6/ *

/#8 8 /#, %#.%- -+9#9+ %$" /#-%*%$%/ /#+"% 2///3 *% %8/ $9/ -/$%.

% %#-4%G%-/ / 94 *%.% % $%.$- , *% $% %# % 2/#. -/# #8 *% %$+>3 *% /- %$#%-'% % /# -8%! A A A A * H$7:

4A 4A 4A 4AC 2'

( '

(3 *%$ %>/#8$% #%-& J* % J* *%$ %$ +%& %