State Of Haryana v. Narender

  
 

      
   

   !

"

"#$% & '

())*+, '" -#&./.  &#'0#&  ( #.)$'0#'"   12 3


3 3  42 3


  


&#.#'"

 &35 )+*66 &7 * 00+"+$'

*08$, "##'#& *   & '

3 &33

&$9 08$, "#%$&"9#&#.)$'0#'"3

 
 3 9#+'."

'" "+$'/'0#& #,"+$':;:<&  .=##'%+*#0="9# "

"#$% & '

.##>+'6*# 8#"$%+*#

,,$?) '+'6

))#

+'."

,@/+""

$% &#.)$'0#'"  8+0# +?)/6'#0 A/06?#'" 0 "#0 B33 ) ..#0="9#*# &'#000+"+$'

#..+$'./06# 

*7 *3
''/".9#**  &$/'03:)3?3 $':33 "9# )&$.#,/"&+C )&#.#'"#0 ' "+$' +' "9# $*+,# "

"+$' "9 " .9# 7 6#0 =$/"  # &. '0 ?

&&+#0 +' 8+** 6# ** *)/&3  ' "9 " 8#& 0   .9# *$'6 7+"9 9#& ,9+*0&#' '

?#* '.9/ '0##"

7 ..*##)+'6$'"9#&$$%"$)3
' "9#'+69"9$/&. 79#'.9#, ?#0$7'%$&/&+'

**$% ./00#' "9#&#.)$'0#'" ))# &#0 '0."$$0+'%&$'"$%9#&3 # 6 66#0 9#& ?$/"9 '0 ."

&"#0 ?+.=#9 8+'6 7+"9 9#&3 9#&#.)$'0#'""+#09#&9 '0. '0?$/"97+"9,9/''+3 9#

 &#.+."#0 =/"7 .'$".) &#03
'A/&+#.7#&#+'%*+,"#0"$9#& 7+"9 0 '0 '0 & )# 7 . ,$??+""#0 /)$' 9#& = "9# &#.)$'0#'"/'0#&"9&# ""9 "+', .#"9#?

""#&+.&#)$&"#0 "$ '$'# 9#7$/*00#."&$9#&*+%#=0#% ?+'69#&3 ' "9# = .+. $% =$8# +'%$&?

 %$&?

.&#6+."#&#03
'8#."+6 "+$'7 .,$??#',#03 "

"#?#'". $%&#*#8 '"7+"'#..#.7#&# *.$&#,$&0#039#."

"#?#'"$% )&$.#,/"&+C /'0#& #,"+$' ! &  7 . &#,$&0#03  9# &#.)$'0#'" 7 &&#."#03  +. 0+.,*$./&# ."

"#?#'" 7 &#,$&0#03 ',$?)*#"+$'$%+'8#."+6 "+$' %+'

*&#)$&"/'0#&

#,"+$' : &  7 . )&#.#'"#0 %$& )&$.#,/"+'6 "9# &#.)$'0#'"/'0#& #,"+$'.:: : :! !
=#%$&#"9# &#   6+."& "#3   ' ,$??+"?#'" $% "9# , .#  9# 7 ,9 &6#.9##"#0 ../,93  ' ))& +.

* $% #8+0#',# '0 9# &+'6 =$"9 "9# .+0#.  "9# "&+ * $/&" 0+0 '$" %+'0 +".#*% ,$'8+',#0 7+"9 "9# )&$.#,/"+$' , .# '0 "9/. ,@/+""#0 "9# &#.)$'0#'" 8+0# +?)/6'#0A/06?#'"0 "#0B333 2# &'#0 ,$/'.#* %$& "9# '" ,$'"#'0#0 "9 " "9#"&+ *$/&"9 .'$" ))&#,+ "#0"9#)&$.#,/"+$'#8+0#',# +'  )&$.)#,"+8# ?

''#& '0 9 . 7&$'6* ,@/+""#0 "9# &#.)$'0#'"39#$,/* &8#&.+$'+'+".#'"+&#"7 .,$'.+."#'" 7+"9"9#?#0+, *#8+0#',#3 %"#& 6+8+'6 $/& "9$/69"%/* ,$'.+0#& "+$' "$ "9# ./=?+..+$'.$%*# &'#0,$/'.#*%$&"9# '" 7#%+'0"9#

)&#.#'" "+$' ,$?)*#"#* ?#&+"*#.. %$& "9# &# .$'. "$ %$**$73 ;+<  )#&/.

* $% "9# &#,$&0 .9$7. "9 " D )&$.#,/"&+C >#)" $' ,9 '6+'6 9#& ."

"#?#'" "+?#

'0 +'9 8+'6'$&#6 &0%$&"&/"93#.+0#."9# ,$?)* +'" 0 "#0 :33 +'." &#.)$'0#'"  9#& ."

"#?#'" /'0#& #,"+$' ! &  7 *.$ 6$"&#,$&0#0$'3!3=#%$&#"9#*# &'#0
** @  6+."& "# +'79+,9 .9#"#."+%+#0"9 ".9# *$'6 7+"99#&"7$,9+*0&#' =#.+0#.%$/&,9+*0&#'$%9#& .+."#&+'* 7 7 . .*##)+'6 $' "9# &$$% "$)3 $7#8#&  "9# )&#.#',# $% %$/& ,9+*0&#' $% 9#& .+."#&+'* 7+.?+..+'6+'9#& %$&#.

+0,$?)* +'"3 ;++< ,,$&0+'6 "$ 9#& ."

"#?#'" /'0#& #,"+$' ! &   )&$.#,/"&+C )/.9#0 = &#.)$'0#'" '0 .9# %#** 0$7'3  #& 9# 0 9 0 = '6#0 +'." "9# =#03  ' &#,#+)" $% +'A/&+#.  .9# =#, ?# /',$'.,+$/.3 $7#8#& 

D &3

'"$.9 5/?

& 79$ ,$'0/,"#0 "9# ?#0+,$ *#6 * #C ?+'

"+$' $% "9# )&$.#,/"&+C 0+0 '$" %+'0

' +'A/& $' 9#& 9# 03   9/.  "9# ?#0+, #8+0#',# =#*+#. $,/* & 8#&.+$' $% )&$.#,/"&+C3

 ;+++< 9# )&$.#,/"&+C +.  ?

&&+#0 7$?

'3 D9#' .9# , ?# 0$7' %$& /&+'

.9# %$/'0 &#.)$'0#'")&#.#'"+'9#&9$/.# '0,$'.#@/#'"* & +.#09/# '0,&3 0.9#& +.#0 '9/# '0 ,&  "9#' 9#& 8$+,# 7$/*0 9 8# &# ,9#0 "9# '#+69=$/&;.< $& " *# ." "9# % ?+* ?#?=#&. $& "9#,9+*0&#'.*##)+'6$'"9#&$$%"$)39#&#+.'$ +'0#)#'0#'",$&&$=$& "+$'"$"9#0#)$.+"+$'$%"9# )&$.#,/"&+C3
"+.7#**.#""*#0"9 ""9#$/&".9$/*0 =#.*$7"$ ,"$'"9#0#)$.+"+$'$%./,9 7+"'#..

'0 '$&?

**  +" ?/." *$$> %$& ,$&&$=$& "+$' "$ ./,9#8+0#',#3 **"9#% ,". '0,+&,/?."

',#. 0+.,&#) ',+#. '0 "9# $=.#&8 "+$'. ?

0# = "9# "&+ * $/&" *# 0 "$ "9# +'%#&#',# "9 " "9# )&$.#,/"+$' , .# +' ** )&$= =+*+"+#. +. % *.#3
' 8+#7 $% "9# %$&#.

+0 0+.,/..+$'  7# %+'0 '$ ?#&+"+'"9#)&#.#'" "+$' '0 "9#&#%$&# "9#.

?#+. 9#&#=0+.?+..#032# 8#"$ ))# *+.0#,*+'#03 ;3 3<  ;

 
<       ! 5