M/S Divyajot Rolls Corporation And ANR v. M/S Avon Steel And ANR




  


  


  


 



         
 
 
 
          AC@@ C@@ C@@ C@@A1@/3 
+
- 
+
- 
+
- 
+
-@ @ @ @ ) ) ) )  

 

 

  %%%%@ @ @ @C 3 C         







!!"#"

$% $&

!!"#"

$% $&

!!"#"

$% $&

!!"#"

$% $& '&$( ")* '&$( ")* '&$( ")* '&$( ")* $ ),"

$ ),"

$ ),"

$ )," D##,!!

##,!!

##,!!

##,!!

$  ;,"0 ;,"0 ;,"0 ;,"0 $ $ $ $ $+ ,,!% $&'$&( ")*

$+ ,,!% $&'$&( ")*

$+ ,,!% $&'$&( ")*

$+ ,,!% $&'$&( ")*

$ ),"

$ ),"

$ ),"

$ )," D ,#$&,$  ,#$&,$  ,#$&,$  ,#$&,$      -  :.  +
  :.  +
  :.  +
  :.  +
+

+

+

+

 .

 .

 .

 . <<<<

",,$ - "')),=+) "8 %& ";) !0# %&2 ,1" 1" ), ##,!!

$  $,1"",#$&,$  <<<< +  +  +  +   .

 .

 .

 .% % % %5 "

!6 5 "

!6 5 "

!6 5 "

!6 / ), 0' $ , #"

," 8 &, $ ), #",,$  ! ", &% )0- >
 % ),",1",% 8  ",#, ,2 10!!

 #"

,& )  ), #",,$

! 8

 =$&!

 ',

!!9,& $& 0&(8,$  & ,& /?@4@/3 # ,& '

 +0' $ ! 0&2 !  ( "

,% 8!)%8

=$&!

',,   &,$ ),$ ,", 1 0 2,E !$(9 ) $ $ #!2 $1"("

$ 1!, ,) 

!',,$ #",1,"",&0$&,"+,2 $3456 " %/73 
 ) , ), "& !, "$,& 20$ ,! 1" ), ##,!!

$  $& ) , #,"0,& ) ),# #,"A'= 8,!,$( )  ,1", #"2,,&$(  ), ), $ 51" ("

$  1 #,2 !!,

,  !6 !$8,"  ),",1% 90!&', ## , ",1," ),", ,$  0&(8,$  # ,& '

 ) ) 0"  $  AA4?

4?

4?

4?A@C @C @C @C C  !,&

 B08 " 

,$&," - @

 B08 " 

,$&," - @

 B08 " 

,$&," - @

 B08 " 

,$&," - @ @C- -@373@ @C- -@373@ @C- -@373@ @C- -@373@ 9),",$% ) 0" %9) )!,",!

$(0#$ ),&2 1 ), ,$:'!,+0#",8,0" $    

A    C@@ C@@ C@@ C@@A1@/3 1@/3 -2- ,!, 08 ,!, 08 ,!, 08 ,!, 08 8 $ $2 ! 8 $ $2 ! 8 $ $2 ! 8 $ $2 !$ ,= "

$ ,= "

$ ,= "

$ ,= "

$ 2@C
+4@-@C56 $ 2@C
+4@-@C56 $ 2@C
+4@-@C56 $ 2@C
+4@-@C56 6666

5"

5"

5"

5" 8$ !6@4 8$ !6@4 8$ !6@4 8$ !6@4%) ),!& ) $ #, ! ( $  $"&,"1 2F0 !

! $  #"2 2,,&$( 0$&," +,2 $ /4 1 ) ), ,(  '!,
$ "08,$  2 % /44/#",1 1,"",&'

 ),28#!

$ $ %1 !! F0 ",!

9 )$ ),#0",91 #"  +,2 $ 3 1 " / 1 ++% @ ) 0&2 !

! ,$0$2  $9 #",&2 ,&0#$ ),$ ,"

"#", ,0$&," $&$( ) %1"

), #0"# , 1  28#!

$  0$&," + ,2 $ /4 1 ), ,(  '!,
$ "08,$ $  2 % /44/% ), 28#!

$ $   ,$28# ,& 9 )$ ), ,G# $, ,&,1$ $1H2 8: &,!$,

,&$ )," %/73++% @  $,F0,$ !

% ), 28#!

$ $    $  2$ "

$,&  #0"0, ), 8", "$ $(,$ #"2,&0",1,,=$(#,2  !!, ,  !0$&,"+,2 $ $ 34561 1" %/73/7561++ +%@)0" 0$&,"2",& )  ),2 2#, $& 8' 1#" +,2 2 $3" /++ ", $),",$ !

'"

&," $&8", 2288&

$(9),$ 0G #,&9 ) ), 28# "

 ,!

 $ ""9," 2$1$, 1 +,2 $ 3456 1 " % /73/75 561++%@%9)2)8 $& , ),#"20",8,$ 1#,2 !

! !, , 1"

8 ), () 0"  1" $ #, ! ( $  $ 2F0 ! $

28#!

$ 2 , 9,,"% &,8$ "

$( #"10$& 288 8,$   ), ,"

"2)$ $( #"$2#!, 1 0 2, $&  & &, ,"8$ $  #",2!0&, 8,", #"2,&0"

! ,2)$2 ! , 1"8 ,2!#$( ), 0' $ , 0&2 $ 1 ),2 ,% )0" %$ , &1088 "!

!

&8$( ), !$ ) ,2)$2 ! $1"8 0&20!

# ,&  ",!,( , ), !$(9 ) )

228# $( $56%  ),2$2, ,"$,&+,$0"   "(I$,91 ),&2 1 1 ),$:'!,+0#",8,0" $ $ ,!, ,!, ,!, ,!, , 08 $ $2 !

 08 $ $2 !

, 08 $ $2 !

 08 $ $2 !50#"

6 ! ),#"$0$2,8,$ 1 )0"

A    C@@ C@@ C@@ C@@A1@/3 1@/3 -3- $

 B B08 "

B08 "

B08 "

B08 " 50#"

6I ), #",,$  #, !$( 9 ) 228# $( (

 $56%&#,&1 ),",0$&,"

"- 56 ),#",,$  !$(9  ) 228# $( $56%  ",8 , ,&  ), !, "$,& +,$ 0 0&(,%

,)( ") + )' 9 )

&",2 $  ",  ),  8,  ) $( ', ,,$ 1!,& 0$&," +,2 $ 3 1 " % / /73+,2 $ / 1 ++% @ @ ),  & !, "$,& +,$ 0&(,8

,$ "0  ), ! )8,!1 ($   $ ),"0" 1 28#, ,$ $  0"&2 $1" &# #,"!

9 56 ,,&!,  2!

"1  )  )  0"  )  $  &,!,& $  ), 8," 1 ), ! ! !$(9 ) 228# $( $56I $& ), 8, !,1 #,$1"2$&,"

$1 1 ),2$2,"$,&!, "$,&+,$ 0" % 9 9)2) ) !! $&0' '!

0&2 , ),  8, 9 )0  (, $( ( $1!0,$2,& &'

'," $8 &,),", $ ', 56 ), ,( "

&",2 ,& , ,$&%,G#,& 0!

% ),28#!, , ",2"& 1 ), #",,$  ! 5$2!0&$ $( ), # #,"A'=6  ),  & !, "$,&+, ,$0&(, @ @ @ @ ) ) ) )     H"

: 





 %@ %@ %@ %@C 5+  .

+  .

+  .

+  .6         ), ),"#, =$(", $,&- J) ,   J) ), )," ,#"

'!,-  ,