Rajinder Singh v. Tej Pal , Driver & ORS




   !    "#$ %&'()*(++",'-./ 0123456378984:;"<<"$"# =1>8:63?@8:AB <<<CD18E1:2(&FF3DD1:2 G3?9H9 I3>J1D1:642B3?9 <<<=39F4:63:29 %&'()+(++",'-./ K1A=1E <<<CD18E1:2(&FF3DD1:2 G3?9H9 I3>J1D1:642B3?9 <<<=39F4:63:29    LM

N

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





 ! "! # !$ $$  !

!% " & ' '(($) *) + " ! 

$

"

,,''

-. 

$( /

0"

123-456-477 *7 8 ( '$ " $ !9%%($ !&( 0( &9!

9( !

$ (#

$ $#

$

" "!,

%(  #

"!

( !" (0 '! " 9!$

 0 %( %'': 9,

( #

; : ! '

 

9

" "

! :(< :"

' ,,''

-= 0 . #

123-457-477 " $ !9%%($ ! 

8



" > 

% 5?@) +

" 0(9 $! %  "

" ,, '!

! &(($

"

" A( 9 " ! ##

$ 0( & ((( :"

' !# !!

0

" '

# %

" ,,''

!

0(

$  '8 # 0( #9

% .!)4???B-  " $(

" " $ % CD 1 9'

8F) A" '

#

! 

0

"

9($

" (

#

!:(!9%% 

,(& "  $

) G) H

( ( '8

" ' ( $ /

9 !' " ! ,,!$

" ,(!

,, '! 8

0

"

" A( 9 ( 0"

'8 !# !!$

" '

#! %

" ,,''

 9

%

" % 

"

" '

#

! :( '

 ,(&

"  $

$ "(%( ",(!

 ,, '!# 8 '!$ !# !!$) 5) ; ($' ( $/

9 !' $,(9!$ "(($) I) +

! ,,!

 (%(



"

0! 

"

!!9 (0 ($

0

0'

0  !(($$8 "A( 9 ':"

"( $ "9!J K>> >>  >> 4) 1(#

" & $  !9!!$ & +

"

" '

#

! " $ '$

 ,(&

"

A L ' (!, $

D! 4 $( &( %

" 9! : !

8 : 8 (!, ' %(

"  $

! LMG /"

E ' $!

 ,, (

 

(9 "%9'

!! A"(

!

 ('

' & $ 

 ,(&

"

" : !

( &''

0

" 9! 

" $ 8 %  $

; 9'$

 ,($9

8

< %

" 9!

 !":

"

" : !

( &''

0

" 9!) ;

!

#

!

 (($$

" #$  '0 ' (,( !":

0

"

" : !

" ,(! :" " $ #,

$

"

9($N +

!

"(%( ,(&$

"

/"

E ': !   :

!!% 8!9"9(( ) 4*) D: : ( '%

"

"

#

%

: '

#

!



 !"# $  %$"%&$ ' '$% $%  (  )

" $

 ' ' *"'% + & ',$"

-) ' "&  '"#'

&  .

% ($% '$%

!

"!  "  '"#" !  .

%/ 0 $ %$ $  $  

" 2$"

3"

$%) ' .

  )

" "

 ' '  *"'% + & ',$"

-) '/ 0 "

 4) $" 

(" $  $    )

" %$"

$  ('  $ ,) $"    "!'  '""% $ "% %$,  ($%

 ' ' .  )

"/ 5 )'"#$ ,) $"  ($%

! "  

'

& ""$ 7$!"%'$ +% $%%9 6$!$'" $&' $.

 ( , %

&  $"  $   $% $," $  )

" $

 $:  $  $"

/ 0 $9 (#'9 $," $  )

" $ 4$,"  ",/ 0 $ & '' %$ $ 

%

 ( ('  )

" %  .$: "% &" " !% $&' " #%"!$"

%   ;$, 7$!"%'$ ('  %$" ,) $"  $ .  "%,"%%/ 5 ,"

!$ ') '

& $",$  -$<" ' 2" ! " "$% $ ' ($% %,

&

"  "% .'$/ 5"% " "$ $ -$<" ' 2" ! ($% "  :  ""

$  ",

& $"  $   %,

&

($% %"

," ! &'

, "% ,

 (   ($% 4$,"  "  8"#"

%)"$ 6$!$'"/ 5 )

& 7/=/-/ >4/1?@; $ .  )'

 .  $",$ % ,% #%$ % ""%"' ( #" / ;A/  %$, '$% %  %$, 

& $",$  6$! -$, "%

 $

' "$.

/ 0 $ %$ "  "% '

%% 4$," $"

$  $ #' $))$' .& '  )

"

 )

" $ %"

 $ " ! &'

, ",9 5$ ,$ % $  #' 

: $  )$"  & !" !  ,$' ') '   )

"9 

!  $ %$ "  "% $", )""

$  )

" $

 '!"%'  $% $  $ '"," $ ,) $"  $ .  &"

 "  

'

& ""$ 7$!"%'$ +% $%%9 6$!$'" / 5 ( $",$ % $#9 '& '9 ,$

% & %'#" ! %$,  $  $  . ' "

) "   &$

& ' "$.

 %$, 

& 5< 1$ $   &$ $

$% ($%  '!"%' . $ 

&  $",$ %/ 5 %$, 

& 5< 1$ '"#'

&  .

% "% )) ' . C$'". D$%%



&  .

%/ 5 %$, 

&  '"#' $ 

 $' " ' "$.

 $ '"% '$%  "%. "#,/ ;E/  '$% % "% %% $.

#9 +9 '& '9

$  $",$ % $# &$"

  )'

# $  $"  $ $:  ) $

  '$% $  !

"!  '"#" !

&  0$'$ $ - $($% .

% . "% '"#' 5< 1$ / 5"% "%%  "%9'& '9"$!$" % $",$ %/ F/ G '$" !

&  $.

# ,$:% " 4) "" $ ' ($%

!  $  #" " ! #" 

 $%  )'

# $  $"  " 



 !  " #$ % !

&$ & %

 ( !) *)+ %+ ) ## ) (

))

 ,) ( - )!

& .

/012+33345  % !)6

' $$ ( 780 90 , )

-*) *

 !)!  #)  ## $  #)  . !.   ;< =%+ . !

 7 ) 1>>+ 

&  .

 !)

' $ ( 78 /0?3+33345+ (+  %$ .

5 ##$$  )

  $!   .

- "

@!&.  (7

8($  B#). )

 CDEDF GH IJKEL MNO PQEKEJ REIST U2339V 12 B:: 112+ -)

 . !.  -  $!

 (

& )) #% * % ) %)0 , )$* # ) -) ') !W5 X1Y0 Z ) 

(  & ! -7  1>99 =%  $! ( $! ( )) #% *

% ) %)0 , ) &

! ( 

 # )  ) !).

! - % 

%

&  %$ . #

) 0 =

% ! )

('

)+  ( 7 !)  =%

  )7 ( 70 , ( 7 $!+ + ( . ! )) #% *

$7 (7 ) 

 

  )7 )$0 [ -  ) )! (   ! \#)$7 (7 ] )$ . 0 =##$7

&  #)

#$

)#) 

 +  1>99 =%

 ( & * )) #% * ''%+ .

) # ) %$ )$7+ -

 % .

)%

(  15^51>9>0 10\\ \\ \\ B%

_  ` ) $ :$  =%+ )'

)+

)  * ) & %%)!

!4

( 7

%))!0 [ 

 %)  ) &0 a B%

_ ##$ 

$7

\ 

& ) &

 *! )(70 , \ 

& ) &

# )7 ( !).

!

 ( 

   - % -  ##$ % ($

!

 !) 

-

0 ['

- =%

') ) &+

   -  #) #% * ''% -

 .

)%+ $ \#)$7  !

)- 0 1?0 B%

13  1>99 =% 



7 #) %!) $ #) 



)

  * )) #% * ''%0 [

  $ )&

7 ) &0 / &

'  # )  ) ( !).

!

 ( 

 $ - 

 

!+* b0+('

) -=%% .

'

)%0 1_0 [

- -$$5$!   &

 ( * $ -+

## ! !@% * $ -+ - $!

 ''% 



  ! ""

#

"

!$ #" % 

#$&"' #$($""

) $*)%""$)+ %  , (( (( (( -., /0'

#$1 $' $ $ 1

#  

#

# 23445%  " #6)$ $ "% 6 $  ,7 3, 8 6& 1

# * 6'

# $"  " * *$1 1 +$ " $"+"", 29, 5% ) 1 #" $$* %  #% % %", -2,22,-9-:

 ;<=>?

"6@A!$ B<=CD 0# #$"A @$"   E F"@G  0# #$$ $  EF"@G