M/S Ratchet Laboratories Ltd And ANR v. State Of Haryana And ANR
!"
# $ %"
# & &
'( )(*
"
+ ! , & & &
-
'(
(
./0 12 3 -(
(
'(- '(./ //(2 42 !(0
/(*5/ ) (5
!" "#""
/(*5/ --72 --7 .
0 -(5 (7 *(2 ( 9-7 & !
(2 :9-5 -(7 --( & ;
<
)*3
=/ ; (>* *7 8/ -( 9 . *- 0
$%&'$()
9-7 8(5 &
& !
2 7 ?
!(0 )(* / #8(( #
/(?
89 * / 1*7 5(2 !(
% 9-7
* /( 775 99 2 -*/87 *(
@ (*5 9 2 A
/(( (((
1 ( *95 5B /(2 -( (( * *992 *-2 /( C/ 89 ((0 * & 9-7
*-(
9-7
*995 (( 89 /775 / *(2 * D
% (7 792 C C/ (- >*/5 9-7
>*/5 *995 ((
*-(
- C C/(C 2 0 C/ 78(0 55(3 --(/ 7
1*5 (
((2 *- D 2 2 (-(* /((
!
"#
$
% & ' () ( *
+ ,-
. +
(
*
%
(
, +
, (
>*702 7
1*52 !( -( 2 9. (93 ;*2 *- -(?
5(3 --(5 370 *9- 5B2 --(5 370 * *995 ((2 >* (7 1*5 (
(( 89 9-*5 /
5(39 (5*92 89 ( 7
1*5 --( 757 (90
7 702 E @ E2 *- 77 9-72 C/ 77 *(( @2 -70 53 -- 8C9 895 *870 -(9 8 37
7 70 77 9-7 C 702 !(02 9 C/ (- 9.5 /( 702 702 !(02 C D E E2 &( '/(9 ((02 (- & 9-7
*-(
(3( 95 *7 --(5 / *(2 0 9*/ 2 &( '/(92 37 73(52 89 8C *- 9
-*(-(70 5(*2 (7( 77 9-72 9**(( /(2 55(3 /(
/((2 0 / 79 :*7- C/ -- /(C/ -(3 5(
E
-(3 98
*-( ( :( /((
# $/0 , 1
2
# 3$ 4(
, +
$/+
,
1
((
,
5 2(
4$
, %
, (
,
,
1
(
,
5 2 (#
( + %
, , 3$6
% - (
#
4$ ,
, 0 , 7 (%
( 8
1
2 '
# 3$
4 (
(- % -
(
, , .$/
% -
# 3$
%
9
9 -*7 /(2 >* C/ E 0 (- -0 (-( 70 C( (7 *7 C/( 9-7 89 772 895 C/ 87 (5/2 (3( (-(2 770 /(2 70 / .5 85 ( (702 9 /( 78((0 (
( 2 ( (5/ (9 * 37 &( '/(92 C/ -(9 -- 77 *((2 C/9 9-C(9 73(5 98 *8 2
89 3
*2 70 83*2 77 *(
-(9 /(2 *(3(70 /( 9**(( -- 77
"# / C/ 9 -(32 /( *7 79 0 -(375 7.
2 3 C( (7 *7 C/( 77 *((
$ 902 832 /(2 9**(( (*5 ( 9-7 -(2 C/ (7(2 C/9 73(52 2 89 98
89 2 79 -*(305 >* 73(5
+( (95 0 ( 79 379 9**((2 9-( 7 2 9 C/ (- 9.5 7 (-(2 70 C 53 /(2 E 2 (
/((2 *95 7. (7( C 7 8 9-7
/(*-
% C # 9(2 C/ E 0 (- 9 ( 9.52 -(* 3 (3( (2 7 (-(2 702 !(
*7 *892 3 *952 7( C/ (- ( 92 89 * E 2 -(2 C (3 *-7 0 /((2 0 / *952 89 (3 -(2
/((2 89 (73 2 C/( 9-* E 02 98
8
7- E 0 2 * :*( 'E2 (C 2
. (5 77 9-72 (70 (7 #8((0 (
>*702 -(2 C/ 98
2
/ -(9-70 /(( %-( 9.5 9 5( (5 ( 70 / 77 9-72 (7 #8((0 (
:-( ( C *5 3 (3( (-( 702 !(02 770 77 9-72 C 73 9.5 9-770 *2 (5/ 3
@
--( 79 73(52 89 ( 9-*5 ((2 7
1*52 !( 2 *-2 (97 3 & @
( 9 9-*5 3(
7
1*52 ( 8(.2 *-2 3( !?87
*-(9
! " ##$% & $& %
*7 -( / 3/970 (5*2 --7 3(
7
1*52 /2 ( /( 9*(5 ( /(2 /((2 --7 /( / 89 9-770 9*
! / 9 3/970 (5*2 9-*5 3(2 7
1*5 / 3 5 : ((52 9(35 C(.5 C( 895 (5/ 37 0 37 2 90
' *2 :*( 'E2 / / (5 >*7 >* /(52 ( (9 ( 90 89 (9 (7 1*5 5 -(
+( (95 370 ( *892 9-( ( (73 :-*7 7C2 92 !?87 -:
;*59
*-(
/*5/2 ;*59
*-( !?87 -:
*(2 /*5/ / :-*7 7C /*5/2 9**(( 7. (7(2 7 (5/2 5 (-( 70
/ -( 2 /(( 9. 7*2 8 ((2 *- (7( 9
3787 9**((2 (*5 ( 9 (
!?87 -:
-(5(-/ ;*59
-( C/( 89 :( /((2 / 0 -( (( 7*2 /*5/2 9**(( 90 8 7 8 *--7 C/ -0 7 (-( 70 0 9**(( 9* 89 (- -- (-(2 87 /775 (( (-( ((5 0 /( 9 C// */ 2 *((5 770 (-(2 89 -(3
(3(2 :-*7 /(2 9**(( 37 (902 3787
*-(
.+
,
, 8 ,
, )
, ,
,
+
,
, :
;
,
. 4$
( < !
#
+ (
, 0 ,
, , 5 (
0 ,
, ,
=
( (
, (
,
,)
,
# 3$ * . 8
% -
>
(
8 +
% -
8 ) ,( % - , * . 3$
,
#
, 9
9 /(2 9- 9**(( (*( 9
89
#
( -770 (>* ( 75 70
>*702 / 8 (9 C/ 98 -(5(-/ ;*59
C//( 9- 9**(( (*( 9
370 87
&C ((-3 9**(( # 895 7 (3 770
) (-(
70 / 77 9-72 0 C/ 85 53 9 C/ (- 9.5 7 (-( 70 / 22 C/ >*.
-(9-* /((92 9*/ 2 C/ 7 / C C. /((2 2 :*( 'E .5 (*5 %-( (5 9-7 ( (70 9-7 (7 (*5 #8((02 7*
>*702 --( 55(3-(2 / 0 ( 702 9-5 (*( 9
-770 C/ (- 379 9
!?87 -:
/ ((3 (5/ 9**((2 0 C/ (( 85 -(9-70 (*(
/((2 C 5(70 -
1*52 !( -(2 ((70 *89 *7 -(2 9*( ( 3(2 2 -(-*2 !?87 -:
*(2 3(
9. (( *89 / *(2 8 8C *- -(2 -(5(-/ A ;*59
/ !?87 -:
*(2 / 8 8/ 5(70 9*(2 / 8 5(70 9--7
+*(/(9(2 / (( *89 3 :2 7
1*5 / -( *870 9-770 (77 (5/ 2 90 ( /((92 55(3-(
/((2 / /*5/ 5( C/ *89 / *7
/( / ( (7 1*5 9. 0 37 (( (70 85 77 9-72 / (7 (*5 #8((0 ( 3*( /*5/2 C
# -(9-70 55(3-( (*5 %-( 0 (9 /(( -(9-70 (*( (9 *8
/ 1*7 5( /( -(2 (2 (*5 %-( (
>*7 /( 852 99 -( 92 / 7- *7 C2 90 85 77>* (( 9-7 *((52 / 9.5 * 987 * (5 85 (7 (*5 #8((02 7*
-**70 9 8 (*( 5 (7 (>*( 9.5 7C*7 (( /(2 5( (
/((2 (( 90 - / ( (7 1*5 (( -- (5
$ 902 9-7 :-(5 2 *9 *9 9-(
( 85 ((-3 2 55(3-( (3 9. -(9- 379 (5/ 3 *(
0 (70 9-7 5 (7 (7 #8((0 C*7 89 9-770 *7 9-2 /( ( 0 770 (-( 70 ( / 9 37 (3( /( / 952 78((0 (
( 85 -- (70 C*7 8 37 3*(2 70 C/ 9-7 C 77 - (70 9*/ 2 / :-(
9-7 / :-(2 /(*-2 /( C*7 8 37 (70 /(2 (7
#8((02 ( C*7 89 3770 7 *70 37 73(5
( C*7 / C*7 89 - ( >*7 - 37 (5/ 895 3 85 (
85 70 /(*5/2 7 (*5 %-( -(9 89 99
/((2 -(0( / >*/5 9-7 5 9**((2 5(*2 -- (70 *(52 (*- * (3( 2 770 (-(2 702 !(02 C*7 8 *7 3*(2 9-7 (3 8 >*/2 89 987 -2 89 9-770 *--( ;*592 2 !?87 -:
7 * + ,
- +
!
. , $##(%'!&&)2 (73 -(5(-/ E C/(2 89 :( /((
-**70 C/ 3 2 -*5 (7 2 C*7 (*7 / 895 *(0 /( /*97
5+68 ? @
$ + ,
* .
3$ (
8 + # 8 ,
,
8 /
%
; *%% A( # 4$ + ( (
,, ,
, % +
# 3$ * 3 6
# 4$ * 3 +
,
,
,
(5 ( + +
, , + + +
, , = %
( !
, , %
/ + ( (
, ,
, % +
,, (
(<
4+ ()%
(
/)%
8 :
)%
B : <
, , , 0 , (
' # /
, "
@
$
:
, ,
% -
+
#A#
!
' , #A#
,
!9
3C / 8 (( !?87 -:
7 */, 0-.
! 1 23 +
&
4 ' #'5 (73 -(5(-/
C/( :( /((
: )%
, % 8 * . 3$ 3
A? (
? %& ' ( & A'(
, ,% - (%
+
,
,
* . 3$ 3
,
/ )%
( (
,8 /
, ( ,
8
: 9
>*702 - 77C
9-7
*995 (( 8 (( - 7
1*52 !( ( 77 >*/2
A
'5 977* --7 2 02 2 -
#*#""#""
+),+)-(.)$/%&01-)$(2&)3 )(12
. 7 /4