State Of Punjab v. M/S Phool Chand Satya Pal And Others

   

       

!"#$#%&'&() 
* +#,"!"#-(.!/"+0-1+ 2#%-"&3# (1&(##04 +!($5-0

('"0-%"&(&3&'&(,6 !(!70.#%"4-(.!/ 55#77!("

8#0'-'

,+7 +!($,!"9!!7!($!("+#0 #'5($#("'

)  :6  , ;

6,  0#'#(")< '!'7##(;!-0,&$+-4''&'"!(" 4-(.!/4 0"+#!55#77!("<,"!"# 0(=&"11!0>!74$3%!"#404 0(-5!?,&(17!4$3%!"#400#'5($#(" (#00#'5($#("
  @+#"+#0"+##50"#0'7%!7(#>'5!5#0?!9/#!77>#$"'## "+#.-$1?#("A
 /#0##00#$""+##50"#00("

 @+#"+#0"+#.-$1?#("'+-7$/#0#50"#$&("+#$&1#'"A << << ;

6, 4

6 +#,"!"#-(.!/+!'&7#$"+&'!55#!7!1!&('""+# .-$1?#("$!"#$ 45!''#$/9"+#7#!0(#$,#(&0,-/-$1#4 -5(!1!04  3&$#  >+&%+  "+#  /.#%"&('  &7#$  /9  "+#  ,"!"#  >#0# $&'?&''#$!($"+#!>!0$$!"#$

>!'?!$#0-7#"+# %-0"!($!%%0$&(1794!$#%0##00#%3#09'B4BB4 * <>!'

5!''#$  &(  !3-0    "+#  5#"&"&(#0

("0!%"0  0#'5($#("     +#0#&( !($!1!&('"0#'5($#(" !55#77!("<,"!"#+#0#&( +#

<
< -"-0#&("#0#'"C
D5#0!((-?0?"+#$!"#!>!0$"&77"+#$!"#   0#!7&E!"&(    "+#  $#%0#"!7  !?-("  >!'  !7'  !>!0$#$  "  "+# 5#"&"&(#0

("0!%"0 0#'5($#("+#0#&(  0&#79 '"!"#$4 "+# ,"!"#  -(.!/ &(3&"#$ "#($#0' 0


 /9("&%#5-/7&%!"&((B 0%('"0-%"&( , !(!7!"
=?'"

=?' +#5#"&"&(#0

("0!%"0 /#0#"+#7>#0 -0"&# '+7 +!($,!"9!!7 0#'5($#("

+#0#&( '-/?&""#$"+#7>#'"0!"#'!($!%%0$&(1794"+#>0= %('"0-%"&(>!'!77""#$"&"+#0#!"#04!$&'5-"#!0'#/#">##( "+#5!0"&#'!($0#'5($#("
>!'!55&("#$!'!,7#0/&"0!"04 3&$#7#""#0$!"#$  #'5($#("
5!''#$"+#!>!0$ $!"#$ 

  !($  (  4  "+#  5#"&"&(#0

("0!%"0

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

< < /.#%"&('"+#,"!"#>#0#$&'?&''#$!($"+#!>!0$>!'?!$# 0-7#"+#%-0" +!3#+#!0$7#!0(#$%-('#70"+#5!0"&#'!($+!3# !7'%!0#-7791(#"+0-1+"+#&7# 5#0-'!7"+#&7#'+>'"+!""+#0/&"0!"0>!'((# #7'#"+!("+#,-5#0&("#($&(1 (1&(##04 ('"0-%"&( &0%7#8 ,6 !(!70.#%"+&?'#75#0-'!7"+#&?5-1(#$0$#0$!"#$  '+>'"+!""+#7#!0(#$,#(&0,-/-$1#4-5(!1!04+!$ $#!7">&"+!77"+#5&("'&(+!($(&''-#4+#+!$$#!7">&"+ %7!&?'">!''"!"#$"+!""+#$#7!9&("+##2#%-"&(>0=>!'$-# "((<!3!&7!/&7&"9'&"#+#5#"&"&(#0

("0!%"0 0#'5($#(" +#0#&( +!$$#579#$?!%+&(#094/-"+#%-7$("-"&7&E#"+#'!?# +#  0/&"0!"0  +!'  1&3#(  '-&%&#("  $&'%-("  &(  !3-0    "+# $#5!0"?#("   +# 0/&"0!"0 !''#''#$  "+# %7!&?  !"  '    7!%' >#3#04"+#0/&"0!"0!>!0$#$(79'7!%'4"+#0#/9/#(#&""&(1 "+#$#5!0"?#("/9'F7!%'+#7''50&">!'%!7%-7!"#$/9 "+#0/&"0!"0CD +#"+#0%7!&?'>#0#!7'$&'%-''#$!($ !"#0?##"&(1!77"+#5&("'4"+#&?5-1(#$!>!0$$!"#$

 >!'5!''#$   !?  "+# 3&#>"+!" "+&'  -0" &'  (" " '&" ( "+# .-$1?#(""+#0/&"0!"0!($'-/'"&"-"#+&'0#!'(&(1/9&"'>( 0#!'(&(1+#0/&"0!"04>+>!'"+#?!("+#$#5!0"?#("&"'#74 1!3#'-&%&#("%(%#''&(""+#$#5!0"?#("!($!"#0%!7%-7!"&(1 #3#09"+&(14"+#!>!0$>!'5!''#$-($#0#3#09+#!$+#0#0#4

<F< "+#0#  &'  (  &77#1!7&"9  0  &(&0?&"9  &(  "+#  &?5-1(#$  !>!0$  $!"#$

45!''#$/9"+#0/&"0!"0!($"+#0$#0$!"#$ 5!''#$/9"+#7#!0(#$,#(&0,-/-$1#4-5(!1!04-5+7$&(1"+# !>!0$

('#G-#("794"+#50#'#("!55#!7&'$&'?&''#$

;

6,   

 
* '.='