← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/728/2019disposed of

State Of Haryana And Another v. Jyoti And Another

2022-05-06Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal26 pages

In the High Court of Punjab and Haryana, at Chandigarh Regular First Appeal No. 728 of 2019 (O&M) Date of Decision: 10.05.2022 State of Haryana and Another ... Appellant(s)

Versus

Jyoti and Another ... Respondent(s) CORAM: Hon'ble Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal.

Present:

Mr. Baldev Raj Majahan, Advocate General, Haryana with Mr. Shivendra Swaroop, Assistant Advocate General, Haryana, Ms. Vibha Tewari, Assistant Advocate General, Haryana, Mr. Harsh Vardhan, Assistant Advocate General, Haryana, for the appellant(s).

Ms. Nikita Goel, Advocate.

Mr. Jaivir Yadav, Advocate for Mr. Harshwardhan Ranga, Advocate.

Mr. Sanjiv Ghai and Mr. Sarabh Garg, Advocates. Mr. Sanjeev Kodan, Advocate.

Mr.Navneet Singh, Advocate.

Mr. S.P.Chahar, Advocate.

Mr. Aditya Yadav, Advocate.

Mr. Sandeep Kotla, Advocate.

Mr. Chanderhas Yadav, Advocate.

Mr. Arvind Seth, Advocate.

Mr. Kulvir Narwal, Advocate.

Mr. Vijay, Advocate.

Mr. Suresh Kaushik, Advocate.

Mr.R.K.Girdhwal, Advocate.

Mr. G.N.Malik, Advocate.

Mr. Saurabh Dalal, Advocate.

Mr. Vivek Khatri, Advocate.

Mr. Abhimanyu Singh, Advocate.

Mr. R.K.Kachwa, Advocate.

Mr. Ashish Gupta, Advocate.

Mr. G.N.Malik, Advocate.

Mr. P.R.Yadav, Advocate.

Ms. Divya Arora, Advocate for Mr. Rahul Deswal, Advocate.

Mr. Ravinder Rana,Advocate.

Ms. Pratibha Yadav, Advocate for Mr. Arvind Kumar Yadav, Advocate for the landowners.

Anil Kshetarpal, J.

INTRODUCTION:

1.1 This batch of appeals has been filed under Section 74 of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (hereinafter referred to as "the RFCTLARR Act, 2013"), assailing the correctness of the awards passed by the Authority/Reference Court (hereinafter referred to as "the RC") on 21.11.2018, 01.05.2019, 19.08.2019, 28.08.2019 and 21.09.2019. As per the office report, the State of Haryana as well as the landowners have filed the cross-appeals.

1.2 The learned counsel representing the parties are ad idem that this batch of the appeals (details whereof are at the foot of the judgment) can be conveniently disposed of by a common judgment. 2.

RELEVANT PARTICULARS 2.1 The relevant information, concerning this bunch of appeals, is compiled in a tabulated form, which is as under:- Sr. No.

Title Details 1.

Date of Notification under Section 4 of the 1894 Act.

07.07.2011 2.

Date of Notification under Section 6 of the 1894 Act.

06.07.2012 3.

Purpose of Acquisition.

340.02 acres of land in the revenue estates of Jhajjar and Sikanderpur for the development of the residential Sector 7, Jhajjar.

4.

Number and Date of the Award of the Land Acquisition Award No.8 dated 04.07.2008

Sr. No.

Title Details Collector.

5.

Amount assessed by the Land Acquisition Collector.

The LAC assessed market value of the acquired land @ 28,13,951/- ₹ per acre.

6.

Date of the judgment of the Reference Court.

21.09.2018, 29.11.2018, 01.05.2019, 19.08.2019 and 28.08.2019.

7.

Amount determined by the Reference Court The RC, vide award dated 21.09.2018, 29.11.2018, 01.05.2019 and 19.08.2019, assessed the market value of the acquired land @ 54,33,469/- per ₹ acre. Whereas vide award dated28.08.2019, the RC assessed the market value of the acquired land @ 67,76,000/-.

₹ 2.2 The landowners claim that the acquired land has immense potential as it is abutting the national highway. It is surrounded by the residential, commercial and industrial entities including Mini Secretariat, District Courts and educational institutions. They claim that the market value of the acquired land is not less than 3,00,00,000/- per acre. ₹ 2.3 Per contra, the State of Haryana claims that the Land Acquisition Collector has correctly assessed the market value and therefore, the reference applications are required to be dismissed. 3.

ORAL AND DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE 3.1 Before the RC, in Award dated 21.09.2019, the landowners have examined the following witnesses:- Sr. No.

Name of the Witness Particulars of the witness 1.

PW.1 Suresh Kumar Moudgil 2.

PW.2 Joginder Singh Patwari, Halqa Jhajjar 3.

PW.3 Naresh Kumar Registry Clerk 4.

PW.4 Pushpa Patwari, Halqa Sikanderpur

3.2 Apart from the sale deeds, the landowners have produced two layout plans No. 252 and 253, respectively.

3.3 On the other hand, the State of Haryana has examined RW.1 Kuldeep, Patwari from the office of the Land Acquisition Collector and produced Aks Shijra as Ex.R1 and the sale deeds as Ex.R2 to Ex.R11. 3.4 In the award passed by the RC on 28.08.2019, four cases were decided. The landowners examined PW.1 Ajay Khatri, Draftsman, PW.2 Daya Kaur, PW.3 Joginder Singh, Registration Clerk and produced the layout plan (Ex.P1), sale deed No. 7860 dated 08.11.2011 (Ex.P2), sale deed No. 5227 dated 28.11.2013 (Ex.P3), revenue layout plan (Ex.P4), the collector's rate list (Ex.P5), sale deed No. 4372 dated 12.11.2012 (Ex.P6) and sale deed No. 4151 dated 13.12.2010 (Ex.P7). 3.5 On the other hand, in the aforesaid award, the State of Haryana examined RW.1 Ajay, Patwari.

3.6 In the award dated 01.05.2019, the landowners relied upon the copy of previous judgment dated 21.09.2018 whereas, the State of Haryana did not lead any evidence.

3.7 Further, for the sake of brevity, a consolidated compilation of the sale deeds/sale exemplars with the relevant information, produced by the respective parties of villages, namely Jhajjar and Sikandarpur, is tabulated as under:- Sr.

No.

Exhibit Nos. Sale Deed No. and Date Total Area Price Per Acre/ Total Price (in ₹) JHAJJAR (Sale Deeds Produced by the respective parties) 1.

P-1 1081 Dt. 08.06.2005 1K-11M 6,56,000/ 33,85,806

Sr.

No.

Exhibit Nos. Sale Deed No. and Date Total Area Price Per Acre/ Total Price (in ₹) 2.

P-2 490 Dt. 08.05.2006 64K-5M 2,89,12,500/ 36,00,000 3.

P-3 818 Dt. 26.05.2006 8K-3M 50,93,700/ 49,99,950 4.

P-4 819 Dt. 26.05.2006 27K-12M 1,38,00,000/ 40,00,000 5.

P-5 820 Dt. 26.05.2006 14K-14M 69,82,500/ 38,00,000 6.

P-6 821 Dt. 26.05.2006 9K-2M 40,95,000/ 36,00,000 7.

P-7 822 Dt. 26.05.2006 4K-5M 19,12,500/ 36,00,000 8.

P-8 1309 Dt. 15.06.2006 5K-18M 30,90,938/ 41,91,102 9.

P-9 1310 Dt. 15.06.2006 9K-14M 50,92,500/ 42,00,000 10.

P-10 1688 Dt. 30.06.2006 20K 1,04,00,000/ 41,60,000 11.

P-11 1734 Dt. 03.07.2006 3K-6M 1,57,77,000/ 3,82,47,272 12.

P-12 1786 Dt. 05.07.2006 17K-13M 92,72,813/ 42,02,974 13.

P-13 1859 Dt. 07.07.2006 40K-9M 2,02,12,500/ 39,97,527 14.

P-14 1893 Dt. 11.07.2006 10K-18M 49,05,000/ 36,00,000 15.

P-15 1894 Dt. 11.07.2006 10K-14M 48,15,000/ 36,00,000 16.

P-16 2095 Dt. 19.07.2006 13K-5M 59,62,500 36,00,000 17.

P-17 2096 Dt. 19.07.2006 3K-14M 19,29,500/ 41,71,891 18.

P-18 2209 Dt. 24.07.2006 31K-11M 1,65,63,750/ 42,00,000 19.

P-19 2228 Dt. 25.07.2006 2K-4M 12,00,000/ 43,63,636 20.

P-20 2226 Dt. 25.07.2006 8K-15M 55,00,000/ 50,28,571 21.

P-21 2284 Dt. 27.07.2006 17K-10M 87,50,000/ 40,00,000 22.

P-22 2301 Dt. 31.07.2006 17K-9M 91,52,500/ 41,95,988

Sr.

No.

Exhibit Nos. Sale Deed No. and Date Total Area Price Per Acre/ Total Price (in ₹) 23.

P-23 2356 Dt. 01.08.2006 1K-16M 11,93,000/ 53,02,222 24.

P-24 2735 Dt. 18.08.2006 25K-2M 1,31,77,500/ 42,00,000 25.

P-25 2737 Dt. 18.08.2006 8K-3M 42,78,750/ 42,00,000 26.

P-26 2994 Dt. 30.08.2006 49K-9M 2,58,91,000/ 41,88,634 27.

P-27 3146 Dt. 08.09.2006 21K-16M 1,14,45,000/ 42,00,000 28.

P-28 3147 Dt. 08.09.2006 11K-2M 58,27,500/ 42,00,000 29.

P-29 3266 Dt. 14.09.2006 16K-10M 97,12,500/ 47,09,090 30.

P-30 3422 Dt. 22.09.2006 1K-10M 10,00,000/ 53,33,333 31.

P-31 3818 Dt. 18.10.2006 21K-9M 1,28,47,500/ 47,91,608 32.

P-32 5793 Dt. 25.01.2007 2K-8.5M 14,55,000/ 48,00,000 33.

P-33 5822 Dt. 29.01.2007 2K-15M 20,00,000/ 58,18,181 34.

P-34 6802 Dt. 07.03.2007 3K-8M 22,63,000/ 53,24,705 35.

P-35 2342 Dt. 04.07.2007 14M 6,00,000/ 68,57,142 36.

P-36 6971 Dt. 27.02.2008 1K-4M 14,40,000/ 96,00,000 37.

P-37 7310 Dt. 20.03.2008 1K-13M 22,00,000/ 1,06,66,666 38.

P-38 373 Dt. 29.04.008 1K-1M 14,15,000/ 10780952 39.

P-39 608 Dt. 14.05.2008 1K-3M 21,00,000/ 1,46,08,695 40.

P-40 1381 Dt. 27.06.2008 1K-18M 23,00,000/ 96,84,210 41.

P-41 491 Dt. 08.05.2006 14A-4K-1M 5,22,22,500/ 36,00,000 42.

P-42 1297 Dt. 15.06.2006 7K-8M 32,37,500/ 35,00,000 43.

P-43 825 Dt. 26.05.2006 23K-7M 1,17,00,000/ 40,08,565

Sr.

No.

Exhibit Nos. Sale Deed No. and Date Total Area Price Per Acre/ Total Price (in ₹) 44.

P-48 2736 Dt. 18.08.2006 8K-4M 43,05,000/ 42,00,000 45.

P-55 2737 Dt. 18.08.2006 8K-3M 42,78,750/ 42,00,000 46.

P-56 2736 Dt. 18.08.2006 8K-4M 43,05,000/ 42,00,000 47.

P-57 3432 Dt. 20.08.2007 4K-3M 50,00,000/ 96,38,554 48.

P-58 4481 Dt. 29.07.2011 1K-5M 23,00,000 1,47,20,000 49.

P-59 3319 Dt. 05.07.2011 1K 15,37,700/ 1,23,01,600 50.

P-60 4623 Dt. 03.08.2011 5M 8,35,000/ 2,67,20,000 51.

P-61 872 Dt. 06.05.2011 2K-16M 17,50,000/ 50,00,000 52.

R-5 628 Dt. 26.04.2011 23K-6M 72,85,000/ 25,01,287 53.

R-6 5001 Dt. 08.08.2011 11K 34,50,000/ 25,09,090 54.

R-7 3254 Dt. 04.07.2011 11K 34,40,000/ 25,01,818 55.

R-9 3855 Dt. 01.10.2012 3K-2M 60,0625/ 15,50,000 56.

R-10 1964 Dt. 09.08.2010 6K-1M 16,65,000 22,01,652 57.

R-11 4253 Dt. 16.12.2010 6K 16,63,750/ 22,18,333 58.

P-2 7860 Dt. 08.09.2011 481.99 Sq. Yards 16,86,965/ 1,69,40,000 59.

P-3 5227 Dt. 28.11.2013 351.13 Sq. Feet 11,12,380/ 4,58,59,618 60.

P-6 4572 Dt. 12.11.2012 Sq. Yards 56,5000/ 2,42,00,000 61.

P-7 4151 Dt. 13.12.2010 Sq. Yards 65,1000/ 1,01,64,000 SIKANDARPUR (Sale Deeds Produced by the respective parties) 62.

P-44 1308 Dt. 15.06.2006 33K-19M 1,61,26,250/ 38,00,000 63.

P-45 1686 Dt. 30.06.2006 13K-7M 70,08,750/ 42,00,000

Sr.

No.

Exhibit Nos. Sale Deed No. and Date Total Area Price Per Acre/ Total Price (in ₹) 64.

P-46 1879 Dt. 10.07.2006 41K-9M 2,01,43,750/ 38,87,816 65.

P-47 2357 Dt. 01.08.2006 21K-15M 1,14,18,750/ 42,00,000 66.

P-49 2993 Dt. 30.08.2006 22K-4M 1,16,55,000/ 42,00,000 67.

P-50 3817 Dt. 18.10.2006 38K-14M 2,32,05,000/ 47,96,899 68.

P-51 5932 Dt. 31.01.2007 16K-7M 85,83,750/ 42,00,000 69.

R-2 9860 Dt. 29.11.2011 8K 15,00,000/ 15,00,000 70.

R-3 6535 Dt. 11.02.2013 2K-16M 8,75,000/ 25,00,000 71.

R-4 1914 Dt. 03.07.2012 468.87 Sq.Yards 90,8000/ 93,73,003 72.

R-8 10435 Dt. 16.12.2011 5K-8M 13,50,000/ 20,00,000 3.8 In order to understand the information compiled in above-noted table, it is appropriate to explain the meaning of the various words/phrases wherein, is as under:-

1. 1 Rectangle = 5 X 5 = 25 Acre

2. 1 Acre = 160 Marlas

3. 8 Kanal = 1 Acre

4. 1 Kanal = 20 Marlas

5. 1 Acre = 4840 Sq. Yards

6. 1 Marla = 272.251 Sq. Feet = 30.25 Sq.

Yards

7. 1 Inch = 2.54 cm

8. 1 Foot = 12 Inch.

9. 1 Sq. Feet = 12 X 12 =144 Inch.

10. 1 Yard = 3 Feet

11. 1 Sq. Yard = 9 Sq. Feet

12. 100 Sq. Yards = 900 Sq. Feet

13. 1 Kanal = 0.125 Acre

14. 1 Marla = 0.00625001 Acre

15. "//" denotes Rectangle Number.

16. "/" denotes Khasra/Killa Number.

17. "A" denotes Acre

18. "K" denotes Kanal

19. "M" denotes Marla 4.

DISCUSSION:

4.1 The RC has noticed that the sale instances (Ex.P1 to Ex.P51) are evidences of the purchases made by the landowners themselves in the years 2005 to 2007. The sale deeds (Ex.P55 to Ex.P57) are pertaining to the years 2005 to 2007, but these cannot be taken into consideration by adding 12% per annum escalation. The sale deed (Ex.P59 dated 05.07.2011) is just two days prior to the issuance of notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred to as "the 1894 Act"), but is found to be relevant. The sale instance (Ex.P61 dated 06.05.2011) is 62 days prior to the issuance of notification under Section 4 of the 1894 Act. The sale instances (Ex.R2 to R11), produced by the State of Haryana, were ignored on the ground that these reflect a price lesser than the market value assessed by the Land Acquisition Collector (hereinafter referred to as "the LAC") on the ground that the compensation cannot be lower than the amount assessed by the LAC.

4.2 Thereafter, the RC took average of the sale instances (Ex.P1 to Ex.P51, Ex.P55 to Ex.P57, Ex.P59 and Ex.P61), which comes to 81,50,204/- per acre. The RC, after applying a deduction of 1/3rd, on ₹ account of expenditure on infrastructural facilities, assessed the market value @ 54,33,469/- per acre as on 07.07.2011.

₹ 4.3 In award dated 01.05.2019, the Reference Court, while relying

upon its previous judgment dated 21.09.2018, assessed the same amount i.e. 54,33,469/- per acre, besides ordering the payment of solatium @ 100% ₹ additional amount @ 12% per annum, interest @ 9% for the first year and 15% per annum for the subsequent period in accordance with Section 70(2) and 70(3) of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013.

4.4 Heard the learned counsel representing both the parties and with their able assistance, perused both the paper-book as well as the various records, which were requisitioned.

4.5 The learned counsel representing the appellants contend that the RC has overlooked the letter dated 26.10.2015 issued by the Central Government which provides that the market value is required to be assessed as on 01.01.2014. They further contend that the RC has not followed the procedure as laid down under Section 26 of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 and has committed errors while taking the average of the relevant sale deeds. The RC has also erred in failing to multiply the market value assessed by the relevant factor as provided in Section 26(2) of the RFCTLARR Act 2013.

While questioning the correctness of the development cut of 1/3rd applied by the RC, the learned counsel has contended that once the comparable sale instances of the contemporaneous period have been produced, the decision to impose 1/3rd cut, on the base value, is erroneous. 4.6 Per contra, the learned counsel representing the State of Haryana contends that the RC has neither decided the cases in accordance with Section 26 read with Section 30 of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013, nor it has taken into consideration the sale deeds produced by the State of Haryana.

real estate market, therefore, the prices are not likely to increase in a consistent manner.

4.7 From a careful reading of the judgment, passed by the RC, it is evident that the RC has overlooked the provisions of Section 26 of the 2013 Act, which provides that the LAC is required to assess the market value which is the highest after examining the three different approaches given in Section 26 itself. Furthermore, the RC has also overlooked the explanation (1), (2), (3) and (4) added to the Section 26(1) of the RFCTLARR Act 2013. It is also evident that the sale instances of the calender year 2011 could not be taken into consideration in view of the Explanation (1) to Section 26(1) of the RFCTLARR Act 2013.

4.8 As regards the issue of the communication dated 26.10.2015, the matter has been examined by this Bench in State of Haryana and Another v. Rajbir and Another (Regular First Appeal No. 309 of 2021, decided on 19.04.2022), the relevant part thereof is extracted as under:- "14. Section 23 of the 1894 Act specifically provides that the crucial date for assessment of the market value of the acquired land shall be the date of publication of notification under Section 4(1) of the 1894 Act. Further, the additional amount/benefit under sub-section(1-A) of Section 23 of the 1894 Act is, also, required to be calculated from the date of publication of notification under Section 4(1) till the date of award of the Collector or the date of taking possession of the acquired land whichever is earlier. Section 24(1)(a) of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 which specifically takes care of

transitional period between the 1894 Act and the RFCTLARR Act, 2013, does not provide that the date of enforcement of the Act shall be construed as the date of issuance of notification under Section 4(2) or Section 11 of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013. Proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 26 provides that the date of determination of the market value shall be the date on which the notification has been issued under Section 11 of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013. Notification under Section 11 is a preliminary notification issued by the Government expressing its desire to acquire the land.

15.

Further, Section 30(3) of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013, provides that the additional amount at the rate of 12% per annum on such market value is required to be calculated from the date of publication of notification for conducting Social Impact Assessment Study of the proposed land under subsection (2) of Section 4 of RFCTLARR Act, 2013, till the date of award of the Collector or the date of taking possession of the land whichever is earlier. If the communication is considered as a direction issued by the Central Government in exercise of powers under Section 113 and the date of such assessment of the market value is taken as 01.01.2014, then, the same shall not only be in violation of Section 24 of the 1894 Act but also an infringement of the proviso to Section 26 (1) of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013. Clause 5 of Section 24 of the 1894 Act provides that any increase in the value of the acquired land

which is likely to accrue from the use to which it might be put when acquired is to be ignored. In fact, by the aforesaid letter, the goalpost itself is sought to be changed. The date of assessment of the market value of the acquired land either under the 1894 Act or RFCTLARR Act, 2013 is sought to be overridden/surpassed. Both the Acts are based on the fundamental rule that the date of preliminary notification shall be the date for assessment of the market value. Once, there is no specific provision providing for assessment as on 01.01.2014, in the considered opinion of the Court the communication should be construed as arbitrary and ultravires to the provisions of both the Acts. 16.

This matter can be examined from yet another perspective. By changing the goalpost to 01.01.2014, the exemplar sale deeds which have been executed and registered post the date of preliminary notification under Section 4 of the 1894 Act which are, ordinarily excluded from consideration, shall be required to be taken into account and thus, will go against the legislative approach, otherwise provided under both the Acts. In such a situation, it will become difficult for the courts to distinguish between bonafide sale deeds and the pretentious sale deeds which have been executed only to jack up the claim for compensation. Once, the factum of proposed acquisition of the land in the vicinity is in the knowledge of the residents of the area or landowners, then, the possibility of

executing sale deeds with malafide intent for jacking up prices in the area would increase.

17 & 18 XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX 19.

This matter for the purpose of interpretation can be considered from yet another perspective. If the intention of the Legislature was to apply all the provisions of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013, there was no necessity to enact a hybrid provision like Section 24(1)(a). In such case, it would have contained a provision that the pending or incomplete acquisition proceedings, shall lapse and the acquiring authority will start the proceedings afresh under the RFCTLARR Act, 2013. On a careful reading of Section 24(1)(a), it is evident that only the provisions relating to determination of compensation of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 have been made applicable while saving the notifications under Section 4 and 6 of the 1894 Act. The Legislature does not also provide that all the provisions of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013, shall be applicable with respect to the incomplete proceeding under the 1894 Act.

XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XX 21.

This court also does not find any substance in the arguments of the learned counsel that the communication dated 26.10.2015 is supplementary and does not supplant the Act. In the considered opinion of the court, the aforesaid letter is in conflict with the provisions of the Act, consequently, if taken into account, it would result in supplanting the provisions of the

RFCTLARR Act, 2013, as to its implementation to the cases arising during the transition period.

22 to 29 XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX 30.

While answering the question No.1, it is declared that under Section 24(1)(a) during the transitional period, the market value will have to be assessed on the date of publication of notification under Section 4(1) of the 1894 Act. Similarly, the additional amount under Section 30(3) of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 shall be calculated from the date of publication of notification under Section 4 of the 1894 Act till the date of the award or date of taking possession of the land, whichever is earlier".

4.9 The RC has also erred in overlooking the sale instances (Ex.R2 to Ex.R11), produced by the State of Haryana, on the ground that they reflect a price lower than the market value assessed by the LAC. Even in the 2013 Act, there is no prohibition on the Court to take into account the sale deeds reflecting a price lower than what was assessed by the LAC. The only bar is that the market value cannot be assessed below the amount assessed by the LAC. In fact, Section 26 of the RFCTLARR Act 2013 provides for a totally different approach for the assessment of the market value of the acquired land. Further, the RC has not noticed that the market value arrived at, under sub-section (1) to Section 26 of the RFCTLARR Act 2013 was required to be multiplied by the relevant factor.

4.10 In the award, passed by the RC on 09.11.2018 and 19.08.2019, the same Presiding Judge has relied upon its previous award dated

21.09.2018. The RC found that the sale deeds No. 7860 (dated 08.11.2011), 5227 (dated 28.11.2013) and 4372 (dated 12.11.2012) are post the date of notification under Section 4 of the 1894 Act, therefore, it cannot be relied upon. However, vide award dated 28.08.2019, the RC relies upon the sale deed 4151 (dated 13.12.2010) with respect to the plot measuring 310 square yards, which has been sold for 6,51,000/-. The RC, after calculating the per ₹ acre rate @ 1,01,64,000/-, applied the deduction of 1/3rd to arrive at a ₹ figure of 67,76,000/- per acre.

₹ 5.

DECISION:

5.1 For the reasons stated above, it is considered appropriate to remit the matter back to the RC for deciding the matters afresh, after granting an opportunity to the parties to lead further evidence, if any. Let the RC decide the matter within a period of six months, from today. 5.2 With the observations made above, all the appeals as well as cross-objections are disposed of.

5.3 The parties are directed to appear before the RC on 06.07.2022. 5.4 The miscellaneous application(s) pending, if any, in all the appeals, shall stand disposed of.

(Anil Kshetarpal) Judge May 10, 2022 "DK"

Whether speaking/reasoned :Yes/No Whether reportable : Yes/No Sr. No.

Case No.

Party's Name 1.

RFA-1735-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT. RAJBALA AND OTHERS 2.

RFA-1737-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PADAM SINGH AND OTHERS 3.

RFA-1756-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S

SURESH KUMAR MUDGAL AND ANOTHER 4.

RFA-1481-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S RUDRAKSH BUILDCON PVT. LTD. AND ANR 5.

RFA-1190-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S AKASH BUILDROP PRIVATE LIMITED AND ANOTHER 6.

RFA-1729-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PADAM SINGH AND OTHERS 7.

RFA-1478-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S JAI NARAIN AND OTHERS 8.

RFA-1749-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S DHANPATI AND ORS 9.

RFA-1752-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S NARAYAN SINGH AND OTHERS 10.

RFA-1187-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S RADHESHYAM REAL ESTATES PVT LTD AND ANR 11.

RFA-1483-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S RAJBALA AND OTHERS 12.

RFA-1484-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S RADHESHYAM REAL ESTATES PRIVATE LIMITED AND ANOTHER 13.

RFA-1192-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S SANYOGITA ESTATES PVT LTD AND ANR 14.

RFA-1743-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S AMAR SINGH AND ANOTHER 15.

RFA-925-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PARTIBHA AND ANOTHER 16.

RFA-1747-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S BALWAN AND ANOTHER 17.

RFA-1757-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT. MIRA DEVI AND OTHERS 18.

RFA-926-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S SMT. RAJBALA AND OTHERS 19.

RFA-1738-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S RAN SINGH AND ANOTHER 20.

RFA-1741-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S DHARAMPAL AND ANOTHER 21.

RFA-1744-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S KAMLESH AND OTHERS 22.

RFA-1733-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S VIJAYPAL AND OTHERS 23.

RFA-1734-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT. RAJBALA AND OTHERS 24.

RFA-1753-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SANTOSH AND ANOTHER 25.

RFA-920-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S RAJ GURU AND OTHERS

26.

RFA-923-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S DHAN SINGH AND OTHERS 27.

RFA-1479-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR.

V/S JAI NARAIN AND ORS 28.

RFA-1487-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S JAI NARAIN AND ORS 29.

RFA-921-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT. CHANDERMUKHI AND OTHERS 30.

RFA-764-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S KAMDHEU BUILDTECH PIRVATE LTD AND ANR 31.

RFA-1739-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PREM SINGH AND OTHERS 32.

RFA-1727-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS V/S ROCKY BUILDCON PRIVATE LTD.

33.

RFA-1482-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S SURESH KUMAR AND OTHER 34.

RFA-1748-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S SMT. MAMTA AND ANR 35.

RFA-1759-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S NAHANTU (SINCE DECEASED) 36.

RFA-1477-2019 STATE OF HARYANA V/S JAIGOPAL AND OTHERS 37.

RFA-1754-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S JAI SINGH AND OTHERS 38.

RFA-1728-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PADAM SINGH AND OTHERS 39.

RFA-1188-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS ANR V/S KAMDHENU BUILDTECH PVT LTD AND ANR 40.

RFA-1742-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S RAM PARSHAD AND ANOTHER 41.

RFA-1745-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S KAMLESH AND OTHERS 42.

RFA-1755-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SANYOGITA ESTATES PVT LTD AND ANOTHER 43.

RFA-1758-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SURESH KUMAR AND OTHERS 44.

RFA-1731-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PADAM SINGH AND OTHERS 45.

RFA-1191-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S KAISER BUILDCON PVT LTD. AND ANR 46.

RFA-1193-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S NARENDER KUMAR AND ANOTHER 47.

RFA-1740-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SHIV CHARAN AND OTHERS 48.

RFA-1746-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PAWAN AND OTHERS 49.

RFA-1750-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S MAHABIR AND OTHERS

50.

RFA-1751-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SH. DESHRAJ AND OTHERS 51.

RFA-1732-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S MAHIPAL AND OTHERS 52.

RFA-1475-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT. SUNITA AND ANOTHER 53.

RFA-1486-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S BALRAJ AND ORS 54.

RFA-1485-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S KAISER BUILDCON PVT. LTD. AND ANR 55.

RFA-1730-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PADAM SINGH AND OTHERS 56.

RFA-1736-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S JAI NARAIN AND OTHERS 57.

RFA-1760-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PADAM SINGH AND OTHERS 58.

RFA-1761-2019 THE STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S PADAM SINGH AND ORS 59.

RFA-922-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT. CHANDERMUKHI AND OTHERS 60.

RFA-924-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT. PREM AND OTHERS 61.

RFA-1480-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S RUDRAKHS BUILDCON PVT LTD AND ANR 62.

RFA-1476-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR.

V/S JAIGOPAL AND OTHERS 63.

RFA-1189-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S AKASH BUILDROP PRIVATE LIMITED AND ANOTHER 64.

XOBJR-31-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PADAM SINGH AND OTHERS 65.

XOBJR-27-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PADAM SINGH AND OTHERS 66.

XOBJR-29-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S PADAM SINGH 67.

XOBJR-33-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PADAM SINGH AND OTHERS 68.

XOBJR-32-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PADAM SINGH AND OTHERS 69.

XOBJR-34-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PADAM SINGH AND OTHERS 70.

XOBJR-39-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S PADAM SINGH AND ORS 71.

XOBJR-14-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S RAJ GURU AND ORS 72.

RFA-416-2019 DHAN SINGH AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 73.

RFA-537-2019 SMT. RAJBALA AND OTHERS V/S

STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 74.

RFA-575-2019 SMT.

SUNITA V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 75.

RFA-411-2019 JAI NARAIN AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 76.

RFA-743-2019 SMT. RAJBALA AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 77.

RFA-410-2019 MIRA DEVI AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 78.

RFA-1802-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S SMT. SARVAN AND ANOTHER 79.

RFA-418-2019 DESH RAJ AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 80.

RFA-414-2019 PAWAN AND ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 81.

RFA-415-2019 SURESH KUMAR AND ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 82.

RFA-417-2019 VIJAY PAL AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 83.

RFA-419-2019 JAI NARAIN AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 84.

RFA-420-2019 JAIGOPAL AND ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 85.

RFA-1765-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S DHARAMBIR AND ANOTHER 86.

RFA-1771-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S RAJROOP AND ORS 87.

RFA-1770-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S MAHABIR AND ANOTHER 88.

RFA-1763-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SUKHBIR AND OTHERS 89.

RFA-1801-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PARTIMA AND ANOTHER 90.

RFA-1769-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S RAJBALA AND OTHERS 91.

RFA-538-2019 SMT. RAJBALA AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 92.

RFA-1278-2019 MAHABIR AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 93.

RFA-1766-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S NARENDER AND OTHERS 94.

RFA-576-2019 JAI SINGH AND ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 95.

RFA-1764-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S SMT. RAJBALA AND ORS 96.

RFA-409-2019 SURESH KUMAR AND ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS

97.

RFA-741-2019 SMT. RAJBALA AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 98.

RFA-1230-2019 BALRAJ AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 99.

RFA-790-2019 SMT. DHANPATI (DECEASED) THRU HER LRS AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 100.

RFA-1276-2019 RAVINDER AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 101.

RFA-1275-2019 RAJBALA AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 102.

RFA-1767-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S MOHIT AND OTHERS 103.

RFA-1529-2019 MOHIT AND ANOTHER V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 104.

RFA-1277-2019 MAHABIR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 105.

RFA-1332-2019 JYOTI V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 106.

RFA-742-2019 SMT. RAJBALA AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 107.

RFA-577-2019 SMT. CHANDERMUKHI AND ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 108.

RFA-1200-2019 PARTIMA V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 109.

RFA-145-2019 PRATIBHA V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 110.

RFA-407-2019 JAI NARAIN AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 111.

RFA-408-2019 JAI NARAIN AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 112.

RFA-421-2019 SMT.

PREM AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 113.

RFA-1762-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PADAM SINGH AND OTHERS 114.

RFA-1768-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S RAVINDER AND OTHERS 115.

RFA-406-2019 SMT. CHANDERMUKHI AND ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 116.

RFA-412-2019 JAI GOPAL AND ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 117.

RFA-413-2019 RAN SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 118.

RFA-1530-2019 NARENDER KUMAR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 119.

RFA-2904-2019 KAMDHENU BUILDTECH PRIVATE LIMITED V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.

120.

RFA-3056-2019 KAISER BUILDCON PVT. LTD.

V/S

STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.

121.

RFA-2515-2019 PREM SINGH THROUGH LRS AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 122.

RFA-3059-2019 RADHESHYAM REAL ESTATES PVT. LTD. V/S STATE OF HARYNAN AND ORS 123.

RFA-2203-2019 AMAR SINGH (DECEASED THROUGH HIS LRS) V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 124.

XOBJR-30-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR V/S PADAM SINGH 125.

RFA-382-2020 SARVAN (NOW DECEASED) THROUGH HER LRS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 126.

RFA-3024-2019 RUDRAKSH BUILDROP PRIVATE LIMITED V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 127.

RFA-2902-2019 SANYOGITA ESTATES PRIVATE LIMITED V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 128.

RFA-4413-2019 SHIV CHARAN AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 129.

RFA-3057-2019 ROCKY BUILDCON PVT. LTD.

V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 130.

XOBJR-36-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PADAM SINGH AND ORS 131.

RFA-3062-2019 KAMDHENU BUIDTECH PRIVATE LIMITED V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 132.

RFA-3063-2019 AKASH BUILDROP PRIVATE LIMITED V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 133.

RFA-2900-2019 RADHESHYAM REAL ESTATES PRIVATE LIMITED V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 134.

RFA-3060-2019 AKASH BUILDROP PRIVATE LIMITED V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 135.

RFA-3061-2019 SANYOGITA ESTATES PRIVATE LIMITED V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 136.

RFA-3055-2019 RUDRAKSH BUILDROP PRIVATE LIMITED V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 137.

RFA-4394-2019 DHARAMPAL V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 138.

RFA-4393-2019 RAM PRASHAD V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 139.

RFA-2903-2019 KAISER BUILDCON PRIVATE LTD V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 140.

RFA-3768-2019 SMT. SHANTI AND OTHERS V/S THE STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 141.

RFA-613-2020 SHRI NIWAS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 142.

RFA-2668-2019 BHAGWANA AND ANOTHER V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS

143.

RFA-2587-2019 POHAP SINGH AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 144.

RFA-2622-2019 DILBAG AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 145.

RFA-4353-2019 BALBIR V/S THE STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 146.

RFA-169-2020 GURDAS SINGH AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 147.

RFA-3681-2019 SMT.

BALA AND OTHERS V/S THE STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 148.

RFA-368-2020 SMT.

BULBUL V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 149.

RFA-2588-2019 SULTAN V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 150.

RFA-3127-2019 SMT.

POOJA V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 151.

RFA-456-2020 MALIK RAM AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 152.

RFA-3505-2019 LAJPAT RAI AND OTHERS V/S THE STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 153.

RFA-3683-2019 SMT. RAJ BALA @ BALA AND ORS V/S THE STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 154.

RFA-1865-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S BHARAT SINGH DECEASED THROUGH HIS LRS AND ANOTHER 155.

RFA-1863-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT. BALA AND OTHERS 156.

RFA-1860-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S BALBIR AND ANOTHER 157.

RFA-1855-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT BULBUL AND ANOTHER 158.

RFA-1851-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S GURDAS SINGH AND OTHERS 159.

RFA-3654-2019 CHANDER BHAN AND ORS.

V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 160.

RFA-1816-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S MALIK RAM AND OTHERS 161.

RFA-1822-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SULTAN AND ANOTHER 162.

RFA-1835-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S RAJU AND ANR.

163.

RFA-1829-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S CHANDER BHAN AND OTHERS 164.

RFA-1828-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT. POOJA AND ANOTHER 165.

RFA-1843-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S DILBAG AND OTHERS 166.

RFA-1849-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S

LAJPAT RAI AND OTHERS 167.

RFA-1795-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT. RAJ BALA ALIAS BALA AND OTHERS 168.

RFA-1874-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S BHAGWANA AND OTHERS 169.

RFA-1877-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT SHANTI AND OTHERS 170.

RFA-1793-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S RAHUL AND OTHERS 171.

RFA-1838-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S POHAP SINGH AND OTHERS 172.

RFA-1837-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PREM AND OTHERS 173.

RFA-1796-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SHRI NIWAS AND ANOTHER 174.

RFA-403-2019 CHATAR SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 175.

RFA-1659-2019 RAVINDER SINGH AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 176.

RFA-1655-2019 SUBHASH CHAND AND ANOTHER V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 177.

RFA-399-2019 RAJENDER PARSAD AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 178.

RFA-402-2019 AKHE RAM V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 179.

RFA-631-2019 BALA DEVI AND ORS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 180.

RFA-1656-2019 SUBHASH CHAND AND ANOTHER V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 181.

RFA-1295-2019 SAJJAN KUMARI @ SANJJAN KUMARI V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 182.

RFA-1294-2019 SAJJAN KUMARI @ SANJJAN KUMARI V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 183.

RFA-401-2019 JAI SINGH AND ANR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 184.

RFA-400-2019 BIJENDER SINGH V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 185.

RFA-3133-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S RAMSUKH AND OTHERS 186.

RFA-3136-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT PARVEEN AND ANOTHER 187.

RFA-3139-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S RAJENDER PARSAD AND OTHERS 188.

RFA-3143-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S JAI SINGH AND OTHERS 189.

RFA-2645-2019 RAMSUKH AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS

190.

RFA-3058-2019 DARIYA V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS 191.

RFA-3135-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S DARIYA AND ANOTHER 192.

RFA-3142-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SUBHASH CHAND AND OTHERS 193.

RFA-347-2020 HARENDER AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 194.

RFA-3162-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S MAAN SINGH AND ANOTHER 195.

RFA-3144-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S BIJENDER SINGH AND ANOTHER 196.

RFA-3131-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S AKHE RAM AND ANOTHER 197.

RFA-3134-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S CHATAR SINGH AND ANOTHER 198.

RFA-3138-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S RAVINDER SINGH AND OTHERS 199.

RFA-3141-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SUBHASH CHAND AND OTHERS 200.

RFA-3137-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT. SANTOSH AND ANOTHER 201.

RFA-3514-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S NAHANTU (SINCE DECEASED) THROUGH HIS LRS AND OTHERS 202.

RFA-3132-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S PAWAN KUMAR AND ANOTHER 203.

RFA-3130-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S BALA DEVI AND OTHERS 204.

RFA-3161-2019 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S HARENDER AND OTHERS 205.

RFA-1078-2021 NAHANTU SINCE DECEASED THROUGH HIS LRS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 206.

RFA-2610-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SAJJAN KUMARI AND ANOTHER 207.

RFA-2611-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SANJJAN KUMARI AND ANOTHER 208.

RFA-3652-2019 SMT. SUDESH AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 209.

XOBJR-62-2022 SMT SUDESH AND OTHERS V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 210.

RFA-582-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S DAYA KAUR AND ANR 211.

RFA-45-2020 KAMLA V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 212.

RFA-48-2020 MANOJ KUMAR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS

213.

RFA-47-2020 DAYA KAUR V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 214.

RFA-46-2020 OMPATI V/S STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 215.

RFA-586-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S MANOJ KUMAR AND ANR 216.

RFA-583-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT. KAMLA AND ANR 217.

RFA-587-2021 STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER V/S SMT. OMPATI AND ANR (Anil Kshetarpal) Judge May 10, 2022 "DK"