Mickey Prem Singh v. Kiran Bhagat
2023:PHHC:157344-DB
! " # $ %! & !!"
"
! " # $ %! & !!"
" ! ""
" ! ""
"
'"!( !) !")*"
! ! "
+ $"") !")*"
"
"#! ( ! *"
!+ " ", !! ! -" * !, ! *!" !
.
/00
!+ *+"
! ! "0
+! !! " "
1 " !"
) , + "
"" " *"
2 !! ") 334* " 5"
"67 * + ) ,! + "
!
" ! $""8)9 ! ! ), ! .
/00
:) ! ""
1 "! *""" *
;
< 1! " ! + "
! 9 8 4 $ 7) =!!4 ! 7 > 3
:
? " *!" ! "
!! +", "
!" ,! @ >
) ! 2 " ! !" ! ( + "*"
,
""
"*"
!!)"
"0,*,! !! ! ! /** 1!+), !"
! ! "0 ,! ! ! ! "!" 427 & !!" " 9!" A"!"9 ! > ( "" * +"
! ! " "! ! !" **! "+ ! "
!"*"
"0 ,*! ! @"
! ! "0 +! " !
1+!"9 !! "!"!*!"! ! "! *
!"9 ! !
B",!*"
! "
"" "
"0,*"-! ,"
"
! ! " "! C "
"
! ! " " "
"0 ,*" !*" !"9 !! ! ! !"" +!,!" * %! !) %! ! %! ! (! ) "
+ ! " ! C "
!" , "
! ! " ! " ! !
"!"" !*! * " ) * , !+"*"
! ! "0,*, " , )+" !+!" !" ! , "
! ! " ! "
C"
!", "
! ! "! !+""
) "!" !+ ! ! * ! ! ! " !" > :
)"
! ! """
""9 !)+"
;< "
, ! ! !**" ",! "
! ! ") ,! "" "
, B" ,! " *"
! "
"" "
! ! " ! ! ! " " ' ! ! " ! ! "* 3 ! ,"
"
"! ! "! +"
"
!"
! + ! + "
, '+! !" +! * ! #B " "+) ) +" "
"0,* " " ) ! " "
* 3)E0 * ! !" * "" ( !*")
) ! " ,! + ! " * "
! ! " ,"
"
! " ! *! + * "
"0,* ! "
"0,* ! ! "
!" , + ! ( !" ""
!" "
!" ! " D
/
)"
+"
*"*9 !!
! ! +! " 9 ! ! " +!" $,! !
) "
*" * 9 ! ( *"
! "
!" " 1 ", !6 "!!" 'F" & !!""
"8! B """ *! ! "! ! +!)" "! "! ! ** !" "
! * "
"0,* / 3
>) "
"0,* ! " 9 ! ! ! "
" " 9 !
>) ! !" !" ! *",! B",!*"
!"
!" ! "
* "
! ! " F
>) +" " ** ! " "
! ! " ! *! + ( "0,* * " 1 " !! ! ! +!"
!" * !"
;>< "0,* !! "
! +"
" "
+"
* "
+! !" 9 ! !
> ! "
!"
,! " "
,* "
+! ! ,! !!+ * !" "
!! ( "0,* !* !*! ! "!"
3 +* "
1!+ "!" G 9 ) ! ! ) * ! !" !! ""
! *! +! !! "
! ! "
!+ "
! *! !* " "
* ! *" !" ! !"9 ! !
> ! ! "!" "
!! " "
! ! " "
* "
"" * "
G * "
$"# "
( ) "
"" )",!!"
!" + !) "! !"*"
,*) !! "! """
! ! "! "
!" ! *""
! *"
! ! ","
"! 1"*!+ ? ")"
"0,*!!! *
,"" "!" " "
! " * " ! " B",! !"
"" * +"
! ! "0 +! ,! ! "0+ !" " "
"" * + "0,* " *"
")*""" * 1! " B",!*"
!"
"0 ,* ,! ! " +! " !" ! ) +" "
"0 +! ! *! +, "!" "!"
"0,*+!""
!" ! B",! *"
! + "
" "
!" " ,! "
+! ) , " "
!" , ! 1+!"9 !
;3< ! +!!"! " ," "
"
! !"" "
! * "
( " ' + "
!" ! "
!" ! ! "+" ! *
))E0 * "
! ) +" " "
" ,! ! ! *"
! "
+ " " "" * ! "
* 3)E0 ! ! !" ! B",!*"
"!""
"0 ,*,!!! , "1 "
! *"
! ! "0
+! ! ) "
! +"
) ! -" "
! ! "0 +! " "! +! " "
!" ! ) +""
! ! "0 +! ) !* !" *" / "
+!*"
! *"
!")"
"! 9" *!"
* , 0 H "
"
"" "" " * "
* "I/
"
"
"" "" " * "
*" I/ "
"
""" "! "! !+ ,* !+1" = I/ > "
"
"" "* " ! !"! *!"*"
9"I/ "
"
"" " * * "
""" I/ * J :
B )"
! ! "!!!G0! !! F! G 0K ! G0$ + ! 9 ! % !"! !) + " "! 'F +" " / "
"
! )"
",*!!!G
;D< ! !! " "! 'F +" " ! GE
( "! 9")!*" "
+ !" ! "
! ! "0 +! *! " "0,* ! "!" ,"
"
! "
,"
" ! ! !+ !
)"
"" * +"
! ! ",!
!! ""
1 "*"
"! 9")"
! ! " !*"
"!!
A! !! * "
! ! " ! " !"
!" "
"" )"
! ! " ! *! !"
!! "
"! " ! + "
"0,* ! "
!"" " "
!*! ! !"
"
! ,! ! ) )+""
!" ,*"
*/: * 9 * 9 ) ! ! " " ! + ! "
!" * "
"0,* ! ! "
1 " * "
2 6+ 9" $'() "$' $%& *+',)- .-! /$)0$ )$-$& '(%1'(%/$2$$%&*+',)-# 345"3! 0
A! * "
! ! " , *"
+" "
!" " * "
+ "
!" * "
"0,*,!"!" ! "-! "" $ "!,"
"
! ! "0 +! "
! "
!" ! ) ! , ! ! !**" ",!"
! ! "! !"
"!" ,"
"! !, ! ! " ( "0,* !
;< "! !" ! ! E!"9 ! "
! * "
, * "
! ! ") * :: ! ( ! ! " !" ! "! **""! !" ! )+"",!"
"0,*), ! ! " " " ! + !" ! ! ,* ! !"
!""
! ! "! !*" ! *""
!" ! ,"
"! 1"*!+ !) ! ""+! ( *!")! ""
! * "
! ! ") ! * "
" * "
"0,*
B" *"
" "
+! ) , !! !G)"!""
" "! "
"" ! "
!" 0F! !" )
"" " + ! + "
"0,* ( ) "
"! "
F! !" 0 0 *) " " !+ !)+"
"! 9"
2,) ! "! 9") ! + ! "
! !" * "
!"" ! " ! "
1 " ! A! * "
! ! " , *"
+" !" "0,*
! !!" !! !" * "
! ! ") ! ) ! "
! !" * + !!+ * !" "
!!! "
" *! "" "! " *"
+" "
!" " "
+! 6 "" "
! ! 0! ) +" G0$ + ! 9 ! % !"! !) "" *! "
;:< "0,* ! * " * ! !" ! "
!!"*"
! ! "0 +! B""
)+"""
!" , "
! !" * !!"!! !" !)"
! "" "!* " " * ! ! ! & 1 "*"
9" "6+!$)%&,)7$().-! +!*2! $8%&,) $2"%9' '22*%#4 8253! > A! * "
! ! " , *"
+" "
!" " "
* 1! " ! + +"! + "
"0,*) ! " 1 "
! *"
! ! "0 +! ! "
!*!" ,"
!" """ ) , ! 0,! ! ! ! " *!" "
" * "
! ! " "
"" " *"
) " " "
!" +! "
!! ", "
*""" * 1! "
! + ! ") * " !+"!" ) " "" ** !"" ! ! ! & 1 "*"
9" "$%+*-'7(6$) .-!*'$% $2#3 : ! 3 A! * "
! ! " , *"
! "
!" * * " ! " +* " ! !"
" + "0,* ! " " ") ! ! "
! ! ") "
! " ! " * ! ! " , ! "
, !! !
!" D / "
"
! ) ! * "
"0,*) , "" "
+ ! +
;
< ! * "
! ! ") +" "
"0,* ! ! ,! + ! " ! ! , " 1 "
! * "
+! ! " "
! ! "0 +! ), ! " !+ "!" !" ! A! * "
" , *"
+" "
! "! 9" ! " "
! ! "0 !*! ""
! !" ! * !+ ! * "
! ! + "
"0 ,*) ! ! "F! "
)! ! "! "
*! +)+*, !+
!! + :
B"*"
" "
"" ,! * + "
+!
D) , ! "
"" * """ * 1! " ,! * + "
"0,*
D ( ! , "
"" " * "
" * + "
+! !" ! !" " * ") ,! ! "+ !" " " "" *""" * 1! "
A! * "
"0,* , *"
" "
"" * G 0K ! G0$ + ! 9 ! % !"! !) , " ! E "
! !" * " ! " + " ! ! "0 +! 2 *"
! "
!" !"
"
! ," ) + *! * * "
! " * "
+! ) ! + "* "
!" ! * * "
!" ! +! G0$ + ! !
;< % !"! !)"!""
"0,* !* "* ! !" ! "
!!" * "
+* ) " "
"0,* ! !! !" "
!!" * "
+! A! * "
"0,* *"
" "
!" " " ! "! ! !" ,"
+! ! "
!" ! ! , " ! 1 " ! * +!
G ! ! "
! * "
!" ! ,"
"
!"! ) !! "
"
* !
"!+)"
"! 9" !*! = ! ! " ! " / "+"
! ) ,! "
+! B" ! !""*!" "
! ! "0 ! 1+ !"9 !), !"
"0,*,!E!K " $" 1!+ ( *!"! " ! !" "
!" ""
!" 9 ! ! ! !)*""" A! "
! * *"
+ "
"
) , " "! "! ** ! !! 1 ! "
6! )! "+! " "! ! !" *" ( ! "
!*1 " "
*" "
!"" , * !" ! *" "
! * "
"
,"
" ! 1"*!)"
+! "
!" ! ! " ,!+ !**! $" * "
* !" ! !**! ! " " ! !+! " * " ! * "
;< ,"
" "
6 " ! ,"
" ! 1"*!+ ! ( ! + !) , "
!" " + *)""
!"" "! , !" !"! "
L$" 6 ! " " ! ) ! " *! ! !+! "* +"
"
,"
" "
6 "! ,"
"! !+ ! B " "
" ) "
", 0 " * 47 "
*!" * !!" ) ! 47 "
" " " + !+"!" ! " "! 4! 7)"+"!+ 2 6+ 9" $)-'$%(;+$.-! $&'0$(;+$# 7 99) ! "
!" +! +! ! ,* !"! !!" )! "+! * " ,* ! ,"
!, *"
! *"
+! B""" !, " " "
! *!" * !!" ! "
! " " "
!"*"
" "+ !+"!" "! "
2,) "
! ! ) "
*!" ! "! ,"
"
! ! + "
! ! "0 +! "
!" , +"" + "
"0 ,*) ! "!+ "
!+ * "
" * " ( ! * "
! ! !" "
"0,* ! *" !" ! ) !" !+ " "
! !!" )""
""" "! " " ), !""
"0,*,! !
; < " " "1 "
! *"
+! ! E"
!" !
> 2 ),* "
"! 9" ! " * ! *! " "
"0,* !"
9 ""
* " )"! "" !, " ! " + * "
"! "
! ! + * "
+! * "
" * "
!"C ! "
* "
* "
! "
"! G "!""
"
! *" * ",!"
!" * "+ 1! ! !+ ! * + 1 ! "!
! 1)"
*!"* "! +!"+ "
2,) "
! ! )"
! !+ +! "
"" , ,"!" , !! ! G ! ! ! "
"!" + !*"
,*C " , ! !**" ",!
! ! ! !" 9 ! !+" ! ! @ " -" 1+ !" 9 ! ! "" !" ! !
( "! "! "" "! ! "
!"* ! ,!! "!*"
!" ! * ( "! "! ** +", "
!" ! " + " " + " ( ! "! 9") !*" ! ! 1 " * "
2 6+ 9" ) ! " !" ! * "
+!
;<
2,) "
9" * "
*!" "
!" , *"
)! !!"!! !" *"
"
)"
!! "" "
:
B "
"! " !) "
+! "" ) !"
"0,* !) * " * ) ! "
! !" ! + !!+ **!"
! ! !" "
!! !! ! G) F! !" 0 0 *) ! "
!" A!!" ,! ," "! "
2,)"
! ! "0 ! *! " F! ! A!!" ! ! ," ( )"
! !+"
! ! "0 +! ) ""+ )! "+!" !+ B" ! + " "
!" "
* """ * 1! " +* "
9" !" ! ) "
!F! A!!"!!$G)+"*! " "
"! " ! B " "
! ) A!!" ! " ! "
! ! "
!!" !! !" *"
! ! "+"
"0,*
" *"
)"
"! *"
! ! "0 +! "
!" "0,* !+ "! "!" ,"
"
, ! *!" ) ,! " + ,! * ! "
! "
"
! "
+! ! !" ( +! F! !" 0 0 * "
"0,* ! ! * "
! ! " ! !**! ,"
! ! 2,) !! ," ) +* , ! + !) ,!
;>< F! + "
! ! "
( ! "
"!" ,"
!""
! ""
" !!+ ! ! ",! "
! ! " * " * %! ! %!,! F! ""
!*!"
!) "
) ! + ! + "
! *"
! ! "0 +! "
" * G0 $ + ! 9 ! % !"! !) F! !" 0 0 *)""
**""
"0,* !* "*"
! !" + !! ""
!!"*"
! ! "0
+! 2,) "
! ," ! "!" "
"0,* ! "
! !" *"
! ! "0
+! + !!+ * !" " !! ! !!" ! " !"
) 0 F! !" )"
!," "
" ! + ! ,"
"
! ! " M" *"
) "
" ! "! * ! " " "" ! "
*!" "
"0,* ! "" ! "
"
! +* ! G0$ + ! 9 ! % !"! ! !* " ( )"
!!"+ + !
! * "
1 " ! !" > 3
: ! + "
9 8 4 $ 7) =!! 4 ! 7 "
" * "
") , , "
!" , !! ! $G "
! ) "
! ! " 0F! !" !" ! " ! ), ,!"
!"" * " +", "
! ! " ! "
" ! "
;3< *"
!!= *"
!1 ")"
!" +", +! ! ,*4! ! "! "7 !+ "+"
!9"! 0 H ( ! " ! "
0 !, " ! , "
! "0 0 !,E"" " " "
*"" !"*"
)+"" "+ ""
!"*0! !+ ! ! * " + "" " +! !
+! )* !" !"9 !)! !
" "
! ,"
"
) , .B ( !0! !"
:
D1"! "
"* *"" ! ! 0! !+ "+ "E +! " ,* =+ ) D ", "
!*" * * "" ) , ! !++!" 5.
!-6 !+ ( !""
"
!" !*"* *"" )
+! ! ,*! "! "! ! ! ,* ! !" , ! " "
!" "
!" , !" *" ! + "
+", "
!") ! " * ! ,! ! "! * !! ! " * ! "!" , , ! " * !" !" ! " !+" ""
J " *"
) , * "
!" +"
"
," G ! G) F! + "
+! ) ! *!! !!"!" "
" +", "
!"! *"
!"
! + ) * "
!" ! ""
( "" *"
;D< "
"! "! ** +", "
!" =, )"
!," "
!," ! " ! " "
+! ! E *! + "
"0,* ! *" "
! * ! ! "0 +! ,"
"! 1"*! > ( ),* "
! ! "0 !*! ""
* " !+ "+"! !* ( ! , "
! ! "0 !*! " " ! ! "!" ! ,!! "! " """ " ( " + , " "! !+ !"" ""
3 ( ! " * "
! * "
! ! ""
"0,* ,"" "!" " " !"! "
! !" "! "
"" ! !! ! ! )+*"*" ! ,"" "!" ", ,"
"0,* ! "
" " * "
"" + , ! *"
" "
+! + " " "" * ! "
! ! !" ( ) "
1 " 8!
!
6!4!7)* ""
! ! "
D B =! %!6 ! 4!7) "
,* ! " !" " "
9 * * "
"!**) !! " "
+! ) , ,! ! /**) ! !" ! !!"! ! " B",! +"
9" !" !" !! !**""
!* +! ) , ,! ! +"! "! + * " " ! " B "
!!)"
"*"
;< ,* ," "",!!+!* "
!"
!!! !""
!!"* +! 2,) "
"! " !) "
"
) F" "
+! ! !" * "
+! ! "
!,!+ " ( *)"
!1 " ! "! !+ ""
*!"*"
"! " *"
)"
1 " ! " %!6! 4!7 "
!"! """
""" * 1! " ) * "
) !! " , !) *" !+"!" )"
!! "+!+!"* !"" B "
"! "!)! "!+)+"
"
, "! ) F" " *!" "
!" * """ * 1! " ,! ! " !" ! "*" :
B ,*"
!+), "* ! " "
"!! ! "
!+ *! ") + ,"
"
( ! "! ! " ! !"! .
/00
) ! "
* """ * 1! " / )"
!! !! ""
! * "
"" "! ) "
" "
! ! "6 ! ""
*""" * 1! " ( * +"
"! 9") " ,!! "! "*
;:< > B ,*"
! *.
/00
), " * ! " "
"!! !, 2 )"
" !! ! "
" "
,<,6=,)5#: "
! E! ME= "
"!+ ME=