← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/12/2022dismissed

Mickey Prem Singh v. Kiran Bhagat

2023-12-07Mr. Justice Sudhir Singh,Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel18 pages

2023:PHHC:157344-DB 

     



       

       

 ! " # $ %! & !!"

  "     

 ! " # $ %! & !!"

  "      ! ""

 "    ! ""

    "

 '"!( !) !")*"

! ! "

 + $"") !")*"

  "

 "#! (  ! *"

!+ " ", !!  !   -"  * !, !  *!" !    

.

/00 

!+ *+"

! ! "0

+!  !! " "

 1 " !"  

 ) , + "

""  " *"

2 !! ") 334*  " 5"

"67 *  + ) ,!  + "

 ! 

" ! $""8)9 ! ! ), ! .

/00

:) !  ""

1 "! *""" *

;

<  1!   " ! + "

 !  9  8 4  $ 7) =!!4 ! 7 > 3

:

   ? " *!" ! "

 !! +",  "

!" ,!   @    >

) !  2  " !   !" !  (  + "*"

, 

""

"*"

!!)"

  "0,*,! !! ! ! /**  1!+), !"

! ! "0 ,!   ! ! !  "!"  427   & !!" " 9!" A"!"9  ! > ( "" * +"

! ! " "!  ! !" **! "+ ! "

!"*"

  "0 ,*!  ! @"

! ! "0 +! " !

1+!"9  !! "!"!*!"!  ! "! *

!"9 ! !

B",!*"

! "

"" "

  "0,*"-! ,"

"

! ! "  "!  C "

  "

 ! ! " " "

   "0 ,*"  !*" !"9  !! !  ! !""  +!,!" * %! !) %! ! %! !  (! ) "

 + !  "  ! C "

!" ,   "

 ! ! " ! " ! !   

"!"" !*! * " ) *  , !+"*"

! ! "0,*, " , )+"  !+!" !" !   ,  "

! ! " ! "

C"

!",  "

! ! "! !+""

) "!" !+  !    ! *  ! ! !  " !"   > :

)"

! ! """

  ""9  !)+"

;<    "

  , !   !  !**"  ",! "

! ! ")   ,!  "" "

  , B" ,! " *"

 !   "

 ""  "

! ! " !  !  ! " " ' !  ! " !  ! "* 3 ! ,"

"

"! ! "! +"

"

!"

! +  !  + "

 , '+! !" +! * ! #B "    "+) ) +" "

   "0,*  " "  ) !  " "

  *  3)E0 * !  !"  * ""  ( !*")    

) ! "  ,!    +  ! " * "

 ! ! " ,"

 "

 ! " !  *!  + * "

   "0,* !  "

   "0,* ! ! "

!"   ,    + !  (  !"  ""

 !" "

 !" !   "  D 

   /   

)"

+"

 *"*9  !!  



!  ! +! " 9 ! !  "  +!" $,!  !     

) "

 *" * 9  !  ( *"

 ! "

!"    " 1  ", !6 "!!" 'F" & !!""

"8! B """ *! ! "! ! +!)" "! "!  !  ** !" "

!  * "

   "0,*   /  3 

>) "

   "0,* ! " 9 ! !   !  " 

 "  " 9  !    

>)   !  !" !" !   *",! B",!*"

!"

!" ! "

 * "

 ! ! " F  



>) +"   " ** !      " "

 ! ! " !   *!  +   (    "0,*   * " 1  "  !! ! !  +!" 

!" * !"

;><   "0,* !!   "

 !  +"

 " "

  +"

 * "

+!  !" 9 ! !     

> !  "

!"

,!  " "

,* "

+!  !  ,!  !!+  *  !"  "

!! (   "0,* !* !*!  ! "!"

 

3 +* "

  1!+ "!" G  9 ) ! ! )    * ! !" !! ""

!  *! +!  !! "

! ! "

!+    "

! *! !* " "

  * !  *" !" !  !"9 ! !  



>  ! !   "!" "

   !! " "

 ! ! "   "

   * "

 ""  * "

 G  * "

$"#   "

( ) "

"" )",!!"

!"  + !) "! !"*"

,*) !! "!   """

! ! "! "

!" ! *""

! *"

! ! ","

"! 1"*!+   ?  ")"

  "0,*!!! * 

 ,""  "!" "    "

 ! " *  " !  " B",!  !"

"" * +"

! ! "0 +!  ,! !  "0+ !" " "

 ""  *  +   "0,* "  *"

")*""" *  1!  " B",!*"

!"

  "0 ,* ,! ! "  +! "  !" !  ) +" "

  "0 +! !  *! +, "!" "!"

  "0,*+!""

!" !   B",! *"

 ! + "

   " "

!" " ,! "

+! ) , "  "

!" ,  !  1+!"9  !

;3< ! +!!"!  " ," "

  "

 ! !"" "

  !   * "

 ( " ' + "

!" !  "

!"  ! !   "+"   ! * 

))E0 * "

 ! ) +" " "

 " ,! !   !  *"

 ! "

+ " " "" * !  "

  *  3)E0 ! !  !"  ! B",!*"

"!""

  "0 ,*,!!! ,  "1 "

! *"

! ! "0

+!  !   )  "

 !  +"

) ! -" "

! ! "0 +!  " "!  +! " "

 !" !  ) +""

! ! "0 +! ) !* !" *"  / "

+!*"

 ! *"

!")"

"! 9" *!"

* ,  0 H "

 "

 ""    ""  "  *  "

 * "I/

"

 "

 ""    ""  "  *  "

 *" I/  "

"

 """  "! "! !+   ,*  !+1" = I/ > "

"

""  "* " ! !"! *!"*"

9"I/ "

 "

 ""   " * *   "

 """ I/  * J :

B  )"

! ! "!!!G0!  !!  F!  G 0K    !  G0$  + !  9 !  % !"! !) + "    "!   'F +"   " / "

"

! )"

  ",*!!!G

;D< !  !! "  "! 'F +" "  ! GE

( "! 9")!*"  "

  + !" !  "

! ! "0 +! *! "    "0,* !  "!"  ,"

  "  

! "

 ,"

" !  ! !+  !

  )"

"" * +"

! ! ",! 

!! ""

1 "*"

"! 9")"

! ! " !*"

 "!!

 A!     !!  * "

 ! ! " !   " !"

!" "

"" )"

! ! " ! *! !"

 !! "

 "! "  ! + "

   "0,* !  "

 !""  "   "

!*! ! !"

"

 ! ,!  !  ) )+""

!" ,*"

 */: *  9 * 9  )   !  !   " " ! +    !    "

 !" * "

   "0,*  !    !   "

 1 " * "

 2 6+   9"   $'() "$' $%& *+',)-  .-! /$)0$ )$-$& '(%1'(%/$2$$%&*+',)-# 345"3! 0

A!     * "

 ! ! " ,  *"

+" "

!"  " * "

 +   "

 !" * "

  "0,*,!"!" !  "-!   "" $  "!,"

"

! ! "0 +! " 

 !  "

 !" !  )  !   ,  !  ! !**" ",!"

! ! "! !"

"!"  ,"

 "! !, ! !  " (   "0,* !

;< "!  !" !  ! E!"9  !  "

 ! * "

 ,  * "

 ! ! ")    * :: !   ( ! ! " !"  ! "!  **""!  !" ! )+"",!"

  "0,*),   ! !    " "  "  !  + !"  ! ! ,* !  !"

 !""

! ! "! !*" !  *""

!" !  ,"

"! 1"*!+ !) !  ""+! ( *!")! ""

 !    * "

 ! ! ") !   * "

  " * "

  "0,* 

B"  *"

  "  "

+! ) ,  !! !G)"!""

 "  "!    "

  ""  !  "

!"    0F! !" )

 ""    " + !  + "

   "0,* ( ) "

    "!    "

 F! !" 0 0 *)  " " !+  !)+"

"! 9"

2,) !  "!  9") ! +  ! "

 ! !" * "

!"" !     " ! "

   1 " !    A!     * "

 ! ! " ,  *"

+" !"   "0,*

!    !!" !! !"  * "

 ! ! ")  ! )  !   "

! !"  *  +   !!+  *  !"  "

!!! "

" *! "" "!  "  *"

+" "

!" "   "

+! 6 ""    "

 ! !   0! ) +"   G0$  + !  9 !  % !"! !)    ""  *!   "

;:<   "0,* ! * "  *  ! !"  !  "

 !!"*"

! ! "0 +!  B""

)+"""

!" , "

! !" * !!"!! !" !)"

! "" "!* "   " *  !  ! !  &  1 "*"

 9" "6+!$)%&,)7$().-! +!*2! $8%&,) $2"%9' '22*%#4  8253! > A!     * "

 ! ! " ,  *"

+" "

!" " "

  *  1!   " !  +  +"!  + "

   "0,*)  ! " 1  "

! *"

! ! "0 +! ! "

!*!" ,"

!"  """   ) ,   !  0,!  !  !  !  " *!" "

  " * "

 ! ! "   "

  ""   "  *"

) "   "  "

!"   +! "

!! ", "

*""" * 1!  "

! +  ! ") * "   !+"!" )  "  ""  **  !""  !  !  !  &  1 "*"

9" "$%+*-'7(6$) .-!*'$% $2#3   : ! 3 A!     * "

 ! ! " ,  *"

! "

!" *   *  "   ! " +* "  ! !"

" +   "0,* ! " "  ")  !  !   "

 !  ! ") "

 ! " !  " *  ! ! " ,   !  "

 , !! ! 

 !" D /  "

 "

! ) !     * "

  "0,*) ,    ""  "

 +  ! +

;

<  !     * "

 ! ! ") +" "

  "0,* ! ! ,! +  !   "  ! !  ,   " 1  "

 !  * "

+!  !  "  "

! ! "0 +! ),  ! " !+ "!"   !" !    A!     * "

   " ,  *"

+" "

 !  "!  9" !  "    "

! ! "0 !*! ""

! !" !     * !+ !  * "

 ! ! + "

   "0 ,*) ! !  "F! "

 )!   ! "! "

*! +)+*,  !+

!!  +    :

B"*"

 " "

"" ,! *  + "

+!   



D) , ! "

""  * """  *  1!   " ,! *  + "

  "0,*    

D  (   !   , "

""    "   * "

" *  + "

+!  !" ! !"  " * ") ,! !  "+ !" " " "" *""" * 1!  " 

A!     * "

   "0,* ,  *"

  "  "

 ""  * G 0K    !  G0$  + !  9 !  % !"! !) ,  " ! E  "

 ! !"  *  " !  "    + " ! ! "0 +!    2 *"

 ! "

!" !"

 "

 ! ," ) +  *!  *  * "

 ! " * "

+! ) ! +   "*    "

 !" !  * * "

!" !    +! G0$  + ! ! 

;< % !"! !)"!""

  "0,* !* "* ! !"  !  "

  !!" * "

+* )     "   "

   "0,* !  !! !" "

  !!" * "

+!  A!     * "

   "0,* *"

  "  "

!"    " "  ! "!  !   !"  ,"

+!  !  "

!"    ! !  ,   "  !  1  " ! * +! 

 G ! ! "

 !     * "

 !" ! ,"

"

!"! ) !!  "

 "

* !



 "!+)"

"! 9" !*! = !  ! " !  " / "+"

 ! ) ,!   "

+!    B"  !  !""*!" "

! ! "0 ! 1+ !"9  !), !"

  "0,*,!E!K  " $"    1!+   (  *!"!  "      !   !" "

 !"  ""

 !" 9 ! !  !   !)*""" A! "

! * *"

 + "

 "

) ,  " "! "!  **  !   !! 1  ! "

6! )! "+! " "! ! !" *" ( ! "

!*1 "  "

*"    "

!"" ,   *  !"  ! *" "

 !  * "

 "

 ,"

" !  1"*!)"

+! "

!" ! ! "  ,!+  !**!   $"  * "

  * !" !  !**!  !   " " !  !+!   " * "  !  * "

;<  ,"

" "

6   " !  ,"

" !  1"*!+  !   (  ! + !) ,   "

 !"  " +     *)""

!""  "! ,  !"  !"! "

 

L$" 6 !   " " ! ) !  " *! ! !+!   "* +"

"

,"

" "

6  "! ,"

"! !+ ! B "  "

 " ) "

 ", 0 "  * 47 "

 *!" * !!" ) !  47 "

  " "  " +   !+"!"  !  " "!  4!  7)"+"!+   2 6+ 9" $)-'$%(;+$.-! $&'0$(;+$# 7 99) !  "

!" +! +! ! ,* !"! !!" )! "+!  * " ,* ! ,"

!, *"

! *"

+!  B"""  !,  "  "  "

  ! *!" * !!" ! "

!  " "  "

!"*"

"  "+  !+"!" "!  " 

 2,)   "

 !   ! ) "

 *!" !  "!    ,"

 "

  !  ! + "

! ! "0 +!  "

!" ,   +"" + "

   "0 ,*)  !  "!+   "

 !+  * "

   " * " (   !     * "

! ! !"   "

   "0,* ! *"  !" !  ) !" !+ " "

 !  !!" )""

"""        "!   " "    ),  !""

  "0,*,! ! 

; <  " " "1 "

! *"

+! ! E"

!" !  

> 2 ),* "

"! 9" ! " *  ! *!  "  "

  "0,* !" 

9 ""

* " )"! ""  !,  " ! " + *  "

"! "

! !  + *    "

 +! * "

  " * "

 !"C  !   "

   * "

 * "

 !  "

    "!  G  "!""

"

! *"  *  ",!"

!" * "+  1! ! !+  !    * +   1  !   "!  

!  1)"

*!"* "! +!"+ "

2,) "

!  ! )"

 ! !+ +!  "

"" ,  ,"!"     ,   !!  ! G ! ! ! "

 "!"  + !*"

,*C  " ,  ! !**" ",!

 !  !   !  !" 9  ! !+"  !  !  @   " -"  1+ !" 9  ! !  ""  !" ! !

( "!  "! "" "!  ! "

 !"* ! ,!! "!*"

!" !  *  (  "! "!  **  +",  "

 !" ! " + " " +  "   (  !  "!  9") !*" !   ! 1 " * "

2 6+  9"    ) !  "  !"    ! * "

+! 

;<

 2,) "

 9"    * "

 *!" "

!" ,   *"

)! !!"!! !" *"

"

)"

!! "" " 

:

B  "

  "! " !) "

+!     "" ) !"

  "0,* !) * " *   ) ! "

 ! !"  !   +   !!+ **!"

 !  !  !" "

!!   !!  ! G)    F! !" 0 0 *) ! "

!" A!!" ,! ," "!  "

  2,)"

! ! "0 ! *!  " F!  ! A!!" ! ! ,"  ( )"

 ! !+"

! ! "0 +! ) ""+ )! "+!" !+  B" ! + " "

!"   "

   * """  *  1!   " +* "

 9" !"  ! ) "

!F! A!!"!!$G)+"*! "   "

  "! " !  B   "    "

 !  ) A!!" !  "  ! "

  ! ! "

  !!" !! !" *"

! ! "+"

  "0,*

" *"

)"

"! *"

! ! "0 +! "

!"   "0,* !+ "!  "!" ,"

"

  ,  !   *!" ) ,! "  + ,! *   !  "

 !  "

   "

!  "

 +!  ! !"   ( +!     F! !" 0 0 *  "

   "0,* ! !  * "

! ! " !  !**! ,"

 !  !  2,) !!   ," ) +* ,     ! +  !) ,!

;>< F!  + "

 ! ! "

  (  !  "

 "!"  ,"

!""

! ""

  " !!+ ! ! ",! "

 ! ! "   * " *     %! ! %!,! F! ""

!*!"

    !) "

 ) ! +  ! + "

!   *"

! ! "0 +!  "

" * G0 $  + !  9 !  % !"! !)    F! !" 0 0  *)""

**""

  "0,* !* "*"

! !"   + !! ""

 !!"*"

! ! "0

+!   2,) "

 ! ,"  !  "!" "

  "0,* !  "

! !" *"

! ! "0

+!  +   !!+  *  !"  "  !!  !    !!"  ! "   !"

)    0 F! !" )"

!," "

  " !  + ! ,"

 "

 ! ! "       M" *"

) "

  "   !  "! * ! "   "  ""  !  "

 *!" "

   "0,* !  "" ! "

    "

 ! +* ! G0$  + !  9 !  % !"! ! !* " ( )"

 !!"+ +  !  

 !  * "

 1 " !   !" > 3

: ! + "

 9  8 4  $ 7)   =!! 4 ! 7   "

     "   * "

") ,   , "

!" ,   !!  ! $G   "

 !  ) "

 ! ! "    0F! !"   !" !  " ! ),  ,!"

!"" * " +",  "

 ! ! " !  "

   " !  " 

;3< *"

 !!= *"

!1 ")"

 !"  +",  +! ! ,*4! ! "!   "7 !+  "+"

!9"!  0 H  (   !    " !  "

  0 !, " ! ,  "

 ! "0 0 !,E""  "  " "

*""  !"*"

 )+"" "+ ""

!"*0!  !+  ! ! *   " + ""  " +!  ! 

+! )* !"  !"9  !)!  !

  "  "

 ! ,"

     "

)   ,  .B ( !0! !"

:

D1"! "

"*  *"" ! ! 0!  !+  "+   "E +!  "  ,*   =+ ) D    ",  "

 !*" *   * "" ) ,   !  !++!" 5.

!-6 !+  (   !""

   "

!" !*"*  *"" )

+! ! ,*! "!  "!  ! !   ,* !  !" ,   ! "     "

!"  "

!" , !" *"  ! +  "

 +",  "

 !")    ! " * !  ,! !  "! * !! !  " * !  "!"  ,   ,  ! "  *  !" !" ! "  !+" ""



J  "  *"

) , *  "

!" +"

 "

 ,"  G !  G) F!  + "

+! )    !    *!!  !!"!" "

" +", "

!"! *"

!"

 ! + ) * "

 !" !  ""

  (  ""  *"

;D<  "

 "! "!  **  +",  "

 !" =, )"

!," "

 !,"   !   " ! " "

+!  ! E  *!  +  "

   "0,* ! *" "

 !  * ! ! "0 +! ,"

"! 1"*! > ( ),* "

! ! "0 !*!  ""

 * " !+   "+"! !*  ( !  ,  "

! ! "0 !*!  "  "    ! !   "!"   !  ,!! "! " """ " (  "  +   ,  " "! !+ !"" ""

 3 (  ! " * "

 !     * "

! ! ""

  "0,*  ,"" "!" " "  !"!    "

 ! !"   "!    "

 ""  !  !! ! ! )+*"*" !  ,"" "!" ",  ,"

  "0,* !   "

  " " * "

 ""  +  ,  !  *"

 "  "

+!  + " " "" * !  "

 ! ! !"    ( ) "

 1 "   8!

 !

6!4!7)*   ""

! ! "

D B  =!  %!6 ! 4!7) "

 ,* !  "  !"  " "

 9 * * "

 "!**) !! " "

+! ) ,  ,! !    /**)    ! !"  !   !!"! ! " B",!  +"

9" !"   !"  !! !**""

!* +! ) ,  ,! !  +"! "!  + * " " !    " B "

!!)"

 "*"

;< ,* ,"   "",!!+!*   "

!"

!!! !""

 !!"* +!  2,) "

 "! " !) "

  "

    ) F" "

 +!  ! !"  * "

+!  !       "

 !,!+ "  ( *)"

!1 " !  "! !+ ""

*!"*"

 "!  " *"

)"

1 " ! " %!6! 4!7 "

!"! """

""" * 1!  " ) * "

 ) !! " ,      !) *" !+"!" )"

!! "+!+!"*  !"" B "

 "! "!)! "!+)+"

"

  ,     "!  ) F" "  *!" "

!"   * """  *  1!   " ,! ! " !" !  "*"  :

B ,*"

!+), "* ! " "

 "!! ! "

!+ *! ") + ,"

 "

  

( ! "!  ! "  !  !"!  .

/00 

) !   "

* """ * 1!  " / )"

!! !! ""

!  * "

  ""  "!  ) "

   " "

! ! "6 !  ""

*""" *  1!  " ( *  +"

"! 9") " ,!! "!  "* 

;:< > B ,*"

! *.

/00 

), " * ! " "

 "!! !, 2 )"

 " !! !   "

 "   "

     ,<,6=,)5#:  "

! E!  ME= "

"!+  ME=