State Of Haryana v. Mewa Singh And ORS

  
 

      
 

  

!"#$"%&'() *"*+"%&"#" ,--./0"#* 1+%2$2 +3" /#45"#6"#*5+%  , +2-#6+#*2 ! 78 9 
9 9 9  :8 9 
  


%+2+#*! %9 "%1++#5"6$(("%&"#"9

 
(9 9; 5+-%"&+%<"6+/#*5+"--./0"*/#/2*0#6#+*5+ 6+."&6"&2/#/./#4*5+-%+2+#*"--./0"*/#$#6+%2+0*/# ;= ;% 9 $/0/+#* 4%$#62 5"1+ >++# 253# /# *5+ "--./0"*/# % *5+ 0#6#"*/#  6+."&9  +#0+( *5+ 6+."& /2 0#6#+69

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

/0+9 3+1+%( "%$#6 )9 "9<(#99;("#/#%<"*/#3"2%+0+/1+6>&*5+-./0+ ">$**5+6+"*5"#-%++*A$"%9C5+%+$-#(*5+-./0+-"%*& %+"05+6*5+2-/*"."#6<+*/%<".(&$#4+%>%*5+%*5+ 6+0+"2+6(354*%+0%6+65/22*"*+<+#**5"*5+".#43/*5 5/22/2*+% 6+0+"2+63"2./1/#43/*5<"*+%#".$#0.+$%<"/./# 1/.."4+5/%"?2/#0+05/.65691+#*5+<"%%/"4+5/22/2*+% 3"2 2.+<#/D+6 >& 5/2 <"*+%#". $#0.+ # =99 3/*5 %+2-#6+#*#995+63%&"%*/0.+23+%+4/1+#>+&#6*5+/% 0"-"0/*&9  3 05/.

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

-#*5/22*"*+<+#*(%<".
3"2%+4/2*+%+69
#1+2*/4"*/# 3"2 0<<+#0+69  5+ %+2-#6+#*2 3+%+ "%%+2*+69  # 0<-.+*/#/#1+2*/4"*/#(05".."#3"2-%+2+#*+69

/#6/#4 " -%/<" "0/+ 0"2+( *5+ %+2-#6+#*2 3+%+ 05"%4+ 25++*+6 $#6+% +0*/#2 '( ;'( ; %+"6 3/*5 2+0*/# ;'
 * 35/05 *5+& -.+"6+6 #* 4$/.*& "#6 0."/<+6 *%/".9
#%6+%*-%1+/*20"2+(*5+-%2+0$*/#+E"</#+6 "2<"#&"2+.+1+#3/*#+22+29 5+ +#*/%+ /#0%/</#"*/#4 +1/6+#0+ 3"2 -$* * *5+ %+2-#6+#*2$#6+% +0*/#;;% 95+&-.+"6+6*5+/%".2+ /<-./0"*/#9

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

( "--+"%/#4%*5+ *"*+"%&"#"9 5+ <"%%/"4+ >+*3++# "#-%++* A"$% "#6 %+2-#6+#*95"6*"B+#-."0+#=999"#-%++*A$"% 5"62$+%+6>$%#/#?$%/+2#99;(3/*5/#2+1+#&+"%2 <"%%/"4+9 5+2$00$<>+6*5+%>$%#/#?$%/+29 5+ "$*5% 
( #"<+.&( /%<". /#45( 3"2 +E"</#+6 >& *5+ -%2+0$*/# "2 C)9  5/2 3/*#+22 %+*%"0*+6 %< 5/2 +"%./+% 1+%2/#( E9 F <"6+ * *5+ -./0+9  + 2-+0//0"..&6+-2+6*5"*5/22/2*+%"#-%++*A"$%3"2#*2+*# /%+>&-$%/#4 B+%2+#+ /.

+1+#6+-2+6*5"*5/22/2*+% 6+0+"2+63"2.+"6/#4"5"--&./+ /# *5+ <"*%/<#/". 5<+9 5+ +#*/%+ +1/6+#0+  *5/2 3/*#+22 2$44+2*2*5"**5+6+0+"2+63"2#*<$%6+%+695+2$%0+ /#%<"*/#  C $%<"/. /#45 "#6 C; ".3/#6+% /#45 3"2 C)/%<". /#4595+2+*33/*#+22+23+%+#**5++&+ 3/*#+22+2  *5+ "..+4+6 /#0/6+#*9  5+& 3+%+ #.& 5+"%2"& 3/*#+22+295+/%6+-2/*/#23+%+6/20"%6+6>&*5+.+"%#+6*%/". $%*# *5+ -%+</2+ *5"* 2/#0+ *5+ "$*5% 
 6+#/+6 *5+ "..+4"*/#2  -$%/#4 "#& B+%2+#+ /. # *5+ 6+0+"2+6( *5+%+%+(#%+./"#0+0$.6>+-."0+6#*5+6+-2/*/#2>*5 *5+2+3/*#+22+295+*%/".$%*".26/6#*/#6*5++1/6+#0+

C$%<"/. /#45"#6 C;".3/#6+% /#45"20%+6/>.+"#6 %+./">.+(>+0"$2+*5+&"#6 C)/%<". /#453+%+1+%&<$05 -%+2+#*#99;/#*5+52-/*".(>$**5+&6/6#*<"B+ "#&0<-."/#***5+-./0+#*5+1+%&2"<+6"&95+"0*$< *5+/%#*<"B/#4"#&0<-."/#*#*5+2"<+1+%&6"&3"2 %+0%6+6 >& C 
 "< /#45 /#   9= 6"*+6 99;9  5+   $%*5+% 2532 *5"* C) /%<". /#45 "#6 C$%<"/. /#455"6<+* C(>$**5+&%+$2+6*<"B+ "#&  2*"*+<+#* 3/*5 *5+ %/6+% *5"* *5+& 3$.6 <"B+ *5+ 2*"*+<+#*#*5+#+E*<%#/#491+#*5+6+-2/*/# C 
 "< /#45 0.+"%.& 2532 *5"*  C $%<"/. /#45 5"6 %+$2+6*<"B+"#&2*"*+<+#*#*5+4%$#6*5"*5+5"6# B#3.+64+ ">$* *5+ 00$%%+#0+ "#6 /* /2 #.& C) /%<".

) /#45( 35 0$.6 #"%%"*+ *5+ 2"<+9  C= 25B A$<"% 5"6 +#6%2+6 *5+ 1+%2/# %+0%6+6 /# *5+ "%+2"/6   >& C

"< /#45 
9  5+ <+6/0". +1/6+#0+ "1"/.">.+ # %+0%6 2$44+2*2*5"**5+6+0+"2+66/+66$+*>$%#/#?$%/+29
#0"2+( *5+<+6/0".+1/6+#0+"#60$."%1+%2/#"%+*"B+#*4+*5+%(/*/2 "--"%+#* # *5+ "0+  /* *5"* *5+ -%2+0$*/# 5"2 "/.+6 * -%1+*5"*25+3"2*%05+6>&*5+%+2-#6+#*29

$%*5+% <%+( *5+ -."2*/0 0"#( %+01+%+6 %< *5+ 2-*3"2#*2+#***5+ 8"65$>"#(#%"#&-/#/#*5+ 60*%3"22$45*"2*35+*5+%*5+/#?$%/+23+%+0"$2+63/*5 B+%2+#+ /.9   5$2( *5+ -%2+0$*/# 5"2 "/.+6 * -%1+ *5"* B+%2+#+/.3"2$2+6/#*5+"..+4+6/#0/6+#*9
# *5+ +#*/%+*&  *5+ "%+2"/6 +1/6+#0+( /* 0"# >+ 2"/6*5"*05"%4+$#6+% +0*/#;
5"2#*>++#-%1+6( 35/055"2%/45*.&>++#0#0.$6+6>&*5+*%/".$%*9 </#4 * *5+ -/#* *5"* *5+ 6+0+"2+6 5"6 6/+6 3/*5/# 2+1+# &+"%2  <"%%/"4+( *5+ #+0+22"%& /#4%+6/+#*2  63%&6+"*5"%+*5"*G2#>+%+*5+6+"*5H(*5+3<"#3"2 2$>?+0*+6 * 0%$+.*& % 5"%"22<+#* >& 5+% 5$2>"#6 % "#& %+."*/1+5+%5$2>"#6%"#6/#0##+0*/#3/*5"#&6+<"#6 63%&9
#*5+-%+2+#*0"2+(*5+%+/2."0B+1/6+#0+*5"* "#&6+<"#663%&3"2+1+%<"6+>&*5+%+2-#6+#*291+#

C "#6 C; /# %6+% * -%1+ *5"* *5+%+ 3"2 6+<"#6  63%& 5"6 <"6+ "# "**+<-* * 253 *5"* *5+ 6+0+"2+6 3"2

= 2$>?+0*+6 * 0%$+.*& % % /# 0##+0*/# 3/*5 "#& 6+<"#6  63%&( >$* 0$.6 #* 2$00++6( >+0"$2+ *5+%+ "%+ <"?% 1"%/"*/#2 /# *5+/% 6+-2/*/#2 35/05 0"2*2 6$>* /# *5+ -%2+0$*/# 2*%&9 %+ 2( 6$%/#4 /#1+2*/4"*/#(  ( /%2" $#6 %+2-#6+#* 9 "2 /##0+#*9  3+1+%( 3/*5$* "#& 04+#* %+"2#2( *5+
#1+2*/4"*/#4 /0+% -%+2+#*+6 05".."# "4"/#2*%+2-#6+#*9(/#"2<$05"2(5+5/<2+."6</**+6*5"* 6$%/#4 /#1+2*/4"*/# 5+ 0$.6 #* %+"05 *5+ 0#0.$2/# *5"* 35+*5+%%+2-#6+#*#93"2/##0+#*%4$/.*&95+6++#0+ 1+%2/# 0$.6 #* >+ %+>$**+6 >& *5+ -%2+0$*/#( 35/05 /*2+. 2532 *5"* *5+%+ 3"2 # 6+<"#6  63%& "#6 *5"* *5+ 6+0+"2+63"2#+1+%2$>?+0*+6*0%$+.

*&"#65"%"22+6%2$05 6+<"#69 
 *5+ "%+2"/6 +1/6+#0+  C) /%<". /#45( >%*5+%*5+6+0+"2+6(/2%+"6/#/*2+#*/%+*&*5"**5+6+0+"2+6 3"2 .+"6/#4 " 5"--& ./+( /# *5"* +1+#*$"./*&( /* 0"##* >+ /#+%%+6 >& "#& 2*%+*05  /<"4/#"*/# *5"* *5+%+ 3"2 "#& 6+<"#6  63%& % *5"* *5+ 6+0+"2+6 3"2 2$>?+0*+6* "#& 0%$+.*&%%/#0##+0*/#3/*52$056+<"#695+0#0.$2/# "%%/1+6 "* >& *5+ *%/". $%* *5"* # +#0+ $#6+%   2+0*/#2 ;'( '
 /2 <"6+ $* 6+2 #* %+@$/%+ "#& /#*+%+%+#0+(35/05/2>"2+6#"--%+0/"*/#+1/6+#0+9
#1/+3*5+"%+2"/66/20$22/#(3+/#6#<+%/* /#*5+-%+2+#*"--./0"*/#900%6/#4.&(*5+"--./0"*/#2++B/#4 4%"#*.+"1+*"--+"."4"/#2**5+?$64<+#*"0@$/**".

 '9 9' -"22+6 >& *5+ 66/*/#". +22/#2 $64+( /%2" /2 6/2</22+69

9 9 9 

 
     "#$"%&'() A