J.S. Prasad v. Deputy Director, Industrial Safety And Health




   
 

"#$%$&'(')*

 +,-'+ -"("%  $#'#')$- .$-(/( $0/#1'-$&#-2
)%/(#-'"3+"$#1")%$"3#,2

$4"-'2"-1")"

 $(0)%$)# *  56  +
7 6
+


-$($)#* -+-2%8&"#$2-#,$0$#'#')$- -,$#")+,"-9"2(('(#")#2"-1")"  :,$#,$-#,$ $0-#$-(3&"3)$4(0"0$-9"1;$"334$%#($$ #,$</%=9$)#>$(

;$-$$--$%##,$ $0-#$--)#$(  :,$#,$-#,$</%=9$)#(,/3%;$-$0-#$%')#,$%'=$(#>$(   6
+
2

$#'#')$-2  4,  ,"00$)(  #  ;$  #,$  $0/#1  $)$-"3 ")"=$- (/%-"$3,' '0$6')$ -<$&#')(,-#5 5! ')%/(#") $#-3$/9-0-"#')6#%')(,-#5 65!,"('3$%#,'( 0$#'#')"="')(##,$$0/#1'-$&#-2
)%/(#-'"3+"$#1")%$"3#,2

$4"-'2"-1")"2-?/"(,')=#,$&903"')#(;$"-')=  ")% 2%"#$%



@2'3$%/)%$-+$&#')A /3$(A2@ ")%+$&#')( 2B")% /3$@@#,$/'3%')=")% #,$- )(#-/&#'):-C$-( $=/3"#')90319$)#")%)%'#')( +$-8'&$! &#2  

  ')  (,-#  5/'3%')= &#  

5!  ))$D/-$ A 331!")%#,$(/99)')=-%$-%"#$%

))$D/-$ @!2 0"(($%;1#,$3$"-)$%,'$/%'&'"3"='(#-"#$2 $4"-'

 
#'((#"#$%#,"##,$0$#'#')$-'(")$9031$$ 6 ")%  '(  ,3%')=  #,$  0(#    $0/#1  $)$-"3  ")"=$-  0$-"#')(!   ,$   62  $4"-' 
2  '(  -$='(#$-$%  /)%$-  #,$

"&#-'$(  &#2   B@  -  (#-"=$  ")%  %'(#-';/#')    0$#-3$/9 0-%/&#(  ")%  '(  ,3%$-    3'&$)&$    + + AB @  %"#$%



))$D/-$ !")%#,$("9$'(-$)$4$%/0#

,$ 6 $4"-'
(/=,#"00-8"3/)%$-#,$ "&#-'$(&#2 B@-&)(#-/&#')#,$"%%'#')"3#")C(#(/003$9$)#$D'(#')= (#-"=$"&'3'#'$(4'#,')#,$)#''$%"-$""&#-10-$9'($(28'%$ "003'&"#')%"#$% @

,$,'$
)(0$&#-#,$ "&#-'$(2 "-1")"2  8'%$ 3$##$- %"#$% 

A  ))$D/-$ !2  =-")#$% #,$ "00-8"3  -  #,$  ("9$  &&-%')=312  #,$  0$#'#')$-  (#"-#$%  #,$ &)(#-/&#')  4-C  #,$-$"#$-  ,$  <;  4"(  ='8$)  #  %'$-$)# &)#-"&#-("(0$-#,$)"#/-$#,$<;,$-$(0)%$)#')(0$&#$% 6  $4"-' 
  )  

A  ")%  0-$0"-$%  #,$ 
)(0$&#')

$0-#))$D/-$ B!/)%$-#,$0-8'(')(/'3%')=&#


) #,$("'%')(0$&#')-$0-#2334')=8'3"#')(4$-$)#'&$%/)%$- #,$/'3%')=&#

* E"!

)%$-+$&#')A2 /3$A2@")% F,$ 9")"=$9$)#,"()#(/;9'##$%")"003'&"#')') -9 "3)=4'#,0-$(&-';$%$$-#,$-$='(#-"#') $(#";3'(,9$)# ;!

)%$-  +$&#')  B  F  ,$  )#'&$   &99$)&$9$)#&)(#-/&#')4-C,"()#;$$)($)# ##,$&)&$-)$%"/#,-'#1"(0-$(&-';$%

 &!

)%$-+$&#') /3$@@F,$9/(#$--33'()# 9"%$"8"'3";3$)%$9")%')-$(0$&#&)(#-/&#')( 4-C$-(/)%0-$($)#"##,$#'9$')(0$&#')G 6
 $4"-'4"(%'-$&#$%#0"1H"9/)##,$ ##"3&)(#-/&#')&(#)#,$;"('(#,$("'%
)(0$&#') $0-# %"#$%

A))$D/-$ B! (,4&"/($)#'&$/)%$-+$&#')(BA2B@")% #,$

&#4"('((/$%##,$0$#'#')$-)

@))$D/-$ ! %$#"'3$%-$0314"(='8$)
#'((#"#$%#,"#/)%$-+$&#')

%!#,$("'%/'3%')=&#

2#,$$(#";3'(,9$)#")%"&&/)#( /)%$-#,$ "&#-'$(&#2 B@2"-$$D&3/%$%#$-&)('%$-')=#,$ -$0312#,$0-$($)#&903"')#(,"8$;$$)'3$%;1#,$-$(0)%$)#")% #,$  0$#'#')$-  ,"(  ;$$)  (/99)$%2  8'%$  -%$-  %"#$% 

))$D/-$ @!20"(($%;1#,$3$"-)$%,'$/%'&'"3"='(#-"#$2

$4"-'
#'((#"#$%#,"##,$("'%/'3%')=&#

%$()#"0031# #,$0$#'#')$- #'&$4$-$'((/$%##,$-$(0)%$)#( $(0)%$)# 2')#,$-$0312"'-9$%#,"##,$')(0$&#')4"(&"--'$%/#")%#,"# #,$  ;/'3%')=  8'3"#')(2  "(  (#"#$%  ";8$2  4$-$  )#'&$%  ")%  #,$ 0-$($)#&903"')#(,"8$;$$)'3$%))$D/-$( A331!
#4"( (#"#$%#,"##,$0$#'#')$-&"))#"(("'33'";'3'#1#&90314'#,#,$ ("'%/'3%')=&#


,"8$,$"-%3$"-)$%&/)($3-#,$0"-#'$(")%,"8$ "3(&"-$/331=)$#,-/=,#,$'3$ %9'##$%312#,$0$#'#')$- 6'(-$='(#$-$%/)%$-#,$

B

"&#-'$(  &#2   B@  +$&#')  %!    #,$  /'3%')=  ")%  #,$- )(#-/&#'):-C$-( $=/3"#')90319$)#")%)%'#')( +$-8'&$!&#

2'(%$')$%"(/)%$-* E+$&#') %!

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
 

 


     

   

  

  

!"

  #$ ##$!  %G ,$-$-$2#,$&)(#-/&#')4-C2#4,'&,#,$ "&#-'$( &#2 B@"003'$(2,"(;$$)(0$&''&"331$D&3/%$%-9#,$0/-8'$4 #,$("'%%$')'#') 42#,$8'3"#')(2"(0')#$%/#;1#,$-$(0)%$)#2 "-$-$="-%')=))(/;9'((')"003'&"#')-9--$='(#-"#') $(#";3'(,9$)#2  ))'((/")&$    )#'&$  -  &99$)&$9$)#   &)(#-/&#')4-C")%9/(#$--33;$')=)#9"%$"8"'3";3$33

 #,$($  -$?/'-$9$)#(  "-$  &8$-$%  /)%$-  #,$  "&#-'$( &#2   B@ ,$-$-$2)&$#,$;/'3%')=#,$0$#'#')$-'($D$90#$%/)%$- +$&#') %!#,$/'3%')=&#

,"8')=;$$)-$='(#$-$%/)%$- #,$ "&#-'$(&#2 B@2#,$&903"')#(;$"-')=  2 ")% 2 %"#$%



@2  '3$% /)%$- +$&#') A /3$( A2  @ ")% +$&#')( 2B")% /3$@@#,$/'3%')=&#2

))$D/-$

A331!2"-$)#,')=2;/#9'(/($0-&$((/-#,$-$'() -$"()-#,$0$#'#')$-90")124,'&,'("+$9'8$-)9$)# 90")12#8'3"#$#,$3"4)($?/$)#312&903"')#(  ")% 2%"#$%



@2'3$%/)%$-+$&#')A /3$(A2@ ")% +$&#')(  2  B  ")%  /3$  @@    #,$  /'3%')= &#  

 ))$D/-$ A  331!  "-$  ?/"(,$%  "3)=4'#,  #,$  -%$-  %"#$%

 ))$D/-$ @!2  (/99)')=  #,$  0$#'#')$-  ")%  "33 &)($?/$)#'"30-&$$%')=( &&-%')=312#,$0-$($)#0$#'#')'("334$% 6
+
!

  

 (<C(