← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/10113/2018disposed of

Krishan v. State Of Haryana

2018-03-09Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi5 pages

  



   

 

 !" #"$%&%'(

*+%&, ' -"!%!%'"+ ."+&/& 0! !" +1 '  -"&2'#"'!   ( 34 0 

054 +"&"'!( +,/2"'#"+0%'6,7#8$ !" +!,"2"!%!%'"+ +0 !%&,0 %'%7 7 +1 '  999   

  :; <!,/6,2"!%!%'/'#"+0"$!%'= %& +>/ &,%'6  # !"# ? ?/'#"+0"$!%'&7 @)  7A=%'"& $!7 )? +"6%&!"+"# ! <%$"0! !%' , + /'# 7 %&!+%$! * +' < ''"B/+" A & <&+#"+# !"#? 2 &&"#C1!,"<" +'"#/#%$% < 6%&!+ !" &! < &&7 * +' < ''"B/+"  #"$< +%'6 !," 2"!%!%'"+ & +$< %D"# 

"'#"+71"! !!,"!%D" ," +%'67<" +'"#$/'&"< +!,"2"!%!%'"+&! !"& !, !,"#"&'!2+"&&!,"2+ 1"+ +>/ &,%'6  !!,%&&! 6" '#+"&!+%$!& ,%&$< %D!!,"2+ 1"+ +>/ &,%'6 +#"+# !"#? ''"B/+" #"$< +%'6!,"2"!%!%'"+ &+$< %D"#

"'#"+ :; 4" +'"# $/'&"< + !," 2"!%!%'"+ $'!"'#& !, ! & 2"+ !," D '# !" 0"$!%' $<" +'!%$"

# 1&%&D/&! +D!," # !" 2/C<%$ !%'!# !"  22" + '$" !," $$/&"#C"

+"!," $$/&"#$ ' C"#"$< +"# & +$< %D"#

"'#"+4" +'"#$/'&"< /+!,"+$'!"'#&!, ! 8%#"+#"+# !"#? @2+$< D !%'/'#"+0"$!%' E &%&&/"#

:; 6 %'&! !,"  2"!%!%'"+ + = @ '# !," & D" E & "

"$!"# ' ,%D '  @ '#%'!,"$%+$/D&! '$"&'= @7!,"$ &"E & #F/+'"#! ? 'E,%$,# !"!,"2"!%!%'"+E &#"$< +"# +$< %D"#

"'#"+ 4" +'"# $/'&"< $'!"'#& !, ! & 2"+ 2/C<%$ !%' "

"$!"# '  @7 2"!%!%'"+, #C""'#%+"$!"#! 22" +%' /+!'= @E,%$,2"+%#E & <"&& !, '

 # 1&  "&%#"&7 !,"+" E & ' +#"+ %' !," 2/C<%$ !%' + !," $$/&"# 6%8%'6 &2"$% %"# !%D" '# 2< $" ! 22" + ' ?   4" +'"# $/'&"<$'!"'#&!, !!,"%D2/6'"#+#"+# !"#? ''"B/+"%& <"6 <<1 /'&/&! %' C<" C"%'6 $'!+ +1 !!," D '# !"  0"$!%'   !,"

 :

; !%$" D!%' :=; + 0 !%&, 0 %'%7 <" +'"# "2/!1 #8$ !" "'"+ <7 +1 '  $$"2!"#'!%$"%'!,"2+"</'$,&"&&%' '#&/6,!!%D"!68"+!,"2 2"+ CG :?; '!,"2&!</'$,&"&&%'7<" +'"#0! !" /'&"<8"+1 %+<1&! !"# !, !%'8%"E $!/ <2&%!%'7!,"D '# !" 0"$!%' , #C""' </!"# '#!, !%'!,"<%6,! $!/ <2&%!%' &&"+!"#C1!," 2"!%!%'"+%'!,"2"!%!%'7!,"D !!"+E &&>/ +"<1$8"+"#C1!,"#"$%&%' !,%& /+!%'&,G*/D +80! !" +1 '  '# '!,"+  #"$%#"#' ?  :;

8"' !,"+E%&"7 & 2"+ !," #"$%&%'   !,%& /+! 2 &&"# '

?  %'         %' $ &" !%!<"# & &,G */D + 8 0! !"  +1 '  '# '!,"+ E,"+" E,%<" ! G%'6 '!"   !," $! !, ! !," 2/C<%$ !%'E &"

"$!"#'  + 

!,"+"C1 $$/&"#E &'! 6%8"' !," D '# !+1 2"+%#   !,%+!1 # 1& ! 22" + C"

+" !," /+! '# #"&2%!"!,"$ &", 8%'6C""' #F/+'"#' 

+

'E,%$,

:

; # !"!,%+!1# 1& +D# !" 2/C<%$ !%', #"B2%+"#7!,%& /+!E &2<" &"#! ,<# !, ! !"+!,"2/C<%$ !%'  !," '!%$" '  7 $$/&"# E & '! 6%8"'!,"D '# !+12"+%# !,%+!1# 1&! 22" +C"

+"!," /+! '#!," D"+" $!!, !!," /+!, # #F/+'"#%! !"+!,"2"+%# !,%+!1# 1&E/<# '!C"!+" !"# &$D2<% '$" 0"$!%'  &!,"+"E &' +#"+ %' !," 2/C<%$ !%' + !," $$/&"# 6%8%'6 &2"$% %"# !%D" '# 2< $" ! 22" +'

$$+#%'6<1!,"%D2/6'"#+#"+%'!,"& %#$ &"E & ,"<#!C"$'!+ +1!< E '#E & $$+#%'6<1&"! &%#" :; "<"8 '!"B!+ $! +"& %##"$%&%'%&+"2+#/$"# &/'#"+( H& 2"+ +#"+ # !"#=  2 &&"# C1 !,"<" +'"# ##%!%' < ,%"

/#%$% < 6%&!+ !"7 '%2 !7!,"$ &", & C""' #F/+'"# +  + %&&/%'6   2+$< D !%' /'#"+0"$!%'& '# +  6 %'&!2"!%!%'"+&,G */D + ,"+#"+# !"# &,E&!, !2+$< D !%' %&&/"# 6 %'&!&,G*/D ++"$"%8"#C $G#/<1"B"$/!"# 0! !"D"'! &"+8%'6 '&! C<"E & <&+"$+#"#"+%#

 # 1& , # '! "< 2&"# +D !," # !"   2/C<%$ !%' ,"+"

+"7 !," $ &" E & #F/+'"# !   ' !, ! # 17!,"2"!%!%'"+E &#"$< +"# &2+$< %D"#

"'#"+ ," +%6%' <+"$+# <&&,E&!, !!,"&! !"D"'! !,"&"+8%'6

%$% <7 ' D"<17 0 %<C 6 0%'6, E & +"$+#"# '  7E,&! !"#!, !') 7,"8%&%!"#!,"2< $" +"&%#"'$" !," $$/&"# <'6E%!,2+$< D !%' !"+ +" #%'6 2/C<%$<17 !," 2+$< D !%' E &

%B"# ! $'&2%$//& 2 +!   !," ,/&"   !," $$/&"# E,"+" ," +#%' +%<1 +"&%#"&  $21   !," 2+$< D !%' E & <&

:=;

%B"# !$'&2%$//&2 +! /+!,/&"7E,%$,D" '& !, !!,"2/C<%$ !%'E &"

"$!"#') + 7 E,%$, &,E& !, ! !"+ !," 2/C<%$ !%'   !," '!%$"7 !," $$/&"#E &'!6%8"'!,"D '# !+12"+%#

# 1&! 22" + C"

+" !," /+! ," D"+" $! !, ! !," /+! #F/+'"#%! !"+!,"2"+%#

# 1&E%<<'!C"!+" !"# & $D2<% '$"   !," 2+8%&%'&   0"$!%'   +  E,"+"%!%&2+8%#"#!, !( H             '1

/+!, &+" &'!C"<%"8"E,"!,"+ !"+! G%'6"8%#"'$" + '! !, ! '1 2"+&' 6 %'&! E,D  E ++ '! , & C""' %&&/"#C1%!, & C&$'#"#+%&$'$" <%'6,%D&"< &!, ! &/$,E ++ '!$ ''!C""B"$/!"#7&/$, /+!D 12/C<%&,  E+%!!"'2+$< D !%'+">/%+%'6,%D! 22" + ! &2"$% %"# 2< $" '# ! &2"$% %"#!%D"'!<"&&!, '!,%+!1# 1& +D !,"# !" 2/C<%&,%'6&/$,2+$< D !%'  BB BB BB BB  BB BB BB BBI ' 8%"E   !," C8" 2+8%&%'&   0"$!%' 

+ 7 %! %& $<" + !, ! !," 2/C<%$ !%' E & "

"$!"# ' )  '# !," $$/&"# E & #%+"$!"# ! 22" + %' !,"

/+! &2"+!, !2/C<%$ !%'' E,%$,2"+%#E & <"&& !, '

 # 1& ,"+"

+"7 %! $ ''! C" ,"<# !, ! C1 2 &&%'6 !," %D2/6'"# +#"+ '  7 !," 2/C<%$ !%' , & C""' "

"$!"# & 2"+ !," 2+8%&%'&   0"$!%' 

+  ,"+" E & ' +#"+ %' !," 2/C<%$ !%' + !,"

:?; $$/&"# 6%8%'6 &2"$% %"# !%D" '# 2< $" ! 22" + '  ,"+"

+"7 !,%& +#"+ %& '! & 2"+ < E '# !," & D"%&&"! &%#" %'#%'6 D"+%! %' !," 2"!%!%'7 !," & D" %& <<E"# ,"%D2/6'"#+#"+# !"# ''"B/+"%&&"! &%#" ,"<E"+ /+!+"$+#C"+"!/+'"#I :); 4" +'"# $/'&"< + !," 2"!%!%'"+7 ,E"8"+7 &! !"& !, ! '' 22" + '$" !,"2"!%!%'"+E &#/"!$%+$/D&! '$"&C"1'#,%&$'!+< '# !, !!,"2"!%!%'"+, &'%'!"'!%' D%&/&%'6!,"2+$"&& < E '#E/<# !,"+"

+" 2/! %' 22" + '$" C"

+" !," <" +'"# !+% < /+! E%!,%' !E E""G&

+D!# 1 : ;  '8%"E !,"2&%!%' &'!"# C8"7!,"%D2/6'"#+#"+# !"# ? ''"B/+"#"$< +%'6!,"2"!%!%'"+ &+$< %D"#

"'#"+%& >/ &,"# ,"2"!%!%'"+E/<#2/!%' 22" + '$"C" +"!,"<" +'"#!+% < /+! E%!,%'!EE""G& +D!# 1E,"+"/2'!,"<" +'"#!+% < /+!E/<#2+$""# %' $$+# '$"E%!,< E :;  $$+#%'6<17 +<%&$2"!%!%'%& <<E"# & C8" 05 <%  /#6"

D%!  5,"!,"+&2" G%'6A+" &'"# ( "&A 2. 5,"!,"++"2+! C<" ( "&A