Sukhchain Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And Another
!
""
!
# !!
%&
""
!'
( !"#$%&'" #"%
#
! )"
* + %,(-.(/ * +0- * .(/ !+ * +, !,!-.+++. %&+ * +++(.(/ !'
( +1+ #"%
##) * !
'
! & $- ( ( 341 + ' 5 6! +778( (98+:+187;( 919.
3:4".38<.;8<(93 (
- .- .!
.* -(-- !&! 6 '
( ! ! $ =
=! ( (4+:+187<> ? "1@+
6 !
A!
(&5 ='- " !'
(
+1 ( / !
== ( + A / . A / $ !' &- !.$--5 ! / ( !
- = (
5 !
-/ ( ! (!' .A!'' = =! + != . ! / '
A
&5' 5 ! '
( !A -(& $ - ? ! (&! !! ( !. 6 !
(-- !&! 6 '
( ! ! $ = =5 & 6! ( $%!
+
! /( ( !( (78+;+1811( ( !
'' & $ --6* B 5* ( !.! ( (& $ .( --6* B * A!-!
( (
! ( ! '
+ ' !
!= .- (*., ! '
( (1;+;+1811
+C '
! !-!
? (
-!
$ ='- B !'
( +1 %A( , .%
! . - ( '-, ( ( 19+;+1811 - A !
$ =% ( ( 1;+;+1811+ !
!.- (*.
, ! -( ( '
'' ! !/ (
=! / - -5( !
! (
' ! ! ( ! (A! / ( - (
-= ( $$ ( !! + / (- ( ! -$ !.' ! ( ( '
! &5- (*., + & ' !- $!
5'
/! 341 + ++A -( ! A =5= ! ( !.!=5& !! 5
/ $$
5 ( ( (
' / &! !!
$5
A!
! (! $%!
+ 918 + ! 6--5 - / !( .A' ! & ! ( $
( $$ !( ( - ( + , ' / A $$ !-- (-5 ==
( $ &
!/ =&-5!
- ( (!' . $ =-'
! A -(& $ - ? ! + D&-
+ ' = =& $! !-(
B.S.Joshi and others /!State of Haryana , -)
+%./)0.) 1$ -- A (&5 -- ! $2.*3,)%4- , -)5% 6.7 8 , -)9
+
/ ( -
A '
! / -/ ( ' ! ! (!
- ( -A+ $ . D&- ' = Gian Singh :State of Punjab and another
%./)0.) + +$ ( -
A !! ( - -A!
- (&5 ' = 6!
State of Haryana :Bhajan Lal9 ;;%.// %+++
<7 %( (!!( )"
!
"
#
$
%&'
(
"
)*+ , #
- +
,
(
!("
( - "
-
(
(
.- -
(-
(
/
(
$
(
(-(
.0
1
(
.
(- *
(
2 ( 3
(
-
(
- -
-
-
.
(
(-
(
(
( -
(
-
-
(
.
# "
#
(
-
(
#
#
-
+ ,
-
#
4
''-5 -A!
- (&5 D&- ' = '-
$%( !( ! . !'' A !/ (
=! . ( !A -(& = -5&! !! (&5-- A ( '
' 5 !&56! A -(& ! (! %!
.A!' = -5 &% - !- ( 341 + ! !- . $(! ! (!6 -5$--!
A =& (' = !!
- (&5%(-' ( !( .
+778( (98+:+187;( 919.3:4".38<.;8<(93 (
- .- .!
.* -( -- !&! 6 '
( ! ! $ = 6! ( 6 '
! =! + (- !!
!5 !
!-- =& (&5 =!( ( ! =! ( ! ( (& $ & - A+
!
(!-- A (+ #"%
# #$ <"
-5 C !' B !
() !B
C '
&- ) !B