Madan Lal Verma v. State Of Punjab And ANR.




   
 
 

!"#$$ 







 






   %"  &'%  (
(('


 
 



 

 



!
"
# $  (()! *)+),) -. /),0 
 
 !

  

 
%
 

 &''( )*'
"

&+ '+ ,-+.

 &&*(*''
"

', '& ,-/,


 0
 
0 


#
1  


 

    
2 (*4

 
0 
"
   
%




 
'/ '5 &''5 (+4
" %
 
"
   

0 

 

 
%
 


 
 





" 
  
! 




  



  



0 




 


%



 
&, ,-+-
0 

 &''()*'
"  

  %







%



,-/,


0 

 &&*(*''




"

', '& ,-/,


 
 


 
0  

  

,+ '/ ,-/5

" 


   

%  
 





 
 
 &+ '+ ,-+.





# # 
  



 



"
 
 60
 0






7 
 0 7
8 9 
"

&+ '+ ,-+.

7


"



"


:




%  
3  


 0  ; 
%





00 
 0


<
 

60

=
 


 0 %
7 
 0


"

:

%  
3  

 





 %
 
 


3  








 


%  
"
 


 
3 



 
 


 


%
 

"
0  
 
"
 ,&'(&''

0




 

 

 ,+'(55'

" 
"
0  



&'

'+ ,-+-
"

&+ '+ ,-+.





!
 7

 
  


 
,-/&
<
 0 % 7
 %
 
# 

!

"

 

0
 %






%  
3  

"

 

  

 

 &&*(*''




0

 %

 
 
0 0

0 
  

<
"




'/ '5 ,-/)
2 (,4




"
%

 

  
"

0 9 

7


 

"
0 9 




"

', ,-/5

 

 
&) '.

,-/-
2<"


 


 %


 

 
%

  
"
0


"


"
  

0


"

 


"
%  
 4

#"# 

"
0  

 

 &&*(*''
"

,+ '/ ,-/5
%
%0

 

" %


 
0 
   

'+ ') ,-/+



 
,'

'5 ,-.,
2

(&4 7





 


>
0
<  0
"

0 

  


0
0 
 
 
%
 
"





 

  


 
,- '- ,--'
 
%


?0
8 
@
A

 
0



 

:
3  


% 

0%


 
  


 

 

  0 


 
0
 
0 

  


 

 




7
 "


  %
  
0 

  

 
%
 

 &&*(*''
"




 

 
 
  '/ '5 ,--5
2 ()4 =
 0 

 
@B
A 55+/
 ,--,
 0

 
 
" 
"
 %
" 
%

    0
?0
%
 0

 

3
 
%


 
  &&*(*''
"




  


%  


 

 
 
        $ %& 
"

" " 




" 

 
 !




 %

 !

    %
 



  
.

,+
&)

5&
% 
" 


 
0  




  



 

&+ '+ ,-+.

# # 



"

 
 

! 

  
 "


 
 0





 0


  


"

  

 
 


  


5+
% 

7

  
 
 
"
 

&+ '+ ,-+.


%
 

 ,&'( &''






  
"

0 9 
"

', ,-/5

  0

:
 


% 

0%
%  
"
 

 ,+'()''

 &&*(*''
"

,+ '/ ,-/5

7 
 
  



"
 

  %



<

60
 0 
"

0 

0


"

,+ ,--+



 

 





0 
  % 
"

 
 

,+ ,--+



 

 
"


 7

 
   

3
"
0 




<
 0 %
7 
%


 


0 9

 
  




  


 0
%
 

7
"
  




 

%  3  
"





00 

<"








<
 0 


%  
3  
  
 
 0 9



 




< 

7 
"




% 
,-+.

,-/,

 00
"
  


00


,-+.



 
 0

%  
3  




 0 
  
$  

 
 
') '& ,-/*
2
(

#'# 54

 



3  
 0 9

  
 0

60
 0 %



 3 
3  


"


<
 0


 
# 

 !

"

 

0
 
0 

0 

 &''()*'
"

,& '5 ,-/'




 

 





%
 
 &&*(*''
"

'& ,-/,

%
"
3 


 

 
" !0

 


   

%  
3  


"
0 
  

 &&*(*''
"

,+ '/ ,-/5




"
 

  %

0 

>

0

  %
"
 
" 
 


"
" 

0 

 &&*(*''


 
 


,.

,, ,-+.
%


?0
8 
@
A






 
 
'/ '5 ,--5

 
  

<"



 
  

  
  &- '5 ,--*

 
 

  

&) ,, ,--*
2

()4

  %

 
 
&, ') &''5
2 (/4
 

 
 





  

5&
%  

 @

0 
 



0  

  
"

0 9 

', ,-/5




   
5&
%  


" 

 

&.

'& &''5


  

.(,.
%  

 
  
0 

', '/ ,-.+

&/ ,--,   %


0 
 
#
1  
"
0 


 0
 


   




 0 @ 


  0%
  



#(#  
"
  
 


 











0 

  




 
 &+ '+ ,-+.


 

 &''()*'

 &&*(*''

', '& ,-/, <"


 


#
1  
0 
" 0


"



"



 
 
') '& ,-/*

" 

"
 


 


 







 0
  
 
00

%
 
%  
3  


 0 %
"





 "
  

  




% 
3  


" 
 
 
 0

%  
,-+.

,-/,

7
"

  

"
 


$  

 


0 %  
 0 


 0  
 

  ! 





"
00 

7

 
 

 
 


  %
 
 
0
 
0  
   

 
  





 0

%  3  


 
  



 

  
"
0  %

#
1  


 


  


 

"  





&+ '+ ,-+.


 

 ,+'(55'

<

 

" !0
"

  



&) '.

,-/-
 "
 

0

"

', ,-/5


 
 
  ,+'()''




   

%  




  


  



 
 


 

 
&) '.

,-/-


 (

#)#
 

     

      

   

  

!  

"

   #$ %   

  



 &'(&()(*&+,((      - !  

&'(*-(&*(&*&./0 0 "  



 

  1

  2-  3   #   

   -   -     

                 1  #       4  - 1       " -    





-

      - 5  

    

  

#   

      -      



      1    1   



#  1    

   



       



 -     1

      

#   

 

-  -    -  6

 1







 

"
0 

  

 
 
  &&*(*''
"

,+ '/ ,-/5

 



"

0

7

  
  

0 


#
1  

  


 

  


  



  "
! 

 


"%
"


%  
3  


 60
 0
" 
"

:
:




   %

 



0  

0 0

 

 

 
0  

  

 % 

 0





60
 0

 
"

0 
 



% 
,--+





## 

  %



 


 


 





0 9
"
! 


', ,-/5


 
0


:
: 

  


    %
 


 "


 


 


 


 

 

   

:
 



 

&.

'& &''5 


 


0  


 

 



 
 
&) ,, ,--*
2
( )4
"
0


"
 C
: 


 
 &&*( *''





 
"
  

<


 0










<
 



 

 
 
&, ') &''5
2 (/4



"


 
%

 



"

 
 

A
  
 
 

 


 


#
1  
0  "
 
'5 ,& &'',



 

  
"


   !0








0 
0




  
.
%  
 

7
 
  
 %

 0 




%


 0


0 
 0    

 





" 



 
   
 
 3
@ 


C *+ , -++ !

'$ &" )

 

 
"


 0

"

0
 

 
 
  :  



 %


  

 
 

 
"

  


  


 


  


" 

# #  
%
 0




 
 


0
 %
 
 

&) ,, ,--*


 
 0 


 
 

0 


 ( 70!"  

  -    

 

 

2 #       -  

 #    

&!8     - 



    1

  # 



      

5 9

   8  - 



  - 1 13  &,   

" 

         

 2

 1 1           

        

"  #   -  

   

    

  

#

 

  

!:-1 # 

   2-    % 9    

 -   6 "  - 

         -         

   

6    -5    

     



-

  

  

 #   

              2             

    9 " -  

       

#  *    6 # -  1

 

 





0!:-1 # 9 

   -  2             -   2       - 

  1   

    #- 

            ;

         

   

  9     

        

-2      

  # 5  

   5 ,- ./+* 0 

!<  # 2         -         

            

2   

   

    9  2    

# !

 #      2 #- -   

2 9 

 1   

      

 6   
 


#
1  
0 
 12 34

'$ &2)

"

 



 


 

  

  






"
 0

  


 
  





0
: 

 "

   
"


 3
@


#
1  

 

"


0 
  
%

@ 
"
0 




   

0 





 "
"
" 
%

 3
@ 



+, -++2 4
" 

  
 0 



 
  








 0 


" 



 
%



   

7
 
  

@ 







 


 


 


 
0%
  

0%
0




  
"


 

  

 .(('
0 #-$     1