← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/9183/2022dismissed

Loven Sharma v. State Of Punjab

2022-08-17Mr. Justice B.S. Walia8 pages

   

      



   !" "#$%$&'(  )*"&+, -. %& +,-$ -$&/"-01. - 2"!$!$&"- *"-%1% +! !" 1&3 4 2"%5&/"&!

- .' &647"-1%!$#"+8 7$  -"%"&!' -&1-""!++$/,19/*# !" -!,"5"!$!$&"- -:1%,+ -& 9%%!! 91&3 4 ;;; +8 7$ 9< - 7=   - :"-$&!,">!,5"!$!$&4"

-"!,$% 1-!91&/"-+"#!$&?

<4"%$/"%!@5"!$!$&%1A%?

4"

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

  )" -&"/ #1&%"7 #&!"&/% !, ! !," 5"!$!$&"- $% $& & @ : #&&"#!"/@$!,!," 77"B"/

"&#"% &/, %4""&. /" %# 5"B !9!, ! !,"7" -&"/+"%%$&% 1-!/$%.$%%"/!,"5"!$!$& $7"/4:!,"5"!$!$&"-

-B- &! 5-" --"%!4 $7*$/"-/"-/ !"/(C9@,"-" !"-!," &647" $B, 1-!*$/"-/"-/ !"/(($&  >   $&$!$ 77: -"7" %"/ !," 5"!$!$&"- & $&!"-$. 4 $7 7&B @$!, # ##1%"/ *$&/"-+$&B,41!"*"&!1 77:/$%.$%%"/% $/5"!$!$&*$/"-/"- / !"/ )" -&"/#1&%"7 1-!,"-#&!"&/%!, !#, 77 &, %4""& 5-"%"&!"/9 # ##1%"/  *$&/"- +$&B, &/ -@$&/"- +$&B,9 . $& ##1%"/, *"4""&-"7" %"/&4 $79&-"#*"-:$%!4""

"#!"/ -.!," 5"!$!$&"-9!,"-"

-"9$&!,"#$-#1.%! &#"%9!,"5"!$!$&"-$%"&!$!7"/!4" -"7" %"/&5-" --"%!4 $7"%5"#$ 77: %!,"5"!$!$&"-$%&!-"G1$-"/ - #1%!/$ 7$&!"--B !$& ? "57:/ !"/ , %4""& $7"/4:!,"7" -&"/ %! !$&B !,"-"$& !, ! !," $&%! &! >!, 5"!$!$& 4" -" !,$% 1-!  1A+ ?

$% B-%% 41%" !,"5-#"%% 7 @ %  > 9  > 9  >  &/    >    @"-" /$%.$%%"/ 4: !," &647" $B, 1-! &/ !,"-"$%&#, &B"$&!,"#$-#1.%! &#"%9!,"-" -"9&B-1&/$%. /"1!

-B- &!  &!$#$5 !-:4 $7,"-"57: 1-!,"-."&!$&%!, !51-%1 &!! !,"-"B$%!- !$& !,"9- $/@ %#&/1#!"/$&@,$#,," *:-"#*"-$"% @"-""

"#!"/ -.!," #!-:5-".$%"%$&#71/$&B4D"% $77$#$! 7$G1-9 ?7!-+5$-$!97!-)- &/97!- %%"&#" 7$G1-9  7!- 9 > )!- 9  +!$#E"-%    -E   %$7  + &!- 9  ,7B- .%9>".5!:, 7 4!!7"% -: 7%! B4- &/9# &!"-4" -$&B -"B$%!- !$&  C>0C  4"%$/"% . #,$&"-:9 -!$#7"% &/ "G1$5."&! - . &1 #!1-$&B$77$#$!7$G1-  ," -"57: 1-!,"-."&!$&%

!, ! ##1%"/+ #,$& &/+ &3 :@"-" --"%!"/&!,"%5!&(>9 @,$7" ##1%"/  *$&/"- 7$ %  @ % --"%!"/ &   &/ -*$&/"-+$&B, , /, F &B  , /, @ % --"%!"/&(( 41! -"% $/ ##1%"/ @"-" -"7" %"/ & -"B17 - 4 $7 @,$7" ##1%"/ -."%, &/!,"5"!$!$&"-@"-" 4%#&/$&B &/#17/&!4" --"%!"/ /"%5$!"4"%!"

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

!"- & (> &  @ % -"B$%!"-"/ &/ /1-$&B $&*"%!$B !$&9$!@ % 1&/!, !!,"5"!$!$&"-@ %@-E$&B % & B"-$& !,"% $/ #!-:@,"-"$77$#$!7$G1-@ %4"$&B. &1 #!1-"/ &/ @ %7E$&B !"-!,"@-E % 7" &/51-#, %" . !"-$ 7% &/ -!$#7"% 1%"/ $& . &1 #!1-$&B $77$#$! 7$G1-9 4"%$/"% %1557:$&B $77$#$! 7$G1- ! * -$1% #1%!."-% &/ , / !,"-"4: 57 :"/ & #!$*" -7" $& !," #..$%%$&   !," #-$."9 77"B !$&% B $&%! !," 5"!$!$&"- @"-" B- *" &/ %"-$1%9 !,"-" @ % #B"&!9 &/ %1

$#$"&! $&#-$.$& !$&B "*$/"&#" B $&%! !," 5"!$!$&"-9 !,"-"

-"9 ," @ % &! "&!$!7"/ ! !," B- &! 

&!$#$5 !-:4 $7 &/!, ! 5 -! -.!," -"."&!$&"/9 &!,"- 4" -$&B>/ !"/?@ %-"B$%!"-"/ B $&%!!,"5"!$!$&"- 1&/"-+"#!$&C !,"1&3 4 D#$%"#!-" /@$!,+"#!$&%?9?C>9 ?C 9?(9C  &/+"#!$&> !,"$% %!"- & B"."&!#!9> !7$#"+! !$&+ / -90, && 9$%!-$#!)1/,$ & 9# ##1%"/$&!,"$- /$%#7%1-" %! !"."&!% % @"77 % @$!&"%%"% $& !,"$- %! !"."&!% -"#-/"/ 1&/"-+"#!$&C , //$%#7%"/!," #!$*" &/%5"#$ $#-7"4: !,"5"!$!$&"-$&!,"# %"9@,$#,#17/&!4"/$%#7%"//1"!5"&/"&#:  !," $&*"%!$B !$&9 !,"-"

-"9 #1%!/$ 7 $&!"--B !$&   !," 5"!$!$&"- @ %&"#"%% -:9!, !#, 77 &, / 7-" /:4""&5-"%"&!"/ B $&%! -*$&/"- +$&B, , /, F &B  , /,  &/ *$&/"-+$&B, 7$ %41!!-$ 7 , /&!#.."&#"/ B $&%!!,". %!,"5"!$!$&"-#17/&!4" --"%!"/ &/$&*"%!$B !$&@ %%!$775"&/$&B > ! !- &%5$-"% !, ! @,$7"  C @ % -"B$%!"-"/ & (>9 !," 5"!$!$&"- , % . & B"/ ! "* /" --"%! % 7% 3$&$&B $&*"%!$B !$&/1-$&B 77!,$%!$."4"%$/"%$% , 4$!1 7

"&/"- %"*$/"&!

-.,$%$&*7*"."&!$& %14%"G1"&!$&-"%5"#! %$.$7 -

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

"&#"9 !, ! ," , / 5-#1-"/ !,"

. #,$&"-: % 7%!,"-. !"-$ 7 -!,". &1 #!1-$&B 7$G1-$&!,"

#!-:9 4"%$/"%9 #&/1#!"/ % 7"   $77$#$! 7$G1- 7&B @$!, ,$% -$"&/ +1.$!&I 

*"-%1%

  69+

&7$&" +  (C9 &647" !," +15-"." 1-! ,"7/ !, ! %1##"%%$*" &!$#$5 !-: 4 $7 557$# !$&% @"-" &! . $&! $& 47" $& *$"@   !," 5"!$!$&"- !,"-"$& 4%#&/$&B &/ &! #5"- !$&B $& !," $&*"%!$B !$& "7"* &!"D!- #! -"."&!$&"//"#$%$&$%-"5-/1#"/ %1&/"-'     

   

            

           

    

  

   

       



         

 

             !       

" # ( -"*"-9 -"#*"-: 51-%1 &! ! -"B$%!- !$&    $%    ,1B" G1 &!$!:   $77$#$! 7$G1- 7&B @$!, . #,$&"-:9 "G1$5."&!9 - @ . !"-$ 7 -. &1 #!1-$&B$77$#$!7$G1- %@"77 %7 4"7% -% 7" % $/ $77$#$!7$G1-   ,"5"!$!$&"-, /$&$!$ 77: $7"/ 5"!$!$& -5-" --"%!4 $7 4"

-"!,"7" -&"/+"%%$&% 1-!9@,$#,@ %/$%.$%%"/*$/"-/"-/ !"/ (C9@,"-"

!"-!,"5"!$!$&"- 55- #,"/!," $B, 1-!4:@ :  > $&@,$#,&/14!!," $B, 1-!-"7" %"/ !,"5"!$!$&"-$&$!$ 77:&$&!"-$.4 $7*$/"-/"-/ !"/((41!!," % ."@ %"*"&!1 77:/$%.$%%"/*$/"-/"-/ !"/ ,"-"

!"-9

 > @ %@$!,/- @&*$/"-/"-/ !"/?  @,$7"   >    @ % @$!,/- @& & C @$!, 7$4"-!:!! E"1! 55-5-$ !"5-#""/$&B%4" -"!,"7" -&"/!-$ 7 1-! $& ##-/ &#" @$!, 7 @ $& *$"@   %! &/   #, &B" $& #$-#1.%! &#"%

,"-"

!"-9  > @ %/$%.$%%"/ %@$!,/- @&&  @$!, 7$4"-!: ! * $7 55-5-$ !" -"."/:9 @,"-" !"- !," 5"!$!$&"- $7"/  5"!$!$& 1A% ?

  4"

-" !," 7" -&"/ +"%%$&%

1-!9@,$#,@ % 7%/$%.$%%"/&4: /"! $7"/-/"-  % 5"- !," /"#$%$&     

  <%15- =9 %1##"%%$*" &!$#$5 !-:4 $7 557$# !$&# &&!4""&!"-! $&"/"%5"#$ 77: $   !,"  ##1%"/  $%  4%#&/$&B  &/  &!  #5"- !$&B  $& !," $&*"%!$B !$&+ ."$%!,"5%$!$&$&!,"$&%! &!# %"##-/$&B7:9$& *$"@ !,"4"$&B !,":" - &/!,"5"!$!$&"-&!#5"- !$&B 4"%$/"% &! 4"$&B !- #" 47"9 $% &! "&!$!7"/ ! B- &!   5-" --"%! 4 $7 )" -&"/ #&!"&/%!, !$&*$"@ " -7$"-5"!$!$& - &!$#$5 !-: 4 $7$"  > , *$&B4""&/$%.$%%"/4:!," $B,

1-!*$/"/"! $7"/-/"-/ !"/  &/!,"-"4"$&B&#, &B"$& #$-#1.%! &#"%9!,"5"!$!$&"-$%&!"&!$!7"/!5-" --"%!4 $7 %!,"% ." @17/ .1&! ! $&!"- "-$&B @$!, !," $&*"%!$B !$& 4"%$/"% #1%!/$ 7 $&!"--B !$&$%G1 7$! !$*"7:.-""7$#$! !$&-$"&!"/!, &G1"%!$&$&B % %1%5"#!@,$%@"77"&%#&#"/@$!,  *1- 47"-/"-1&/"-+"#!$& ?

 /" -$.$& 7-#"/1-" &/$&%1#,7$E"# %"%9"

"#!$*" $&!"--B !$&    %1%5"#!"/ 5"-%& $%   !-"."&/1% /* &! B" $& /$%$&!"--$&B1%"

17$& -. !$& &/%1#,$&!"--B !$&@17/"71/"$ %1%5"#!"/5"-%&E&@%!, !,"$%@"775-!"#!"/ &/$&%17 !"/4: 5-" --"%!4 $7-/"-/1-$&B!,"!$.","$%!4"$&!"--B !"/)" -&"/#1&%"7 -"7$"% 15& !," /"#$%$&   &647" !," +15-"." 1-! $&  

             

    !   9@,$#,$&!1-&-"$!"- !"%/"#$%$&$&"#

 $%$  &

'   ( ) ( ) *+ $& %155-!   !,"

-"."&!$&"/%14.$%%$&%"7"* &!"D!- #! !,"% ."$%-"5-/1#"/

%1&/"-' J  $

 %         

  



           

       

    

   

 

   

   & 

            '               (           

          

          

    

    

        

 

 

   )* +  ,  -,)    *   .//$  $ *-- .0$   *  -      12  3  4 

    

  -,) 

      5     

  5         

       *  670

 -  )  

   

      

        

         

   *

                          2       8 

    

           &*$"@ 5%$!$&&!"/ 4*"95"!$!$&"-&!#5"- !$&B &/. & B$&B!"* /" --"%! -#7%"! K:" -%9 77"B !$&% B $&%! 5"!$!$&"-4"$&B%"-$1%95"!$!$&"-4"$&B , 4$!1 7A-"5" !

"&/"-$& !@/$

"-"&!/$%!-$#!%9# ##1%"/$&!,"$-/$%#7%1-"%! !"."&!% %@"77 % @$!&"%%"% $& !,"$- %! !"."&!% -"#-/"/ 1&/"- +"#!$& C  , *$&B /$%#7%"/ #!$*" &/ %5"#$ $# -7"   !," 5"!$!$&"- $& !," # %"9 #1%!/$ 7$&!"--B !$& !,"5"!$!$&"--"G1$-"/4:!,"57$#" &/!,"-"

4"$&B&#, &B"$&!,"#$-#1.%! &#"%9!,"$&%! &!5"!$!$&$%,"7/!4"&! . $&! $& 47" &/$% ##-/$&B7:/$%.$%%"/ %%1#, ("&,  )    -%.  (  9+!( 4  :   1 ;:  4     1 ;: