High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/325/1992disposed of

Mohinder Singh v. Bajrang Lal

2024-01-18Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary5 pages

! "#$ %&'()"*(++",'-./ 0123456378984:;<=#="#"$ .4>8:63?@8:A> =====B:CD?36(&EE3FF1:2 G3?9D9 H1C?1:AI1FJK1EEDJH1F1C81:6 =====L39E4:63:29 MN

P ! K?393:2; Q4:354?2>31EE3FF1:2= .?=033E1R@D?8S&6T47123S 54??39E4:63:2Q4=)(B:9D?1:73U4VE1:W= X YYYYYX !Z O = B:CD?36(1EE3FF1:2 >19 58F36 2>3 E?393:2 1EE31F 933R8:A 3:>1:73V3:2 45 2>3 74VE3:91284: 1V4D:2 1[1?636 \W 2>3 F31?:36 .424? &77863:2 UF18V9 ]?8\D:1FS ^1?:1F ,54? 9>4?2 _2>3 ]?8\D:1F`/S T863 1[1?6 61236 "#=#<=++#S 4: 1774D:2 45 2>3 8:CD?839 ?3738T36 \W >8V 8: 1 V424? T3>87DF1?177863:2= "= B2 >19 \33: 921236 8: 2>3 A?4D:69 45 1EE31F 2>12 2>3 8:CD?36(1EE3FF1:2 >16 V32 [82> 1: 177863:2S [>3?38: >3 >16 9D553?36 VDF28EF3 8:CD?839 8:7FD68:A 231?9 8: F8T3? 1:6 >13V124V19 8: 2>3 AD2= a3 [19 1F94 >1T8:A 8:78984:1F >3?:81= a3 ?

3V18:36 >49E821F8b36 5?4V "*=#c=+<d 24 +=#<=+<d= &2 2>3 28V3 45 177863:2S >3 [19 ") W31?9 4F6 1:6 31?:8:A L9="###e( E3? V4:2>= a4[3T3?S 2>3 ]?8\D:1F >19 1[1?636 1: 1V4D:2 45 L9=")S*##e(D:63?1FF>3169S[>87>894:2>3F4[3?9863= )= ': 2>3 42>3? >1:6S 2>3 F31?:36 74D:93F 54? ?39E4:63:2 Q4=)(B:9D?1:73 U4VE1:W >19 4EE4936 2>3 E?

!" #$ % &

' # #% ""#( '%$ %)*$ % !#+ ,+ -"* + .+ / " 0*#%( $# '

#%'%$ # 0 # #% 1*2!# $ 345678 9:; <494:4=>7?

7>7@A6B C>4DA5 E>547 E>:F67>GA =; HD5; 7>5 7>=DIA6 JKLMN OPO LP$Q$N ,,( #$2 # $# #%# #

R "

MS+JT+JM( '%$ #% $1*U $!# '

#* R

Q%$

$2 $Q $ % 2$2# !( * $2 "!# $ $$#& # #% V##

0 ,.W( % ' ' O + X(MK(JJJYU

& Z # [ $# P$!

/$ *( \2*!( Q$

# M+JM+JM,( '%$ % ' %

& #% -$2% P *# # #% #*

0 O + ](X(SJJYU Q$

# .+J,+JMS '% #% ""#( 0$2 22$Q( "" % - ^ #% _*"! P *#( $# ' %

Q$2 #%#( `/%$ P *# % !"% $a #$! 2$ #%# `1* #

!" #$ b

% * $ * !# #%# '

* # " #% Q$ #$! $ "

$#$

% ' $(

0 #%

0 #% $#+ c%$ # !

0 &

#% !#$

!" #$ #% #*!( "$

*00$2 #%# Q$ #$! *2 0#

$ * $#( L " #%

N( #&

!" #$ $ #% ! R ' # '( '% &

$#&

! ! *

0 #$#*#$ # #%

*Q$Q( #% Q$ #$!

'% %Q # 0 #%$ $Q +b d*#%( '%$ '$2 #% "" #%

!" #$ ' % &#R$2$# $#$ #%0

'$2e `.X+ /% Q$

$$ # #%# #% ""#

*00 ""2$ * # #% $#+ f"2$ $ !

0 "& $

&+ g# #$ # Q&& *#$ "#$ *& #% "%& $ #$Q$#& # L$N "$Q#$

$!" " * !$#$

0 $0( L$$N MJJW

0 $2 " $#&( L$$$N

2 #!

!"# $#

%&# #' $#&&

( # " $ $ $

)!#$ "#* $#( +#,- ."#' . )"!"(

' $ (

/#$( $0 1 ) $(

!"'# # !

# !)# "( $ "

!)"'# " ) "$)

)

, $ $#' # !

$ $) # " .# # "2""3#'.$),#$# 0 450 1 $) ) $)

!!""

$ # $) 3&# . ""#' &$#"

& $ $

," $ ,

#& ,#""

' $ "" $) 0 6#$) $)#

# 3#"#$ # $) . .

!"'# 3#' &.. 3 $)

!!""

$( #$ # $ !#3" . )# 2 $ "7

#$ $ .

"' ! # 0 8# 3&# &"

3 # $ ) , 3 '

," # !

$ 0 9& $) $)

!!""

$ $) $# .

# $2 :&$;<

=> ?/ // // ;;@0 A) $$ " ! $#

3 & &

#.. $)

# & B ;0 C.

#' &$ # 3#"#$BD05(55(EFFGH @0 C.

#'. E $)B D0IJFFFGH 0 K # "/! D0;(44(FFFGH I0 9&$& # "/! D0@(;E(FFFGH 40 L$$

' D0I(@(FFFGH E0 C#$#'

$#)

' D04F(FFFGH 50 C., D04F(FFFGH J0 M # &.. #' D0;(FF(FFFGH <0 K

# '!

!$ D0(FF(FFFGH ;F0 C. #$# D04F(FFFGH A$ " D0@;(5J(FFFGH> E0 8N3" $) O&!

P& $ #

QRST UVWXXY Z URVW[Y \]]V[^ _]T `Xa[Q^Vb

V^VaXYc d UeVeX `QVS fYV^]gQYe QYgQYVe[Q^ @F@+;- DPD +P#,#"- I<( 2) # $)

# $ )

;@0FE0@FF<( &#' !

# 3#"#$ $ $) /$$ . 5Fh #

$# $

#')$ "2 "# 3( $ $) "

# $(

( )# #' )# 3#"#$ ,#' .&$# "

# 3#"#$ , " # !

$#' )#

#' #$

) ,#' $ & $)$# "# 3(

! $# . D0 D0;4(5E(IE4GH 3 $) K$ L# $ P"

# #3& "( i")#H11( i2

P& $( j2 i")# 3

$ FJ0F@0@F;( 2)#) $ #.# 3 $) 8#') P& $ $ $) /$$ . D0;E(5F(<@GH ,#

$ ;;0F<0@F;J0 k#' & $#.# $)

!!""

) 8N3" $) O&!

P& $

!" #$%&'()$%*

!" +,- ./$% /%) (++0-$%* 1

!" .0&$/' )$02

!" ', ,+ /30%$2$0 ,+ '$+04 56$'0 ,70-8$%* 260-0$% 26/2 $2 $ / 50'' 022'0) .,$2$,% ,+ '/5 26/2 $% &/0 ,+ .0-3/%0%2 )$/7'030%2 &/(0) 79 / 3,2,- /&&$)0%2 260 &'/$3/%2 $ 0%2$2'0) 2, %,2 :(2 +(2(-0 ', ,+ $%&,30 7(2 /', +(2(-0 .-,.0&2 ;2 6/ 700% -0$20-/20) 79 26$ <,(-2 $% 3('2$.'0 $%2/%&0 26/2 =:(2 &,3.0%/2$,%> 3(2 70 $%20-.-020) $% (&6 / 3/%%0- / 2, .'/&0 260 &'/$3/%2 $% 260 /30 .,$2$,% / 60 5/ 70+,-0 260/&&$)0%22,,?.'/&0

@,8$%* 2, 260 .-00%2 &/0 260-0 $ %, )$.(20 5$26 -0*/-) 2, 260 /&&$)0%2 &/(0) 79 260 )-$80- ,+ 260 ,++0%)$%* 7( $% 56$&6 260 /..0''/%2 6/) (2/$%0) 3('2$.'0 $%:(-$0 A0-2$%0%2'9 $%&0 260-0 $ %, &6/''0%*0 2, 260 +/&2(3 ,+ 260 /&&$)0%2 260 3/%%0- ,+ $2 2/?$%* .'/&0 / 50'' / '$/7$'$29 +/20%0) (.,% 260 )-$80- ,5%0- /%) $%(-0- ,+ 260 ,++0%)$%* 806$&'0

2 , 70 :,$%2 /%) 080-/'

26$ $(0 ),0 %,2 5/--/%2 /%9 +(-260- &-(2$%9 B)3$220)'9 260 /..0''/%2 -03/$%0) 6,.$2/'$C0) +,- 1 )/9 ,% /&&,(%2 ,+ 260 $%:(-$0 (++0-0) AD" E-B6,? F/%),% 6/) )0.,0) 26/2 / .0- -0&,-) ,+ @0)$&/' <,''0*0 G H,.$2/'

,62/?

60 -03/$%0) /)3$220) 50+ 1IJ 2, JJ /%) 5/ ,.0-/20) +,- 6/03,.0-$2,%0(3 /%) 5/ +,(%) 2, 6/80 3('2$.'0 20/- $% 260 '$80- /%) 603/2,3/ $% 260 *(2 F60 '$80- 20/- 50-0 (2(-0) /%) 080% /+20- ,.0-/2$,% 60 6/) )080',.0) 0.2030/ 56$&6 -0K($-0) /%2$7$,2$& /%) )-/$%/*0 ,+ &,''0&2$,% ,+ +'($) +-,3 (7 60./2$& ./&0 F60 /..0''/%2 3(2 6/80 -03/$%0) 70) -$))0% +,- /7,(2I3,%26;2$%,2)$.(20)26/2605/0/-%$%*

!".0-3,%26 L00.$%* $% 8$05 260 .0&('$/-$29 ,+ +/&2 /%) &$-&(32/%&0 $% '$*62 ,+ 260 /+,-0/$) )$&2(3 ,+ '/5 26$ <,(-2 +$%) 26/2 +,- 260 0%) ,+

" #$ % & '

% (

)

%* ( + ,!

! '

** ## (, ", ! (' (

!'- ./0 ( (!)) ,(1- 2/3&33345 6/7 ! #, % ( (!) ## +*- 2/6&33345 8/9 (! (&*

#! &

$ (

' ,1 - 2/6&33345 ;/< ) % ( 4 ( $% ( )#) - 2/3&33345 /< )(

% ) ,=% ('- 2/.6&33345 #- 2/.&=6&33345 >/

,!(1#$& '

(' (

! % (

)

%* (

) 2/.&8?&3345

, (!

% (

) 2/68&3345 #, !$ + ,!

! $ '

@,( #/ + :

,& '

) ( ,

(' (

! % (& ( : +

) '

!1% ( ( BCDEDFGDH IJK LKK MNO & P633?Q .6 RSS 63?& ' ##

T/U * , ((%&

,(1 ), % '

) '

+ ,!& ## , #V (& +' ' +##

* ! '

# % (5 ** ## ( +'( * , !

) + % (' ), % '

) ,

)

,) !

) ' !1% (& ) #(1 +' '& '

% ( ' ##

,,$ ( , '

, #, !$ + ,!

! $ '

@,( #/ .3/ !)$(1 '

+ ,! '

) , !

W (& '

*, ( ** # !* ! )/ ../ 1,$ !,

! (!

) '

!1% ( '

(

,( !@,( #) ,(

%*# (

XLBNY ZLB[\ .?/3./636; 9(], ^'

,* ](14, ( ! -_ 4` ^'

,, * , # -_ 4`