High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/297/2014dismissed

Haryana State Pollution Control Board v. Jyotirmay Daw

2015-07-16Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan6 pages

!""#$%$&' ()) * +, & -! !" ../!$&&!+. +0 11".. &!

2"+%/% ,!$+3 , 4 "%1&0"&!

+"%"&!' +) )-) &$ 506# !"+!7" 11.$# &!8 11".. &!) +))-)"0$506# !"+!7"+"%1&0"&!) 7$%$% & 11.$# !$&1+""++"0/&0"+-"#!$&:;

!7"

0" +$3$& . +#"0/+" + <+ &! ." 6" ! 11" . < $&%! !7" =/0<"3"&!0 !"0 :51 %%"0>,!7"." +&"0 +"%$0$&< $#"+5-1"#$ .

&6$+&3"&!/+!5 +$0 > 0 #?/$!!$&<+"%1&0"&!8 ##/%"0) 7"1+#"%%. 44 %%"!$&3!$&& #31. $&!$."0>, !7" +, & -! !" ../!$&&!+. +0!7+/<7$!% /!7+$@"0$#$ . & 3"., +) )2) -$&<7) 31. $&! 4 % $."0 %%"+!$&< !7 ! !7" ##/%"08+"%1&0"&!7"+"$&7 %#&%!+/#!"0 +37/%"&)

5+ 6 .$

"!+" !5 $%$& 5/+< &$&6$. !$& &!$$# !$&0 !"0)*) % 1"+47$#7!7"$&$%!+,&6$+&3"&! &0 +"%!%56!)&0$ 7 0 +"%!+$#!"0#"+! $& #!$6$!$"%$&!7"&!$$"0+"<$&%!7"+ 6 .$ &<")% 1"+#31. $& &!5 %74# /%"&!$#"+1+%"#/!$&0 !"0))*4 % $%%/"0/1&!7" ##/%"0++ $%$&<$.."< .#&%!+/#!$&)-/>33$!!"" 4 % .%#&%!$!/!"0#31+$%$&<$#"+%!7"&6$+&3"&!"1 +!3"&!5 +, & -! !" ../!$&&!+. +0 &0$%!+$#!03$&$%!+ !$&47$#7 7 0"A 3$&"0!7"%$!" &0 !"+#&%$0"+$&<!7"+"1.,!!7"%74# /%" &!$#"5+"#33"&0"01+%"#/!$& < $&%!!7"6$. !+%$&#./0$&<+"%1&0"&!

7"+"$&)%1"+#31. $&!5 ##/%"07 06$. !"0&!$$# !$&0 !"0)*) &0 % %/#7 4 % .$ >." ! >" 1/&$%7"0 /&0"+ %"#!$&% *8 !7"

&6$+&3"&! +!"#!$&#!) 7"#31"!"&!#/+!!B#<&$@ &#"!7"#31. $&! &0 $%%/"0%/33&$&<+0"+ < $&%! ##/%"0&() )$&1/+%/ &#"! 47$#77" 11" +"0 &04 % 03$!!"0!> $.)31. $& &!4 %!7"&# .."0 /1&!." 01+"#7 +<""6$0"&#") &$&0$&< 1+$3 #$"# %"#7 +<"/&0"+-"#!$& *!7"

&6$+&3"&! +!"#!$&#!4 %+ 3"0 < $&%!!7" ##/%"06$0"+0"+ 0 !"0) ) :)7"+" !"+5#31. $& &!"A 3$&"0-7)$&"%7 0 6 % C &0+))2)-$&<7 %C)-! !"3"&!!7" ##/%"04 %+"#+0"0 /&0"+-"#!$&:

:+) )547"+"$&7"0"&$"0!7" .."< !$&% &01." 0"0 $&&#"&#")&0""&#" ##/%"0"A 3$&"07$3%". %C &00#/3"&!% A) !A) 4"+"!"&0"+"0)""&#""6$0"&#"4 %#.%"0& :) & !7" !+$ . !7 ! 7 % "&%/"05 !7" ##/%"08+"%1&0"&! %! &0% #?/$!!"06$0"=/0<"3"&!0 !"0 :) /&%". 11" +$&<+!7" 11".. &!4/.0#&!"&0!7 !!7" +$ ./+!7 %"++"0$&6"+.B$&<!7"%#1" &0 3>$!&!$$# !$& $%%/"0>,!7"$&$%!+,&6$+&3"&! &0 +"%!%56!) &0$ )!$%#&!"&0"0!7 ! %1"+%/#7&!$$# !$&#&%!+/#!$& +3 7/%" 4$!7/! 1+$+ 1"+3$%%$& !7" #31"!"&! /!7+$!, $% !! .., 1+7$>$!"0 & . &0) ! $% +</"0 !7 ! !7"

##/%"08+"%1&0"&!7 01/+#7 %"0 +37/%" &0+ $%"0#&%!+/#!$& 6"+ & +" 81 +#".. &047$#74 %+"."#!"0 % % 1"++"6"&/"+"#+0+". !$&<! #!>"+5 )/+!7"+%/>3$%%$&7 %

: >""& 3 0"!7 ! !7""&!+$"% $& !7"+"6"&/"+"#+0 7 6"!7"+" !"+>""& #7 &<"0$&#&&$6 &#"4$!7!7"+"6"&/"$#$ .%)

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

!" ! #$

# & & $ #

! " !#$ ( '

)*+,

-#../01./23*45+ .*.

$ 6 3030 " !

( 7

84 30134,9301/:

!4/.05!7/%5>" 31.,#." +!7 !#&%!+/#!$&8 &,!7"+B$&0 #!$6$!,# &&!>"/&0"+! B"&4$!7/!1+$+1"+3$%%$&/1&. &08 +" 47$#7$%%74& % #

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

7 !"6"&$$!4 %!7"# %" !7"#31. $& &!!7 !"&!+$"%$&!7"+"6"&/"+"#+0%7 0>""&#7 &<"0$& #../%$&4$!7!7"+"6"&/"$#$ .%>,#7 &<$&< ! 5,"!5%$&#"!7"," + &1+#""0$&<%7 0>""& $&$!$ !"0+#++"#!$&<!7"% 3") !4/.0 .%>"1"+!$&"&!!! B"&!"!7 !!7"#31. $&! % .% 1+%"#/!$&4 %. /&#7"0&!7"> %$% +"1+!7 6$&<>""&%/>3$!!"

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

>"=/%!$$"03"+"., >"# /%"!7$%/+!4 %!>"$&#.$&"0!! B" 0$"+"&!6$"4) E" +&"0 #/&%".+!7" 11.$# &!8 11".. &!7 % $."0!1$&!/!

( 1"+6"+%$!,83$%+" 0$&<+ .+0#/3"&! +,"6$0"&#"&+"#+0>,!7" ." +&"0 +"%$0$&< $#"+5-1"#$ .&6$+&3"&!/+!5 +$0 > 0$&!7"

$31/<&"0=/0<"3"&!0 !"0 :)

+!7"+" %&%+"#+0"0 >6"5&# %"+$&!"+"+"&#"$% 3 0"/!) 7" 11.$# !$&%""B$&<<+ &!." 6"! 11" . < $&%!!7" $31/<&"0=/0<"3"&!0 !"0 :5$%0"#.$&"0 &0#&%"?/"&!.,"6"&!7"

##31 &,$&< 11" .$%0$%3$%%"0)

./#B,