Employees State Insurance Corporation v. M/S A.V. Auto Industries (P) Ltd
!
"
##
$ %&'$' ( ") *+ ('
## (
!"#$%
&'()* %
&+ ,'
*))$- )*!.
*% &'()* %
!"#$%
&'()* %
)%&*!% (*!.
*!(
,# % '''
-(.!
/ 0
'
/ 0 (
'
)%&*!% (*!.
*!(&
/0 2'
""
3 04 (3
(
(25'26'2776 ( 8 0
! -0
("3 00 ! 8/
/ ! ( 8
( "
3 (3 ."( ( (
( 26'9'6:29
(;0"!0 ( ( ,#
! " #$%& ' (
! "
" #$%&'
!"())
)
('* + ,
!
" * + , " -./ '
#$%1'
!"%11 +
4&4 *
('
, - ) ( .
6'
!
/ 0
!
""
;! '
<'
(
" ".
""
(!
( 3" ( (
0
!
"!
' .;
! ( !
(8 0!
0 "
( 0
!
" )"
0 0
" * "
0
0/ 8 -27=9
( 0 (
;
/ ( 0 . (2= / ;
38"("
;" !
'" !
; ( ;"
3 >6:::&#
0;''/' -27=9'!! ("
3- ( (
(6:'7'27==
(62'?'27=7; " (8 0
" @"
3 0 ."" / 0
!
" !
-27?=)/ 0 0!
* "!
8 0 (
(/ ! ""
3!
"8 "
/ 0 "( !
8 -27=9 -27==
"
3 2695:&#
( "
/765&#'33 ".(/ 0 ; / # "!( ( " (8 0
" - (
/"(
"!
" ( !
" 9A/ 0!
8/ 0 '' - 0
("3 0' $"( " 3 ( 4 (3
(
( 25'26'2776 0 ( (
(6:'7'27== @"
3 0 (
8
0 ."" ( 0!
0 ( (
(62'?'27=7! ""
!
"8 " / 0 "( !
8 -27=9 -27==-0 .8 "('
$";
@ 8 0'' "
0; @/ +""
(
" !
"( 8 0" !
(%
3"
3" !
( 0 / 0 ; (!;"
0"
0(/"
"
" /B "
!" C ( !
" 6 )7*/ 0!
' !! ("
3-
( 0" !
&%
3"
" !
!
/ 08 "/ "
3 0!
"8 " ."((/
( 0!
' ;
/ 0 0(8 0''
0 ;" !
( 0 (
(;0; / (; @"
3
(( ;"
3 ! ( 8
( BC ( !
" 6)7*/ 0!
'
?'
D0 .0 (
(! / 0
0
( . ( 0!
8@' !
" 6 8!
" )7*-!
" 6 8!
" )29*
(!
"
6 8!
" )66*/ 0!
(/"
"
3BC-B "
!" C
(BD 3C; (8 .
/ 0"
0
(
( ( !( 0 ( ,# /0$1 2 + "
3 0#14
+
+ +
5 0##1
+ + +
5 01
5 +
" " #$6#
5 3 1
5 01 07 +17
8 9 07 +17
8 0 1
5 :/0#;1 29
3 01
< " #$%& 5 01
8
8
5 01
5 /0//1 2 :
7
+3 +
3
7
3 1 "5 01
5 01
7
4)4 5 01 5:
A'
0" ;"
0 3 ( %
3"
3" !
/ !
/ "
3;"
0"
0
"
3/BC ( !
" 6 8!
" )7*/
0!
" 3 ' !0E " (
(F "
(
( (4 ("!
( 8 0F "
!
"
3
6
.7 '
-#$$%/#""%8'
5'
0!
/ 3
6
.7 '
) * 0''
( "."" !0/ 08 "30 - 3 !00(
%
3"
3" !
(8 0 (
#!
0 "
( / ;"
0"
0
"
3/BC ( !
" 6)7*/ 0 !
'0"30
0 8 .(
0%
3"
3" !
;
0
"
!" ' . "
3 !0.";- 0F 0(
"
!
0%
3"
3" !
0 ( ; @ ( 0!
( ."" / 0 (/" !
( ("!0 30"/ !
" -0;
8"
33".
" /2:::&#
0- 0 E ""
! ("
" / "!
8""
/ 0 BC (/"
( ( !
" 6)7*/ 0!
(
"/"(' ;
/ 0 0(
0(/"
"
" /B "
!" C !
"
("
!
" 6 8!
" )29*/ 0!
; ( "
!
;0 0%
3"
3" !
"/ ( 8 0;
!! " / 0 / !
' ;
8 .(
%
3"
3" !
80"/!
8 "(
8 0;
/ 0/ !
;0"!08 3 ".
""
(!
( 0; @"
3/ 0/ !
"!
(8 0
" 8(/ (/ " !
' 0 F / 0 8 .(
. "
3
%
3"
3" !
8 B "
!" C- 0 " 0"
3"
0!
"
("!
0%
3"
3" !
8"
3 0B "
!" C !
8
(/"
( ( !
" 6)7*/ 0!
'
1 0 ; ( 0%
3"
3" !
;
0( 0 . ( !
!"
'
9'
05-9-=
(7/ 04 (3
( ("
3
.7 '
) * ; ( 8 .
( F
!
( 0 ( ,# 6 =
2
!/!3 0$1"
> :/0$1 2
+ " 3 014
+
+
+
5 01
+ + +
5 01
5 +
"
4(4 " #$6# 5 3 1
01 07 +17
8 9 07 +17
8
0 1
5 " +
7 ? 30#1,
= 3
5 0/1! + " 5 0@1,
+
+ 5 0%1
5 0A14
0@1
(
B ,
+ 4
7
4%4
061= ' 7
7
8 =2
!/ 3 0//1"
> :/0//1
7
+3 +
3
7
3 1 "5 01
5 01
7 5 01 5: " '
"
!
+ C
#/ DDDE3
C
#DDDE3 7
=
(
7
!
4$4
=
!
+ + =,
" "
7 ( 7 +
7
?
, 7 2
!
(
+ =
=
%
3 !
!
A !
+
, 7C
#D DD DDDE3
,
7C
#D DD DDDE3
,
4#94 7C
# DDDE3 =
"
=
!
C
#/ DDDE3 C
#DDDE3
8 2
!/ 3 0$1" =
? 2
"
! ;
, (, '
! 3
29
! / 3 0#;1"
> :/0#;1 29
3 01
< " #$%& 5 01 8
8
5 01 5
4##4 =
B
+
(
(
B
!
< " #$%& !
2 !/ 3 0#A1"
< " #$%&
!;0#1 < " "
!
" -
+
( -
- *
) F.
< ( F.
G0#$$616!66AH
!/01 < "
?
>3 :/# =
33
(
=
( 33
4#&4 (
2
7 :
, ' !
!/ 3 0#;1"
!/ 0#A1" !/01< " "
" "
+
(
,
!
7
7
(
&
(
,
!
"
!
( -
! C 9 0
?
=
+ - C -
6 ;C
> :8
!
4#54
+ =
?
=
7
?
"
,
+
4
:
#@ C " "
> :4
+
4#14
= 7
B
7 + =
7 7
(
=
7
7
,
:
4
!
"
"
=
+ ( C
#DDDE3 +
7
$
=
= ( '
' = 7" " 4
(
?
'
C
! = C '
0
(
4#)4
-
!/ 3 0$1" C
- 0
+
"
=
?
?
=
?
+
='
;"
3 0 ("!
"( (;
"
0 !
/ 3
.7 '
) *-;0(
0%
3"
3" !
&" !
/ 0 (
!
; ( / ;"
0"
0 (/"
"
" / 0 F " BC ( !
" 6)7*/ 0!
( 0 8 @"
0
8 0 ."" / 0!
"
/ !
"8 "
;
("
!'
7'
0 / !"
; ( !! ("
3'
2:'
."; / 0 8.- 0 " 3 ( 4 (3
(
( 25'26'2776 (8 0''' -0
("3 0-" "(' E
0 0 ( (
(6:'7'27==
(62'?'27=7 (8 0
" @"
3 0 ."" / 0 !
"!
8 0 (
;''/'2'2:'27=9 ! ""
3!
"8 " / 0 "(
4#84 ;''/' !
8 -27=9 -27== ;
("
!-
( .".('
22'
" ;("
0 / "( '
&+ ,'
*))$
)%&*!% (*!.
*!( )*!.
*% &'()* % &'.%
!@ D0 0 @"
3& (, & D0 0
8, &