High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/9780/2022allowed

Rubal v. State Of Haryana

2022-08-29Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal3 pages

!"#$"%&'&()

*+ , "!&!&(" - ! !"# . ( "'/($"(!

) 01 21

"'"(!) . (3*/! 4$5% !"4#!6"/"!&!&(" '6""(** 44 . ( 7777777 2148 19 (: !6&'*!6 $/ ''"$!6"#,,;&(<$") = (:>4!6&'*!6 $$&"%!"$!6"! !"!/$*%"!6" /'"%*!&?+"#"!6"& ,*!+*!!6"! !"$&$(! "?/, ( !&(&' ,'#!6%@&(<#@!6"," ("$! !"%*('", ' !;6.!6"$"#!6&'*!$ !"$:>; '(!%@/,&"$;&!6 1"!(!&%"+"&''*"$!!6"*/"&(!"($"(!# ,&%"4&($ '!;6.

#'*%6, /'"/%""$&(<'*($"!6"(!"@/!#*!'%!4

+"(!&(&!& !"$ < &('!6&@ (@, ,&344 . ( 4 %%"/!'(!&%"(+"6 ,##!6" ,,"<"$%(!"@(" ($/ .'#!&@"!#&,"6&' ##&$ 5&!

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

EF 6"/"'"(!/"!&!&(6 '+""(#&,"$*($""%!&(: #!6"

< (!#"<*, + &,&( D$ !"$ "<&'!""$*($""%!&(' ($D#!6" !"%!&(#6&,$"(#@"?* , ##"(%"'%!4 ! ,&%"! !&( ,"; 4&'!&%!&($ 6"/"!&!&("&'+"&(</'"%*!"$#6 5&(< /"$ @&(<&, 1" ("$%*('",#!6"/"!&!&("%(!"($'!6 !!6"/"!&!&(";6&' ." ,$+.6 '+""(# ,'",.&@/,&% !"$&(!6&'% '"G6"$"'(!6 5" (.!6" %&@&( , (!"%"$"(!'G6"&'&(%*'!$.'&(%" G&(!6" !6" ,,"< !&('

;"" < &('!("3'6 .G&(!6"'! !"@"(!<!"%$"$+.!6"/'"%*!&?( +"#"!6" <&'! !"*($""%!&(D '6"6 ''/"%&#&% ,,.

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

,$ +.G 6" 6 ' ( !6" %&@&( , (!"%"$"(!'G6"&'&(%*'!$.#!6", '!(" ,.("." G '/"!6"/'"%*!&?0' 1 '6"6 $"#*'"$&(!"( ,"? @&( !&( ($6""?!"( ,"? @&( !&('6;'( &(A*.(6"/"'(G '/"!6" 1"/!('"@"(6 '+""($"!"%!"$( (.#!6" ' @/,"'#!6"/'"%*!&?'"(!##"('&%"5 ,* !&(G&(!6" ' ,'!

'! !"@"(!<!"%$"$+.!6"/'"%*!&?*($""%!&(D ( !6"/"!&!&("; '(!( @"$!+"!6"%*,/&!G ,,@ !"& ,/'"%*!&(;&!("''"'4

E:F &(%,*$&(<!6"/'"%*!&?4 ," $.'! ($"? @&("$&(!6"/"!&!&("0'!& , ($!6 ! '&(%":/'"%*!&(;&!("''"''!&,,"@ &(!+""? @&("$&(!6"/"!&!&("0'!& ,4 !6"' @"&',&3",.!! 3" ,(<!&@"!%(%,*$" (5&";#!6" +5"4!6"/"'"(!% '"&'%('&$""$!+" #&!("&( ;6&%6!6"/"!&!&("+"$&"%!"$!+""," '"$("<*, + &, "'*,! (!,.4'*+A"%!

!!6"' !&'# %!&(#!6"%(%"("$H*!. <&'! !"4!6"/"!&!&("&'$&"%!"$ !+""," '"$(+ &, !&'%, &#&"$!6 !!6" +5"+'"5 !&('6 5"+""(@ $"(,.#!6" ,&@&!"$/*/'"#$"%&$&(<!6"/"'"(!"<*, + &, //,&% !&( ($!6"' @";*,$ (!+"%('!*"$!+" ("?/"''&(#/&(&((!6"@"&!'#!6"% '" E 21F '6 @'6" I6"!6"'/" 3&(<H" '("$ ) "'H I6"!6""/! +,"

)"'H