State Of Haryana v. Ishwar Singh












 



  

 

! " #!$!%!

&"   %" '"(  )*! %+) ,"- %."% 


 
 
 

    


!

"
!#
$!%&$
'

(" & 
)&*
+
&$$!( ,
!
"

-.,/) '

1 "2!3 4 !
+
#

,
!
!

"
!
'!

1 "2!3 5 



-.,/) '

"

!.$,
+
!

,
6'

6/ "

1 "2!3 &""% '/!!/0 10#!$!%! !-!%2(3!0 .4 ! "

 )""- %."%  
  7
 $
6"%
!
895
!#
49:

)!-- !  %)!6""%".  %.

%!  7.!$ ."!$%%+ )"!

3-!%$%+!-- !  "!4" !--"!

-- !  %    ! *".  !%.  ."!$    7  .!$  %  %+  )"

!

3-!%$%+!-- !  "!4" !--"! %.

%".!-"+ (%. 3"%  %".% )"!-- !  $
6"%
!
558
!#
49:

)"-""% !-- !  %)!6""%".6$ )" ! " #!$!%!

(%." %87 
&
 +!%  "!4" !--"!!+!%  )"

  ! :( !  .! ".  7;  -!".  6$  -" !  <(.+"

(3



..  %! " %<(.+"0<)!99! ="$0  )"  !     )"  !"  !  3!."  (  %  )"  -""% !-- !  "!4" !--"!!" )! 

,

.! ".8*! "+ "".(%." %8!%.. &
 0>77! &  " !  %

'=#0, ) !/!+!% ! (".

%."% 0%!3"$0 )*! %+) % )"6! 3-!% 3!."6$)!!36&?

!"+%+ )""% )! )"

+ %(".)6(!  3 !  %! %(!% "
3-!%$@3 ".6( ) 6(! )!.."..(" !3"%  #"3"  )*! %+)0'" "%!$

(+"

%0 %3!# - !0'!+"(6!.)!%% )"+!.0*) ."3!%.".

 A !66" +" %+ )"%(!% "!3 (%   
;0A   )"

6(! )" 3-!%!% *!% %!4 ( +4%+66"0 % ."

!/"!  %!+!%  )""- %."% 0)"3!."! 3-!% !+!% )3% )"6! !. 3-!% 0!!.%+-! $*! %  ( ".!%.!3 (%  66"*!"

4"".% )"-""% " )!.

** %")"

,*! "+ "".!+!%  )""- %."% ,"- %."% ! ". !!%.( 3! "$ )"*!! :( ".  )" )!+"6$ )" !
( 4." 9(.+3"% .! ".

7;  %  )"  + (%.  )!  )""  *""  3! "!  % !.  %  !%.

% % "% "  %  )"   ! "3"%     )"  * %""0  !%.  )!  )"

- %)!.!". 4" )"."3!%.!*"!! "- !% " 66"

%"$  6$  ! (".

%."%    4"%  3-!%!% )!3!6  *)"

!--"!%+!&?

!%.3&!/!)0)!.

** %"!&?

;)!4"%

(--  ". )" !" )"  ! "!.  9(.+3"%    ! :( !    (69"  3! "  )!"%+"% )"-""% !-- !  "!4" !--"! @"!%".  (%"     )"  !-- !%

! "  (63   )!  )"

! :( !% 6!". %- -"!--" !  "4."% "

%$ )""

4"$ 66"!3 (% *!3!." 3! (".

%."% 6( )" 3-!%!% )!.! !.3 ".)+%! (" %! )".

(3"% "

 "

4"$3"3 !%. 3-!% 0*) ) )"6! "+ ! 

, )  !   "    ( "%   ) *  )!  )"  ! (".

%."%  )!.

."3!%."."+!+!  !  %0*) )*!-!. )36$ )" 3-!%!% !%. )"!3"*!"4"%"

4"".6$ )"%4" +! %+  " 3 )"

- " ! (".% )"-""% " ( $!+ ! "!%. )!.

* * %"@"!%". (%"  )"!-- !%

! "( )"(63  )!  % "

!%!3 (%  
A *!"

4"". 3 )"- "  )"! (".

)"% )"6(."% 4")%% "% " ")!.) ". % )"! (".

6(  )"!3")!% 6""%.

%" 

%$ )"."3!%.6( "4"% )"

! "- !% ")!! 6""%- 4". @"!%".  (%"     )"  "- %."%  (63   )!  !$  !

.""% 4" %)!6""% ! ".6$ )" 3-!%!% %) ! "3"% "

.".(%." %;
&
)" 3-!%!% *)"!--"!%+% )" 
(  )!  %   ! ".  "4"%  !  %+"  * .  !+!%  )"  ! (".

%."% 

%$ )" 3-!%!% 6( "4"% )")!.

** %")!%

(--  ". )" !" #"!. )"!+(3"% !.4!% ".6$"!%". (%"  )"

-! "!%.)!4"! + %" ) (+) )".

(3"% !4!!6" % )"" )!!36  &?

    )"   !  * %"  !  )" 

,  *! "+ "". % )"6! 3-!% 3!."6$)3#")! ! ".%)  ! "3"%  )! )+%! ("*"" 6 !%". %6!%/-!-"!%.%" )" )" -"   %"."3!%.".% ! "- ".!%$66" 3 )3 )"!.

* %"*! (%".)  "!..% (--   )" !" #"*!!    "B!3%".! "%+ )6( % % 3%! %+"4."% ")!

3" %"

.!+!%  )"! (".

%."% 

3!$03&!/!)&?

;0*) *!!-- % ".!)!.

* * %"  %  )"  !.%+  -! $  !%.  *!  % ( ".   !

3-!%$  )"

3-!%!% #" ! ".%)   "B!3%!  % )! )+%! ("*""

;

6 !%". %6!%/-!-"% )"'" "%!$# - !#")!!  ! ".

)!  )"-  ""3!%". )"" !6 (  %") (% )"=&  "0 <)!99!!%.-  "-! $ 6 !%".)+%! ("% )"=&  "0<)!99!  & !99!%2(3!&?

8

/!.""%  !%.6$ ! %+ )!

!* %+* /*!.

%"% )"'" "%!$# - !!%. 

/ ) (

-"(!  ! "3"%  %* %"") * )!  )""* %"")!4"+4"%.""% 4" %* )"+!.  %.(  )"  - "".%+  !%.  "4"%  * )  "+!.   -! "    "" %+  "

4"$

!99!%2(3!&?

8)! ! ". )! ! )"- "".%+*"" %.( ".

!  )"- "'" "%!$# - !(- -30*)""!0,!32!!%0 ( $!+ ! "&?

)! ! ". )! ! )"- "".%+*"" %.( ".

%&?=,," # ("! <)!99!(-  ;-33&!/!)0)!.

* * %"&?

;)! ! ". )! - "".%+  )" !"*"" 3-" ".% )"=& "! <)!99!)" ! "3"%  ! "!.* %""!"%

%$% % "% 6(  % !. $ "! ) )"

3!$ %2(3!0#"!.
% !6"&?

)! ! ".%)  ! "3"%  )! )")!%.". 4" )"-" !"-   !:!!+ ! "% &?=,," # ("! 8-3!%. )""! ")"3"  & !99!% 2(3!&?

8%&  "@%"0<)!99!! 7-3!%.)!%.". 4" )"

-$  )"

, )30*)""!0 & !99!%2(3!&?

8)! ! ". )!

%  2(3!0  #"!. 
% !6"  &?

  3"  )3  %  '" "%!$  # - ! (6!.)!%! -33&!/!)0)!.

** %"&?

;.(%+ )"

(" )"

"B!3%!  %"4"%)!."%".+4%+ )"!3 (% !66"

)"! (".6$ )" 3-!%!% )""! % !.  %* )"+!.

-""% " %."-"%."% * %""!  )" 3" %.( %+!.

%4"*  )"!6 4"0 )"- %)!!". 4"  !"6"$ %."! %!6".

(6 !%. )" !
( )!+) $! :( ". )"

! (".

%."%   %.% %3 $ !%."+! $% )"3-(+%".

 ! :( !!%. )""6"%+% 3" % )" % "%  %!".6$ "!%". (%"  )"!-- !%

! "0 )"!-- !  +!%  "!4"

!--"!)""6$.3".  6"0 1
  3 -

9!