High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/230/2021disposed of

Ravi v. State Of Haryana

2022-09-05Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary12 pages

! "#$ %& ' !

()*++,- *'

-&.*,--.,%& /*' ' *) +)&' , *++ 0 0*1(02 ,')&*+ - + 3(0,4,2 0*''++)&*' 0 * 1(02 56 7, )&*+ () +3(+ 0,8+, 4***(' *) (

9:! 6 :2 * 9:! 6 : & 7:! :& 6 :2 * 5-:! :& 6 :2 * -++* 4( ( +& /*)*'( *2'+ ;1 2 2 ) * '+ 0 * *

9< ,4*+* 0*2&+) 00 %

5;<

+ 04**( +'++ 42 02 ++0 3=*+* ++0.( ,;+ 22*'' *0*' * 0+0 2

**0*2 *)*( +/*,* *++ + ( (+ 97/*' 0 0 * *++ ( 1(/*&4(***'+%4 ,* * ;+ + 4& 2 * ' >: 4 0 ( 0 ,2= 4** *+4) 0 )&(* 8(2? ' '

*2 ,40 0 *( *2'+ ++*2+,*++

4' 0 *( *( > 0'2, + +(2* *00 *(22 ( 9, 9,7 5-:!,4***'+ 0(+& +2+ /*'( ,4* 4' ,'( 2 & 5 '( 4 , ) '+ 0 * (2 &

+ 0 *'( , 2 * (4( ! -++* 2 2+4'(*(% *++0 ,++0+ 2'+ +2*2+)

%4 ,*( + & * -* 0*+ ( +*' 0 *(0** )(0* ,*+ +(2* +( **'( *' ,) 0 0*20(+

0 *(- 0+&,*(' 4 2 ) ' >+ 000 ,* ' *+ ''+, 4**42)&*+ - + 3(0,4 2'(0 1(02 % ,*' @ ( +*' ,* &(,()2 ** 4* *++ 0* +& '& 2 4*' *' +&( ( *, 2+&A*' * +& )4

*2+&,4** *2*,4 4 2 *+ A*** 0 5A*2*,4*9

&0, 2 00*+*,2 * 5,'' 4*''+ *,4* * *+***(* )*' )(* **() (+ 4**' ,*4 *4 *+ 0& <&:+ ' <** * * 0+ 4*** *(,) 0* ' (' *' = 0''* +0,*

*('' ( 0 02+'( *'+ A * *2+22) *2+&B'*' ****,*2+& (++& * 0 * (0 *22=C( 02 * ( +A +*,*+ ( +* ' *()2**2+ 2'2)4

*' 2+&*,4** 0 ' (* 0 * ' ' * (& , * ' *+&( &,2 * <&, +( 2 ,(*+ 4&4*2 * ' *+*0 &'+ * 9 @ ( +*2'+ *+'( '' +*%*'( 4 , 4***) +)&(*+, 1( *;1 0*, 4**= =D-D D;D:

* ,* ) 2 * *& 0 ' (* 0 * ' * 0(0() 0)4 *2+& * *'

*** ,+ ( +*''* '& * ' * * + ( )+4 B2 0++'*2,* 0*+& * ' :* **+ ( +*' '(* /*+ +(**(0*+&B2 * , 4**4***2'+ *( +4 ++ *2&+,4* ;+ 22*'' ) 0 E0E02

, 0*2'* *+ * *)(++* 0 *+) 0 *

0+0 2

**2 *( + *0*+ 0*2

++ )&' * 0 *++22+' ''( 97**( ('4 /*( 4 *( *2'+ ,4*'' !F74))& ' 4 ,4*''!F,4* 4*+* 1(&4 ' *2+ * 4* **)* *+ )&*(' ,4 ) 0 &' )* ,* 4 =+24 * *+''+&,)(++ :4 ( )&*+ +(* &*(+ 04* 2 *) (+&' )&!F7;1 0* !F(*+:

* , 1(;2+*,*!

4 ' )&!F5- *4*+*-*=,4*+4' )&!F" 8(2# *B2 * 0 *+ 4 ()&!F#% 1&,'*'4**+ 04* '*0'*#B!-!.,40++&' **

C( 422)&* 0 *+ )&(G ' :4+*2+'(* 0) )&!F7;1 0* !F(*+4' )&!F (*!( /*+ +(,) *2 !F7 !F *2+ ,*+*4' )& )+ ()*** 0+0 0* 0 *+)&* ' ,+* /* ()2 )*+ * ' 4 + (++& , +&)) 02 22+*02 (* @ - +

< 3(0)4*2,*' ' *+ ''+0 * 1(02 *+ +(+ *(2* -*=8(2 ;2+,4**4(+&' )&!F5 !F7,* 2+0 ( 1( )&!F7 !F,' &*( *(2* 0+0 0

*', +(*4* *' 0* 0 *+

)&*' G((+ '**(' 4

0*2+& *(' 2()4 *2,4**2&+* @ - + 3(02**'( *((++&)+*** ( + B (& 4* )+ '' '( 0( 0 0 * 1(& '()+ 0 ++&

(+ '(+4**(+ *( (+ * -*= ;2+ 0 ( 1(;1 0* (*+ - 0+&,)**()+4* 0( E* * 0*+& *' * ( 9,9,7 5-:! * ' * ( 0)&)**()+4-(*,* *' 2 0 0* +2)0(2 *+ ( + *' * 4*20 0(2 , * *' )(*'+&( , *(* 4* 4*'(+ (2 *' ,'(++& 4* *2** ' A*2* 0) 2'2)4 *',+

=D-D D;D,*' * 0( (& &,2 * <& *0 &'+ , ,1( B' (* *' * '+&( )&*2:+'' +4** ) '(+ (2 /* 4=

)&*(+ (''2*1(02 *% D)+('2 ( *H

!""

#$"%&'() &"

&*"H'< 5 2 + <5 AH ( '

+*! & &", -

I,7-: 9 *1(02 *(

J * )'

+*!#& &", -

. + 99 /*+ ) 2)&*% D)+('2( *

(' ( H<F* (++&'(* (2 **+ ( + *'+ 0*

*+& * (2 *,'(++&

4*2 2)&*+ ( + *, ( 4,* 1( 4(+)2,* *''++ ( *'+&( )&*2/*''++ 4+)&*(( 0' &* ''+ *& 4 C(( /* 2')&*+(, +&', 4(+)'4* (4=2** 1(02 H

2++& * ( '

+* (' *-'B( *) ( H-* 0( +*',4 **++ 0( *' < *,C( '+ , * +4* *2 2(2')(+ )4/*%0*(++)( 4 *2 2(2 )( 24* *+0+' 4 *''++ (+)0

+ F 02 4** 4* %0*(/*''++ 6' 0)(9 ( 02*2++ *+ ' ;,*' 0 &*4

*2+=+)&*245K * % 00*,*B' * 4*%0*(41(F 0+& (* *''++ *'+& ( /* , 2 4 2***+&'* * +& )+,**(+)+*4* /*''+' 0+&H :

* * )'

+* (' )&++4 0*1(02 *% D)+('2( J& &",

)!# )* /#*'L 2 + 5 ,*(4*+('*+ 0*

* ' * * ( * * ' )& ) 0( J%4 , * '& * + ( + ( *() *' B 2 * 4 * % I)+ ('2 (D 1(02 )* /#*'#,2' :2&) * '*(& '( ,*' *+&( 92 * &(*+ 4 &2'(' *2 /*% I)+('2( )* /#*'I (' ,4*+ 0**%0*(, *)&( 0* 2'(' *( &*'+&( )&*2 5,&,4* B2 ** (' * :4*+( J9:

* *(2* 0+0 0 * ) )+* /* ( * )

+& 0 * (2) *+ *4* *+ * ) ++&* 0+0 : 2( 0 ( = , * 0+0 2

04*&(*(+ (( *(2 * (+ '+ +4* 2 * 0 /* '0 , 4

' ,* +++'+4-2 4** 2 *, ')+&,0(*2+*)( *** '2*() )&'&2 2' **+4 * (*2'+2 *+4*(+ 0)+ ( ** (* '(+ + * 24*( ''++4**, 4&,4* *(* +' 0 0('* 2 +&&M( 00

)'+)' ++(2 @ *'*2'( (4*+ 0 * * * +(B((+& 2'2 + +&,*' '+ 00 E * 2()(* 4* * 2' &' 0(' * *:

(' ,4*4 &**%0*(*)

4&4&)&*' 2& ''+& 0* ' '+*'&2 2' ( 5&:)+(+& * +22'+&2'*&:, 4&2=& 1(;(1(H*4 00+&H,H* 0 2H HC( (H* (* 2 )+0* +& * + * 2)(2 &*( *2:(+2+&

****'()+ 1(+&2:

( 4,* &2')&*+

0 4** * ) 2)&* ''++ (*(+)(B2 *L 0**' =' 0 4 *20 0(2 ) ,*(* 4 * * +(** 1(4(+) C(+&2* *' )( *'+&( )&*2&,2 * <& +( 02 ,'*(&,()& '(&(' ,! ,.((02,+)&*+ ( +* :

4*'(+ (2 *' ) ,('+4** 2 ,*

*' *2 + ' ('*+%4 ,* )(*'+&( )& ' %4 ,* *++2 /*' 4(++ '& ,62' *@*)** -*= ;2+ 6* /* 2( 2' *++ ) ' )& * ' 4** *3(+ 04* ' 2 *2&,+ 04**,*' ' *++)2 )2 *' 4(+( 02' 2 4 )&*+ +()+4/**3(+ 0 4(+)(*2( *+0+**0 *

''' F**2 * 7 ')&+ +(, ) ,*2 + '

'+&++4

0 1 0 F**'= 06 M6 F**')+