Amritpal Singh And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ANR.


  

       


 


 !"# #$%&%'(
)**


+,%"!-.%'/0.!'/0!!'1"0#,& ***#"%"%'#,& 2#,&3& ."!"# !,4!'!!'1!'"0#, *** #&5'1#'"&



 !  ,#&#'"( ,*##5!6 35"!718$!"# ,"0#5#"%"%'#,&* ,*&06.* 0!310!,4711-* *!,4!'!* ,*2%6!& !,/718$!"# ,"0#$+5-!%'!'"*  ! "   * ,!4#,  %&  ,  :3!&0%'/      *  )  1!"#1  ;**
 ,#/%&"#,#1 3'1#,  .#$"%'&  )
)7  )7  < 7      !"  -%$#  ."!"%'

3,3/,!+7  .!1!,7  %&",%$"  3,3/,!+ ''#=3,#   7  '  "0#  >!&%&  

$+5,+%&#  1!"#1  *;*
;  ''#=3,#  
 #'"#,#1  %'"  >#"?##'

5#"%"%'#,  *    !'1  ,#&5'1#'"  * 
># ,#  "0#  #1%!"%'  !'1

'$%-%!"%' #'",# "0%& 3,"%'#1%!"%' !&#* 
;%'

*
< 
*
* 3,&3!'"""0#&#""-#+#'"@$+5,+%&#!,,%8#1!">#"?##'"0# 5!,"%#&%*#*''#=3,#
7"0%& 3,"78%1#,1#,1!"#1
*)*
 1%,#$"#1 &"!"#+#'"& "0#5!,"%#&">#,#$,1#1>4"0#A1* ,%!- 3,"@--!:!

!/%&",!"#* #5,",#/!,1%'//#'3%'#'#&& "0#$+5,+%&#!-'/?%"0"0# &"!"#+#'"& "0#5!,"%#&0!&>##' ,?!,1#1>4"0# 3," "0#A#!,'#1 11%"%'!-  0%#  31%$%!-  !/%&",!"#7  3,3/,!+  "0,3/0  "0#  A#!,'#1 11%"%'!-%&",%$"!'1.#&&%'&31/#7 3,3/,!+*0#,#5,"%'"#,!-%!

 +#'"%'&"0!""0#5!,"%#&0!8#$+5,+%&#1"0#+!""#,8-3'"!,%-4?%"03" !'4 5,#&&3,# ,$#,$%'7 "0# $+5,+%&# %&  /#'3%'#!'1  ?%"03" !'4 5,#&&3,#,3'13#%'

-3#'$#!'1 "0!" 3" !$$3&#1'!+#1%'"0# !$$3&#1B03&01##5B!3,0!&>##'#='#,!"#1>4"0#'8#&"%/!"%'//#'$4 %'"0# %'!-,#5,"!'1 !&5#,,#$,1 ''# "0#!$$3&#1%& !5,$-!%+#1 

#'1#,*  54    "0#  &#""-#+#'"@$+5,+%&#  1##1  !&  !-&  "0#  ,#5," &3>+%""#1>4"0#11%"%'!- 0%# 31%$%!-!/%&",!"#7 3,3/,!+"0,3/0 "0#%&",%$"!'1.#&&%'&31/#7 3,3/,!+7%&"!6#'',#$,1!'1&0!--

,+5!," "0%&,1#,* )* A#!,'#1  $3'&#-  ,  "0#  ,#&5'1#'"$+5-!%'!'"  &"!"#&  "0!" 5!,"%#&0!8#$+5,+%&#1"0#+!""#,!'1"0!"%'"#,+& "0#$+5,+%&# "0#5!,"%#& %-#1 ,!'10!8#>##'/,!'"#11%8,$#3'1#,.#$"%')

"0#%'13!,,%!/#$"7>#&%1#&"0##'"%,# !+3'"%*#* &*77@ "?!,1&5#,+!'#'"!-%+'4!'1+!%'"#'!'$#!/,##1">#5!%1>45#"%"%'#, *",#&5'1#'"*
0!&!-,#!14>##'5!%1!'1%'"0#$%,$3+&"!'$#& "0#$+5-!%'!'"0!&'>C#$"%'%  *)1!"#1;**
3'1#, .#$"%'&)
)7)7< 7 ,#/%&"#,#1!/!%'&""0#5#"%"%'#,&!"-%$# ."!"%'  3,3/,!+7  .!1!,7  %&",%$"  3,3/,!+  ''#=3,#    !'1  !-- 5,$##1%'/&$''#$"#1%',#&5#$""0#,#"!,#:3!&0#1* * 'D>-#.35,#+# 3,"%'$!&#"%"-#1%"#'1,! !/038!'&0%

,&*8*!>%"! !/038!'&0%',*E ,%+%'!-55#!-*; 
)7

,%&%'/3" .*A**

,%* *
 

F!'1*.*&0%!'1 "0#,& 8*."!"# !,4!'!!'1',*,#5,"#1!&
) .

;!,#C31/+#'"&%'

&355," "0#5,5&%"%' ,:3!&0%'/  %'&3$0-%6#$!&#&!&"0#&!+# ?3-1>#%'"0##'1& 3&"%$#* #-#8!'"#=",!$" "0#1#$%&%'>4"0# 'D>-#.35,#+# 3,"%'*.*&0%8*."!"# !,4!'!7
) .

# ;7%&!&3'1#,(
     

          

   

 





  

     

   

 

               

!

 "

 #  

$ 

               

      %

 & '

  

     

           

 



  

 

  

  

 (        )      

     

 

  

'   %

* ! +"$ 

'

 

 ' 

,  

 

)

'  

-

     

   

 



 

    



     -

''        

 

  

'   %

* ! +"$ .

'      



  /   %

0+  .  .





  

      1$2   

  3+$%  4 ()56 

'



        %

. 

         &

   

 

 .  





   

 

 

 -



 $   )    . )  -   

. )'      

    



  ( -

'                    

-

  -

            -

    

  

 

 ' 

  

     

' (

 )



 



-    )

  (

)     

 -

   %  

-

.

  



            

   

- 

 

7

.

 



 



 (

    )  

,  

     

  



1$2 '  

!

 

. 

   )

1$2 



 

    

      

$

   

''

 



     

  $  '    

     

 

)

 

  

 '    

  ) 

 

                 '     '   

  )    '          

 

    ) 

)' )    



    

   

 

 

   $ ) 

'.  

   ) 

, 

 

 8

&

         

     

    

      /     9 '






)
$  . ).  



  

  '   ') 

  (     33  $6)  :

-   %    )  %-   -  !

   &

      %

.



 

(





'       

 



  

&   

-





 



 ,. 

 .  

  ) 

(

% .  .   

 ('

 )'

    



 . 

'.  (





 

 .

      3     

  )  $    ' 

   



 

  30  )

'

 .  

 '   & . ;<2 )5<  .

+++  0  %  "*0  )'             

( )    

 ' 

$     

 

     

   

  6 

  '.     

 '

 

       )  ' =  

    ( 

'    

 

 



     

    

         '

) )

 

      )         

       

     '     '



 



 

   





'     )     

       

   '  '     

 

& 

 

( '  '

    






'


'





  



 

   -    >>/!  %

* /! $ 

 

)



 '  '

)  %

* /!

 

) 

 

 



)  



  

  

)



'/    ' '    )           

)     



 

-   

 )

 

)'

(

  /&

  

 

 

  -

 )

  

 



-  >>/! $    3?$)   )



.    &

        1$2   %

0+   



     %

   3"1   



. 

   -       1$2 ) 



* 0!8#0#!,1-#!,'#1$3'&#- ,"0#5!,"%#&>#&%1#&,#&5'1#'"

*
?0%&5,#&#'"%'5#,&' !'1%&%1#'"% %#1>4-#!,'#1$3'&#- , ,#&5'1#'"*
*'&"!'"5#"%"%' ,:3!&0%'/ "0# 0!&>##' %-#1%'

"#,+&    5!,!/,!50  *  %8    "0#  +5,+%&#  ''#=3,#  
*

#&5'1#'"*
&"!"#&"0!"&0##=#$3"#1"0#$+5,+%&#3" 0#,?'

,##?%--!'10!&'>C#$"%'% "0# !'1!--$''#$"#15,$##1%'/&%'

,#&5#$""0#,#"!,#:3!&0#1*A#!,'#111%"%'!-18$!"# #'#,!-0!&!-& '"55&#1"0#5,!4#, "0#5#"%"%'#,& ,:3!&0%'/  *) 1!"#1;**
,#/%&"#,#13'1#,.#$"%'&)
)7)7< 7 !"

-%$#."!"%' 3,3/,!+7.!1!,7%&",%$" 3,3/,!+ ''#=3,# !&!-& !--$''#$"#15,$##1%'/&%',#&5#$""0#,#"7%'8%#? $+5,+%&#1!"#1 *;*
; ''#=3,#
#'"#,#1%'">#"?##'"0#5!,"%#&># ,#"0# #1%!"%'!'1 '$%-%!"%' #'",# "0%& 3,"%'#1%!"%' !&#*  
;%'

*
< 
7&"!"#+#'" ,#&5'1#'"*
!&?#--!&"0#,#5,"&3>+%""#1>4"0#11%"%'!- 0%# 31%$%!-!/%&",!"#7 3,3/,!+"0,3/0"0#%&",%$"!'1.#&&%'&31/#7 3,3/,!+7 !&?#--!& -!?-!%11?'>4'D>-#"0#.35,#+# 3,"!&,# #,,#1"!>8#* * '8%#? "0#5&%"%'!&'"#1!>8#%*#* 5#"%"%'#,* !'1,#&5'1#'"* 
 0!8%'/1#$%1#1"5!,"$+5!'4!+%$!>-4&!&" +8#'%'-% #!'1'"/#">//#11?'%'3'#'1%'/-%"%/!"%'&!&",> "0#+   "0#%,  43"0  !&  !-&    $0!'$#&    3-"%+!"#  $'8%$"%'  %'  "0# !

,#+#'"%'#1 >#%'/>-#!671%8,$#0!8%'/>##'/,!'"#1"5#"%"%'#, *!'1,#&5'1#'"*
7#'"%,#5!4+#'" 5#,+!'#'"!-%+'4!'1 +!%'"#'!'$#!/,##1">#5!%10!8%'/>##'5!%1>45#"%"%'#,*" ,#&5'1#'"*
7,#&5'1#'"*
'"?!'"%'/"53,&3#  *) 1!"#1;**
3'1#,.#$"%'&)
)7)7< 7 ,#/%&"#,#1!"

' -%$#."!"%' 3,3/,!+7.!1!,7%&",%$" 3,3/,!+ ''#=3,#  !'4

3,"0#,%',1#,"0!8#5#!$# +%'1!'1"&#""-#1?'%'-% #7'3&# 353,5&#?3-1>#&#,8#1>4!--?%'/"0#$,%+%'!-5,&#$3"%'"$'"%'3#*

!"0#,''#=#,$%&# "0#%'0#,#'"5?#,&8#&"#1%'"0%& 3,"":3!&0 "0#5,$##1%'/&?3-15,#8#'"5#"%"%'#,*!'1,#&5'1#'"*
 ,+ &#""-%'/1?'%'-% #!

,#&0#!,-%#,*$$,1%'/-47   *)1!"#1 ;**
3'1#,.#$"%'&)
)7)7< 7 ,#/%&"#,#1!"-%$# ."!"%'  3,3/,!+7  .!1!,7  %&",%$"  3,3/,!+  ''#=3,#    !'1  !-- 5,$##1%'/&$''#$"#1%',#&5#$""0#,#"7!,#-%!>-#">#:3!&0#1!'1!,# !$$,1%'/-4:3!&0#1* ;* #"%"%'%&!--?#1%'"0#!

,#+#'"%'#1"#,+&* 5,%-
)7


*.*GA 4"%2     G0#"0#,&5#!6%'/@,#!&'#1( #&@ G0#"0#, #5,"!>-#( #&@