Jatinder Pal Singh v. Ut Chandigarh
!"# #$%%&'
!"%&(#)!*+%&,- #"%"%&#) . +"!"# -!&(%,!)- #/&(#&"
!""!&+%&,- #"%"%&#) . +"!"# -!&(%,!)- #/&(#&"
'
! "
# $%%
& !
' ()'
++++
,#- . / 0 1 * 1* *
, - 2 ""
$%%
3* ! 3
1 "" 0 35 ""
3*
, -
3 0 *
5 6 1 !
*4
8
* 1 ! (7$ (7$8(7 #(# .
6 ! ! #% ,7-
91 6* :
"3 ; * ! ! 8
66* & <
=
. !
! #%
6* 6 /
6 * 66 1
! 8 "
6* &
6 "
#7 1 ;63 '5 .># 1 2 6 / ?/"
41 /
%
( @ 11
0 1 * 41
"
8>
#7 1"
0 1 1 ;63 '5
@ :
*1 5"
,>- " & 0
0 1 6 0 '5
41 "
;63 '5 6 A 30*
#7 66
" @ * ;63 '5 6
0
1 1"3
$ # #$% / " ;63 1"36 @1
"1
0
"1
#
0
1 &
< # $%%
= . * ! ! #% / 1 15
1" &
*1 :
,$- :
* 3 6 & 1 "" 20
3 / "6 0B 0* *0
6 5 /16 * "
1 1 * 3 *
20
0/6*
31 "
1" / * * "
"
66 "
6 /
20
, - : 1 "6
66*
$$
!
#7
!
C 01
7$
$ #
!
5
$ #$ 8
!
* 6 *
* 20
"
1 / 61 6
,8- :
* 3 6
6 6 "
& "6 "
#7 1 ;63 '5 6
*
3 1"
6*
16
*16 5* 1" & & !*
"1 &
5
1
$ # #$% 1
,%- 6
* 3 6 ()'
3
5 "1 6 &
3 5
"1
#
0
1 "
1
$ # #$% / 11665 11
"1
& * 1" 6
6 30*
# 0 66 30* '
6 1 ,# - E * 6
!* 6 /1 6"
!*
"1 16 A 63 65 5
6 1"1 "
* 1 5 6
6 1 "
,##- : 1 6" 3* 3
6* 20
16 1
* 66 *
* 1 * 91
,# -
13" 6 ,# -
" 1 #8
"
& 41 11 1 66 * 20
3* FB 0* *F
5 6G
1
!
" "
# $
%& '
$
(
)# ** +"
"+ ",! & -"*-,.- " -*/-*!-*0-!,, "12#3(3 &
4 5 )# -! +"
"!
",-
3 &6 )#
-* "* , ",! 2 7
& -*/-*.-!, - "#3( 8
9:
7 8 9;
< 2 = >
; ? ,#7- * * @ "65 3
1
1
6 ! 1* 1 " "65 #8
@ " 16* * "
"65
*65
1
"
1 D
6 1* * * @ "65 #8
' 1
*
66/*
= 1 , "+ " "
; @= ( ; ,0 " "
8
; :
7 8 ?; < 2 $ ,0 " "
4
,0 " "
) ( 4 84 "0 ,"
" "
;
> ;
# ?
,#>- @/*
1" 1 139165 6 3 6 )'
11 66
1 1
*6 1 1*
! :
6 ! A @ !
! #%
,#$- /
65 1 20
/
FB 0* *F 6
* 20
/ 915 & 6
6 30* 1
"1
# 0
* 30* 66 / 6" &
3 5
"1
#
0
1
1
6 1*65 * ,# - * "
/ 16 31 /1 3*
1 6
/1 3*
5 5 16 65 36 6 " 20
1
66* 6
FB 0* *F
1"3
1
11161 6 41 1 31* 1 / 6" 20
" '
13 /16 * * * @
"
"1 / 1* 136 "5 6 ' 1
6"
1 * 5 ' 3
1* *
5 6 "
*65 " ,#8A/ 0* / 6
* 1 1 5 * * " ? "6 1 "
1" '1* 66
* * 0* / 6" 1* 136 "5 ! !1 6 1 * D" @ E* )' 1 16 65
36/ B! D@E )'
:
5
6* ! !1 6 "" "6
2
+3 @3
8 E 0*( H( E 36 H(