Jaspal Singh v. State Of Punjab
!
!
!
!
"+, :,6'#'-(2
"+, :,6'#'-(2
"+, :,6'#'-(2
"+, :,6'#'-(2
/)/#+
/)/#+
/)/#+
/)/#+ 9
"#$"% &'()*
C7 ,+'+'-(,3
;,3#/#
"1
/(0"
C7,#$-(:,(+ 4 4 4 4
2 2 2 2
3,#,(+2
3,#,(+2
3,#,(+2
3,#,(+2 = 4 7
& & = 4 7
& & = 4 7
& & = 4 7
& & 37
#*-8 ,6+-39
:;-6"+,
37 "%0'(:,3 &'()* &3"9
::'+'-( ("%
/(0"17
>>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>>
4
4
4
49
4
4
4
4
&
&
&
&
-3 3,"#-(# #+"+,:
"$$% %'6"+'-(9 #"<, "%%-?,:9 #/10,6+
"%% 0/#+ ,56 6,$+'-(#7
<,(:,:
<,<- $"3+', ,# +"8,( 3,6-3:7
"'(
"'(
"'(
"'(
7
3,#,(+ .'%,:
/( (:,3 *"3"+'A"
")"3'8 &/3"
"8#*"
&"(*'+"9
#*-3+ @ &&=
1,"3'() -7 :"+, D779 3,)'#+,3,:
-..,(6,# $/('
'#*"1%, "36-+'6 3/)#
#A6*-+3-$'6
&/1#+"(6,#
#*-3+ @
6+=9
-%'6, &+"+'-( "(:,#3"9
'#+3'6+
")"39 -*"%'7
7
)3";"<,( B/, ,#+'-(
$,3+"'('()
'(;-%;'()
+"1%,+# 4- -<-+'%
'$*,(-5A%"+, A:3-6*% %-3':,
7D )3"<# "%%,),:%A
3,6-;,3,:
.3- -< $-%A+*,(, 1") (,39 ?*- ?"# "$$3,*,(:,:
$-%'6,7
7
4,"3(,:
6-/(#,% '+,3"+,:
6/#+-:A #'
'(6, D777 4,"3(,:
6-/(# #,% ./3+*,3
#/1<'++,:
+*"
<"(:"+-3A $3-;'#'-(#
. +*,
*";,
6-<$%',:
?'+ +*9 +*/#9 $3-#,6/+'-( 6"# #, #/..,3# .3-< '(*,3,(+ :,.,6+#7
4,"3(,:
6-/( (#,% '+,3"+,:
:,%"A,:
%'"1'%'+A +*,3, ,-.
."#+,(,:
4,"3(,:
6-/(#,%
./3+*,3 '+,3"+, #/..,3,:
'(6"36,3"+'-( <-3, +*"(
A,"3#7 */#9 $3"A,:
.-37
7
4,"3(,:
6-/(#,% -$$-#, "3)/'()
"%%,) "+'-(# 3"'#,:
$,+'+'-(, ,3 "3, #,3'-/# ("+/3, "(:9 +*/#9
:,#,3;, 6-(6,##'-( 3,) )/%"3 4,"3(,:
6-/(#,%
./3+*,3 /1<'++,:
'(#+"(+ $% %,"
3,#+3'6+,:
3')-3#
+*/#9 #"< <, -/)*+ :'#<'##,:7 4,"3(,:
6-/(#,% #,,8# $%"6, 3,6-3:
6/#+-:
:A 6,3+'.'6"+, :"+,:
77
+"8,( 3,6-3:7
*";, *,"3:
6-/(#,% 3';"
"% $"3+',# *";, )-(, +*3-/)* *
";"'%"1%,
3,6-3:#
7
?"# "33,#+,:
D77 ?*,3,'(".+,3
'(;,#+')"+'-(
?"# 6"33',:
-/+ 6*"%%"( ?"#
$3,#,(+,:
777 -+"%
$3-#,6/+'-( ?'+(,##,# *";, 6'+,:
-(%A *";, ,5"<'(,:
+'%%
:"+,7 3';
"% 6-(+,(+'-(# 3"'#,:
"3 )';, 3'#, :,1"+"1%, '##/,#
3"+'-6'("+,:
/ :/3'() 6-/3#, %7 :,,<
"$$3-$3'"+, :,%;, :,,$ +*,#, 3';"% 6-(+ +,(+'-(#9 #+"),9 %,#+
$3,0/:'6,
-+*'() +"()'1%, 13-/)*+ .-3?"3:
'(:'6"+,
%'8,%'*--:
"1#6-(:'() .3-< $3-6,## '(+,3.,3'()
$3-#, ,6/+'-( ,;':,(6,7
77
$,3/#"% L'<('
-3:,3# $"
"##,:
13-/)*+
.-3+* $,+'+'-(,39 '(:'6"+,# '(:,,:
$3-63"#+'("+'() .-%%A
+*,3,-.
6"((- -+ #"::%,:
$,3 6/#+-:A 6,3+'.'6"+, :"+,:
77 .'%,:
%,"3(,:
6-/( (#,%9 "%3,":A
#/..,3,:
'(6"
"36,3"+'-( <-3, +*"( A,"3#9
#+"+,:
<-3, 6"#,9 ?*'6*9 #+"(:
:# "6B/'++,:7 ;',?
<"++,39 3'
)-3
#+"(:# :'%/+,:
%')*+
3+'6%, -(#+'+/+'-( :'"7
77
0/:)<,(+ +'+%,:
E/%?'(:,3 ;,3#/# E/%?'(:,3 ;,3#/# E/%?'(:,3 ;,3#/# E/%?'(:,3 ;,3#/#
/(0"1
/(0"1
/(0"1
/(0"1 $"##, D D D D
2 2 F 3,%A'()
3"+'
+'- :,6':,(:'
0/:)<,(+# -(=1%, &/$3,<,
/##"'("3"
E*"+--( ;#7 -<, &,6A79 '*"3
& F
1:/%
,*<"(
(+/ /%"A ;# 7&7 "A"8
& F
";,:
/%"< "1'
&*"'8* *
;#7
"*"3"#*+3"
"(-+*,39
3'<'("% F -*:
/#%'< /##"'( ;#7
,%* *' 3,$-3+,:
& F
3'<'("%
$$ $,"% -7 H :"+,:
D77 +'+%,:
K*'++"
'#?"#
%'"#
&/1*"# ;#7 I,#+ ,()"%JF K'+ +'#*
:*'8"3A "$"( ;#7
I,# #+ ,()"%J9 &$,6'"% 4,";,
$$,"%
3%7 -7 :"+,:
77 +'+%,:
K-*"<<":
&"%<"( "('.
&*"'8* ;#7
/0"3"+JF 3'
'<'("%
$$,"% -7
:"+,:
77 +'+%,:
-$"%
E3'#*("
"+3"
-$"%3/#<"
;#7 ('-( (:'"9
(8/3 *"/:*"3A ;#7
":* *A"
3":,#*9
3'<'
'("% DF *,%:9 +*/#2
KD77
3')*+ #$,,:A ;'+"% #".,)/"3:
$3,;,(+ /(:/,
"(5',+A 6-(6,3( "66-<$"(A'() '<$"'3<,(+ "1'%'+A "66/# -;,3"36*'() #-6',+"% '(+,3,#+ $";'() 3,$,"+,:%A "6+/"+,:
3,6,( "1-;,3,.,33,:
&/$3,<, -/3+=# 0/ :,6'#'-(# -$,('() /$ (,?
;'#+"#
#$,,:A "<"%)"<"+,:
./(:"<,(+"% 3')*+ %'., %'1,3+A9 -(#+'+/+'-(7
3')*+ #$,,:A +'<, "33,# '(6"36,3"+'-( 6-(+'(/,#
'(;,#+')"+'-(9 '(B/'3A9 +3'"%9 "$$,"%
$3,0/:'6, 3,#/%+ :/, '<$ +'<, 6-<<'##'-( 6-(#/<<"+, .'("%'+A9 6-/%:
*,"3'() B/'68 :'#$-#"% "3, #'(, B/ -;,363-?:,:
-/3+:-68,+#9 *,";
$3,##/3, $3-#,6/+'-(
63'<'("% 0/3'#$3/:,(+'"% <,6*"('#< / ,56/#, 8,,$'() '(:,.'('+, +'< 63'<'("% #A#+,<9 3"+*,3 < )/"3"(+,, #$,,:A '(+,(:
'<$-#'() $3-6,,:
3,"#-("1 +*3,,.-%:
$/3$-#,7 '3#+%A9 $3-+,6+# '<$3'#-(<,(+F #,6-(:%A9 3,%', $/1%'6 #/#$'6'-( :/, /(3,#-%;,:
3'#8 ,;':,(6, ?'%% $"##"), +'<,9 +*/#9 '<$"'3'() *'<#,%.7 + )-,# #"A'() "3, )3";,7
66/#,:9 $3,#/<,:
#/10,6+,:
$#A6*-%-)'6"% $*A# -(,3-/# 6-(:'+'-(#7 B/"%%A '< #/6* .3,B/,(+%A ."%%# *,"
."<'%A7
*,3, A,+ "(-+*,3 6-(#':,3"+'-( #+"),7 "%%,)
6-(+3"1"(:
'(;-%;'() 6-<<,36'"% B/"(+ 3')-/3# ,(/<,3"+,:
-/3+# 6"( "6 $3-#,6/+-3 *";'() #"+'#.',:
3,"#-("1%, )3-/(:# 1,%',;'() 6*"3),:H"%%,),:
+*"+9
?*'%,
#+3'(),(+ 3')-/3# </#+ <,+'6/%-/#%A #63/+'('L,:
./(:"<,(+"% 3')*+ #$,,:A
3,(:,3,:
(/)"+-3A /(?"
$"3+'6/%"3%A ?*,3, #/6* # ,5$,:'+'-/# -(%A : -$$3,##';, '(6"36,3"+'-(F <'+')"+,
"66/#"+'-( ?,%% 6/3+"'% #,:
:,.,(:
*'<#,%.9 1/+ +*,3, ?"A #$,,:A 3')*+ (+ $"#+ 3"+'- :,6':,(:'
0/:)<,(+# *";, %"':
:-?( #,3',# . ./(:"<,(+"% 3')*+#7
6-(6,$+ 3+'6%, ,##,(+'"% $"3+
)/"3"(+,,:
$3,#,3;,:
-/3
1,)'(# "6+/"% 3,#+3"'(+ #+ 6-(#,B/,(+
"%% #+"),#9 ("<,%A9 #+"), % "(:
3,;'#'-( #- $-##'1%, $,3<'##'1%, ";-':"1%, #'(6, +'%% 63'<'("% $3-6,,:'()# ";,3+,:7
#$,,:A +3'"%9 ,"3%A B/"
(-( 63'<'("% 0/3'#$3/:,(6,7
";A ;-%/<, ?-38 3,#/%+"(+
-%'6,9 '(:/1'+"1%A 8,,$# ,(+'3, #+3,## #+3"'(7
-?,;,39
#?-3:
"<-6%,# *"()'() <,7
+ #,3;, 63,:'+ <"8,# #":
#+"+, ".."'3#7 :,:
";-':
-$$3,##'-( $3,;,(+ $3-#,6/+'-( -1%')"+'-(
"1%, :'#$"+6*7
)/"3"(+,, #,3;,#
-$$3,##';, $3, ',;,# "(5',+A 63'<'("% 6*"3),# %"#+%A9 $3-+,6+#
%-#+ <,<-3',# :'<<,:
"1'%'+A :,.,(:
6-(#,B/,(6,# $3,+3'"% :,+,(+'-( ((-6,(+9 +'%% $3-;,( -+*,3?'#,9 "3,
#'6"% :,$3';"+'-(# 0"'%%'.,9 /#/"%%A '<$-3+"(+9 1/3:,( :,+,(+'-( ";'%A '((-6,(+ <,<1,3#
"#$,6+ <"++,3 :,#,3;,# ,)"+'-(# 3,%"+, 3,%"+'() 6-<<,36'"% B/"(+'+A
7
I*'%, 6-(#':,3'() +'+A9 8,,$ <'(:
<"(:"+,#
66/#,:
-(%A *,"3'() $/1%'6 '+#,%.
+?'( 6-(:'+'-(# "3, *"+ )/'%+A %'8,%A 6-<<'+
1"68:3-$ "66/#,:=#
3')*+ %'., $,3#-("% %'1,3+A "33"(+,:
:,%"A# 0/:'6'"% $3-6,##9 (,'+*,3 "++3'1/+"1%, (-3
0/#+'.',:
,(:
$3-#,6/+'- 8,$+ 1,*'(:
1"3#
3,./), 3')-/3# %"':
:-?( &,6+'- %,)'#%"+/3, '+# ?'#:-<9 -3:,3
6"#,#
$3-;':,:
6+7
-?
,A, $3-+3"6+,:
:,%"A# #A#+ %,)'#%"+';, $/3$-#,7
%"?
1,6-<, 6-<$%'6'+ ;'-%"+'-( (-+?'+*#+"(:'() "(A+*'() 6-(+"'(,:
'
)-;,3(,:
3') 9 </#+ #+3'8, 0/:'6 '(+,(+ 6/31 <,("6, :3/)# ."'3 ,5$,:'+'-/#
3-%-( 6"/#,9 3'#8# +3"(#.-3<'() $3,+3'"% :, -/+6-<, "(+'+*,+'6"% $3'(6'$ 3)-9 /(,B/';-6"% ."'%,:
6-(6%/:, ?'+*'( 3,"#- '(6"36,3"+'-(9 <'%'+"+,# %'1,3+A )3"(+,:
%"?
-;,33':'() #+"+/+-3A ,<1"3)- 63,
-/)*+ 6-(#':,3,:
?-3:#9 $,3+"'
)3-/(:
/(:/, +3'"%9 6"((-
7J
'-( 6-),(+ 3,"#-(#7
'(:';':/"%
'(-3:'("+, +'<, +"8'() '-(
7
,(#/3, #$,,:A +'<,%A :'#$-#"% 6-(#+'+/+'-( #$,6'"% -/3+# ?,;,39 +/3( ,%#-(=#
+,<"+'6 '(,..'6',(6A .3/#+3"+, :/+A1-/(:
,(#/3, '(:';':/"%=# ./(:"<,(+"% 3')*+#9
'%
+9
#+"+/+,7
I*'%, :,"%'() )-/3#
6'-/# 1"%"(6, 1,+?,,( %,)'#%"+';,
(:
#"63-#"(6+ 3')*+ (),:
'(6"36,3"+'-(9 0/#+'.'"1%, :,+,(+'-( $/('+';, '<$3'#-(<,(+9 $%, ,B/'+A7
+9
'(.,3,(6, ?*,3, -("1%, +'<,9 3,#/%+'() $3-%-(),:
$3,6'-/# ./(:"<,(+"% 3')*+# %'.,
"(:9 #/6*9 6-(:'+'-("% %'1,3+A ,"+,:
$,3 ."6+# )';,(
-+*,3 '('() 6-<<,36'"% B/"(+'+A9 -+ #"':
.,++,3,:
&/..'6, #"A9 ./3+*,3 :,+,(+'-( /(:,3+3'"%
?"33"(+,:
."6+# 6'36/<#+"(6,#
D7
;',?
"1-;,9 "%%-?,:7
,+'+'-(,3
-3:,3,:
3,%,"#,:
./ /3('#*'() 1"'%H#/3,+A 1-(:#
#"+'#."6+'-( 4:7 6-(6,3(,:
-/3 3+H /+A ")'#+3"+,7 -?,;,39
"::'+'-( 6- -(:'+'-(# 6-(6,3(,:
-/3+H /+A
")'#+3"+,9 3,<"'( 1-/(:
.-%%-?'() 6-(:'+'-(#2
'
<'
''
+"
:-6/<,(+"3A9 :/3'() +3
'''
"1 #/#, %'1,3+A )3"(+,:7
"<$,3 ,;':,(6,9 -3"%
3'"%7
1#,(+ *'<#,%.
:"+, 1,.-3,
';
6-<
;
:,$-# -/3+7
<<'+ ?*'%,
#'+ $"##$-3+9 '.
"(A9
;'
)';, (;,#+')"+'()
..'6,3H&
6*"(), 6, $,3<'##'-( -/
;''
;''' #/1< 6,%%$*-(, (/<1,3
6-(6,3(,:
-%'6, &+"+'-(
,%%$*-(, (/<1,3 $3'-3 /3+H%%"B"
")'#+3"+,7
<"((,3 +3A
<'+9 .'3#+ ?-38'() :"A
,;,3A <-(+*9 "..':";'+9
,..,6+ (-
.-/(:
'
,(%"3),:
"..':";'+ -+*,3?'#,9 .-3+*?'+*9 6"(6,%%"+'-( 6-/3#,9 3"+'-6'("+, 1,.-3, 6-(6,3(,:
6-<<'##'-(
3,%,"#,:
9 1"#'# <"(:"+,:
<-;,9 $%,"9 1/+ <,3'+# +*,3,-.7
7
13,"6* ".-3,#"':
6-(:'+'-(# +*-#,
6-(6,3(,:
-/3+H /+A ")'#+3"+, :'3,6+,:
*,3,'("1-;, #*-?'() -+*,3 #/..'6 6',(+ 6"/#,9 &+"+,H6-<$%"'("(+
%'1 1,3+A <-;, 6"(6,%%"+'-(
7
3:,3,:
"66-3:'()%A7
7
-+*'() #"':
*,3,'("1-;, 6-(#+3/,:
,5$3,##'-(
-$'('-( <,3'+#
7
&'(6, <"'(
:,6':,:9 $,(:'() <'#6,%%"(,-/#
"$$%'6"+'-(9 '.
"(A9 "%#- #+"(:# :'#$-#,:
-..7
/)/#+
/)/#+
/)/#+
/)/#+ 9 <"*";'3
I*,+*,3 #$,"8 I*,+*,3 3,$-3+
& 4 & 4 & 4 & 4
'()H3,"#-(,:2
!,#H-
+"1%,2
!,#H-