Suresh Yadav v. State Of Haryana And Another
()* +( !,
-.( +(!',
/(0*) 2(( /-3 *0 (4*( $ 56$
/ 7
( % $ (0800*03,*).- $ 9 ,*).-04
$ )79++:,,3
$ 9*/+0,*).-(4*
7
,
3:3-0(4-**/.; &< =*:0 /.;> -0*-9 .*,4,:0(0 .94- !# **!;
;
!'+(**/.( ;
'*;
- , ./70*?0,+9,(?( ..-.438+* ..(*%(4*
, 2?9 /09, 83 0 . - *** /((( *+, +9
:(*+*:00+(0.94:( 0*+ *3 *3 --( - 0 : -9( 93, $@( )* /0+/,-:0.00(044A*/ /,:0.0( 044(04-9-0(:- 0(*-9(*0(443- (0+9 :(+*0*+04*
!#,0-9(-040*(44*(0+9 ..(* $@( /49 -(. * 6* , 4) 9* .943,-()(4B.(.**--4.( (4*
%2?9/09+:0 / /09*2?(/09 (*80.(-0..(*.943 0.94+) *(-0-0(0+9-0*--4B.(- 0..(*,*(.(+0-.)8,(9:(4* *9+9*4* :((+*0(0+ 9:(*830..(*%.943*0(9:( ₹ 9(444* (40.94,9- #, ;, >, @% :((*+:*(0-0(0+9(44* *--4B.(A:0(.(-0(0+99(444* ₹ 830.943:( !,; ,>#,&!
@% :(+*0..(*(. 8++ 0* 8(* - 0 +* 4 * *.* 0 .94*)0)8(.3
6* ( - 0 4 .*( 0 (4*
%..(*2?9/09:(*.*4.9*--*,)* ***!# !!
!"-**.$+(!(((,+9 <C !=**(40(*-.,00(8:*.43 8830-***/(((*+,+9,)* *** !
<C
=
;
(.**0.(*+-0..(*( .((3.)09+9A000*(.4*-90 (4)09(--9.+0*9*0(.09- .949(*+98:$@(/49-(.* 6* *(.*(-*83***/(((*+,0(
-! 4+(
+3(.0*94(03
!'A:0(0 9 8- 0 943 6: 8 :( *.**
'
-0(89(00(0+04((830 (4*
93)08839((+0(83*0(, 0(..9(.(,0.438+*09,8..*
#
0(043-*830(4*%/0+0 --*)-(((99((- .,$(,((*0 *+.(-)(+,:(-(:+((*+( (4*
%2?9/09* .%..(*2?(/09-9 99*9308((-4.9*/.>
,(03**44,03:*.*4.9*--*( 830!# !!
!"
6,(4*
:(+* 9 .43 8 83 * ** /((( *+, +9, &
(4*
B* 0 )(+ 0+0 )* .-.+ ) .* :( (44* 83 09 0+00(.( ..(* / /09:(-*8))* 0.( /.;
:(***08-(4*
:(9*8(83***/(((*+,+9
((89*-00.(,0(.9(0 ..(0 0( .( ( -.(- ..- 8, 0 (:+(4*0(8B.
'
<= 043-*83(4*
,((89*0 0:8((((.(8:04*$@(/49 -(.*6* ((.)084(-0
.)*8..9(.(,8((((.(.* 8 -.-* ( C4.* * * 0(( * 09 0
-! 4+(
(4**0( -93998(,4( :(++(* *(4)(B*+9(83058/49*0( 0.)*(4.8+).9.4((D0 4( <= (4*
(89(-00(0.9?:
80.94.*+(+(09,044.0*0- ***/(((*+,+983-+.438 44.,:0.00(8:*-8()+09:(- .) (4*
-0 (89( 0 0 B* 0 )(+ * .%4* 0 (9 0 ((-. - 0 )(++ --.A 0 0( .(*3 :( 8+ (+0 83 0 )(++ --.*098:(9*8( (4*
(89(000((8+*8(4 +(* */.!";% ,+*+*.+094.9*4(, *(40-.00*-+(-0 */. !";% &
,00**38:*.438 09.( <= (4*
-0(89(04(40( 8-*83..+0-.040*.0+*0 *++.4380983-+..4 8-0-/(((,80(9:(*(9((* /-0, ((89*0(4*
)9((*0..((-8 +*09)*3.* (*(,4((0 8-.30(.09-.949(*+98:$@( /49-(.*6* *(4.*(* /.
-094(.,:0.0:(44)*)****
;-! 4+(
!'
'
8309436:8,$98*00 -***/(((*+,+9:04((+ ***!;
!!
0(*3+*8304 4(04449*383-+9436: 84.*+( <)= E00((89(((,43(9*-*(9((+0 4
"
0).(**(89(((-800(*(*0) (4(*0.*.-3
>
(-(.(-04%.94(?0 ..-8..(*(..*,6* (0(-* B*(:2( $,
&<!= <9=# &,:0 0(80*83F8/490G.94.:3( H(0*++8..(*,-0(**( )*34((*A*0((-.8(+*833, 03:3(+..*..-(9(( :(-0 0*00*.(8(*9((I &
4(.(,8-.(*+0.((* 0(4,.4.4(,:0.0+)0+-.43 8,H*8.* /(0++:2( /<- 0=,<
=#/!,F8/490(.*0 .(*(09(+)0+-.43830*+( * % &
1E0.(*+44.<-+-.438= 0.0(.(*0-0--.,0-04(, 0 ?0* - 0( -.+ 0 .( - )(+, 94+:0)*.<.*+9*+:(((=,?0* --+B(.<(.0()+0.3=,.
#-! 4+(
&
;
(+08+3+**83.(*((.0(0 *+)3-0--.(,08*044., *0-.(-0.(,:0.(*+:00+.43 8,-( E00+(9-*(.A H3:00*-(,:0?*-(4..*(8 94(*<94(*=*4*-.(-0.(,*(8B. 0*(.-0. I
/93,*)2( /-
J ,<
!'=!# /;
,:(0*83F8/49(* % G!!
(0*3-0?.(*. -.(*038(.3,<=0-..(*0 ()3 - 4(09 .(( - .). * 0 - (44+)*.,<=(8440(-94+:00 :(((-440(-00.94,*<= 9 -.((-.-0.(44-0.0+ I !!
.*+0*,0.8*800-(* -.( H* 8 ? .(* :0 ++ .438..(*,8(:%(8(0*4.40 .80(8+*,:*H.+*):09+ ..9(.(-(.. 0(99,H394( 08.8)?*830(4.,-0.++ 80(+*)9)8.*,(8()*830 F8/49247902( /- B8
/ 6/>#;
/0+00*9()(/B3*0, !&"> &'!,0(88()*83F84C0 B.-8:08(44*-(0+A..- 8 *3 +* ( H 0 ( ( B. 8 44.%88.(0..8+*(.0 .( .-8.((3))(0):-*.( *39**.83*+849*3-,83(- (4)+..9(.(,:*8+.*.)-
'-! 4+(
:0..(*0(-*9*+0 I
$( K)(0/-+<
>=!'/#!!, F8/490*0 G .(( - 4.* 0( 0( 940((* 0 *(.8:0B.-8%88.(0 (+*0..-8-0(8+* *)+0*(.,.0-:**+(-0( 9)/-3L<!&&#=!/ ;&=M8()*0 B.-8%88.(0(+*0 ..-8(+*,0)8.(****:0 *-- 8(( 23 .+ * ):09+ ..9(.( .((3-**.+0..-08,*3 +* <3(4?+,0+*(-..
-08, *3 +*, 8*3 <() * C0()= -. 94 - :0 0 * .( - *9(-B(.)(-94)*0*.( -B(.8(-0..((+*0..(*3 9 0((-.-0.,08((-94.* 0.*-04((83-0..(*8(.*+(30 (B(-3+0..-8 :),8.+* (0*8..*9.0.9:0.(*+ :003(4)+..9(.(0)**+ .*.)-:0..(*0(-*983 B3+0..((-8*+0 I 0(4.
4(0)8*830:*+.0 *.( -)(+,3*8*)/89 4?
!!=#/ &'*9.39/+0 )/- *(0<
!>= /
N(()00(*--.8:3*(.?(- ..-8*44+(0*++8 23 .+*):09+..9(.(.((3-* *.+0..-8*3+* 3(4?+, 0 +*(-.. - 8 ,-. 94 -:00*.(-*9(-B(.)( 94)*0*.(-B(.8(-0..((( +*0..(*39 0(3-:() 9( 0((-.-008((-09( 4.*.*-04((83-0..(*8(.*+(0
"-! 4+(
(B(-3+0..-8 0:*(,8. +* (0* 8 ..* 9.0. 9 :0 .(*+:003(4)+..9(.(0)** +.*.)-:0..(*0(-*9 83B3+0..((-8*+0 N !;
$3? 09B9 2( 0 / - +, <
= /"; ,0(80*830F8/49 % G& (:0..-8.8*.((:00 * ++ 8 (--( -9 (( -9( (+ 9(.+-B(. -0.++8+()9 *.+49-.))9-0..(*?(.. )9,:0.00().0H(-+- 80..(*,0+00/(((:*8 B(-*..+08 I !#
0F8/49944 '#>-
<(+-/6 <=
"-
=*(92( $
$099*0)*0*.**
;
,0(0*(* '
0(,:0.(*+..-8*3+*83 :.,:***H(+-.(.30(.- (4.,0:),8:0+*.:3(8)?*-0 )9.*,+)3-0--.((.94. 0)8.(**830:. (.0(.(,:0 8(+*9.0.9,0*++8(8 8((* $),0*.((.*08),9 .8(.4.4(:0.09(889*:0*.*+ 444.-+-8 0(,:0.0.(0((: H-.9C,:0.0((9((+-.*9 -89(,+-89((8C.(*830)++* 08)%9*:%(*4.4(I
!'
(,0(,.044/4.( (*0*++8,-0++8**.(* 0)-.( /*4(-:0(89*-0.83 F8/49944 '> -
!(+ -/6 <= !##-
!>*( $@(/490:*E*
>-! 4+(
$-(. ) 6* 2( 0/-$0(0*0 *.** '
"
!"
74+9*,0+4((8),((0 -.9C-0(.( 04(.(,03+*4((*83 *.(-04-..+0.438 +* (4*
( 0 (*(4*0*8 *.*(4.9*4(,)****!# !!
!"<C % !=*04(:0(8(.*+*0(8*.*4.9* --*,(*-+-.438 6*.(0( -*G 9/0? (*) 0/-0J I<9 44
&-
!,*.**83058/49
!=<66
!/#"&= 0(.(,058/49 -*0.(-G6)(0) /I<-0=L<
=>/ "
M,:00(.4-++-*/.; >)(%%)( 4(:0:(*.*(8(.*4.9*--*9( -/.>
,:(.(***:(0*(* % G!
90(9(*-9,(.004( 44:()8-+*)(+*:( *.*(58(.*5 93,:00..(*(58(.*+5* *.*(54.9*--*50(H(-++ .438 E 0:0 4( +( :09 :0*8((**(8(.*+..+09(- * )* C. - : * *.* ( 4.9* --*9(-/.> -0*0(*0- -.438 I !>
0 58 /49 0 0* 9 /0?
(*5( .( <(4= 0 (, 0(, . 0 - 3 ( *.* 4.9*--*9(-/.>
,0(* 0--.438 58/49(.(**
&-! 4+(
8 0 8()( 9* 83 0 +0 :0 ++ .4380--.0-..((0*(- 8((((. :(0*(* % G> )08()(9*830+0:0++0 .43 8 (4*
%..(* 0 0 - ..(((+-8((((.*0-0 ..(*(*0.438(..*,0(9. 8..4* )0.(-8((((.(0938 --.(*0 94.3/.(;
',;
,;'",;'> .
E0(H*8.(**(0-+*0 ..(*00-..(((+- 8((( (. 0( (+, ( H* 8 * 0 (4*
%..(* 0( 8 .0+%(0* - 0 --.( 4(08*/.(;
'*;
,.
*.0+%(00(8 -*0.-*$+( I !&
90+4((C4*6)(05(.(<(4= *(* 9/0? (*5(.(<(4=,(.0 :00..(*()8-+*)(+* (8(.*+*..+09(-*)*C.- :**.*(4.9*--*9(-/.>
,0(*0--.438
:),(94004(.(,( 40.-040(.98,
!00 .9?:804.*+(-0.(*044.0*0 -/(((83443+-.438 0(.:( ((*44.9)*83(4* 8-/((( ., :0044*- .43 8 )*C # 0 4@43 -* 83 0 (4* 4. )( 0 0+0 % 88:(:((*+((4*
-999, 8(:0(*0(4*
)**0(*(40
-! 4+(
?:*+ - %88 :( 0 ( )9 0 3 (99(:((*()*40(4*
0, (44.4,-8++*098,(4*
, 3B*0)(+,84)**0).* 0+00(.(
( ) . 0 8- 4( ( *.* 4.9*--*,...*(H*(0(99(, 88:(%88:(0)8*3()*4 04(..**0(*83)*+0(9 ((+ (99(,88:(*%88:(:*(--., 8:0(94((().40..(*):-0 *.9-058/49G*$0(:9* 0)( /- .0*0(IL44< =! & -
", *.** &
"M,(0(..)(4(*.3*:0 083-04(:0.0(4.**. !-0 (-*
*8 0 4(, :0 0( 8 8(.*+ * ..+09(-*)*C.-:**.*( 4.9*--*9(-/.>
,(*0 --.438(0* 9/0? (*5(.(<(4=, 809(89(0:80().-(99( 88:(@:(-(4(.04(4((. -4.9*/.>
*-0000(8 *.*4.9*4(..*.:0:
4(.(,(+034*836* (0 (4* ((*-$98 9(4.*-
!!-! 4+(
08304%.940(4*/08- *.+0(4* (4.9*4(,0:(*3()* :0(99(88:(@:(-(,*-000 0(8*.*4.9*4(..*.:0: 03 4.9.(().34-().-(99( :(40(4* (4*.*-
;
4-98),4(483.94(?+ ..-8(8(*..9--.( (0*.9( 4.*.*83(4*
)049)* 44.<C % @ =(?+..-.438 8-0-/((( -()+.4(4*
, (4***!;
&
<C % @;=,044.:( B.*830-***/(((*+,+9, )****!;
!!
<C % @#= (*(,(4*
(4.*.*0***!!
<C % @'=, :083 0 0( 8 :* 8 (4 +(* * /.!";% 0():0(4*8-0(. 89)+44.-..-.438+* (4*
* ( B. 83 *** /((( *+,+9
#
/-0, ( 8()* 9 /0? (*5( .( <(4=, 0 -.0 0 - +( 0) ( - 8((((.(-()8.(8((((. 93())--.(,4.3,*/.; ',;
,;'",;'>, ;"! .
*(:0(H*8.(**(0-0 +(*0..( 04(.(,(04.4
-! 4+(
)(0-)(+,/.;
0(*38**
030++((4*
(9(444- (0+9
'
)++*0-(*-.(*..9(.( *0-0+*..(+((4*
0-.044.-..-.4389)*830 40(*38*(9((*830-*** /(((*+,+9*(*-.0(8..*-90( 8304,0((-0.(**):00( 90(4 ((.0,0(9(083*(9((*
+(!',
< 7
= / E00(*@(4?+ (@ E0048 (@
! -! 4+(