High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4375/2020disposed of

Neelam Bala v. State Of Punjab And Others

2024-05-01Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary5 pages

!"#$%&$ '$$ $ $( $ )

*+,-./0-1232.4 5 5 6--7+89+7+ 555-,2,2.4-: ;-:3<3 =,+,-./<4>+?+40 ,@-:3 555A-3B.40-4,3

$CD E%FC G#H $C$ $($ ' IIIII :-3-4, :5*24-3@+@+>+4JK0L.1+,-/.:,@-B-,2,2.4-: :5K:<4M<B,+J*KM<4>+? :5K3--8KNN+:O+7+40 :5+:3@KNN+:O+7JK0L.1+,-3/.::-3B.40-4,6.35+40 IIIII $C$ $($ 'G#GP $FQ 5 R@- B:+S-: 24 ,@- B:-3-4, B-,2,2.4 23 /.: 3-,,24N +320- ./ ,@- .:0-: 0+,-0 5 5

T 5

B+33-0 ?S :-3B.40-4, 6.5J O@-:-?S ,@- 1+4020+,<:- ./ ,@- B-,2,2.4-: O+3 :->-1,-0 .4 ,@- B.3, ./ -+0 R-+1@-: +40 /.: 1.4320-:24N @-: +BB.24,8-4,,.,@-3+8-5 5 U-+:4-0 1.<43-7 1.4,-403 ,@+, ,@- B-,2,2.4-: +BB72-0 /.: ,@- B.3, ./ -+0 R-+1@-: 24 :-3B.43- ,. +0L-:,23-8-4, 0+,-0

)5 5 J /.: +BB.24,8-4, ./ ) -+0 R-+1@-:3 +40 -4,:- -+0 R-+1@-:35 =@- @+0 +1V<2:-0 ,@- ,-+1@24N -WB-:2-41- ./ ,@:-- S-+:3J O@-:-+/,-:J @-: 4+8- /2N<:-0 24 ,@- 8-:2, 723,J @.O-L-:J O+3 7+,-: 3@.O4 +3 O2,@@-70J .4 ,@- B:-823- ,@+, 3@- N+24-0 -WB-:2-41- O@27- O.:X24N .4 B+:, ,28- 1.4,:+1,<+7 ?+323 24 Y-40:2S+ ;20S+7+S+J O@. @+L- +//2:8-0 ,@23 /+1, 24 ,@- 1-:,2/21+,-J K44-W<:- +40 ,@- O:2,,-4 3,+,-8-4,5 6. 3B-12/21

# ! $ %

& '(& %

) *+ !

& "

!,)

+ !(& + -% ( .

)

!$ !- /

& # !$

&2 (

# &# +! + %

- & "

- (!% 34567 89:;56 <=> 3;4;? @A 8:BC4D 4BE @;5?9= % F F

F 2 2 % "

! !#

. + ! ! % "

++& +(!( # !- $

# ! $ % " ! !$

(

*+ !

. %

G(! -

$ " !

+ ! $

H !- I- - H/ "

% J !

K +(!% ! & # + !

( L2 ( + +! !

*+ ! )

+ !$

+!$ !- "

( & "

! ! - !M *+ ! ! G(! + ! '(& N # ! $ 2 O2 P + ! ! . ! ! & # + !

. Q0 (R / S& $ !- S(

) ! 1!

(+ / !# '(& %

FOM

! . ! ! . !! Q FO '(& M% ! ) ! *+ ! %"

( L **

(& + ) *+ !

. "

!,)

!$ !- /

& .

$$($ + !

. ! - !

&N/ 1 # !$ /

&T U 2

! + !( &

! % . &- &

*+ ! ! G(!

G( &.

&- Q! )(& !M 2 2 ( # &#

! ) !V WXYVV Z[\X]W^V %

3?_>` aBb> c?d49;e?B;` f>g> hEe6B6=;94;6@B` i54BE6b495 <=> j6d6B k:d;4 hBE 4B@;5?9` F

2F % l# m

( &- & !.

% L0 *+! n "

!,) *+ ! n !(

# ) *+ ! "

& "

!,)

+ !$ ( # +

! )(&

2 P

!% ) !$ ! )(& +!

(& !- ) *+ !

. "

!,) ( "

+ ! "

"##$ "

#%$

& $#!$'# #&

"#$ ( "$

"$ )$ $ '$ *

#$%"& #& #'$ $# *"& #$+"#$

#%$,- .$$# % $

(#$ "' $ /0 1$

23456 7894855:; <=> ?@> ABC DB:EF GBH4B I8J KL35:@; M $

, M, M N * &$ "% $

)$ $ ( $ $#' O#$%"& #O $ "#$ $&"

PQR "# 0$*N S $ *#T% $U$#$ $S

#"$ '$

$ '"

0$ % $ $ #$%"& # $U$#$ $ * &$ *#T%

$#'

$ ") 0$ *

)$$

$ #$%"& # ) ,- MM, R V:> AB?48J5: WBH XBE: ?@> DLBL5 Y6 WE8ZB[ B8J YL35:@ N

M \]. * &$ )$#0%

$#$ $U ''

& (($#$ $ $(($ $

% $U$#$ $

+"#$ #"%

'$ 0$#" #$%"& #

N P^ $#$

# &

(($#$ $ ( #

% $U$#$ $

$#$ * $ $# % $

'$ # #$%"& #

'$Q _ $ \ "# ."&$

($ $ $

% $U$#$ $ $ % $ #$%"& #

'$N $ $U$#$ $ % $ ) $ $$#

_ #($# .

) (#' MMN M `$)#"

# MN MN

)$ %#$ $$#'$

$# $&%)& (#

#($# $

& &&$%$N ,- M , ^ $ /0 1$

V>W> a53LB bV:>c ?@> W>d>e> B8J 4L@ dY?5:8489 fYJg; ,,, h, i ( M $ M,,M $($ j$U$#$ $k

# % $ $)$# # h$* R$# & / #

O)$% $% %$

# "& #

0l #$ )$#0 ( # # $0$N $ "$#%N " $#%% # &0% #"% % %$$# &

T$ &

$ $

"#$ ( '$,O R

$U$#$ $ '$ O

& &0% #"% '$ %

'% T* (#

# $#

#"%

# # #$#O $'

$#(#'

$ ( "$ (#

$"% "$$U$#$ $, M, R AB4 D4893 ?@> XE:En@35L:B <84?5:@4Lg; XE:En@35L:B;

i $ Mi, i,

iN $ /0 1$

)$#0$

$ $'&$$

) N *$#$ )$ #$ $ $+"

&&N

$ '$#$ (

' & )#$ T # &$$# *$#$ %0$ # #$'$ *$#$ %# $ N * %#" #$ $ $#0 $ (($#$&, M, ^ $ o" %'$ fBHZ4L XBE:

"# N * #" $

&% $ '$ &$, R *

&" $

$ $ #"&$ +"$ & #0 $ (# $ &$% ( $

% $U$#$ $

#$ #)$

$ '$ "& )$

* &$ '$# #

# "& # "N $#$(#$ &

! "# $% & '

$ ' $ ( ') (*

)' !+'

,' ( - .

! !'

% '# !!$ $ '

' !+ '

! $(! !! '

/!!')( - 0- 1 '

++2% '

&! '#!$ 3

/ )'# $ !' ') ('

! '# ') "# $ 2 !% & '# $ ') /'# 00 ('

! /# ! ( ( 2 456% & '! !/+2 &! )$ /2 + ') !''+ /2 )

' (! $ '

')' ( '/!(!'

#+ /!!- 0- 4

( $ )'+ !! ') ! ! $ + ') # '

') +& ) $ ' /'3% '! &' *

/2 &2 ') !'

( % ++ 7$ '8 ' ( !%

'( +# ') & (2 /% (% '

#+%

#! - 9 !

$! ' / ! ! ! ') $#!% !'

!/+! $ "# #( ') &' *- :

2 & &2%

' / !$ '

' '!!!! "#! - 9#!% ! '# !

' !'

+#!'

&! '

'#! '

') !'

$ ! ' ( ! ! 3!- 6"# ++2% (#

$ ' $ ! $! 3 ' / $ /2!!$-; - 9! '# <=>?@ ABCB DEF G?B?H >I JKLMBN BLO >?PHQER 00

% $$$ '

0 - - % &+ $+

& ( & + )'

3 (

$$ 0- - 0 $$ /2 6 2% 6''+ S$#'

% # T/% &! '

+2 ) '( !''+ ) '( 6 ') # T/ &! ' / '

!$ $% )'# $ !( ' / # /+ $ $ $ '

/' $% +3 & ') $!#! U- 9 !#/(!!'

') + $ 6 '# !+ (

') ! 3 768 !

0V W#+!% ') & ! "# $% ! +/+ ' / '

! #$ ! "# $ '

+2 ) '( X'3 ( !''+! ') !'

$ 6% ! '

3+ ') + )'

3 /2 $( ! 3 #' 2% /

& )# $( + ''!'

') ! 3 T# ! #$ % $( ! 3 ! #'

' !#+ !#' 2 #+!% ! +$ G?B?H >I YBQ=BLB DEF GPBZEPHQ <BL[ ABPBOKQ %

0 6 0VV% $ '

#( '#! '!'

+#$

GF G@DB[KQK DEF G?B?H >I \BZ@C ]BOK %

6 - 9 '& ' !!# ! ! 3 ' &!% 3!$ '

+2 #' 2 ! '( '

"# $%& '&(! "

& &" )"#&* &" + "( ! , -. /012 34516 784219:;<=>1>?@AB6C;;1D

E. FG , )" H46I6??> 3146 19J @>8?6; :;< =>1>? @A K4901L 19J @>8?6;D E E E* #(&## "

M, , "# N (""(# $&&"

* &" ( N &" !

(""&" & # + . N O$&"( P&"# Q' ( * $ & + * R ( ! * (, N " ( "+! &" %&N (!&&(&" +&"P P&%" &" &"P ## E, , E

## + .( * .( S# (&"* "T+* N T(# "# $&&"

N !!N#P"&"P$$&"" + + %&"P

UE, Q ("%"&"P &"P*

+ V " ("("

!(&" $(

* N + V !&&(&"

V &# + W !

P + !#* N !# " ( "P&"P W ! P N ! +!N",G , X"# . ( "

!* # $&

+ *

"+! ("% ( ! &&" "# #N

" #& &"(&% $( &" "&"# T #P" (&" (" !N, , )" %&N &#* $ " $&&" !!N#, Q $&&" + ("

&## "# & "# !&P&+! $ &* + $$&"#, Y# +#"N& &"$&#N"

, , "#&"P$$!&(&"

*&" *!

"##& #, Z/[/\]^/_`^/abc d_`He fg<fh<ifij ,k $l&"Pm "# n mY $+! n mY