High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1869/2022disposed of

Rinku Mandal And Others v. Mahendi Hassan And Others

2026-01-28Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja7 pages

(

)

/ 0 &- 0 &- 0 &- 0 &- +&-!-#!3

+&-!-#!3

"# $% !5 "# $% !5 "# $% !5 "# $% !5 6 6 6 6

- - - - ;DC ;DC ;DC ;DC-2 -2 -2 -2(<(( (<(( (<(( (<((= HG = HG = HG = HG I++

I++

I++ I

+-!

"# $% & &'

"# $% !*+&-!-#!3

"# $% !*#+,-

- "# $% !*#+,-

- -!,1-+ *'

+ &-2 "# $%

-!,1-+ *'

+ &-2 "# $%

-!,1-+ *'

+ &-2 "# $%

-!,1-+ *'

+ &-2 "# $%

4< 4< 4< 4<(<( (<( (<( (<(D

(;<(<(D <(<(D <(<(D <(<(D -! .*

-! .*

-! .* (;<(<(D <(<(D <(<(D <(<(D

!* *+&-!-#!3

*+&-!-#!3

#,,

-& & 2#,,"# $% !*

-& & 2#,,"# $% !* 15*2 !15-2 +&-!-#!3 5*2 !15-2 +&-!-#!3 15*2 !15-2 +&-!-#!3 5*2 !15-2 +&-!-#!3 !- &

-! -2 &

-! -2 22#,, 22#,, 22#,, 22#,, - ++,*3

- ++,*3

- ++,*3 7 7 7 7

!6 & 2-& & & 2-&

5 '-3

! *!- #+ 5 '-3

* * ! !5 '-3

+-!

!-)8!#& -% %+ !1 EEEE 5 5 5 5 9: 1

1-2+&

,53 !$ .

!, -

;<(<(+

--&33*

!, *%&*.#!

,5-!

= =2-& .& '*15 > & &*.#!

,FG5 .1 %-#! - -2 /5DD5/<<8J

*-! - - ,-!

!$ * *!

? @A + !!

!#% 2&-%

-2 2*!*#*-!-23, *%+ **-!*,, ,*&

,*B *-!-! 33-#!-2

-2 #% &

, ? *! %-- -& '

*3#, 33*

!5 -33#&&

-! <C<;(<;

9(: 3, *% **-! - 2*,

*! -2

! .

&*.#!

,5 +& 1*!$ 2-& $& -2 *-!- - #!

4<5<<5<<<8J= #+

2*21, K-!,1G5-! 33- -#! -2

-2 #% &

, ? *!

%--&'

*3#, 33*

! *3 --K+, -!< C<;(<; *, $*!$&

$,*$ &*'*!$-2& +-!

-8 &*'

& 9): 2

&$-*!$&-#$ +,

*!$

,# *!$

.1 .- + &* 5 5,

&*.#!

&&*'

3- -!3,#*-! 33*

!-33#& &&

-! 33-#! -2 !

$,*$ &*'*!$ -2 2 & +-!

! -8 &*'

&5 -,

*!$ +-!

! - )8!#& -%+ !1 ,*

3-%+ *-! *! 2-,,- *!$% !!

( ) / 4444 DDDD @@@@ - - - - #&

#& -!,1!3-%

##& &-+ 3=(4AG

#3*-!=8/G !!# ,!3-% -2

#,*+,* &=4G #,*+,* &=4G #,*+,* &=4G #,*+,* &=4G --2

--2

,L+

,L+ - - - - ,-%+ -%+ -%+ -%+ --23-!-&*#%-3,

--23-!-&*#%-3,

%-#!=*! %-#!=*! %-#!=*! %-#!=*!

;54<<8J

(5)<8J

(5D4<8J

C45@D<8J

/5)D5/<<

45<<<8

45<<<8J

45<<<8

45<<<8J

/5DD5/<<8

/<5<<<8

/<5<<<8J G G G G J 9/: *!$ $$&*

;<(<(+

&*.#!

,5 + +&

+& &&

.1 2-&

! !-2 23-%+ *-!

35 + 3*2 2*

*! 3, *%+ **-!5 .-# !!

&-2 33*

*# & *!$!

$,*$ &*'

*! '-#& -2

! .1

&*.#!

,5 .

*!$ !- #!

3 !$ !- -.

*!$&

2-& K K -2.& '*1

8 8 8 8

94:

3-#! , 2-&

! #.%*

*%+#$!

;<(<( +

&*.#!

, #22 & 2& &-% $& *,, ,*1 5 %

&* , *&& $#, &*1 && &-!

-# ++& 3* *-! -2

*!-2 % !-23-%+ *-!*3- -!3

#.%*

&*.#!

, &-!$,1

*!3-% -2

? ;54<<8J %-!*!

- -2 45<<<8J+ &%-! #,1 .,*

-!& 2#& #.%*

++,*3 *-!-2%#,*+,* &-2 4 ,- &&-!

-# 3-!& &1 -

+&*!3* *+, 5 && !*!$ ++,*3 *-!-2

*$ &%#,*+,* &*!'*

,*2 L+

!31-2

,- -#.%*

**-!-2- -!,1 (4A - 2# 2##& +&-+ 3 -! ,-

& *

-#$ - .

/<A #& &%-& 5* # #.%*

#3*-!-28 8/ - + &-!

,*'*!$ L+ , - -! *$ & *

%-#! -2 3-% %+ *-! $&

& 3- -!'

!*-!

*!$ !- *! 3-!-!

5 +&

2-& ! -2 + &,

3**-!-! #."

3 -)8 -)8 -)8 -)8

9D:

& 3-!& 5 ,

3-#! , & +& !*!$ & +-!

! -)8!#& -%+ !1 !

& & 2#

2 3#% -2 33*

! !-& ! !

$,*$ -2 -22 *!$ '

*3 3, 5 - & #.%*

*! 2 3 -2 +& ! 3

&*.#!

2-&!-*!

9@:

3-#! , 2-& + &* + &#

.--K-2 3 2*!

2-&3 *! &$#%

3-#!

2-& 83, M

9;: ! +& !3 2 *!3 3-%

*3-!3

&*.#!

, K K *!3-% -.

;54<<8J J+ &%-! ,-#$ 3,

- .

45<<<8J +

& %-! *!3 -3#%

5*!

2-&%-2 &1,*+-&*!3-%

L& 5 !-.

!+,

-! -#. !*

3, *%-2*!3-% 45<<<8J+ &%-!5 * 2*$#& 3 !!-.

-#&-!*2

,# - &5**+&-'

-&K*!$ #+

&'*-&*! * -#, &1

&%5 *% &+#&5*& &*3-!

2&-% *%-!*

-2 0 0/ ,, -! .

*-23-+ -2

& $* & *3 L)-L<*,,2#& &5 * 3-% -!& -! 2

2#,

, -5

& #&!*!$2& &-% +-#,&1 12 &%-*& *

*!$*.#*!

5*! 3*&3 3#% 5 *!3-%

3 !!-.

K !-.

5 <54<<+ &%-!= )4<L) )<G

,* *!*& 3 !.

-!> > > > ?

? %'

'#K #% &

'H & '#K #% &

'H & &F &F &F &F5 +-&

=(<( =(<( =(<( =(<( ((GC;5 ((GC;5 ((GC;5 ((GC;5 *!* .

! *! . -2+& &--2 -2*!3-% 5 % %*!*%#% !-*2*3 *-!3 1 *3K.# * !!-.

.-, -!

-2*L *!3-%

-% $# -&K K* N#*&

- *!3-%

L3 &+ -2*& +&-

>I II! . -2 &13 &*2 2*3

%*!*%#% !-*2*3

1 *3K.# *% 3 !!-.

.-,# -!

-2*L L *!3- -%

! . -3#% &1

-!& -% %-#!-2$# -&K*& N#*&

# *%

-&K 2-& *!$ *!3-%

-2

-#, !- .

,,1

2&-% &

,*1 ,1 .

# # 3, #!

- +&-

-3 3#% &1

-- % %-!,1*!3-% -2*'+ ,5

- !- "#*21

-+*-!-2,- * &-2 2 %*!*%#% *, 3-%+#*!$ $ *!3- -% *!-&

-!- *3

*2 2

*'+

&!*!$ &-#!

<<<8J+ &%-!IIF 45< 9C: -!O., #+& -#&*! 3 -2>% &, &%

>% &, &%

- & ' , - & ' , - & ' , - & ' , ,* & !+-& -&+-&

,* & !+-& -&+-&

!- &5F

!- &5F& +-&

(<<C=)G

=*'*,G@@5 =*'*,G@@5 =*'*,G@@5 =*'*,G@@5 -!--, *!3 !#% %.

&-2

!2 %*,1% %.

/-D58/ -#, .

+ &-!

L+ 2&-% - ,*!3-%

!+ -2 2 "# $% !*3#,,

-# #!

>) )<-#$*! -% 3

#3*-!-.

- + &- -!

,*'*!$ L+ *3 ,3#,

*-2#!**!

*!&* &*,-K 9=CCDG/)D(:5 $ ,+& 3*3 *- ++,1

#3*-! '*!$3-!*

,#. N#

3**-!-2*- -#&5

-2 '*

% &&*

#3 3*-! -

+ &-!

,*'*!$ L+

-2

5-#, .

J *& 8)& G !#%.

& -2

! 2 %*,1 % %.

& * ( - )5 - -!

J -#&=8/G !#%.

&-2

2-#

!2 %*,1% %.

&*/- -D5 -!

J2*2 =84G !#

#%.

& -2

! 2 %*,1 % %.

*LF

L M M M M

9<:

#& & &%-& 5*!'* "# $% !-2 -!O., + L-#& *! % &, &% % &, &% % &, &% % &, &% &% O3 =#+& O3 =#+& &% O3 =#+& O3 =#+& G5 > ,!

> ,!

!#& - ' 1

* * * *

- &F

- &F& +- -&

=(<@GDD;< =(<@GDD;< =(<@GDD;< =(<@GDD;< > !*

> !*

!#& - !#& - !#& - !#& - ' *!

& ' *!

#&F5

#&F5& +-&

=(<(G =(<(G =(<(G =(<(G @;<5 @;<5 @;<5 @;<53-%+

3-!'

!*-!

,- N#*&

33-& *!$ $,1 ++ #5 !*,

2-&

;5<<<8J 3-%+ *-!#!

2#!

;5<<<8J- ,--2

--23-!-&*#%*

- #!

-2

(5/<5<<<8J = /;5<<< L 4G G !5 .

*!$ +-# # 3*, +

!-2

,- !*

2-&+-# ,5+ 2* *,* 3-!-&*#% 9: !'* - -2 *3#*-!%

.-'

5 !83, !*

!*,

2-& $ $& !-23-%+ *-!*! 2-,, - *!$% !!

- - - - #&

#& %-#!=*! %-#!=*! %-#!=*! %-#!=*!

5(D5<<< !!# ,!3-% -2

<8J

#3*-!=8/G (

)54<<8J J ) !3-% = 5(D5<<<P )54<<G

C/54<<8J J /

##& &-+ 3=)<AG

(;5)4<8J J 4 - ,!3-% =C/54<<Q(;5)4<G G

5((5;4< <8J DDDD --2!3-% ++,1*!$% --2!3-% ++,1*!$% --2!3-% ++,1*!$% --2!3-% ++,1*!$% %#,*+,* &-24 %#,*+,* &-24 %#,*+,* &-24 %#,*+,* &-24

;5/(5@4 ;5/(5@4 ;5/(5@4 ;5/(5@4 4<8 4<8 4<8 4<8J & -2/<1

&=5((5;4< & -2/<1

&=5((5;4< <L4G <L4G <L4G <L4G @@@@ --2

--2

;5<<<8

;5<<<8J J ;;;;

,L+

;5<<<8

;5<<<8J J CCCC --2-!-&*#%=/;5<<<L4 --2-!-&*#%=/;5<<<L4 --2-!-&*#%=/;5<<<L4 --2-!-&*#%=/;5<<<L4 G

(5/<5<<<

(5/<5<<< <8<8<8<8J < < < < - ,3-%+ - ,3-%+ - ,3-%+ - ,3-%+

(5;5@4

(5;5@4 4<8 4<8 4<8 4<8J %-#!

&*.#!

%-#!

&*.#!

%-#!

&*.#!

%-#!

&*.#!

/5DD5/<

/5DD5/< <<8 <<8 <<8 <<8J ( ( ( ( !

-%+ !

-%+ *-!

D54(5)4< D54(5)4< D54(5)4< D54(5)4< <8<8<8<8J 33 *!$,15 ! ,, .

!*,

- &

*-!*!

+&-+-&*-! ,&

&%*!

&*.#!

9(:

$& !-2*!

?@A+

!!#%*!- N#* "# *! -.

*-!%

-!O., #+& -#&*!>%#+ >%#+ >%#+ >%#+ * * * *

- &'

- &' ,!#& -%+ !1*% ,!#& -%+ !1*% ,!#& -%+ !1*% ,!#& -%+ !1*% *%*

- &5 %*

- &5 *%*

- &5 %*

- &5& +-&

=(< =(< =(< =(< <<CG <<CG <<CG <<CG =/G4) =/G4) =/G4) =/G4) +&-'

*! #. N# !"# $% *,

> %% - & > %% - & > %% - & > %% - & ' ' ' '

!- &5(</=G

!- &5(</=G =*'*,G//)5 =*'*,G//)5 =*'*,G//)5 =*'*,G//)5#5 *!

- CA A + !!#% -! %-#! -2 3-%+

- 3, !2&-%

-2*!*#*-!-23, *% **-!*,,*&

,*B *-!!3 %-#!

! * !- + **! &

%- -!5 ,, .

,-!$ *(A*!

2&-% L+ +*&1-2+ &*- -2&

%-!2& &-% -

-% !*-! %-#!

!-23-%+ ,&

- 3, !

,,.

2&-% !

3-%+ *-! 9): ! '* -2 %- *2 2*3 *-!5 +&

*+-

-2

*!$%*3 -# ++,*3 *-!= =G5*2 !15 ,, ,- *+-

-2 = G = G = G = G !# &1 !# &1 !# &1 !# &1(;5(<( 5(<( 5(<( 5(<( *K D

K*!$8&

&& +-& 8- 0