High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/10450/2016disposed of

Jagwati And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2017-05-08Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal15 pages

! " # $% & ' (

! )*#(+, -

( * ( .# +,,*+& ' ////

0 1 2 # 3 ,4 ,

5+ , - (( 65 ( - ( $ #2 2( 2 $ +5 #5 ( - ( ( (( 01 ! - 5 ( ( # % ! 7# 89

# % + + :+33+3 + 39! %3 ;

5 <!5% . 4 #5+ *# ;,=# ! < #67#( # 4(# #

6 2( 2 031 $89 >25-

2) 55 (5+ 5 ;- < 2(5 ( 5 (5 2)(5=$ 2

6' 2(5 5( - 2+2(5+ #6

2) & -55 .4 56# 3

2 ,' 2 + 5

+ >#+# ( 5 ( $' #5' 2 5>##6 2(52 ) 5 &#6 2(5 55 >#5 5 65 & 5 5 $ +#& 565 #55'+ & ( )# #5 2(5 5 2(5# 2

-6 2(5 5( ( 5 -6 2(5 1 955'+

# % + + :+33+3 +39!$ +

# % 3 9!

6 ( -6'

)# '

( 2) #5 1 ? #5 ( #62

2 %3 9!

#67# 6 ( ( )# '# #

# '# # $ @ #5 @

@ 5 @ 6 = %3

A 5' 9 !5 A- '# 5

#5 6 -## #

# %3 9!+ )# '#5 6( 6

#5 #

# '

# # %+ # ( 6'

+ +5 #5 ( #62

)# '( 2)6 6'

)# '# %39!B# 5 ( #

+ -6=2 01 > ( 65 5 $# # ( '5 - 2)# 6# -

01 ? #5

! " #$% #"&'

()*+,-./ //, 0.

-1 #62

# % 3 9! ' + 6 ( 2(#

5- # 6 2( 2 $ 2( 2 6

# - 5 (65( -55 2( 2 #5 6 ( 5 2( 6 6( %6( 5 5-+ +2( 2 #5 6 - 5 5 6 ( 6 (

7#5'(5 2)#5 >#+ # $ 2(5 5 # >#+# & 5# >#+ #

2 >#(#

( ( ' 6 5 265'

6 ( 01 $= ( ( &

# # % !+ 7# 25 ( #2 556 2( 2 6 # -2 2 7# ( 5 $ &@65 ,(= # # )#

## $% "# &'() * $ #+(, -.!"

## $%..$# " &''/ * $ #01+

## $%2.#3!"

"4 .$# "

&'(( * $ #&+)'+#22 #( - ' ## #$ 5* 6 47 !"

!-$#. 8 %". .$# "/119/ )01$ 5 5(#22 #( )#

2 55

" " # $

" %

" "

! "

" "%

" ! &

' "

! "

( %

# )*

(, ( # )*

# -.!

+ # "

, "

# !

/ 0 1

! !

" "

! "

" ' !!!

' "

" ! ! !

" !

! 3 0:1 8#55> # 2 4 . .5.

$# "!"

## $%:

.-;..$# /11(9 &1</ ( ( # % !+ 5 & # ( 7# ( # - )# ( - 6# ( 5 $ ( 52 2 25 (#5+ ( #52 & - ( 6= - '( 5'

#2 #$ # '6

( & # # % ! $ ( # % !+ 6 = 4

( -6# ( # 1 9 = ( # % !+ 25( 67#

## ! 5'67#

#- 52 5' ( 25' -5 ( 5 # 22 5+ 5+2 5 -5 2 25 # 9 ' (# 2' -5-

655'( - ( 5# ( - 26' 2( 2 0 1 9 . .5!"

## $%:

.-;..$# /1&/+ <+9+&@65%#( 2#

'2( 55( -#( 6 -

55 2 7 ! !

8 '

&9!

# -:

;<0 1 0

& 9!

" ! ! "

! "

! !

% !

" ' ! != " #

" #

" "!

% + !!

< "

" 5!

" !!!

: !

" "

" !

! "'

! !

' 01 !

3 0 1 $7# 25(

# %3 9!2#( 5 #6 &@65%#( 2# !# !" #%$%/

#"&'

() ! " #*+2,. , 0/.23,

# &@65,(=# 25 # 2(#

# %3 9!'

' 2(# 65+6# & # #5 6 # - 7#

2526 ( = ( # % !855 ( (5

5 ( 3 )#

2 -?

' ! !

# )* ! '

8 01+ # )*

# -: , # )*

01@

8 1

" @

01#

% !

" #

% + !!

" +

# %

' ! "

! 0A1 B

" 5!

" !!

" '

! ! 0A1 @

" !

! ! "'

0A1 B # -: +

" !

! " ! # -:+ &9 !

# -:+ %

# -:+ &

" !

" B

" !

% ! ! '

" " !

!" ! !

0A1@ # )* !

! '

$ %

! "

! ! C!

! !

# )*

"! !

# -:+ !!

" "

! !

! '

# -:+

" ! '

" ! 3 0 31 9#556 2 C5= ( +& # =2 (65' - 654

# ( #5 (# # (( ( )# #5 #5 #5'B

# % 3 9! 55 # ' #

55'6

%D' - #5

,22 & # #5 6 2 5'6#

# %3 9!2 89 955(6 #

# %3 9!6 - )# 4 ( 89 9 '+# 2( 54# )# '# 6'-2+ #)# ' 5

-5( 6 '+# (# 2+2 5- 6 # ( )# # 6'-2+(5 # 5- # =2 (65' - - 654 2 9 7# 25( # #

# %3 9!+ 55 '6

- 5# 1@ !

# C "

! "

-:+ 1 ! "!

( (5 5 # 5

2 -5# #5(65' 55 6 2 (#65- =6 (#65 - 5' ( 2 5- 5 6 (+ - 5 (( (( ( #5 -

%3 9!6 2(# 6 2( 2 1 9- #+92 - 2 526 ( #5 $((565'

# %3 9! ( 2 # 67#65+ +92 - ( 2 5 # !# 4% 5%#,%'6.6((5 ( 6 ( 655

2(# 5- # 1 $4 5'

#2+# - 6 7# 89 5 #67# ( 2 6 2( 2 #55'+ 89 3

# % + + :+33+3 +39! %3 ;

5 <!5%. 4#5+ *# ;,=# ! < 55 #67# (

2+ 6'7# 0 1 ! ( ' + , .

" D

C (4 D

ED C ( 65 ED