← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/10470/2016disposed of

M/S Rgvp Energy Sources And ANR v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2016-11-29Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri4 pages



                 

 

 !

$!%&'&"()

"*!+,!- ./ 

1'

2 (!-34 "5-%!'

(" 6!-  *0     

        )

  



 -!'!( ) 6-& 2&7+ &(36/ $*"% !

8! & &"(!-'0 '0 (5'6-!!

58 / !85 4 $*"% !

!(!-9/ -4(0 6-& :59$!!8 &;-&/ $*"% !

-!'8"($!(

"0 0



!0

-9 ) 59!0

!-$ #"- 6;& 6 ;& 6 %"('!( 8- &!'

*&!;

( 5-!

9& &3 &"(0 6&'

8! & &"( 5($!- !% &"( < -!$ ;& 6 !% &"(  -000 %"('"9&$ &"( 85-8"'!'

6!-&(30

-4!- +$!

-!3&' !-!$ &' -&% '

-4( 3&('

$! &9'

6!-!"# 5($!-)    

  

      

  

            

   ! "# $ % %&  ! "" & '  ! "(   '' )  *   +" ,)  *

  %&  -

' &%  .  

   

  

  %&  ! "(   &&  ./+" ,./ 

%  0/ #/   &  "  +" ,( $"

    &  " +" , " % %' - 11 +" ,- 11 &  %&  

2

 +" , =0 6!

%'!

%"( -% ;'

!( !-!$ &( "

(%6759 '58894 '"9- 9( !-('

5-(   !

$+&(&' - &"( $&' -&,5 !

'+!

&' -&% '

  !0

6!

8-"'!%5 &"( %'!

6$ '5889&!$ , !-&!'

;6&%6 ;'

("

8-!'%-&,!$ %"( -% ,5 6$ &( !( &"(994 '6";( '+!

8!- 3-!!+!( 6!-!#"-!

6*!

,!!( #%&(3 8-"'!%5 &"(0

0 6&'

8! & &"( "88"'!$ %"+89&((   !

"( 3-"5($ $&##!-!( $&##!-!( $&' -&% '

%"(%!-(!$ $&' -&% "##&%!-'

  !0

&##!-!(

(*!' &3 &(3 ##&%!-'

;!-!

&(*"9*!$> $&##!-!( ;& (!''!'

&(%95$&(3 "##&%&9 ;& (!''!'

6*!

,!!( &(*"9*!$ #-"+ $&##!-!( $&' -&% '

("

;"- 6;6&9!

"- %"('"9&$ !

%"5- 0

"5( !-&(3 '5,+&''&"(/ ?!-(!$ "5('!9 '5,+& '

'+!

'5,@!% + !-/ -,& - &"( 6'

7!( 89%!

(%6759 !*!( ;-$ 6'

,!!( 8''!$ -,& - "-0

%%"-$&(3 ?!-(!$ "5('!9 8! & &"(!-'/ -,& - &"( %"59$ 7!

89%!

89%!/ ("

-!'"( ;64 %-&+&(9 '6"59$ -&!$ $&' -&% '

8-"*!

%5+,!-'"+!

&(%"(*!(&!( ("

"(94 ,5 9'"

= ;& (!''!'

8- #-"+ -&'7 %"( -$&% "-4 "- !*&$!(%!

%"( -' / $$& &"( 6*&(3 &(%"('&' !(%&!'0

(*& &(3 +4  !( &"( 8-

-!894 ##&$*& / 9!-(!$ %"+89&(( %"( !($'

(*!' &3 &(3 ##&%!-'

;& (!''!'

8"' !$

$&##!-!(%!

89%!'

9'"

6*&(3 -('#!-,9!

@",

-!'59 ;6&%6 *!-4 $&##&%59 ,-&(3 6"'!

;& (!''!'

%"5-

(%67590 A0 *&(3 6!-$ ?!-(!$ "5('!9 8- &!'/

"5 '!

#&($ 6"536 -5!

;!-!

-!3&' !-!$

$&' -&% '

,!6!'

$&' -&% "##&%!-'/ #% -!+&('

'&$ -"'!

"5 99!3!$ #"-3!-4 ! %0 99!3!$94 %"++& !$ -!9 &"( '58894 9( !-('

  !

5 6"-& &!'

;6&%6 ;!-!

59 &+ !94 $&' -&,5 !$ $&' -&% '

  !

-4(0

( " 6!- ;"-$'/ %"( -"*!-'4 6"*!-'

-"5($ '58894 , !-&!'

;6&%6/ %%"-$&(3 8-"'!%5 &"(/ ;!-!

("

8!- 3-!!+!( 0

( 99";&(3 6"9$&(3 -&9

$&' -&% '/

6&(7 !*!-4 9&7!9&6""$ %"(#9&% #&($&(3'/ &(%"('&' !(%4 !*&$!(%!

'"

"( '"

#"- 60

( %"( --4/

+ "8&(&"( !(5-!

,!(!#& %"+89&(( - 6!- 6( 8-&* !

($1"- "##&%&9 ;& (!''!'

!B+&(!$ ,!#"-!

%"5- ' -!+9&(!

!( &-!

-!%"-$&(3 !*&$!(%!

"##&%&9 8-&* !

;& (!''!'0

0

( '"

#- %"(*!(&!(%!

%"(%!-(!$  !($ -&9

89%!/ '+!

+4 ("

+5%6 -!9!*( 0

";!*!-/ '"

#- %"(#9&% #&($&(3'

"( #% '

!*&$!(%!

"- &(%"('&' !(%&!'

%"(%!-(!$/ 8-"'!%5 &"( & '!9# '5##!- 59 &+ !94 !*&$!(%!

 99";!$ -!%"-$!$

89%!'0

( +4 "8&(&"(/ &( !-!'

@5' &%!/ '6"59$ -&!$

89%!

,!#"-!

%"5- 0 <0

( '"

#- '8!% %"('"9&$ &"( %"(%!-(!$/

6&(7 8-!+ 5-!

+!

( "-$!- %"('"9&$ &"( -&9 %"5- #&-'

#&($ "5 ;6! 6!- (!%!''-4 6*!

%"('"9&$ &"( 85-8"'!'

-&90

?&,!- 4 6!-!#"-!

-!'!-*!$ #*"5- ," 6 8- &!'

-&9 %"5- %"('"9&$ &"( 85-8"'!

6!-&(3 -&9 %"5- %"('&$!- 889&% &"( #&9!$ (4 8- &!'

%%"-$&(3 9;

"-$!-'

-!3-$&(3 %"('"9&$ &"( %%"-$&(3 9;0 .0

( '"

#- %"(%!-(!$/ #"99";&(3 "-$!- +$!)

99";!$>

&&

'/ $! &9!$ 8-

,"*!/ -('#!--!$ %"5- 6&!# 5$&%&9 3&' - !/ (%6759 #5- 6!- $&'8"'9 %%"-$&(3 9;>

&&&

6&!# 5$&%&9 3&' - !/ (%6759 '699 '!!

'!( $&'8"'9 %"5- 0

&*

?&,!- 4 -!'!-*!$ #*"5- 8- &!'

%"('"9&$ &"( 6!-&(3 -&9 ,!#"-!

-&9 %"5- # !- -!%!&*!$0



D

"*!+,!- ./    "  E6! 6!- '8!7&(31-!'"(!$ !'1 E6! 6!- -!8"- ,9!

!'1