High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4057/2019allowed

Jasveer Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others

2020-09-23Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal19 pages

# $% "

&"' # '

() %"

,-. %"%/ ,! + "

%))"

#%"0/ #"

,1/ '

() "

,( # $%/ ,! ++- 2"+ 3

5 6

8% 9" +

,"- 52 '

- . ' 9" """/ ""'0

2!"0

:'" / " 9% ""$ '0

:'" / %"

;' - "-

" !9 % '"/ ;' 9%%

%%"

+"0)- ')-

!-! 9

0% -

9%%

9% "0 )< = >)- 1!"

"! ,"-

%%"

%"0

# ')-

!'--<2:-'!-< . 0+" +-<

)%-

9%% '- 0)"

"$ @ / ' "

,"-

8% '

() ')-

' ""'0

6/ ! ++-

+ A:" , "!"

+"0 B" - C " / '

() 4 9

++-

')0 '+

8%""/ !"' ""$ '0 9" ' -"< "

') " '" + < !- "

3 6/

/ - ""$ '0 9 '/ "! ";'"0 0 0'0 +%<- " 0- 0- 9%- : +" ')0

++-

4 9 -

0+! 9"

%-- %-

8% 9" +

9 -

4 0 '+ %"

/ )" D % )' 9 ('"

: 9". <

/ " D % + --9 ""

! !" # "

# #$% &$ $&%'

( ) " # # *# +

8% 0+! 9"

%- '" + < 9" +

89 +" 9"

0 %!

- ( -< )< *+ 3

/ 9%"/

( -< )< "+ 3

, "( "

0 "+ 3

/ -

- )< 9" + "

, % $/ 9'- ++"+"

= >)- 1!"

()/

:" +9" "" )< +"! ,"-

() B"

- 44 *'-/

%" "

""" E%

6E *'-

9%" " "

, !) " # -. ( !) "#

/0 1 " ## # " 2

# 3 " ## #

* # #*424

/0( ## # # /0 ## # # # " # "

)

- )##)

"* ## #" # " # #3) " )

/0 # ## #) # # " # )

8% ++ :

>> -< 9

0 0'0 ";'"0 9%% ";'" + 9% "+ A' - F'- +%<- " 4 - ";'" 9"

!"' ')( !! ! 9'- %- -

" ""' *-!

+" %"

:" "

5 6 * -6 * -.

/0 # %&& /07" 7 %&& /0 %&& /8! #" 3) ##0 /)0 " -.

9 "

%&& : "

( ## *

2 "

9 #

" "

2) 7 2 ! ;);-.( ## 3# ) 2

-. # " ## # " 2

)* #

) ## ## ) " ## #

$ # 9 ! ! $ # #4# <#= )" 3) 3 # = )"#

# ## >? +

)!/ ""'0

9 '

-' 9%" :" "

#2 )7* #

##)

-@@ ) - ( ## =!( 33

( #

1 +

9) '

() ')- / --9 $ "- "0

9 0 !-)- ! ""# $"" % ( ## ) # 7* 2 ) 1 B 1 # 6 # C )

) * ##

$ (# ## 7* 2 ) 1 B 1 #6 #C

3 -.

/06 (/%D&3 $ .( 5>&0 / 0" 2(/2 ## #3 "

( # 0

/0 ) A&

%- ( * %D& 3 # -.

!!"# $ %!&$ , # "

5 # #2 ?& /%& ##0 5?

7 /%$! ##0 5?

-$%& (("

)*"+(

,, ( "(" -.

)*"+( /01+", % B)

( B

2 7 > C ?

! . ! . ! .2

! .2

(

,"* % "

; > ! , ( ?

B ! ( 2

B! "

. !3 << << ( %& 9 #, %%

2# .B# %$ #, %5 , %>

;

B %A 6#!3 %D 2 %E !3 %'

B $&

(

$% 7 "(

(

,"* % B

# 1 # " > 2 3 #( ?

! "

" , 1 # 2 %& 2 #B %% 6 %$ %5 1* %> 2

### %A 2

%D , B

%& (("

2( 34(0* 0 1 ",.

/0 # #2 # # - /07

/0 " /07 )

/)0! #( "

/)0 " / 0 /08" # #

1# ! ) /08"

.%> "

1 ) 2 ##

/9# # * 0 #

6 " $? ) #@@@ )# (

) ##

#0 3 ## " /

) "0

( " # # # 3 " ## # 82 #42* 4

> ( ##3 " " # ## # )

2 ##3 " " 2"

" 2 ## " 2 ## /

) " 2 ## "0 (

## ## # " # # # #3 " ### "2

) " ) ## ( ## ## ") #

# ##

# #

8 )## ##/ 5 0

"3 "" # ) ) " ) 3 #

" (

) * ## 3

" ##

( " # #

3 " "

( ( ## 3#

# 2

" # ")

8 !2 "#) # ## " # # #" $? ## # # # "

# @ # #

" ( 2

" " # 3 " " # " @ @# ) ) " 4#4 "

( ## # #3 "

" 2 ## " 4 4 "

" ##4 #4 2 ## 3#"

# #@ "

") # @# ##4#3 #4

4# )

( ) " A& ( ) ##4 " 7* 2 ) 1 3 ## " )

1 # #

# "2 ## 6 2 ) 7* # )

&&( )*

/0( )

3 " #3 #

/ 0 " !2

/ * 0 ## #

2 ## ) #" #

#4 ) 4 "#

) 3 3

/0( ) "A& ( ) ##4 "

3 " )

/#01 # # # "2 ##

6 2 ) 7* # ) /0 ( ) *

# " ## ) # # ## ) )# ) 8 ) # # ) ) 2

- + "

!"0 2""'0

-)- 9"

" 9%

6 #% 9%- -)" 0/ +"

,++ :

>>/ 0 "< 0+! 9"

9-- ! +" ++"

! ')(/ ' 9%%/ %" 9'- 0+'-"< ')(

0-< 1 "- 9-$/ A<

$-% %0

=$%"

# "</ "'-

;'- "/ % %!

0". 9%" 9 ++" 9'- ";'" + "0

+ - ')(

+"!

! #% '"%"

')-

6 4 9 '"%"

')0 # ')-

'- 0)"

' - )< / %""/ %"0

. 0+" +-< :-'!-<2 !'--<

'++" %"/ % +- "-

('$0 #'+"0 '"

5" '"*6 30 0 6,

, '5# 31 0 6,-

% & '1 1 !

4 9 '"%"

0 +" - ;'-

- B""</ %'- %!

" / ""'0 # B" #"! #% +- "-

)< !"' # 1!"

0 -' # G"

./ 80- 3'/ 1'("/ "/ G"-

8"""< 00'

G%0"

4 9 " # %! +"! D%-" $"

B""</ 9'-

- ;'-

+ B" * $"

% / -"

- ++" "+ / +"

3 $!

,++ :

>>/ ')-

)- +9"

"-< + 9% ";'"0 %- 0+! 9"

- -<

)

"!9 #% ')-

+""/ ' ""'0

/ !-! 0% 9%% 0)

9--

"!9 4 9

" -$)-< "" 0 0'0

9% I 0"./ +"!

3 0 0 %- 00

0+! 9"

%"- +'"+ ' "!9 4 9 9%- -'- - "/ 6I 9$%$

0+! 9"

9%" !! !2 "!9 9'-

I 0". 8% <--)' 00

9 $

-' ;' %" 0+'-"< ')(/ '0"

,++ :

>> %- +" :0

+ - ++"/

;' -$- " 0 - )-</ 9" "+"

4 9 + ' '

() 1!"

0 - 9< 9% + - ')(

() !- #"! A:0 / " ;'- 0+

:+" %9 )"

%- 00

0+! :0

9% 0 <--)' -- /

$! ;'- +-"0

+" / - %" 9" +

9 %- %"'$% & "

!9 "" '

'" ' +" &4

= / -"

- +"/ 9" - +"0 - %"

')0 %"'$% - A0- '" C"

- + "

9-- # "

+'< ,! 1 "-/ '

()/ 9% "+" # '

() ')- / %! - %"

"+! 9"

')0 8% '" " "- 9-- 9"

')0 -"

- +" 9% %"

)- $ %"'$% ++"

8% 1!"

() 0

() B"

-44 *'-/

6 #'% "

")- '"< "'- *'-

-< 9

+"'" ""'0 "! )< " ""'0 ,++ :

>>/ 9%% -"<

:"/ '0" 0 0'0 ' - ;'- 0 0'0 " +%<- 9%% " ";'" + -'

+"! !"< %-- ";'" ++"

! 9"

++" " ')( 4

+"! 0+! ++"

% ')( 9'-

0". % 8% ++" 9'- %- %" 0+'-"< ')(/

0-< 1 "- 9-$/ A<

$-% %0

=$%"

# "<2"'-

;'!- " 9 + - ')(/ +"!

!/ '

')(2- - %"

A% :0 9'-

0".

9"/ !"< ++"

! 9"

++"2:0 ')(

)! -' +"! %-- - ";'" ++"

!! ! )"

B"0 " 9"

0 -"

- "+ / ++"

!-! 9

+"!

$ "- "' %" 9-- -< 9"

0+"

;' % 9'- "0 ')( 1 "- 9-$ %0 9%" ;' % 9'- "0 " 0 - )-< 9-- 1 "- 9-$ '"" ," 8%'/ +"

"-< % $ 8% ;'

9%% ";'" "

9%%"

+"0)- ')-

! "0

# ')- " '

,"-

/ 9%% ;' "

"+(78 1("+ '#"+ ",,", 6 9" 0 6 ', /%0!

) !)2

= # !)2

/$0( ! " !)2

! # # "8 8 "8 C ! " " )# F ! !) 2

/ # 2F 2

# !

/50 " # " # # 3 ) " " # )

/>0( !)2

= 3# # ") ! " ) # ) " # !

/?0, 2 = !) 2

! !) 2

* 3 # 2

) # =

" !

+ B'"%"/ ,"-

/ +"! %"0

00)" ')-

%-- ++ +" :

<" "0

9%% " '+

% "

- % /

')- / $ 5 <"

$ <"/ 9%%!"

"-"

8% '

')-

,"-

+'"+

+" / ,"-

/ "-! 4 +"!

# ')- " ";'" ' :0 ++ 0 "!

"! #/ "+!-< 4 ++"

# ')- %!

$ '< ' 0+! :0 / - "00 %"

0 =9!"/ %!

"" 9% +9" !-! %"

%- :0 "

"!9/ +"'-"-</ 9%

%" " 0 "

"! ,"-

/ $!"

2'+< -

+"! 0

0% ""'0 /

" !9 % '"/

('"

! "

$ " 0 8% + -"<

:0 )< #'+"0 '"

0" %

% "$"

/1* 6 ",

, ' ",, %:

;& < ' !<!- ' 15 0 6,

, 5" '"*6 0 6, % 8& ' :

% <& !

' ;

0 =,6 21

, ' >1 0 3,6" 0 6,

'"$ %"

#'+"/ '

# '- #"! 9" - 8% ')-

+"! '

I 0".

!! ! 9%% 9

+"!

8% #'+"0 '" "

:0 +"! ,"-

*'-/ %- ')-

+9"

+"! - ;'-

5 %'--< --9 #0-"-</

# '

()

#'+"/ #

%- " 9% !9 %"- 4 9 '-0-< %-

0. +"!

' 0"./ +"'-"-< 9%

+"!

0". )

!! ! 9"

#0-"-</

".% 1'+ #'+"/ #'+"0 '" %- #

"'+'-'-< --9

!9 " #'+"0 '"/

')-

";'" %'--< "'+'-'-< --9 "0 '( )!*+$ !**!) + "*!, ( +-, & $!" ( .* , !* / 39/ $ :0

4 ++"

' 9"

3 -< 9"

9 + - ')(

%- )' !

%- :0

')( 1 "- $-% -

% $

+- A<

$-%/

"0".

0'-+- % ;' ')( 1 "- $-% #0-"-</

+- ;'

++"

0". 9 +"!'-</ ;' 0". %!

$ ')( %0 = /

%- :0

" 9%

!9 " / "$'0 -"

- + "

*'-/ "" % / "! + 8% '"

"$'0 -"

- "+

!9 3 ++ ,++ :

>>/ # ')-

('"

!-! 9

:0 /

+ 8% 3 ,++ :

>>/

') )- ')-

- --<

)

"!9/ )< .

)" ! ++- / %9!"/ 3

A:+

- 9

#'% A:+

"-< "' %- "+" 3/ 9'-

++"+" %-

+9"

!-! 9

+" /

!. 9%

+"!

3 8%

%- 9"

--9 )< "!9

!! ! =9!"/ " +"

% $ "0 9%

+"!

8% " -"

- "+ / !

) 3/ - ! % '" = / %-

' :0

" 9%

!9 " ' / ;'

!'"

+ "

% "$" ;' / 0<

,"-

/ !$ # ')- %-- '- 0)"

)<2"$ @

8% %"0

< :"2'+"! +9" 9% "$" -

,"-

8% %"0

0< %! "

- 0 "! +9" 0 $ "$'- < < "

=9!"/ %"0

. 0+" +-< % !'- -!- ,

% '"

< )- %"0

)%- 00)" #-- '"%"/

"+ "0 00)" % '%" %"0

)%- ,- $9% 9"

')0 - )< -"

# '

-/ " - +<

%"0

- 4 ++" %"0 / % !'- -!- .

9%%/

" +

% '"/

% "$"/ -"

- + "

""-< "- '+

('$0 #'+"0 '"

*0( # $% G"0 %"

#'+" %- ' + 3/ 9 %- )< %"

-"%+ / ) '- 0)"

D</ -- +" #-

"" " ";'" .

!9 "/ ;'

3 -

!'"

+ "

- ++" "+ + ' + "

+"0 ++") "

"+") #% + "

-"< ++"

%""/ + "

9 +"0 . '"

%-- $ 9"

%- 8%" " 9 '

0 - -9

"$'0 -"

- B"/ 9" +

9 - )" + "

9 ++"

# / %"

< ++- $ ' 8% "0 "

"! ,"-

/ %!

'"< " C"

- + "

')0 # 1!"

0 0' +"") D%-" $"

B""</ - ;'-

% "$"/ ""

0 "0 )< !"' # 1!"

0 8% '" " ')0

=9!"/ # 1!"

0 .

% + 0"

9--

++"+" '" ' < 9"

% "$" 8% + -

:-'! 0

0+-<"

# 1!"

+" 8%""/ + "

- "+"

# 1!"

% "$"

!9 "/ 9" +

--9 !"0 2""'0

6/ - $9% !"' ""$ '0 ' " ,-- + 0-- ' ++- / </ " + /

!9 )! ('$0 01230202 '

4( ( *$.

56%&-7* 5$!& +8 $7!

4( ( ** .!* 5 8 $7!