Punjab State Warehousing Corporation v. M/S Vishal Exports Overseas And ANR

 
   

     




    

 !"
 #  ##$  %  &%!

$'(# )*  +, ! #,



      !       -!

.,* . !  / ! #, "#$%&&"'()"#*+ '",-

 0! !

$,!#  ,  12 3

 "

$ *$ $ "

!4#",  , , ,  

# , 5$ ,6, $ "  7 
$ .

!

,"

!.8!  5.!  $
 !

9,! #, ,  4#$ ,   1!/"

$: 4.    ;< $ # 4
  .% $,$%/01203"340",5%

3"3"%$6"'"3  /4*  +-    + '0203",-  *   ,

$ , ,4#

* #   1 ,12 3

.$,,!

!*4!

 "!$ $,  1

  !
  $* #

! ,

,"4 ,  = 0!   !

*,    , $

 , $$8 7 $5.!*4  44!

$ "!#   $8!!   4  ,

5 5,# ,:!  . *4 ,   1!.. # 5 !!$,  !9 # 8!!

 ,!4#  !44, 5 # 8!!

",! . 4$5.! ,.8!!9!

 ,! ,

,$5.! "! *4  44

 #$ ,# 8!! "! ,8!!

  , *.8!. 4   "! # 

$,  1 !

#  *,  4!

! "!#   ,  1 4   "! , "



,   5 ,  4$ $5. *4     4.  8!

*    !        !   4.

, $$54!

 "!#   $ 0! ,$5. !  !

! $ 4 !"! !# * 1 8!  4 , "  5  ,  # ,    $$$, 5!*4 .8!!(# 

$  $,  !  $"

$  #  *     , , *48! #   $ )! 5. "

  ,  9 $.

! .! "!! $   #   

$*!4#$  ,#  ! 

$.!"! ! $8!!$ * ! ;8* . $8 5 5 !

  4#$  #   $>8! 4     *4?  "!    #     $.  ! -"# $$ * $ 4! ;"!
 ,  12 3!

8$,  58!

!

,, 5! $ 4  !# * 1!

 7 !$5.! $ 4!

 4,, 1 4  !*4? "!#  

 !

8! "

, 4#$   !  $" $)!! !

,.! $ 4!

  ,!# * 1 * " #   "! !*4 #   

$!" ,4,!  4# ,

4#$   7!$5.!*$*4!  #

,   1!#

5

0!  !4#$ $,, !

# *!   # * 4#$   #   !

 

1!

5 (#  # !# *!

!4    $! ,4,  ,  4 $0!  .!4#$  .

8!!*4 ,! !94  , *4 4!# * 1  , 8!!,*4,  28 3!

@ 1  7 ! .  ##$5"  !  ,     # #*  * $". ;< $ # 4
  0'$4/7'"/$78$5$31$3/$,,09$34$5%"#

1 :12"''7'"03 '0203",;;$",7

< 8
)0/& '0203", ;;$",7=78
($40($(73
=* 8!$$ 5"!

,"4!

$$ 

$  #*$5.!

!$, ,  =A 0!,$

  , $"8!  * "!. 5!$"$  ., , # #*$     (# $5    5   5  4#$   4 ,    !

*  #*# 0!$"

$4 (4B/* 
 7 7 4 :4#  ./  B, "

!

 8$ 8"! "$ 8!

$$8 ,! # . 8! # 4## #*5 ,! # 4#" $$5 ,# $! 5 !8  5    (#   # *    !         !  #*5    ! 8  ,  $  ! "!   4#$   0!       !     8$,  !

*  ! 9 "*, "!.4#8  , 4#   ("   $"

  ;8* .  8!   , , " #  "

,! #   # # * 9$5* $, 5!, $ "

!.!9!* $" -$5, 

5, $.  #*&0%0%>$4"1%$0/0%%$//,$(,") /&"//&$,")($4,"'$(>?/&0% 71'/0%'$/'7%;$4/05$"3(0% 37'2",,?"%%12$(/7>$/&$,")8'72/&$034$;/073 A0!#  8$5 ,   $4 ,  8!  !      ,"4   #1(92$3/  7'

($40%073  )&04&  03/$';'$/%  "  %/"/1/$  7'  ;'750%073  /&$'$78 ($4,"'$%/&$2$"303978/&$%/"/1/$"%0/%&71,(>$473%/'1$( 8'72  /&$  ("/$  78  0/%  $3"4/2$3/  3  7/&$'  )7'(%*  /&$ #1(92$3/($4,"'$%)&"//&$,$90%,"/1'$&"(%"0("//&$/02$ )&$3  /&$  ,")  )"%  ;'721,9"/$(  "3(  /&$'$87'$*  0/  &"% '$/'7%;$4/05$$88$4/)! 5.!  ! $ 8!!# 4, # #*$(# $54 ,  #*!

$$8 4! 4.!

 ,

 

,"4 " # #$$ 8

$ $$   #*! "#,5  ,   48!

!

 ,!4 "! 88!!(, 4!#! ,   # *!

!

,$ , !$ 8!$ , 4 !$,!

$8 5 !$ 8!$ ,0! $ $4 4!  $!

!,5!  B#  8$ 8 4   , (#,!$,B24#!

 ,,,3

 0!  .*8! ,"4 , , 5!;< $

# 4 
     $,$%/012  03"340", 2# 3  , 0'$4/7'"/$  78 $5$31$  3/$,,09$34$ 2#

3.  $ ,    6,". 
!

,"

!.   , ,  !# $ * $ $$,,  1

 , ! 4! ## #  
  ,# 4   " 5, ,,!4#$# # - ,!  ,! $ , 6,".
!

,"

!. !8! C

#,.  ,"$5," . 5. $  ,,#, + !- =  

!

4$ !!  # -"& ,  D&/ !! # 

$  D&/