← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2957/1995allowed

Dr. Harpal Singh Sandhu And ORS v. Pb Agriculture University Ludhiana And ORS

2016-08-23Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh11 pages



   





 !"!#$%&'!%(')!%(*'+, +*$*$%+, -+,), )%.!/&$0)#*)!#1%$2+,$*345)('$!%!!%(, 6+,"%(+%*, 

     +,+%*7 8!%(')4(20!*+

*'+"+*$*$%+, ++"!9&%$'*$4(20!*+

+,"%(+%*, !%(  :$##4(20!*+

+,"%(+%* ;;;;

   '+"+*$*$%+,<++<9$%&!,,,$,*!%* +,,,$%*'+ ##+&+ -+*+$%!30$+%0+ +,"%(+%*71%$2+,$*3$%*'+"!3,0!#+



6+,"%(+%*71%$2+,$*3'!($,,)+(%*$ $0!*$%(!*+(

+&!($%&*'++2$,$% "!3,0!#+, *+!0'$%&,*!

*'+1%$2+,$*3<+

!,"+*+=,!%(0%($*$%,=+%*$%+($%)%.!/:2+%=+%* =+= (!*+(   

'+ "!3,0!#+  ,,$,*!%*  +,,,  <!, !#, +2$,+( =

*  

7>

<+ 

'+"!3 *'+ "+*$*$%+,!#%&<$*'*'+,$=$#!#3,$*)!*+("+,%,<!, $?+(%*'+/!,$, =)#!#!$((<%/3*'+*!*+:2+%=+%*!,"++2$,+("!3,0!#+ )/,+@)+%*#34  ,'<  0!),+  %*$0+,  <++  $,,)+(  *  !##  *'+  "+*$*$%+,4 <'++$%4$*<!,=+%*$%+(*'!**'+/+%+ $* $%0+!,+  A /!,$0"!3

 <!,%*!(=$,,$/#+**'+*+!0'+,!""$%*+(%! *+

$%*'+ )%+2$,+(,0!#+<'$#+ $?$%&"!3$%*'++2$,+(,0!#+'+"+*$*$%+,<++ !00($%&#30!##+()"%/3<!3 ,'<0!),+%*$0+*+?"#!$%<$*'$%!

"+$( (!3,!,*<'3*'+$"!3,')#(%*/++ $?+(!00($%&*

=)#!  *'+"!3$%*'++2$,+(,0!#+!%(+?0+,,"!3=+%* =!(+**'+=/++02++(6+"#$+, *'+,'<0!),+%*$0+,<++ $#+(/3 *'+"+*$*$%+,4<'++$%4$*<!,=+%*$%+(*'!**'+$"!3<!,$&'*#3 $?+(  *+ $#$%& *'++"#34%!0*$%<!,*!9+%/3*'++,"%(+%*71%$2+,$*3  *+!"+$( =+*'!%+$&'*3+!,4*'+(+ +02+3 *'+!=)%* <!,"!,,+(4<'$0'$,,)/.+0*=!**+ 0'!##+%&+$%*'+"+,+%*"+*$*$% 5+!%+(0)%,+# *'+"+*$*$%+,0%*+%(,*'!**'++<!,% 0%0+!#=+%*=$,+"+,+%*!*$%%*'+"!* "+*$*$%+,!%(*'+$"!3 <!, $?+(/3*'++,"%(+%*71%$2+,$*3$*,+# %*'+/!,$, %*$ $0!*$% (!*+( 

 !,  "+  *+=,  !%(  0%($*$%,  =+%*$%+(  $%  )%.!/ :2+%=+%*=+=(!*+(  

5+!%+(0)%,+# )*'+0%*+%(,*'!* %<'++$*<!,=+%*$%+($%*'+%*$ $0!*$%*'!*/+%+ $*  A$%0+!,+

/!,$0"!3<!,%**/+&$2+%**',++="#3++,<'<++!""$%*+(%

!

*+<!(, '+!

+,!$(%*$ $0!*$%(+!#,<$*'%#3 $%0+!,+ /!,$0"!34<'$0'$,*/+&$2+%**'++?$,*$%&+=#)=+%*,%

00($%&#34*'+"+*$*$%+,<+++%*$*#+( +2$,$% "!3,0!#+

=

*

7>

<+ 

%<!(,!#%&<$*' $%0+!,+ /!,$0"!3$%*'+)%+2$,+("!3,0!#+ 5+!%+(0)%,+#!#, 0%*+%(,*'!*+,"%(+%*71%$2+,$*30)#(%*(+%3*'+/+%+ $* +2$,$% "!3,0!#+**'+"+*$*$%+,!

*+

**'++%(#+!%+(0)%,+# *'+"+*$*$%+,0%*+%(,*'!**'+!0*$% *'++,"%(+%*,$,2$#!*$2+

*$0#+, >!%(

*'+%,*$*)*$% %($!!%(*'+,!=+$,!#,0%*!3

 **'+"2$,$%, "$%0$"#+, %!*)!#.),*$0+!,%""*)%$*3 '+!$%& <!,!

(+(**'+"+*$*$%+, 5+!%+(  0)%,+#    +,"%(+%*71%$2+,$*3 ,)/=$*,  *'!*  *'+ "+*$*$%+,  <++  &$2+%  /+%+ $*   $?!*$%    "!3  $%!(2+*+%*#3  !%( ,)/,+@)+%*#3<'+%*'$, !0*0!=+**'+%*$0+ +,"%(+%*71%$2+,$*34*'+ "+*$*$%+,<++&$2+%,'<0!),+%*$0+,!%($*0!%%*/+,!$(*'!*% ""*)%$*3<!,&$2+%**'+=5+!%+(0)%,+# )*'+,)/=$*,*'!**'+ "!3 *'+"+*$*$%+,<!,+@)$+(*/++ $?+(!,"+"!3 $?!*$% =)#!

#!$((<%2$(+%*$ $0!*$%,(!*+(

!%(

!%(!,,%!, *'++ $%!(2+*!%* "!3 *'+"+*$*$%+,0!=+**'+%*$0+  +,"%(+%*71%$2+,$*34  *'+  ,!=+  <!,  +@)$+(  *  /+  +0*$ $+(  !%( *'++!

*+,'<0!),+%*$0+,<++$,,)+(*+2$+<!##,)0'0!,+,5+!%+( 0)%,+#!#,,)/=$*,*'!* A$%0+!,+<!,&$2+%$%!(2+*+%*#34<'$0'<!, 0%*!3**'+&)$(+#$%+,$,,)+(/3*'+1:'++"#$+, ,'<0!),+ %*$0+, $#+(/3*'+"+*$*$%+,<++()#30%,$(++(!%(*'++! *+*'+ (+, +02+3<++"!,,+(**'++%(#+!%+(0)%,+# +,"%(+%*7 1%$2+,$*3!#,/)&'***'+%*$0+ *'$,)**'!*%+02+30)#(/+ +

+0*+( =*'+"+*$*$%+,!,$%*+$=(+<!,"!,,+(/3*'$,)*$% *'+$ !2) )$%&"+%(+%03 *'+<$*"+*$*$%!%!""#$0!*$%)%(+(+

6)#+

+!(<$*'+0*$%

<!,!#,=2+( $="#+!($%&:)) %&!(+2-+*+$%!3!%(%$=!#0$+%0+,1%$2+,$*345)('$!%!*')&' $*,6+&$,*!!,"!*34<'$0'<!,!##<+(2$(+(+(!*+( 

+!(  *'+  !&)=+%*,  !(2!%0+(  /3  #+!%+(  0)%,+#    *'+ "!*$+,!%('!2+!#,&%+*')&'*'+(0)=+%*,!2!$#!/#+%*'+ $#+ !0*,+&!($%&!""$%*=+%* *'+"+*$*$%+,!%(&!%* "!3

> ,0!#+ 

!+%*($,")*+(*$,!#,%*($,")*+(*'!*"!3,0!#+ 

<!,+2$,+(*

7>

<+ 

!%(*'+"!3 *'+ "+*$*$%+,<++ $?+($%*'++2$,+("!3,0!#+/3*'++,"%(+%*71%$2+,$*3 !%( *'++<!,% 0%0+!#=+%*=$,+"+,+%*!*$%%*'+"!* *'+ "+*$*$%+,)/,+@)+%*#3,'<0!),+%*$0+,<++$,,)+(**'+"+*$*$%+, *0!##)"%*'+=*,)/=$*+"#3<$*'$%!"+$( (!3,*+?"#!$%!,* <'3*'+$"!3,')#(%*/++ $?+(!00($%&* =)#! "!3 $%*'++2$,+(,0!#+!%(*'++?0+,,"!3=+%*=!(+**'+=$%!(2+*+%*#3/+ %*+02++('+"+*$*$%+,+"#$+(*,'<0!),+%*$0+,*+,"%(+%* ,*!*$%&*'++$%*'!**'+ $*=+%* =)#!"2$(+,  ,!#!3 )%+2$,+(,0!#+ 

!*

'+,!$( $*=+%* =)#!<!,"!* !%(  "!0+#    *'+  $%,*)0*$%,    *'+  +2$,+(  "!3  ,0!#+,  *  <!,  !#, =+%*$%+($%*'++"#3*'!*!"+,%<'<!,&$2+%,*!*$%&,!#!3 

!%(%0%2+,$%'$,"!3<!,*/+ $?+(!*  

!

*+*!9$%&$%* 0%,$(+!*$%*'+$%0+!,+  A!,"+"2$,$%, *'+6)#+,'+&!%* /+%+ $*  A<!,*/+!##<+(*!##*'+*+!0'+,<'<++!""$%*+( /+ +$,,)!%0+ %*$ $0!*$%'++!

*+*'++"#$+, $#+(/3*'+"+*$*$%+, <++%* )%(,!*$, !0*3!%((+, +02+3<++"!,,+( !

*+!

"+$( +$&'*3+!, '+(+, +02+3%+ "!3 *'+"+*$*$%+, '!2+/++%0'!##+%&+($%*'+"+,+%*"+*$*$% '+$=")&%+((+,'!2+/++%0'!##+%&+(%*'+&)%(*'!* *'++<!,%=$,+"+,+%*!*$%0%0+!#=+%*%*'+"!* *'+"+*$*$%+, %0+*'+/+%+ $*<!,&$2+%4*'+,!=+0)#(%*/+<$*'(!<%!,$*<!, &$2+%/3*'++,"%(+%*7!)*'$*$+,$*,+#  6)#+ !$!%($$ *'+ +%*!#$2$#+2$0+,6+2$,+(!30!#+4

$,+#+2!%* +,#2$%&

*'+0%*2+,3$%'!%(!,$*(+!#,<$*'*'+ $%$*$!#"!3$%*'+ +2$,+("!3,0!#+4<'$0'$,+"()0+(!,)%(+7 B$?!*$% $%$*$!#"!3$%*'++2$,+(,0!#+C '+$%$*$!#"!3 !:2+%=+%*,+2!%*<'+#+0*,4$,(++=+(*'!2+ +#+0*+()%(+,)/7)#+ )#+ */+&2+%+(/3*'+ +2$,+(,0!#+%!%( =*'+ ,*(!3 8!%)!34

4,'!##4 )%#+,,$%!%30!,+*'++,$(+%*/3,"+0$!#(+*'+<$,+ ($+0*,4  /+  $?+(  ,+"!!*+#3  $%  +,"+0*    '$,  "!3  $%  *'+

$0$!*$%&",*'+#(/3'$=$%*'+ ##<$%&=!%%+4%!=+#37  $%*'+0!,+ !##+="#3++,7 $ !%!=)%*+"+,+%*$%& "+0+%* /!,$0 "!3$%*'++?$,*$%&,0!#+4;;=+%(=+%*,=!(+* *'+,+  )#+,  <$*'$%  *'++  =%*',    *'+  (!*+  

")/#$0!*$%    ,)0'  !=+%(=+%*  ,)/.+0*  *  !

=$%$=)= 6,

4,'!##/+!((+(**'+B+?$,*$%& +=#)=+%*,D *'++="#3++,E $$ !

*+*'++?$,*$%&+=#)=+%*,'!2+/++%, $%0+!,+(4*'+"!3,0'!##*'++!

*+/+ $?+($%*'+ +2$,+(,0!#+!**'+,*!&+%+?*!/2+*'+!=)%* *'),0=")*+( 2$(+(*'!*7 ! $ *'+=$%$=)= *'++2$,+(,0!#+$,=+ *'!%*'+!=)%*,!$2+(!*4*'+"!3,'!##/+

$?+(!**'+=$%$=)= *'++2$,+(,0!#+E / $ *'+!=)%*,!$2+(!*$,=+*'!%*'+ =$%$=)= *'++2$,+(,0!#+4*'+"!3,'!##/+

$?+(!**'+=!?$=)= *'!*,0!#+ ?"#!%!*$%C*'+")",+ *'$,0#!),+B+?$,*$%& +=#)=+%*,D,'!##$%0#)(+47 ! *'+/!,$,"!3$%*'++?$,*$%&,0!#+E / (+!%+,,"!34!(($*$%!#7(+!%+,,!##<!%0+ !%(!('0(+!%+,,!##<!%0+!"""$!*+**'+ /!,$,  "!3  !(=$,,$/#+  !*  $%(+?  !2+!&+ 

E!%( 0 *'+!=)%*, $,*!%(,+0%($%,*!#=+%*, $%*+$=+#$+ !(=$,,$/#+%*'+/!,$,"!3$%*'+ +?$,*$%&,0!#+ED '++2$,$% "!3,0!#+ *'+*+!0'+,$%*'+1%$2+,$*$+,!%( ##+&+,<++%*$ $+(/3*'++"!*=+%* ()0!*$%4$%$,*3  )=!% 6+,)0+,+2+#"=+%*4:2+%=+%* %($!!%($*/+0!=++

+0*$2+ =

6)#+ (+!#,<$*'*'+"!3 $?!*$% =)#!4<'$0'$,+"()0+( !,)%(+7 B'+"!3 *+!0'+$%*'++2$,+(,0!#+%

<$##/+

$?+($%!00(!%0+<$*' =)#!+0==+%(+(/3*'+)*'

!3==$,,$%<'$#++2$,$%&"!3,0!#+, *'++%*!#:2* ="#3++,'+(+*!$#, *'+"!3 $?!*$% =)#!!+&$2+%$% %%+?)+

!3 $%  *'+ +2$,+(  ,0!#+,  ,')#(  /+ $?+(  )%(+ *'$, ,0'=+%#3!

*+7 ! +2+3*+!0'+'!,'!(!%""*)%$*3*(+0$(+ <'+*'+'+G,'+<$##"* *'++!#$+,0'=+!!

E!%( / *'+  1%$2+,$*3    ##+&+  0%0+%+(  '!,  =!(+ %+0+,,!3 0'!%&+,  $%  *'+$  ,*!*)*+,4  ($%!%0+,4  )#+,4 +&)#!*$%,4+*04*$%0"!*+*'+"2$,$%,  *'$, ,0'+=+  '+"!3 *+!0'+,$%1%$2+,$*$+,!%(0##+&+,=!3/+

$?+($%*'++2$,+(,0!#+ "!3$%*'+ ##<$%&=!%%(+7 $%  !=)%*  +"+,+%*$%&   A    /!,$0  "!3  $%  *'+ +?$,*$%&  ,0!#+  ,'!##  /+  !((+(  *  *'+  B+?$,*$%& +=#)=+%*,D $$ *+*'++?$,*$%&+=#)=+%*,'!2+/++%,$%0+!,+(4 *'+"!3,'!##/+ $?+($%*'++2$,+(,0!#+!**'+,*!&+ %+?*!/2+*'+!=)%**'),0=")*+( 2$(+(*'!* ! $ *'+=$%$=)= *'++2$,+(,0!#+$,=+*'!%*'+ !=)%*,!$2+(!**'+"!3,'!##/+ $?+(!**'+=$%$=)=

*'++2$,+(,0!#+E / $ *'+!=)%*,!$2+(!*$,=+*'!%*'+=!?$=)=

*'++2$,+(,0!#+4*'+"!3,'!##/+ $?+(!**'+=!?$=)= *'!* ,0!#+, ?"#!%!*$% $ '+B+?$,*$%&+=#)=+%*,D !*+!0'+% ,* 8!%)!34

,'!##$%0#)(+ ! /!,$0"!3E / (+!%+,,"!34!(($*$%!#(+!%+,,!##<!%0+!%(!( '0(+!%+,,!##<!%0+4$ !%3E

0 $%*+$=+#$+ 4$ !%3 $$   *'+  ")",+    !(($%&   A  *  *'+  +?$,*$%& +=#)=+%*, ! *'+/!,$0"!3,'!##/+*'+"!3% ,*8!%)!34

$%*'+1:,0!#+,E / '+%!"*$% *'+**!#+=#)=+%*,'!,/++% =+&+(<$*'*'+

1:,0!#+,"$* ,* 8!%)!34

4*'+/!,$0"!3=!3/++09%+(%*$%!##3$%*'+

1:,0!#+, *'+")",+ "!3E!%( 0 <'++  *'+ 

  1:  ,0!#+,  '!2+  %*  /++% $="#+=+%*+(4*'+!0*)!#/!,$0"!34"2$(+(*'!*'!(*'+ /!,$0"!3$%*'$,0!,+(+,%*+?0++(*'+%*$%!##3 !$2+(!*/!,$0"!3$

1:,0!#+,'!(/++%&$2+%  +<$##),*!*$%$%($0!*$%&*'+=!%%+$%<'$0'*'+"!3

*+!0'+,,')#(/+ $?+()%(+6)#+ !+&$2+%/+#<7 ##),*!*$%7

?$,*$%&,0!#+ "!3 6,

7>

 ",+(,0!#+ "!3 6,

7

7H7

7>

 ?$,*$%&/!,$0"!3 6,

> G%

6,

G7

<$%,*!#=+%*, 6, > G7 $%*+$=+#$+

?$,*$%&+=#)=+%*, 6,

G7

(( A /!,$0"!3 6,

GI !3*/+ $?+($%*'++2$,+(,0!#+I6,

G7 ,  "+  +%*!#  $2$#  +2$0+,  6+2$,+(  !3  0!#+4 

+2$,$% "!3,0!#+,/3*'++"!*=+%* ()0!*$% :2+%=+%*

  %($!  (!*+( 

4  +2$,$%    "!3  ,0!#+,  /3  *'+  1%$2+,$*3  (!*+(

!%(!,"+*+=,!%(0%($*$%,$,,)+(/3)%.!/:2+%=+%* =+=(!*+(  

4*'+$%0+!,+  A<!,*/+&$2+%*!##*'+ *+!0'+,  $%  *'+  /!,$0  "!3    *'+  +?$,*$%&  +=#)=+%*,  <+  

%<!(,$%*'+3+!

1:,0!#+$+

!%(

*'+/!,$0 "!3*!##*'+"+*$*$%+,%*'+%*$ $0!*$%$,,)+(/3*!*+:2+%=+%* +&!($%&+2$,$% "!3,0!#+<+ 

4%<'++$*<!,=+%*$%+( *'!* A$%0+!,+ /!,$0"!3<!,%**/+&$2+%**',++="#3++,<' <++!""$%*+(%

!

*+<!(, (=$**+(#34*'+"+*$*$%+,<++!""$%*+(!

*+

!%( /+ +  $,,)!%0+    *'+  %*$ $0!*$%  /3  +,"%(+%*71%$2+,$*3  (!*+(

'++2$,+("!3,0!#+ 

7>

$%0#)(+( A$%0+!,+

*'+/!,$0"!3$%*'+)%+2$,+(,0!#+ 

!%(%*'+/!,$, *'!*

=)#!4*'+"!3 *'+"+*$*$%+,<!, $?+('+3<++&!%*+(/!,$0"!3 

$%*'++2$,+("!3,0!#+ 

7>

=*'+(!*+ *'+$ +,"+0*$2+!""$%*=+%*,$%*'+3+!

*$,0#+!*'!**'+"!3 *'+ "+*$*$%+,<!, $?+(!%(,!=+<!,&!%*+(!,*'+3<++!""$%*+(! *+

'+/+%+ $*  A$%0+!,+%*'+/!,$0"!3<!,*/+&$2+%* *',++="#3++,<'<++!""$%*+(%

!

*+<!(,<'++ $*<!,=+%*$%+($%*'+%*$ $0!*$%$,,)+(/3*!*+:2+%=+%**'!*/+%+ $*  A$%0+!,+ /!,$0"!3<!,%**/+&$2+%**',++="#3++,<' <++!""$%*+(%

!

*+<!(, !$(%*$ $0!*$%(+!#,<$*'

%#3 A$%0+!,+ /!,$0"!34<'$0'$, * /+&$2+%* *'++?$,*$%& +=#)=+%*,%

$%*'+

1:0!#+,  *+0%,$(+$%&*'+ ,"$$* ,!$(%*$ $0!*$%*'+"!3 *'+"+*$*$%+,<!, $?+('+(+

+02+3<!,"!,,+(,)/,+@)+%*#3!

*+!"+$( +$&'*3+!,

%      !"

#  !$  % &'  (' 

)*   ')%  +,%)

, '% &- ./012+1- 133 %J/#+*'+"+?)*'!(,)==!$,+( 0+*!$%  ,$*)!*$%,  <'++/3  +02+$+,  /3  *'+  +="#3+,  <)#(  /+ $="+=$,,$/#+$%#!<!%(*',+,$*)!*$%,!++"()0+(!,)%(+7   

            



 

 

!



   "  #$      #$   " $  

!



 "#$$% $ 

  %    "

$ 



 !

 

#$  $# 

 

&   $   $$  "$   " $ $$$ $  $

 

&   # '   !

      $  "  #$   $  

  

     $    "$ 

 

$ "#  &   $ $   

  $%"#  

#$  $  &      $     $  

 !( '+0!,+ *'+"+*$*$%+$,,@)!+#302++(/3*'+!*$

#!<#!$((<%$%

)* ')%'.

'

+' 4& -<'++$%$*'!,/++%'+#(*'!* *'+  +02+3  =  *'+  +="#3++,  /+#%&$%&  *  #!,,7  !%(  #!,,7- ,+2$0+:)"JJ!%(:)"JJ,+2$0+0!%%*/++

+0*+('++02+3 0!%/++

+0*+( $%0!,+4!%+="#3++'!,<%& )##3/++%+@)$+(* ($,0'!&+()*$+, !'$&'+",*!%('!,/++%"!$(

%"!!  *'+

)* ')%'.

'

+' 4& -$*'!,/++% '+#( *'!* $% 0!,+4<'++ "!3=+%*,  '!2+=$,*!9+%#3/++% =!(+/3*'+ +="#3+4$%+?0+,, *'+$+%*$*#+=+%*4*'+%+02+30!%%*/++

+0*+( $*$,$="+=$,,$/#+)%(+#!<)%(+ $2+,$*)!*$%,!,=+%*$%+(!/2+ %*'+"+,+%*0!,+4*'+/+%+ $* "!3<!,&$2+%/3 +,"%(+%*71%$2+,$*3!,"+%*$ $0!*$%$,,)+(/3*'+*!*+:2+%=+%* )/,+@)+%*#34,'<0!),+%*$0+,<++$,,)+(**'+"+*$*$%+,4*<'$0' +"#$+,<++!#,,)/=$**+(/3*'+=/)**'+,!=+<++%*0%,$(++(!%( !

*+!"+$( =+*'!%+$&'*3+!,4*'+(+ +02+3<!,"!,,+( '+,!$((+ +02+3<!,,*!3+(/3*'$,)*<'$#+$,,)$%&%*$0+

=*$%'+"!3 *'+"+*$*$%+,<!, $?+(!%(/+%+ $*<!,&!%*+(* *'+=/)**'++<!,%=$,+"+,+%*!*$%0%0+!#=+%*!,*'+/+%+ $*<!, &$2+% !,  "+  *'+$  +%*$*#+=+%*  '+  0!,+   *'+  "+*$*$%+,  $,  ,@)!+#3 02++(/3*'+(+0$,$%  %K/#+*'+"+?)*$%

)* ')%5'.

'

+' 4& -*'!,!#,/++% !$#3!(=$**+(/3#+!%+(0)%,+# +,"%(+%*7 1%$2+,$*3*'!*%+02+3'!,/++%+

+0*+( =*'+"+*$*$%+,!%(*'+3 +2+%(%*$%*+%(*+

+0*!%3+02+3 %2$+< !0*,!%(0$0)=,*!%0+, *'+0!,+!,<+##!,#!< ",$*$%!,+?"#!$%+(!/2+4*'+"+,+%*"+*$*$%$,!##<+(!%($=")&%+( (+,(!*+( 

!%(

!+'++/3@)!,'+( )&),*4

+  - ".!

  '+*'+,"+!9$%&G+!,%+( L+, '+*'++"*!/#+ L+,