M/S Chawla Enterprises Thro Davinder Singh Chawla v. M/S Harjot Engg. Works And Others











   





 





 ! 
 "#

$ ! 

!!

!!

%& ' " 
( )
## 
* +


  

!%& 
 

 


  



       

   

  

  

 

  $ 




 
,,-
.-





 
!!




///// 
!

" #


 

 
 

 

  
  
 
 

 


 

 
 
  !"#!"#

$

%
&  
'
 (
%   )$


 
$



  
#

 *

  
'
+ 
 






  
,


  


  




-
 




 


) 
 
$


 

.

 

  
#


*

  
' + (
##

 
 
"
0


!   !
 1

" 0


 

!  
2 3
 
  #


!4 

  1

 
"


4"

"
!"  

 
!#  
 1
 
1!


 1
1

1

 #

" 4+

 
1!



"1


-5-56

"#
4 



!34 
43
 
"

 
1!




 
   #
 
! 

 
4 3
 
"
"

 7"
4 # 05555






6


"1


-

-


  

8 

9+

11 -
:8

-
8!!
 
:  -
; 
- <   -

."

 
1!



 
" 
 
1

"


4
" 

! 

( . -


! 
 
 7"

" 
4+
 " 
.
11

 


1 +
=>"
?"@

A!
 -
1!


#
"

#



 


 
"
"
:
5

 0#4 
> "1

 "#
# 
!



A$ 

#
"!
 
"

1+
 
!31
 
 
!"

 ! 


3-
4"
 
"
 



(-
 
1!




 
/

 

  $
  (
  


  
 

 


 
  

  
#

 *

  
'
+ (
##
) 
 





.





) 
$

 
0 
 $0



  

 (


 



(
1 


 


2#
 (
 




.


   
#
 
)



)
$

 

 

 

 


 


 (


  

  (
,
 




  


  (
 



(
 
 
 
!"#!"#
3 (


 
 
 


 


  '
 
 
 


 





  

 
  

 (


  

  



(

 

4.

   

   





    

   

    

  

   

 



  

            



  

   !

           

"#  $%   &    

'

( )        

  



                    "#$% &  



'

( $ 

     

 ( *   !  ! 



   

    

 

 



  (
      





       



   !



        

    



 $%   &     

 '

        

  +

,

- +.

 

       

  !  !

"  !##    

 



  

   



       !  

     

     

    



     /





 

  

   0     

     

                    

  

  

 

  

    

 /   

     

       

      !  ! 

 

       

 

 

    



 

 

 

) *

  

    

  1

  

  

 

) $

 

   

                

  

)             2# ' 4 

 .

  

 

20' 2



   

 5 

      

  



    

  

      

   45$)       









    

     

     

  

 

  



  



) $

      

 

   

  





     



  

 

 







  


 $ 

  

     

  



   !   

             !

  

"



#



$ %    



  &  '



   

   &  




(

) *  +

 & , -., /   
  

    

  !

&

        

 

 

       0

&1

   '



      

    !    





   

      

 

    

 



'

0 !

1


(

) * 

+       !

"        

  

   !      ' 2 

$  

   

         



     

     

        



$*



 3

"

  4 

             

    



$

        



$  3       

  



      

          



            '

  $6  " 

  

 1


(

)  *  +  



        $  1         &  

  !            





 

   

  &  



  !              

&                  

     

 "  $ "#$%&%#

'(
$ *



&  

   

   "!



         $  *  

 

&  1

 
7
8
 

) *  +



 !

 



   



 &!

 & 



   &  

& 

  

 





 &   &   



     



    $  3 !&  , -  1  / 

*  )*

+,- *.& , /& ,"

0* 1   ,,112

  



  






(

) *  +

 &    !





  

 





 

  

 





  



$  

!



   #

 

   


(

) * 

+   



  

$ "#$%&%#

'( $ *



  

        !    

 

 



  $* 

 ! &  #   

/
    



       

          

$7&9(&9(:5'

    1

 

  

 

;#$/'
 !

 

 ;#$/'

 ;#$/'
$%    

     



   

"



  

   

 !  ! "

  



 

   





  $3 !&  

       !  #

     $0 



'# 

    !    

  ;#$/
 ;#$/


     &  /" 

      

&      #  $3 !



    

  

&   

 

%

    

 &   

 

 

$   ! 

     !    $
7$ +   

1


:

  !

 <'

=*  &

 

!  ! &

         1

 
(& 

  

&    &



  >$
9$ , !



 

 

  !

   

# 

  

   

           !

 

   $*

    

   

      

   

 


:5

(

) *  +$
?$

  !



 

/'
 

  

                   

  

   !  



    ) $9((((@A
$A
$AA:

 

$

&AA&AAA5'      

   

        $  +      

 1

 
( 

) *  +    !$
@$ !   

        







         

     



 $0



 

"

  !

$   

&





&                        

       1

 
( 

 )  *  +$+  

    $  %             

$6 

  



 !

!        

      



 $> 
3 0 
 
 

"%&'%%()  #  *
!"#!
55
 
6"
 
 

4 =
A$0 * ,,2 23 , 45 3  $ 17

" 8 9:  



  ,   /       

       

   $B  

 &=,  /     !

 



   8
!



  C           

    

D  8  



  !



 &



  "     

 D8  

  



 D87 



  

 

 

 !     C        ! 

     

$> 

B  

 

  ! $

$+  
:9&

/  1 1 !$ 1DE+* 
:91/9F&   



  ,   /       

          1

7
@

/ 0 /   !& =, /  

 !

!



 



  

  

& 

   

 

 





     &

 

    !

  

  !

!  

!     

$>
$ 





  

      

/  &,  

 2;6 $ 17!

21: *  24

2 .< "

;6 $ 17!

2= 9: 8

2 .< "

;6 $ 17!!2>9:   

2 .2,;6 $ 17!=219:
 24

2 ." ;6 $ 17!921=: - 4

2 .,;6 $ 17= 2:% 

2 . ,;6 $ 17= 2>=:*  

2 .
;61792 !:2 2  *

2 .,;6179 297 : 0?@*

2 .
;6179 2  :    

 2  .  < "

;  6179    2  = :
,24

2 ." ;6179  2>>: < * *



2 .-;6179>12 >: - 3 **8

2 .

"

;6179712

!!:& 24

2 ." 617>9

  !'17>92!7:   

2 .)8;6177 

 = 1'177!233 12 >:*0

2 ./;61779

 >7'177992=99:2 , 

2 .;6177>

 =7 '177> !2 1:
424

2 . "

;6

   !7  '     2  >!:  ) &3 

" " , )4   .

"

;



6 

 >=1'=2 9:

 8 

   - 4   %;  6  

 9!' 121:2 .?

  - 3?,;  6! 

     '

!7271:2 .- 

28&?;

69

  !>'9 29!!: *33 

 2  .  ?;  69 

 7'91  3A*4 ,

> 1'9 2 1!:

*

 

      !

$1

  

/   

   

    &    

               

  <8  



  !



     

      

 

       

    

    

!

          &  8

      

 

  





  

       

   

       &  8



&





  

    

             #

!  

 

   !





 

  

 

 

    $*

        ! 

       

   

$*   " 

!







 &  

      

    

    

$  G

&   

     

           !

 

      

 

  & "  

  !   &           

 

      

 



&8 !3 

 

'

 

'!

!



  "

!

&    

  

 



!

"   



!

$ ! !



!

       

  

  $> 7 


 



 
  

 )
$
  
)


 


 

) 
 


 
$
  


 


 
+
 (

 
 
 













"
#

 

 3 ?