← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4704/2019disposed of

Union Of India And ORS v. Central Administrative Tribunal And ANR

2022-12-09Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan8 pages

 

  !

    

 "#$  $%&'&() 



 "#$ $'$*+$,)- 



(&( (,&""(,#.$*' $#&#&($* /' $(#*"0 ,1&(&'#*"#&+$*&23("0"(,"(#.$* $'4(,$(#'

 ) 56 777   6

567 7 8    

 



 

  



8   9  

 



! 

   "# #

"#$ & '#(  

  )   + %   , ,( )*



   - ". "# "#/



)   

0

 12 '

 4"5"'/5." ) 



 2 

 

 % ,2,(

 

 #" "/ ""/ 6   *   77 

    %  , ,(

# "/ "#/ 9

 



 #: #"

"#/ 



- 

 7   

*

  * )  ;20 



/"""'

:"""0'

   +'# 5 ""0'

" ""0'< /""

"# "# "":





*  



 ". ".

"#:

9 

*





0  *

     





 

   /"""'

:"""0' #" "/ ""/   



# "/ ""/ 9

 

 



 "## #: #"

"#/  

   

""=  

  



  

/



 

)

%

(    



# "/ ""/ +* *  #: #"

"#/ 

0 

   9 

    ) 77

# "/ "#/  

- *     

- ) 

1   )

 



) 12 %1 ( %; ( !

 



   *  12 3





 

) 7 77



     

:

!    )

  

$ )



   



) 12











 12 "4 "$ ""

 

 #" "/ ""/ 

 

 7   > :

 

    

   





 

 #" "/ ""/ 

   12 

 4"5"'/5."0'   



 /"""':"""0'

7  



    )



   



# "/ ""/

 #: #"

""/



?

 =  



   

 )  ?

)

 "$ ": #.:. 

6   3 6  & 3'4 ) (  

 )    

  



  

)  

 *

)  

  * 9  

 

-  )     

    ;2,  % 

(

   



'

@   

  

   

       

     



   

   

 

    



  

 

 

!

         

    

         " 

# 



      " 

   

      

   

       

 

"  



     

 



: 

 "     $$$ $$$$ $$$$ $$$$%

%A 

( .

; -*

      *   )  



 #: #"

"#/

   #: #"

"#/     ) *  

 & 3'4( )   

 3

 )         *

  -  ) 





#: #"

"#/ *

 "##    *  "##  

 

 

 



 

 )

   

 

 

* 

   )  )  

 

  )



## !   )

 9,) 8  7

(&( (,&""(,#.$*'

 / ."("("&*

( 8   4::  

;  

?

) 9,) 8  7  '

&'(  !

     

 

 

#

 )

#

    







#  



*

 

  

  

 



#$

 

  



 

+  

   #  ,'- ,

* #

 

#.

  . -/001 !23*4.#!# 23"3 #33."3#567

.!8 #3 !494 .

  :  +   





  + ;<-;:<-;

<6;< $       

 

      

      *$'$(#7%"0$ $+&'$,"<7#*3%#3*$ >

0B

 8

> *





+08

+08 

B *

%#(

(

%4(

%/(

%5(

%:(

8'/

$5"'$"'4=""'$5'//""

+'#

""'

""

#=""

:

8'5

4"5"'$5'4.5"'="'/5."

+'#

""'

""

#.""

$

8':

""'=5'/.""

+'#

""'

""

"""

=

8'$

/"""'#""':"""

+'#

""'

""

/""

.

8'=

/5""'# 5'$"""

+'#

""'

""

=""

8'.

5"""'#5"'="""

+'

.4""'4/=""

/ ""

##

8'#"

55""'#$5'."""

+'

.4""'4/=""

/ ""

#

8'##

:5""'

""':.""

+'

.4""'4/=""

/ ""

#4

8'#

:5""'

""'#"5""

+'

.4""'4/=""

/ ""

#/

8'#4

$/5"'

5'##5""

+'

.4""'4/=""

/:""

#5

8'#/

$5""'

5"'# """

+'

.4""'4/=""

/=""

&'="  

 

#$

 

 -

# 50(0,>(,5?(0,10,7(?0 @   : ,' .(/00,/0/00 + 

.'?00A,@  -

# 5/00,1(, 7?00@   : ,' (/00,/0/00

  +  ./000A, # "



@7000,'00,=000@  



 : ,'     (/00,/0/00      +     ./700A, " 





 #

-

 +



  @ 

 

@

# 50(0,>(,5?(0,10,7(?0-    '/ 

 -  

   

  

$   

 



"  # 7000,'00,=000    @  





  



)

#

-

+

  

 

@ 

: ,' .(/00, /0/00A, +  .'?00A,-     '0       

   

        

 -    

  

 

 $



+  ./000A,  

        

  *  

 

#



    

 

      

-

  

  



+  .7/00A,     

$      

    

  

    

 



  )

#

-

    



 $ 

+    

+   

$   

@ #

 *

(&( (,&""(,#.$*'



=> /&*$(,$*7&(?.

%/( 8 ::



 

;67

  *    -   ) * 

  - 



* ) 

@ 8 # '

 8 

8  %3  *( 3 

""=

#4 7              

 

) &



)  

/ ""0'



9 

)

*  ) 

8 '7 

 8 

8  %3  *( 3 

""=

* ++'7D  * +08  ""'

""D  B *

=""   

)?  *

 

77   6

 8          $%$12$* 9

 ! 8

E ! 3) E