Ram Asra Singh Etc. v. State Ofpb.
% 8 72'%2%7
!" # " $% $ & $ $' $ $(
+,"-" .....
) *
+ #!
. ( * / 0
1 +
223333 (
) .* ) #
223333
9 : & $'4 345
%'%334
6 $77'3 334" #
8 + ". # "
!! 8+
" / 0
". # + 33'
8 + " . # " + 3341333 / " / ;
0
).<.=
+
$; ( * /
8 + / 272<334 + #
8+
+ ". #
8 + ". # " / 0
/ >4? % & " ,
,"@ ". # " "
+ " $
' # + " /#" & $' + #
"# %2%2% '
!" #"
$%.
+"/ !
!&! 5 A +" $' #
.B 2%37"2%%37
2<%37" # +
/ B " # +3=2
+ " " 42<3=2" 2=%3=2
42<3=2" # +B +3=
3=5" CB . # :/ +#
#
#
.
" %4 B " 6 $=''5 3=7 " / / " # 2%2'345" /#" +
& $'4 345" @
2%2'345" / / / + 8 # A " # @
2'33= # @
2'33= .
! " # $ %%
" " $ & "
"
!$ " " #" $ '
" "$ ! " (
% #
$ %)%
"
*
!! <
" / / + # /
6$=''53=7/ &$'4345" + 6 $77'3 334" / / / " #
%'%334" # @
2'33= &$'4345 #
%'%334" 6$77'3334"
. + "
$
" $ & " " +,- ./0 01/' " .
01123&
+ 5 "" $ -
$ " (
$ $ " "$ 6
" " (
* <(* # "
/ 8 + " . # ( 8+ *" # + / " #
2=%222 (
) .< .=* /#" + / + 8 + ". # "
!'!
/ 272<334 / 0 9 " 7 /
$
%"
. +%7 ! $
0 0111 "
$ " 8 $ 9
7 :
011/ .0 0;
<;;; .0 0;
1/ .;
0111 "
$ "
+ =
& " " , " " </ 0112 = "
$" " $ " " " ,# " " $ ! ! = " " $,#
" $
"
"
! $ ,
9 " 0< ;0 " + ,
9 " 8 $ 9 " " $ 8 +
<;
.
;0 ! " 8 $ 9 " < :
<;;0 $ "
$" 8 $9 " $
!(!
" ,
9 "
( 8 $ - <0 " " 0.
0< <;;0 "
$ = "
$"
"
$ " - $ $
+%2 ! "
#
!
$ " / 0< 1/
$ 8 +
> ? & + 9 @
A & ,&9011; 30724 !$ $ # # +%/ +%1!" "
, $
" "
#
$% & " '
%'" ( ( ( "
'" +-
0;0. +%0'3434
!$! 34 ! $= " </ , $ ,9 <;
;2 1.$011/ $ :B1/ $ 8 $* 89 343#4 * =
! +
.
C # /! 18
" "
+" + /
8 + " # :
# + " $4 2725%22'" $ (
* + 8 + " # " / + / 9/#" " # +/! #"
# + + ". # %22=33' + 334" # / %23%22" D $'3< 333" / $= 2725%22'
" "
! +
!)!
.
#
#
+ " 4 B #
# 3
#+ / +
/ + +
/!
+ # / #
+ # /
# + 2 +" #
8 + ". # ( 8+ * "/ #"
+ # / + @
2'33= &$'4345
%'%334 6$77'3334"/ + + /!
8 + " . # ( 8+ *
223333 (
) .*" # / / #
223333"
. *** *** *** ***
!#! ! " " & " ,
B8 $ 9 " $ C
+ , -1/,03,17,3-8 +,.,17,3 "% *** *** &
2-39-+-44 ( $' * -./,012/345/61,+
,,5 ,67/17/4 !$!#& 1, ''#) -4 4411 /:741+-+
,,5
,67/17/4 -3; -4 /5<1= /:741+-+
> ? <51, &!(!##
@2/31274/.58,=//74A/73: 4<5/+-33<-1/;
2-. 73:2 ( $% * !$!#& 1, ''#) -4 4411 /:741+-+
,,5
,67/17/4 -3; 0+,. ('#) 1, &""#) -4 /5<1= /:741+-+ ,,5
,67/17/4 > ? 12/ ;-1/ @2/32/@-44<5/+-33<-1/; -4 /5<1= /:741+-+ ,,5
,67/17/4 > ? 12/ ;-1/ @2/32/@-44<5/+-33<-1/; ' -.4+- 73:2 ( $ * !$!#& 1, ''#) -4 4411 /:741+-+
,,5
,67/17/4 -3; 0+,. ('#) ,3@-+;4 -4 /5<1= /:741+-+
,,5
,67/17/4> ? (1,# *** *** 2(*
223333 # + . ) # / + @
2'33=
&$'4345
%'%334 6$77'3334;
#
!"!
+ " / ! 2%+"
+ #
/ / / " # /
&$'4345 +"/ #
223333" + + /. )
0 + 223333 +/
(* # +
" $%
' +
"/ + "
+
+/! 8 + " # / 8+ 223333 B /+ 9 :
C ) "
'
*+ ,' - .
/ 01 & 2 "
"
" $ $"
" $ " D $?$*
"9 : ) # D( $ "
$
? %
9 : E+ ' ' 3
4! 5(0.
1 +
E + /!F" "
/ + +
/
!""! /
"
" / #
/ / 9/ + + # + + + / + 9 : ) 67 3' ( , 8 ( 9 "
( 9 %
50.
1 2 ' 9#
#
/" 0 / +GB /! + / + / # +
39+ # H
BB" 6! 8 (B A * 3=2
/ +
I ) "
"
+ # # +8 + " # " /
+
# / /!
"
5 # / #
/ / #
" +
!"! / ( $(
* +"
" + /! 8 + " # " 8+ "
" " + 8 + " # "223333
+ (* $%
' " #
/ " +/ +
+
+ # + /!
" "
223333"/ < " $(
* #
+ " & +
/ " #"
+ "/
2' " + 7
" +"
= + & $(
*+
"(&( #1!!
6 !
1
1$
1$