High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/10493/2018dismissed

Vivek Jindal v. State Of Punjab

2018-05-10Mr. Justice Gurmit Ram8 pages

!"#$%&'( )#** &# !#+

*(*# )+&,(- .#/ &'#&*

)##&*

+(-01 #2'"

(*# *0#/#** &# 3**(& #0(2''123(4(&( 5*6+5(1 4(2'"

(*# *0# 5/(&(&* 0#/##&*/#** &0(-##&#'+&'# &) 4-(* /#** &# !"#$%&'(& (#

'(*#' #8*##'+&'# & 2 92:2 9(&' )(* ) # *(* &*4;(&(( <#(&#' +&# *0# /#** &# &*#&' *0(* ( /# (#8(* &&*0#

.2*0#/#** &#=('"&8*0#5 4 #(&'=0#

( +#'=0 =((**&8/ &'# (+#''(5(8#* *0# (

5/(&(&*0#

.0(-##&#8*##''+#* *0#&+#& # *0#-(&$

((&'=*0 +*#"#&(//# (*&8*0#( **0(*&( **0## "#4 (8#&*#&*-4*0#-(&$=##*4&8* *($# -#/ # *0#3 *# '#/*#*0##-#&8*(4 (#&(* &-4*0#*( +*&( "+*#'-4 (+&* *0#/#** &#<#(&#' +&#+*0# &*#&'*0(*((#* 4 0(-##& *#'-4*0# 5/(&(&*& '#* /#+>#*0#/#** &#

0(&' "#*0#$#4 *0#3 *#* *0#-(&$ <#(&#' +&#(

&*#&'*0(*& &,+4=( (+#'* *0#-(&$ ((&' &4'(5(8# =(* *0# ( ("#&*0##& (#8(* &&*0#

.*0(* &,+4=( (+#'* *0#/# &=0 =##**&8&*0# (

# "#4 -### *#' 5*0#/#** &#(&' +* '(&*# 8(* && *#?+#' **0##&'2#(&#' +&# *0#/#** &# &*#&'*0(* #& #+&'#

& 92:(&' 9 )(#-((-#(&'*0##& &8#'#&*

& )&*0#

.0# 8&>(& # #& #+&'# & 92 ) (&& *-#*($#&#@ #/*-45 "&8(=**#& 5/(&* <#(&#' +&# *0# #/ &'#&*

*(*# 0( // #' *0# +-5 &5('#-4#(&#' +&# *0#/#** &#(&'+-5**0(* &*#&* *0#/#** &#=( #((0# =#'*0#-(&$ ((&'

'(5(8#'*0# (2=0##(2*0#-(&$ (=#&**0##* /# 5*0#

( '+*# (&' * /(*# *0# & * # &4 <#(&#' *(*# +&#

&*#&'*0(**0#/#** &#=('"&8*0#5 4 #2=0##(2*0#

( +#'2=0 =(**&8(/ &'#0**0#=&'

=/(&# *0# ( <#(&#' *(*# +&#( &*#&'*0(**0# (=('(5(8#' 5-( $( =#( 5 &*'#(&'*0#/#** &#'

#& *'##"#*0# & # -( <#(&#' +&# *0# 5/(&(&* 0( ( // #' *0# +-5 &5('#-4#(&#' +&# *0#/#** &# &*0#8 +&'*0(* *0#/#** &#& * &4 (+#''(5(8#* *0# (-+* (+#'&,+4* *0#

+/(&* *0# (0#( *(&' &'+ * *0#/#** &#=(=+(&'

(0#& * &4/#"#&*#'*0#-(&$ (* /# 5*0# ('+*# -+*&*5'(*#'*0#5(&' (+#' * *0# ( 3#(' *0# (8+5#&* ('"(& #' -4 #(&#' +&# *0#

/(*# (&'0("#( 8 &#*0 +80*0# &*#&*

.(&' *0# '

+5#&*("((-# &*0## 0#

.=(#8*##' &*0#*(*#5#&* (0#00(&'#2 =0 =(= $&8(0#(&(8#&)+&,(- (* &(;(&$2;(*0&'( /#(#8(* &&*0#

.20#( &8=*00*(5#5-#=#&** *($# 45- / # & 5*0#'#(+*# *0#-(&$(&' @&8*0# * # *0#-(&$ A0##*+&&8-( $2*0#/#** &#( &8=*0

( +#'2=0 =## &5 4 #(5#'=*0 & '0('- $#&*0# =&'

=/(&# *0# (2=0 0 #( 5*0#/0 8(/00 =&&*0# +*(**0#*5# 0#(&8 *0# (#&#( 0&8*0#/ #2=0 0=( (#'-4*0# +/(&* *0# (2*0#( +#'#'(=(4 5*0#/ *

* &4*0#'(5(8#=( (+#'* *0# (-+*(&4+&* =('& '#&* +'

0("#0(//#&#'( &# *0#( +#'=(0 '&8 & '&00(&'(&'

*0#=('"&85 4 # *( #( 5*0#/0 8(/0*0(**0# -(&$ (=##*0##* /(*#*0#& * #(&'=##' 0(8&8*0#

('+*4

4-(2*0#&(*+#28("*4 #& #( =#( # *0#( +#'* -###&0##(# #*(&( * 2=0 0(# -# &'##'=0#8(&*&8-(+&'# &)3 &B-#*0# /#@ +*&(,+'85#&*#&'##'&

!"!#$ !%& % %'()*

% # #'% % 0(+55(>#' #*(& ( * * -#*($#&&* &'#(* &=0#8(&*&8(&* /(* 4-(2=0 0 (##/ '+ #'(+&'# C0#/& /#=0 0 (&-# +#' +*2 *0#/+/ # &*(&* (#2 (&-#*(*#'(+&'# 0# 5/(&* #' (8(&* *0# ( +#' &##' * -#

*0 +804 #@(5&#'2 & +'&8 *0# (/# * =0#*0# *0#

5/(&(&*0(#'((# "

+ 5/(&* &#(#

( &0# +*0 +'( #@(5&#*0#( *=0#*0#*0## (&4(54'/+*#-#*=##&*0#( +#'(&'*0# 5/(&(&* (&'*0# 5/(&(&*5+*-# #(4* '*0(**0# 5/(&* +&'* -#(# "

+2*0#&* *( * &=-#*($#& (8(&*05&( '(& #=*0(= &&"(& #-#*=##& *0# 5/(&(&*(&'*0#&"#*8(*&8 ##*(-0#'*0#& ( * &-#*($#&(8(&**0#&"#*8(*&8 #&( '(& # =*0(= 0#8("*4 0(8#(&'*0##@( * # *0#( +#'5+* -#/ /#4 5/#0#&'#';# #(#*2*0#(#*&8 # 5+*# '*0#"('#( &=0 00("##'* *0#(#* ( +#'&*0# (#'(4 &#@ #/* &( (#2*0##( &

+'-## '#'55#'(*#4(*#*0#(#*2 *0(*=0# '#(&8=*0*0#-((// (* &2*0##5($(&' -#"(* &

*0#(#*&8 # (&( -#/ /#4#"(+(*#'-4*0#

+* * 5/#(*"# *0# +* * (#+4 (&' =*0 5#* + + /# & #"(+(*# *0# ( * *0# (# 0# ' #* &* 8(&*-(5+*-##@# #' &*0#-( ("((-#5(*#((&'*0#( * *0#/(* +( (# & (# =0##*0# +* &'##'"#=*0(**0#( +#'0( , &#'*0#&"#*8(* &(&'0#+4

/#(*&8=*0*0# &"#*8(*&8(8#& 4(&'& *$#4* (- &'2&*0(*#"#&*2 +* '(&*# 8(* &0 +'-#("

'#'8#(*8& 5&42

0+5(* &(&''8( #(**( 0#'* (#*#*#('*

5(&4# + &#?+#& #& * &4 *0#( +#'-+* *0# #&*# (54 (&' (* *5# *0# #&*# 55+&*4 * /# /#'

& *5($#(&4'*& * &-#*=##&(#*(*(/#

&" * &*(8# / *

&" * &*(8# "0##& ,+* (* & #('&8&* &) *0#5*(* &5#&* &#'& &:)0#/#&**+'#

& 5+* -# 8"#& * + /(4 0## &

#?+#5#&**0(**0#( +#'5+*5($# +*(C/# ( (#D *0# #@# # *0# / =# * 8(&* (&* /(* 4 -( 0 "*+(42#'+ #*0#(+*(4/ =# &##'-4 & )* ('#('#**#/# &##$&8(&* /(* 4-(* (##5(&#&**#'* *0#/#+5/* && #& #3# =&8* +-5** #*(&*(&' &'* & &0##'

-4*0#( #/*(& # &'* &=0 0*0# +*5(4'##5**

5/ #2& &'#(* *0#(+(& #*0(*(#*#'20# 0(-##&(8#' &-( " 0# / /# +# ( * & & (& (// (* & 4-( +80** -#*0(*(*##"(+(*&8*0#("#5#&* (&'( +(* &("((-# &*0## '*0# +*& &#'

8(&*(&* /(* 4-(*0#&(&&*#5-(-#8(&*#'(&'

* #-#+#'* *0#)+- ) # +* *#0#(&8*0# )+- ) # +* *0# +*5(4#*0##,# **0#(&* /(* 4 -((// (* &5*0#&*( '# 8(&*&8-(0#

+*= +' #*(&4-##&**#'* 5/ # &'* & *0# 8(&* (&* /(* 4 -( 0# )+- ) # +* *0#

5/(&(&*= +'-#(*-#*4* 5 "#*0#(5# +* (& #(* 5 '4&8*0# &'* & (&* /(* 4-((* (&4 *5# -#*4 8(&*#' -4 *0# +* 5+#' 0# 4 -( 8(&*#' -4 *0# +* 0 +' '&(4 -#

&*&+#'**0#*( *0# (# " *(#**#'#8(/ * &*0(**0# +*=0 08(&**0# -(( 0(*0#/ =#* (& #*0#' #* 8(&* (& #(* -( (&-##@# #'#*0#(**0#&*(& # ( +#'2*0#)+- ) # +* *0# 5/(&(&*2 &&'&8 &#=5(*#( +5*(& #(*(&4/ &* *5# " &/++(& # '# *0# +* # *0# 380 +*2 & #*0#( +#'##(#' &(&* /(* 4-(-4 *0#*( +*2*0#&*= +'-#+&#( &(-#* 5/#*0# ( +#'* +#&'#-# #*0#*( +*(&'(8(&(//4 #8+(-( " #* &"#*#'&*0# +*&(5(**#0 +'-# #@# #'=*0 (#(&' +5/# * &'#/#&'&8+/ &*0# ( *(&' +5*(& #,+*4&8*#@# # 5(42*0# ' #* &"#*#'=*0*0# +*+&'# &)0 +'

( -##@# #'=*0 (+* &(&'/+'#& # *+&&# #(4 *("#-#4 &'*(&'+-,# **0#='#/ =#(&'' #*

&##'-4*0##8(*+#* (8 + '# # 5/ #'

5*(* & @

&#@-#8+'#&# *(*,( $#* 5+( (&-# / "'#' #+( 4-(-# (+#( +5*(& # (&' *+(* & +*+# (&& * -# #(4

: "+(#' *0# 8(&* #+( (&* /(* 4 -(

& &(& #=*0#8(*"#&*#&* &2*0#8(&* #+( 4-(0 +'&# #(4'#/#&' &*0#( *(&'

+5*(& # #( 0 (# @A#0(( #/ '+ #/((

*0#,+'85#&*=0##& *0# +*'#&#(*#'*0# =&8( * (&'/((5#*#*0(* &##' * -# *($#& &* &'#(* & =0# '#(&8 =*0 4-( (0#&(*+#(&'8("*4 *0#( +(* &(&'*0##@( * #

*0#( +#'5+*-#/ /#4 5/#0#&'#'-# #(#* 5('#E -0#(&*# #'#&* *0#(// (&*& +'&8*0#( *(*

=0#*0#*0#( +#'0(/#" +4+&'#8 &#5/ &5#&*

&" * &-4( +*&#/# * (&4 8&>(-# #& #E 0#/ -*4 *0#(// (&** ## 5,+* #E '0#/ -*4 *0#( +#'B$#0

'* #/#(*5(

*0# #& #E #A0##*0#( +(* &0("#-##&5('# &4=*0*0# -,# *

&,+&8 0+5(*&8*0#(// (&*-4(#*&805 0#E 5/( * 8(&* 4-(/(* +(4& (# (8#5(8&*+'#(# *&8("#4(8#&+5-# /# /#E 8 0# +* 5+* #"(+(*# *0# #&*# ("((-# 5(*#( (8(&**0#( +#'"#4 (#+40# +*5+*( #(4

5/#0#&'*0##@( * # *0#( +#'&*0# (#0# (# &=0 0*0#( +#'5/ (*#'=*0*0#0#/ & (&' *0#)#&( '#2 9*0# +*0 +' &'#=*0

#"#&8#(*# (#(&' (+* &2-# (+# "#5/ (* &&*0# (#(5(**# &$& =#'8#(&' & #&E 0A0# &'#&8*0#/(4# 4-(2( -((& # 0( * -# *+ $ -#*=##& *= ( * 2 &(5#42 &

/#,+' #0 +'-# (+#'* ##2((&'+&"#*8(* &2 (&'*0##0 +'-#/#"#&* 0((5#&*20+5(* &(&'

+&,+*#''#*#&* *0#( +#'E 0# +* 0 +' &'# #( &(-# (//#0#& & *(5/#&8 *0# =*&# (//#0#& & *0#(* * *0#

5/(&(&*E , "

*4&/ # +* &0 +'(=(4-# &'##'(&'* &4 *0# ##5#&* 8#&+&#&# *0(* 0( 0("# * -#

&'##'&*0#5(**# 8(&* -((&'&*0##"#&* *0## -#&8 5# '

+-* ( * *0# 8#&+&#&# *0# / # +* &2&*0#& 5( +# #"#&*2*0#( +#'& #&**#'* (& '# -(

&"#= *0#( *(5#&* &#'(- "#(&'*0#(#8(* & #"##' & *0#

.2 *0# /#** &# '

# & * '##"# *0# & # 4-((# +(#8(* &(#*0##(8(&*05 '&842 *0## & 5#* & *0# &*#&* & (#' -4#(&#' +&# *0# /#** &#(&'*0#/#** &-#&8'#"

' (&45#*0##-4'5#' (4 2 + , /

,( A0#*0#/#($&8F#( &#'

G# A0#*0##/ *(-# G#