Gurnam Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

 



    

 



 !"
# $%& '&()*)+,!- !

./+$01)+23 4556)($+% 7&/*.* 1%$%& .+8$9$+'/* 4&*5+'&+%*

,

:;

1 

111

:;

1 

  /&*&+%, /$/<)+'&/1)+23='<($%& /%3&$556)($+%>)%3

./+$01)+23=(056$)+$+%?$556)($+%)+5&/*+ @@@ 111$/+= 3&$556)($%)+ /6&$<&%$55&$6$2$)+*%%3&$(A.)%%$6   /&*5+'&+%* =  $+' " / %3&  &+(& 5.+)*3$96& .+'&/ 1&(%)+* ?

"+')$+&+$6 '&
B : /*3/%9C%3&6&$/+&' '')%)+$61&**)+*.'2&=3$6)<)'&*3)*)05.2+&'8.'20&+%$+' /'&/ '$%&' !D!!" 3$* 9&&+ )6&' 9C ./+$0 1)+23
$556)($+%?$55&66$+%>3)*$6*5/&*&+%)+5&/*+)+ ./%%'$C ((/')+2 % ./+$0 1)+23
(056$)+$+%?$556)($+% 3& $+' /&*5+'&+%* =  $+' " $/& /&*)'&+%*   <)66$2& 3$+')$6$ 1.'$+=6)(&1%$%)+13$+$=)*%/)(%11$2$/
3$6) 3&/&3$* 9&&+ 6)%)2$%)+ )+%&/ *& $0+2*% %3& 5$/%)&* 3& (056$)+$+%?$556)($+%$+'3)* $0)6C0&09&/*$/& $()+2%/)$6)+($*& !"'$%&'!/&2)*%&/&'$%6)(&1%$%)+13$+$ /%3&  &+(&* .+'&/ 1&(%)+*  = !"D $+' !"    3& *+   %3& (056$)+$+%?$556)($+% +$0&6C &*3$0 1)+23
'&(&$*&' )+ %3& ($*& >$* % $55&$/ 9& /& %3& ./% $% 3$6) + !!   & >$* %



    *.//&+'&/)+%3&$ /&0&+%)+&'&*3$01)+23
'&(&$*&'>&+% %9.**%$+'%9$/'%3&9.*>3&/&$66%3&$((.*&'
/&*5+'&+%* %">&/&5/&*&+%$%%3&9.**%$+'$+'%3&C%3/&$%&+&'3)0%3$%) 3& >&+%%%3& ./%+%3&*$)''$C)&!! %3&+%3&C>.6'3$/0 3)0&*3$01)+23
'&(&$*&'2% /)23%&+&'$+'($0&9$(E%3)* 3.*&  >&<&/= $% %3& )+*%$+(&   3)* 0%3&/= 3& $2/&&' % 2 % 3$6) $+' 9$/'&' $ 9.* /0 %3& %3&/ 9.* *%$+'  3& $((.*&' +$0&6C 13$093.
/&*5+'&+% != &>$ $0
/&*5+'&+%  $+'1&&0$
/&*5+'&+% >&/&$6*)+%3&*$0&9.*+*&&)+2 &*3$0 1)+23
'&(&$*&'= %3&C
$((.*&'  /&*5+'&+%*  % " ($0& % 3)* *&$% $+' 13$093.
/&*5+'&+% !

 $+' &>$ $0
/&*5+'&+%  *$% 9&*)'&* 3)0  1&&0$
/&*5+'&+%   %E .%$9%%6& 5)*+ /03&/5./*&$+'3$+'&')%<&/%13$093.
/&*5+'&+%!&>$$0
/&*5+'&+%($.23%36' %3& 3$+'* &*3$01)+23
'&(&$*&'$+'13$093.
/&*5+'&+%! %3/.*%%3&5)*+)+%3&%3/$% &*3$01)+23
'&(&$*&'$+'(6*&' 3)*0.%3>)%33)*3$+'*66%3&>3)6&=&>$$0
/&*5+'&+% 3&6' &*3$0 1)+23
'&(&$*&' /0 3)* 3$+'*  &*3$0 1)+23 ')&' '.&%%3&$'0)+)*%/$%)+ 5)*+ 3&&+%)/&)+()'&+%>$*>)%+&**&' 9C $0 <%$/= $)9 1)+23 $+' ./(3$/$+ 1)+23 >3 >&/& $6* %/$<&66)+2)+%3&*$0&9.*$+'>3&+%3&C$*E&'%3&$((.*&'5&/*+* >3$% 3$' 3$55&+&'= %3&C *$)' %3$% &*3$0 1)+23 >$* 3$<)+2 *0& )%*  F3&+ &*3$0 1)+23 (66$5*&' )+ %3& 9.

*= %3& '/)<&/ $+' (+'.(%/ %3&9.*)00&')$%&6C9/.23%3)09$(E%<)66$2&9.%9C %3$%%)0&=3&3$'')&''.&%5)*+)+2 / 1$+'&&5 1)+23= &')($6  )(&/= )<)6 *5)%$6= 3$*& 7= 3$6)
F" *%$%&' %3$% %3& ($.*&   '&$%3 )+ %3)* ($*& >$*= G/2$+53*53/.*5)*+)+2H 3&6&$/+&'%/)$6 ./%$ %&/(+*)'&/)+2%3&&<)'&+(&$+' 0$%&/)$6+/&(/'3$*$(A.)



     '/)<&/$+'(+'.(%/ %3&9.*>3)6&+$//$%)+2%3&((.//&+(&')'+% *%$%&%3$%$+C %3&5$**&+2&/*%/$<&66)+2)+%3&9.*3$'$'0)+)*%&/&' $+C5)*+.* *.9*%$+(&%&*3$01)+23  3&C)+ $(% *%$%&'%3$% &*3$01)+23')&'+6C9&($.*& *0&<0)%$+'%3&+5$**)+2  ./)+& )+ 3)* %/.*&/* >3)6& *)%%)+2 )+ %3& 9.*  ((/')+2 % %3& %/)$6

./%=$66%3)**3>&'%3$%$6%3.23$*5&/5*%0/%&0/&5/%5)*+ >$* *%$%&' % 9& %3& ($.*&   '&$%3   &*3$0 1)+23 9.% %3& 5/*&(.%)+ 3$' 0)*&/$96C $)6&' % 5/<& %3$% %3& $((.*&' 5&/*+* 3$' $+C /6& )+ $'0)+)*%&/)+2 $+C 5)*+.* *.9*%$+(& % %3& '&(&$*&'&*3$01)+23 3.*%3&$((.*&'
/&*5+'&+%* =$+' ">&/&$(A.)%%&' %3&(3$/2&* /$0&'$2$)+*%%3&0 ;&$/+&' .+*&6 /%3&$556)($+%>3)*$55&$/)+2$6+2 >)%3 $556)($+% )+ 5&/*+ 3$* *.90)%%&' + )+*%/.(%)+* %3$% %3& $556)($+%)*+>+%)+%&/&*%&')+5./*.)+2%3&$556)($%)+ /6&$<&% $55&$6$+'3&0$C9&$66>&'%>)%3'/$>%3&*$0& F& 3$<& $*E&' ./+$0 1)+23
(056$)+$+%?$556)($+% >3 )* 5/&*&+% )+ ./% $* % >3&%3&/ 3& >$+%* % >)%3'/$> %3& $556)($%)+ / 6&$<& % $55&$6  & 3$* *%$%&' %3$% 3& >)*3&* % >)%3'/$>%3&*$0& +%3& $(%*$+'()/(.0*%$+(&*=%3&$556)($%)+ /6&$<&% $55&$6)*5&/0)%%&'%9&>)%3'/$>+ )*0)**&'$*>)%3'/$>+
111$/+ .'2&
./0)%$0 .'2& !- !

$0)%