High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1784/2003disposed of

Chhittar Ram And ORS. v. State Of Haryana

2015-09-01Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain26 pages

!"!#$%$&' (

) *$ + ,&" *!+% --!..& % /!+%0% !+1& !%-&"!&

(

!"!#$%$&'

(

)

,*+& ! $ $&!+ /!+%0% **$ + ,&" *!+% !%-&"!& % 2' 342

!"##$%& # ' ""#("##$%

) *+,

' ""#("##$% -*. / )

0 0

!"##$%& ' ""#("##$% 55555 6*! *!+ !-+ !+%.#.--!+%,17!..8!" %!! *!90":!,!& ;!%

7!+!!++!" *! !-+ !+%+& ;!%

6*! *!+ *!90":!,!& %*0."7!+!-+ !"$& *! $:!% ;!% <

-.20

! "##$' ""#("##$3

. 0-.20"( # "##$

!"##$ 3 3,

0 2 -.20 "( # "##$

5 6%0

% % 3 2.

, . 3 .

$" $"6$# 4 $ 7 7%

% 0 ). "% , 0 $%80 %) 0

#% 3 2.

, . 3. $"$4 $ 7 9 . 0 :% %!3

(% 3 2.

, . 3 .

$"$$":4 $ 7 3. ,!

&"!+!# $& !& !&#!

5 $" 4

$ 7 2. 0 04,, :##; 7.,0 . .2 2. 0 0 0

$"6 4

$ 7 2. 0 0 ,, :##; 7.,0 . .2 2. 0 0 < 0 $# 4

$ 7 2. 0 0,, :##; 7.,0 . .2 2. 0 0 < 0

&"!+!# $& !& !&#!

0 $" 4

$ 7 2. 0 04,, :##; 7.,0 . .2 2. 0 0 0

$"6 4

$ 7 2. 0 0 ,, :##; 7.,0 . .2 2. 0 0 < 0 $# 4

$ 7 2. 0 0,, :##; 7.,0 . .2 2. 0 0 < 0

,!%

&"!+!# $& !& !&#!

5 $" 4

$ 7 2. 0 04,, :##; 7.,0 . .2 2. 0 0 0

$"6 4

$ 7 2. 0 0 ,, :##; 7.,0 . .2 2. 0 0 < 0 $# 4

$ 7 2. 0 0,, :##; 7.,0 . .2 2. 0 0 < 0

,!%

&"!+!# $& !& !&#!

$"$ 4

$ 7 2. 0 0, $": 4

$ 7 2. 0 0 4 , , :##; 7 . ,0 . .2 2. 0 0 0 9 .0 $"$ 4

$ 7 2. 0 0, $": 4

$ 7 2. 0 0 4 , , :##; 7 . ,0 . .2 2. 0 0 0 ! ..,

,!% !& !&#!

0 0 ). ,080 ) 0

433 233 3 .0

:###;4 ., 0. $

' ""#( "##$ 3

3,0 -.0 4 , 2 ;0 , 2 2 .

0 0 ). , 0 80 ) 03

#% 4 2 0 .2 0 0 4 0 0 .9 .

0 50 !3

00 .

3 2 2

. #

(((0 0 =6%4 2 .0 /

=% . 0 /

0 22 2 4 .0 2 43 2 0, !. . . +2 0 .0 . 230 +43 3, 2 8 <, #"

(((3. ## . 0 5 04 >>0 .0 0 0

. /

4 2

0 ,

0 ..0 ,. 0 52

34 0 5 2 34 /

, 0 8 2 0

* /03

05 5'0 0 . 0 7 04

. ,0

0) 0 0).0

0 2 2 3 2 0 1 32 2 0 , 0 0 . 0 1 . !3 80 9 .). 04

0 ,2 23 2 0

0 /

) /03 5. ,. . -.4 0

7 .

7 2 8 00 3 2 4

4 0 0 8 3

0 ?< @ A7 ?< ;

4 2 8 2.2>4 -. ) B, 4 0 . 3. $":$"64

$ 74 5 "

0 42.

$# 4 $ 74

80 0 2 .

$ . ( $ % 4 .

. 50 4 2 . 3 . $" $"6$# 4 $ 7

0 0 ). , 0 ) 0 4 2 . 3. $"$4 $ 7

80 9 .0!3

4 2 . 3 . $"$4 $ 7 .!3

9 . 0 4 2 . 3. $":4 $ 7 4

.2.

, 0

7 .3 . <0 0,.4

= <0 . $ $ . . 5 4 2 ., 5 04

/03 0 !3. 0 0

0- 5

,05 '

04 >2 >

>0 . 0 , 4 ,. 4 4, 0 1 4 3 34 3 , 1 , . 2 2 24.2 0

7 <0 =$) '

8 5 '

+ /.. . 3.2 0 2 5*. ,0 5 94

?< ) ?< )A , , 3.2 B, 5?< )*<,

?< )+ <0 = $)

/ 8 5'9+ /..

(

8 2 3, . . 4 0 . -.20

7 0 . 2 , 9 . 0 :% "(

# "#

. . -*. / )

0 . 0 )., *+, 0 .., <0

7 2 2.0

. . 0 0 2?< ) ?< )A 3 .03 4 . 003 ., + 5 . 7-.

:44 4

*. . , 0 . 5 .4 94 .4

.4 .4

-.,

4. 2 . . 003 . , .4, 4

3 < 0 . =6 0 =/

-., 4.3, 0 .,4

4 2 . 3 .3, .

+ . . 2 2 7 2 0 2 0 -.

' 4 3 <0 3, . 4 <0 3, . 4,

+. 3

4 0 7 0 , 4 ... 0

0 4 0 ,. 4 , 2 2 2 2 3. 0 0 /

4 0 .. 003 0 ,

+. . 3 . $# 7 0 . 1 .

. -.$&:*/% !

0&97

= > =+$,$&.> < &" $&:* /% ! 0&97

=> =+$,$&.> < $%*+ $&:*/% ! 0&97(( => =+$,$&.> &" 2* $&:* &" & *!+ /% ! +1&

= > =+$,$&.>

0 ? . , 4 .4 0 /

. , 0 -., =$) '

, . 3, 0 42. + ,2 2 2. 4 0 .2 ,.2, '00 3 . 4 0 3 <0 4 , -., + .3,0 4 2 . ?< 8 5 ?< ;

2.3

+ . 0 , 4 22 0

. .,. 0 3 . <

+. 4

, <

8 . 3 0 .04 ,4 2 .0 -./

. ,..03 0 /

) /0 5

,4 22

3 ., < 3, . =( /0 = # 2 , ,. . + .3 22 0 1 .

.+.?$ * &" *!+%/% ! =

)> 0-+!,!0+ %!%

&" 7$" /% !

(=>

=+$,$&.> () + . . 5 0 . 0 /

7-. ' ".3,0 32. $# 7 , +. .

<0 -.4 0 3 0 0 7 4 ,<0 ,4 0 +. 4 3, . -.

(

5 .

. 3, .

,. 4 C. 5 . 4,0 0 4

. . -.,4

4 2.

7 .,

= + 3 D

7 2 28 2 , <0 2 3

8 E

0 4 E 0 2 2 0 , 5.

0 , 3C.

3, .

3 .33,. 0 .

,. 42 2 0 , . 003 ., . 3 . 4 < =( /0 2 , , .

. = #

,. .

., 4<

7 ,.3 3, . . < ?< F;

.3,= +D

7 2 28 ?< 1 .3,=:

3 ./.0 3 2 <0 3, ., '.22 3. 4 4 33 . 0 , ! . .-. .0 = /

1 . 4

04 40 . -./

. 0

7 2 28 3 0 . 2. 3 . 4 . .2 .

((( 0 2

3 3, 7 2 28 0#(

((( , 7 3 , 3 4 3 3 7 2 28 4

.2 1 . , 3 003 0 , 0 ., 5. 003., 7 .0 0. .04 40 .0 -./

3, . 003 0 , 0 ., 5 . 0 3

? .3, 4 422 ?< 0 2 0 0 + . <

7-. "

4 4 ! 3 2 . ?< 8

1 ?< .?<).+00 510 2 4 .0 .4 . 03 0 2 32 3,= $)

/ 4 2 ,<0 0

5'9 + /.. = /

.. . 2 -., .2 0

. = ) .

-.,

42 . = (/0 .. = # . 4 5 . .

A0 . .

8. :44 4 0 2 4 3. 4 + . ,2 . -., *. . 0 5 ?< )!

. ,0 . 0 4

3.4 5?< ) . 5 .4 0 4 3.4 5?< )) 94 .4 0 3. 4 5 ?< )? .

.4 4 3. 4 5 ?< )A . < 0 2 2 2 4 . 2 . -., 3.3,, -.32 2 .,<

0 ?

0 . 2 .

-.,

3, = 0 . -.0 0 .4

2 . /

-., ) .2 . -.,

? . -., 4 003 0 ,4 ,

. .3 22 , 0 37$"/% !

=0-+> 4 +>3 < . 2 , 4 .4 22

. <0 -.4 0,=60 = ) =/

=(/0 =

# 1 , , 3. 0 . . 0

5. 33 . , 0 0

. .,30 0 0 -.4 2 ,. 7 4 42.

3 2 4 7 . , 3 22,0 4 83 .,. ,

4 4 . +>3

.0. :+9$ *$+/% !$*+

)= > =+$,$&.> @ &" 9 +$& $&:* /% ! &" *!+%

(=> =+$,$&.> 4 , , 4 4 0.3<0 <0 4 03 2., 2 3 0 -.

'4 C. 4 $# 7 $# 7 . G= , 4 . 42.. .0

3, . 4.32.

, 0. 3. 4 0 0 04

0,< , 3 3 H

. .,3,. 3 3 0 0 . . 0 3 0 I 4 2 = ,4 . 42 .. .0 3, .

4. 3 2.

, 0. 3 . 1 $# 7 C.

42 .

2 . .

4 0 42 C. . . <. 2 7 423 0>0 3,33, 3 3, .. 2 .0 7 -. , . $# 7

-.,3. 2 . 3.

.2 . -.,.,.0,3 2 0 2. . "

7 $# 0.2-.20 . 0 -.,

0 $# 73.

-.,4. 4 . 0 . 50 . $#

4 $ 7 . -.,

.3,0 !.

. . . 3

. 3, 0 0

4 2. + 30 2,<0 3, =$) '

8 5'9+ /.. 7-. " 0 . 4 4.60<"0 3 2 3 C., 2 0 0 3

-.,4 <,

7 4.$0< 0<3 2 $00 -.,

"03

<,4

) '

2 .4 4 3 B,

?< 8 #

((( 1 7 2 2 8 2 0 #

((( ?< , 0 2 0,32 4

. 3, 0 . .

=$ ) '

2 ?< ;

, -., 2.

. 2 ,

".3,0 2.

.. 2 0,0 7 44 3 2

7 <0 0 0034 3 0 4 2 ?< ;

+ . <0 0 #"

(((2 003 1 . 3 0 4 .2,.2 .

.3,

2;.2

3<0 3 ,

.3,0 =$) '

0,0 2,<0

) 4 /.0 *. = $ ) / 0, 2 ,<0

2 3, =$) '

3., 2. 2 ,4

".3,0 0 3. 0 . 0 ., -.,4

42. . 0,0 42

. 0 ? 0 . .4 ,0 2 2 2 4 .434. =/

. . 0 ,. 0 7-.

3 3. . 5 0 4 4 ,4 . 2 2 2 -., 3. 5

4 0 . 7 ! 0&97 /% & $&:* ((@ = >

=+$,$&.> ) -.,4. 4 24 ) !

. 4.2 3 2 . $# 7

7 3 4 4 4 .

4 4 . -., <02.3,, 2 78$&:*&" *!+%/% !

0&97

= > =+$,$&.>

.2 4 -.,. 42. 3. 0 43.2 4 0,3. 0,0

4. ,...

42.

. . -.,4. 4

0 . ?

, $"#74 3. 3.

$"67 . $# 7 4 1 4 4

. , ., 3

. 3,0 42. =$) '

,2 2.2

2;.23. , .3,

0 4. 3 0,0 . +4 4 1?<

B,3,= $) /

".3,0 0

4 . 2 . . ?< 8

4 $"6 7 C., 5 0 . $# 4 $ 7 . 3 ,4 +4 4 , $" $"6 4

$ 7. 2 /

2 . 0 0

. 50

5 3 .2 2.

0 0 , . 3. $"64 $ 7 24 :##; .. .2 2. 0 0 <0

. 003 . ,

. 2 5 . 0 3

. 5 0 , ,4 . ! 0 2

. #"

((( 6, 3 . , 0, 50 3 -. C.

0 . C..0 . 3. $"64 $ 7

70, 2. 0 0 .,4 . -. 2.

0 0 ,43, . 4 ,

0 -. 0 . 2 . 7

.2 0 !. 3 0 4 2.

0. 3 <3,

0 4 4 , 0 0 40. < . . !.

4 . -., .< 0 , 4 3 0 .

% 4

3 . .

30 3 -.0 0 3 0 %8,1 /% !A+& ?

(=> =+$,$&.>) =>

. 2 40, .

!"##$ 3,, 4 50 . 3 . $# 4 $ 7 3, +4 . $" $"6 4 $ 7 3, . 0 4 5 0 . 3.

$"6 4 $ 7 3,

. 2. 0 0., 2. 0 0 ,4 3, . +4 0. 0

:##; . 3. $"64 $ 7

. ,0 , 4 .2 2.

0 0 <0

8. J

###; :

###; 3 0 -.0 0 . $:

% 0. 3 4 . +4 0 2 3, . 0

C., 3,

-.0 0 ,4 0 3 . 50 !3

3 3 , .4

:,0

-.203

9. 2 /.. 4 0 - .2 0 2 7 , .

9. 2 /.. .

0- .2 0 !- !,7!+ <

) = > %?*&