← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/683/2015dismissed

Sewa Ram v. Neelam Rani And ORS

2019-09-12Mr. Justice Manoj Bajaj5 pages

  

      

       

          

    

       





 



    



  

  !

 !"#$%%&"'$(")*!$#+,,*-"&,.+/(!,$%%&"'$*(')0%&$"*$*( 1*.,2,'(")*345678)- 

%2$/"*9-)2&,$:,()$%%,$&$9$"*#((!, ;1.9,0,*(  .$(,.  4  <  %$##,.  +/  (!,  1."'"$&  $9"#(2$(,  #(  &$## =$2*$&:".,>!"'!(!,')0%&$"*(-"&,.+/!"01*.,2,'(")*#33373< 347<<? >$#."#0"##,.$*.(!,2,#%)*.,*(#>,2,$'@1"((,.

2",-&/(!,-$'(#)-'$#,$2,(!$((!,')0%&$"*$*($&&,9,."*!"# ')0%&$"*((!$(!,>$#&":"*9$(!"#2,#".,*',-)2(!,%$#(7/,$2#$&)*9>"(! !"#0)(!,2$*.)(!,2-$0"&/0,0+,2# ''1#,.$*$2#"!$.$*,:"&,/,)* (!,#$".!)1#,$*.>$*(,.()."#%)##,##(!,0>"(!$*"*(,*(")*()92$+(!, #$0,$*.>"(!(!,#$"."*(,*(")*!,!$('!,.$'2"0"*$&')*#%"2$'/>"(! $''1#,.  ,,&$0 $*"     >!)  +)$#(,.  (!$(  #!,  >"&&  '2,$(,  #1'!  $* $(0)#%!,2,(!$((!,')0%&$"*$*(>"&&!$:,()&,$:,(!,2,#".,*', (>$# -12(!,2  $&&,9,.  (!$(  )*  5 <  $( $+)1(     $   $''1#,.  $*$2#"

$;"*.,2 0$2A$#! ,,($ $0,,&$0 $*"$*.$*( $02,$'!,.(!,

 !)1#,)-(!,')0%&$"*$*( >"(! .,$.&/>,$%)*# )* 0)()2'/'&,#  !,/ -)2'"+&/  ,*(,2,.  "*()  !"#  !)1#,  $*.  $#A,.  !"0  ()  :$'$(,  (!,  #$0, "00,."$(,&/ !,*(!,')0%&$"*$*($*.!"#-$0"&/0,0+,2#)%%)#,.(!, #$0,(!,$''1#,.#($2(,.0"#+,!$:"*9$*.(!2,$(,*"*9(!,0   !,*(!, ')0%&$"*$*($*.!"#+2)(!,2!2,, $0(2",.()2,#"#($''1#,. $;"*.,2 9$:,$A*"-,+&)>)*!"#&,-(&,9 !,*+2)(!,2)-(!,$''1#,.(2",.()#$:, (!,')0%&$"*$*($''1#,. ,,($ $0$(($'A,.!"0>"(!$A*"-,$*.$''1#.

,,&$0 $*"9$:,$.$*.$+&)>)*!"#+$'A ''1#,. 0$2A$#!!"((!, ')0%&$"*$*(>"(!$.$*.$ !,2,$-(,2,,&$0 $0!"( $;>$*("0)(!,2)- (!,')0%&$"*$*(>"(!$.$*.$ (!$#+,,*-12(!,2$&&,9,.(!$(!2,, $0 +2)(!,2)-(!,')0%&$"*$*(-,&&.)>*$*.+,'$0,1*')*#'")1# !,$''1#,.

')*#".,2"*9!2,, $0()!$:,.",.-&,.$>$/-2)0(!,#%)(>!"&,"##1"*9 (!2,$(#(!$((!,!)1#,+,:$'$(,.)2,&#,(!,')0%&$"*$*($*.!"#-$0"&/ >)1&.+,%1(().,$(!

!,#$"."*'".,*(>$#2,%)2(,.()(!,%)&"',$*.(!, ')0%&$"*$*($*.!"#-$0"&/0,0+,2#>,2,0,."'$&&/,B$0"*,.  (>$# -12(!,2$&&,9,.(!$((!,2,$-(,2)* <$($+)1(?

% $''1#,. ,,($

$0"A,*.,2$*( $0,,&$0 $*"$*.=$&" $0'$0,()!"#!)1#, $*.'$1#,."*;12",#()(!,')0%&$"*$*($*.!"#-$0"&/0,0+,2#$*.$&#) .,#(2)/,.(!,!)1#,!)&.$2("'&,#$*.())A$>$/;,>,&&,2/'&)(!,#'$#!,('

#*)$'(")*>$#($A,*+/(!,%)&"',(!,2,-)2,(!"#')0%&$"*(>$#-"&,.

!,$''1#,.>,2,#100)*,.()-$',(2"$&-)2(!,)--,*',#1*.,2 ,'(")*33373<34$*.<?

12"*9(!,(2"$&$''1#,.$*$2#"

$##$*."A$*.,2,B%"2,.$*.(!,%2)',,."*9#@1$(!,0>,2,.2)%%,.

!,(2"$& )12()+#,2:,.(!$((!,%2)#,'1(")*!$#-$"&,.()%2):,

3 "(#'$#,+,/)*.2,$#)*$+&,.)1+($*.(!,2,-)2,$'@1"((,.$&&(!,$''1#,.+/ 9":"*9(!,0(!,+,*,-"()-.)1+(

("#$9$"*#((!"#;1.9,0,*((!,')0%&$"*$*(!$#')0,-)2>$2. >"(!(!,%2,#,*($%%&"'$(")*"0%19*"*9(!,#$0,

,$2*,.')1*#,&-)2(!,$%%&"'$*(')*(,*.#(!$((!,(2"$& )12( !$#>2)*9&/$'@1"((,.(!,$''1#,.)*(!,92)1*.(!$((!,')0%&$"*(>$# &).9,.$-(,2$.,&$/)-7.$/# '')2."*9()!"0(!, )12(!$#>2)*9&/ %2)',,.,.()!)&.(!$((!,)''122,*',())A%&$',)*5C <$*.(!, ')0%&$"*(>$#-"&,.)* < < ,#1+0"(#(!$(')0%&$"*(#>,2,9":,*() )&"',>!"'!>,2,*)($((,*.,.()$*.(!,2,-)2,(!,%2,#,*(')0%&$"*(>$# -"&,.)* < <

*(!,)(!,2!$*.&,$2*,.')1*#,&-)2(!,2,#%)*.,*(#!$# $291,.(!$((!,;1.9,0,*()-$'@1"(($&%$##,.+/(!, )12(+,&)>"#>,&& 2,$#)*,.$*."(!$#($A,*"*()$'')1*($&&(!,2,&,:$*(0$(,2"$&$*.,:".,*', )*2,')2.

,#1+0"(#(!$()*,)-(!,$''1#,.$&)*9>"(! ,,($ $0>$#*)( ,:,*%2,#,*()*(!,#%)(+,"*9$ ):,2*0,*(,0%&)/,,$*.(!"#-$'("# %2):,.(!2)19!(!,)--"'"$&2,')2.%2).1',.$#B  C

-(,2!,$2"*9(!,&,$2*,.')1*#,&-)2(!,%$2(",#(!"# )12( -"*.#(!$((!,&,$2*,.(2"$& )12(!$#'$2,-1&&/,B$0"*,.(!,,*("2,,:".,*', )*2,')2.>!"&,$'@1"(("*9(!,$''1#,.%,2#)*# !,(2"$& )12(!$#*)("',.

(!,."#'2,%$*'",#"*(!,%2)#,'1(")*>"(*,##,#%$2("'1&$2&/$2,-,2,*',>$# 0$.,()(!,0,."'$&,:".,*', !,2,&,:$*(%)2(")*)->!"'!"#$#-)&&)># D   

    

           







       



7

  

 

    





   

  



 

 

  







      

 

  

   

         

               

 

     

!   "

    #$





    

% 

     

    

  &

'! "

"

  $

  

    $





# #    

 

 

   

 

    

  

 

         $        

 

             $





# #       

   

   

    

(           )    

 

   



 



  

 

    

       

   

 

 

,#".,#"("##%,'"$&&/)+#,2:,.+/(!,(2"$& )12((!$($''1#,.

) ? ,,($ $0+,"*9$ ):,2*0,*(,0%&)/,,>$#)*.1(/"*!"#)--"',$(

<

!$*."9$2!$*.(!"#-$'(>$#%2):,.+/(!,)--"'"$&#)-(!,)--"',)- ,9$&

,0,0+2$*',2  $2/$*$  +/  %2).1'"*9  (!,  ((,*.$*',  ,9"#(,2 6B  C8 ("#$%%$2,*((!$($&&(!,0$(,2"$&$#%,'(#)-(!,%2)#,'1(")* $2,#122)1*.,.+/#,2")1#.)1+(#$*.(!,2,-)2,(!"# )12(-"*.#(!$((!, :",>$.)%(,.+/(!,(2"$& )12("#$%)##"+&,:",> ,#1&($*(&/(!"# )12( .),#*)(-"*.$*/2,$#)*()"*(,2-,2,>"(!(!,>,&&2,$#)*,.;1.9,0,*( %$##,.+/(!,(2"$& )12(

,$:,()$%%,$&"#.,'&"*,.

 ,%(,0+,2    1&$("

"#

!,(!,2 ,%)2($+&,  ,#C)

!,(!,2%,$A"*9C ,$#)*,.

 ,#C)