← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/768/2017dismissed

Kulbir Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2018-04-30Mr. Justice T.P.S. Mann,Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal5 pages

   

           

 !" #$ % &'( )

*+&, -.

/$/ ,+,.01 $&2+%+&30,(.

/  ) 0&3.&,/   45 6 6 66  75 6  #5

./.&,   65663($"380*+,.10 ,(.+

*+&,6  #5"6 ( 0$'(,(.&/,+&,+

*+,0&1 .3$&3.

.*,0& !9!:01,(.03.01 ;&+ 

0*.3$ ."<!910 /(0 , 66:",(.+

*+&,/..=/,(.'

+&,01 .+8.+'+&/,,(. 2$3';.&, 3+,.3 <66 +//.3 %> ,(. 33,0&+  .//0&/$3'.";

,/+ "910 /(0 ,,(., + 0$ ,:",( 0$'( ?(*( 0&3.&,/06,0?.

.+*@$,,.301,(.*(+ './ +;.3+'+&/,,(.;$&3.

.*,0&/!A!A!!AB .+3 ?,(.*,0&B<01,(.&3+& .&+ 03."910 /(0 ,

 ,(. 03.: +&3 .*,0&  01 ,(.  ;/ *, 910  /(0 ,,(. *,:6  .1 >/,+,.3",(.*+/.01,(.

0/.*$,0&/,(+, 0& 66B" *0;

+&+&, + %  &'( ?+/ '0&' 0& (/ ;0,0 *>* ." ?(.& $  &'( + +/ 0& /0& 01 $

+ &'(?( .3 8&'+ ,$&.

+&3*0;&'1 0;,(.

0/,./3.38.

,.3(/8.(* .,0?+ 3/,(.*0;

+&+&,& +& &,;3+,&' ;+&&.

6  0?.8.

" ,(. *0;

+&+&, ;+&+'.3,0/+8.(;/. 1%>/(+

>,$ &&'(/;0,0 *>* . ,00&./3.01,(. 0+36(.

.+1,.

",(.*0;

+&+&,+ 0&' ?,(0,(.

/?.&,,0,(.(0$/.01$

+ &'(,0*0;

+& +%0$, ,(. +%08. &*3.&,6  8.

 ,(.

." $

+  &'( +&3 $ &'(%.*+;.+''

.//8.+&3($ .3+%$/./ 0& ,(. *0;

+&+&, +&3 0,(.

/ ?(0 (+3 *0;. + 0&' ?,( (;6  (. *0;

+&+&, +&3 0,(.

/ ,(.& *+;. %+*=6 (.

.+1,.

" $

+  &'(" $  &'(" +&% &'(" +820, &'(" #

+  &'(" +/%  &'(" + ?&3.

#+$ " +&3..

 &'( + +/+&2+" (+'+&3..

 &'( + 0&' ?,( ,( ..10$  $&3.&,1.3 /0&/ + ;.3 ?,( 3.+3 > ?.+ 0&/ *+;. ,0 ,(. (0$/. 01 ,(. *0;

+&+&, ?(.

. $

+  &'(" 1 .3 /.8.

+  /(0,/ ?(*( (, ?+& &'("

+'(%  &'(" 3..

 &'("  + /.; &'(" + *(+&3 &'(" #+/(;

 &'( +&3 $=(,+  &'(6  $ &'(,(.&,00=,(. 1 .1 0;(/1+,(.

+&31 .3+,$2

..,

&'( ?(*( (, (; 0& (/ *(./,6 +&%  &'( ?(0 ?+/ ;.3?,( .80 8.

+ /01 .3&,(.+ 6(.

.+1,.

"+ ,(. +**$/.3 +& +?+> + 0&' ?,( ,(.

.*,8. ?.+/ 0&/6 $2

.., &'( /$**$;%.3 ,0 (/ &2$ > 0& ,(. ?+> ,0 ,(. (0/ ,+ +&3?+/3.* + .33.+3%>,(.30*,0 6(.&2$ .3 ?.

.+3;,,.3&,(.(0/ ,+ 10 , .+,;.&,6 & *0;

.,0& 01 &8./,'+,0&" , $&3.

.*,0&! 66?+/1 .3+'+&/,,(.+**$/.3%.10 .,(. 33,0&+ (.1$3*+ +'/, +,.";

,/+ ?(0*0;;,,.3 ,(. *+/. ,0 ,(. 0$ , 01 .//0&/ $3'." ;

,/+ " ?(*( .&, $/,.3 ,(. /+;. ,0 ,(. , ,6  (. , , *(+ '.3 ,(. +**$/.3 10  ,(. 011.&*./ $&/(+% . $&3.

.*,0&/ !A!A!!AB .+3 ?,( .*,0& B< 01 ,(. 03.+&3.*,0&01,(.*,6C(.&,(.+**$/.3 .+3.3 &0,'$ ,>",(.>?.

$,0&, + 6 (. , ," +1,.

 /1,&' ,(. .83.&*. ?(*( (+3 *0;. 0& 3"   *0&8*,.3 $

+  &'( $&3.

.*,0&/!A!B+&3!01,(.03.+&3.*,0&01,(. *,6 &*. $  &'( (+3 %..& 3.* + .3 +

0* +;.3 011.&3.

" ,(. , , 3 .*,.3 ,(+, +/ +&3 ?(.& (./ +

./,.3" (. %.

03$*.3 %.10 . ,(.0$ , +&3 0& ,(. (+

.&&' 01 /$*( +& .8.&," ,(. *+/. ?0$ 3 %.

.88.36

 0 1+  +/ 0&3.&,/ 0/6 ,0  + . *0&*.

&.3" ,(.>?.

.+*@$,,.3+&3,//$*(+*@$,,+ 01 0&3.&,/ 0/6 ,0  ?(*( / ,(. /$%2.*, ;+,,.

 01 *(+ .&'. & ,(.

./.&,

0*..3&'/6 5.+ &.3*0$&/. 10 ,(.+

*+&,"?( . .,.

+,&' ,(. /$%;//0&/ ;+3. 0& %.(+ 1 01 ,(.

0/.*$,0& %.10 ,(. , ," /$%;,,.3 ,(+, 0&3.&,/ 0/6  ,0  (+8. ?

0&' > %..& +*@$,,.3 +/ ,(.

. ?+/ 08.

?(. ;&' .83.&*.0& 3* .+ >

08&',(.;,0(+8.*0;;,,.3 ,(.011.&*./10 ?(*(,(.>?.

.*(+ '.36 (./$%;//0&/;+3.%> .+ &.3*0$&/. 10 ,(.

*+&,(+8.%..&*0&/3.

.3%$,,(./+;.30&0,?+

+&, +**.

,+&*.6 , ?+/ ,(. *+/. 01 ,(.

0/.*$,0& ,(+, +**$/.3 +&% &'( (+3 1 .3& ,(. + 6 (. , ,+*@$,,.3 (;+1,.

30$%,&',(.

0/.*$,0&4//,0 >+&3(0 3&',(+, $/$+ >1 .&,(.+ /;+3.&0 3.

,0* .+,.,.

+&3 1.+ " %$, & ,(. *+/. & (+&3" %.10 0&3.&, +&% &'( / /+3 ,0 (+3 1 .3 & ,(. + " $

+  &'( (+3 .+3> 1 .3 1 0; (/ 1 . +&3 *+$/.3 &2$ ./6 (. , +  0$ ,?+/ 1$ ,(.

 01 ,(. 0 &0&,(+, &*+/.+&%  &'( (+3 *0;. ?,( + *0;;0& &,.&,0& ?,( $

+  &'( +&3 $ &'("(.?0$ 3(+3$/.3(/ .80 8.

,01 +,,(.*0;

+&+&, ,>+&3&0,&,(.+ 6($/"'8&'(;

 ,(.%.&.1,0130$%," 0&3.&,+&% &'(?+/0 3.

.3 ,0 %. +*@$,,.36 0 + '$;.&, ?+/ +/.3 %.10 . $/ %> .+ &.3 *0$&/.  10  ,(. +

*+&, ?(*( ?0$ 3 /$+3. $/ ,0,+=.+311.

.&,8.?6 0 1+  +/ ,(. 0,(.

0&3.&,/ + . *0&*.

&.3" ,(. , , (+/ / .*1*+ > 3.3 + 1&3&' ,(+, &0 .83.&*./10$&30&,(. 3?(*(?0$ 3*0&&.*,,(.; ?,( ,(. * ;. +&3 ,(+, ,(.> (+3 %..& .3 & %> ,(. *0;

+&+&,A

0/.*$,0& 0& > %.*+$/. ,(.> ?.

. +,.3 ,0 +**$/.3 $

+  &'( +&3 $  &'(6 0 .83.&*.&,(/ .'+ 3?+/+ /0% 0$'(,,00$ +,,.&,0&6 &8.?01,(.+%08."&01+$ ,*+&%.10$&3&,(. ;

$'&.32$3';.&,+*@$,,&' 0&3.&,/0/6,06 **0 3&' >" ,(.

./.&, +

*+,0& / 10$&3 3.80301+&>;.

,+&3",(.

.10 ."3/;//.36

./$ ,+&, >" .+8.,0+

.+ /3.* &.36 96 66:  9 #5:      

 !" #3 C(.,(.

/ .+=&'A .+/0&.3

./A0 C(.,(.

,+% . 

./A0