High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5188/2021disposed of

Neeraj Sharma v. State Of Haryana And Another

2022-03-02Mr. Justice Arun Monga21 pages

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (1)

!"#"$%&%'()

( *+

! " # !

" $ ! %# & '(#%# ! )* +

, - &./&0))1)&2

*&04"( ! !# +

# !253!

!4"!

!# -

- #

&.16)1&7 *&14 !

( ! ( # !

# !

(+#+ -2 +4 !! ## %#+ - ) !!

)81&)1&6 *&4 ! # 9 9

:- ( !#!

# !

(+# !

# !

(+#(

"% /% ;

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (2) <!# (## !

3!# #

)0=

( +# :-

)11))1&8 2 *)4 "# ! ! +

.. + 253!

!4 ## !> 61 (+253!

-(> ## ! 61+253!

!4 ("

! %#*&?+*? +*6 + *&5*& !## ! *)

# # %# + - > ( !

# !

( +# 2 +4 :" !

( ! !

# !

( +# ! - ((

( ",

6&16)1&?2 *84 6

( !!

161@)1&8 ##( "

(

&818)1&? )118)1&?

( ! 8 ( " !#

# !

(+#

( # + +A )88&?10? &6&.1)1&87&6))1&.( $

! B

##( - +A 7&6) )1&. )010)1&. *64*

!"#$%&'( !"#$ %&!') *

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (3)

* +

* ,* ,&- * . /- - / , 0 1

2 3

/2 - 3 4

. -

5 ) 6* 7"!' - 78 * 3 ,

9 : + 3

* 0 3 4

, 0 1

2 *

- /* 3

* 3

3 - * 3 -/ 1

# 3 ; . C ( $

! (

% !

)&1@)1&. 3*)/&4:# !

*! * ! # 3 3 - + 3

3 3 3 /< /

= * 3 /%->/-- ?

* $ 3 $*

$ 3

4 ?

6 3

- + 3

3 $

3 6 - + 3

* - + 3

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (4) 3

6 - + 3

3 $*

6 3> - + 3

* -+ * 3 3 > 3 $

> - + 3

?* ->->:+ ; ?

" !

+ )01&)1&?"# ! ()@1&)1&?2 3*)/)4 ! - - + ! - ! >

* ' -+ 3

# 3 3 3 ' -+ 3 $

1 ' -+ -+

3 3

; 0 : # 3

( !# 1.10)1&? *?4C # ) !!

#, ! ( ! * -+ / 3 ( ! -+ 3 3 @ /</

A@ & % @> %B! 7":CA' 3 -+

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (5)

1 4 1

3 $ ( 7 1 /D @

* ! ## (!#1)17)1&?2 * 04 !

( " + 2 )4 1.17)1&?2 3*)/64

## +253!

!4 + 7

(#! &0

# # %#+ -:(#&? %#+ - &0 + 253!

!4 ( !

# !

( +# - :

( #!

/- + 253!

!4C (#!

## ! $ !

E # + ##

161))1&0 2 *@4 + ! % (## ! "# ! !+ # ! + +253!

!4 # &0" ##"%#+ -! "- "

#+A )0?61)1&0;! & !!

)?1))1&72 * 74( " )(

F+A )0?61)1&0G D ( &0

"! $E+ &0 +253!

!4 + - "! -#! -

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (6) "! - !, # $E+ ( #### ! && : + ! % ( #

1.16)1&7 2 *&14 ! + +

# ! ! "#2+A ).7@6)1&@*' 4 + # - )11))1&7 F 3 -+ * 3

3 1 D' ( % !

( (! " # +"(

*# + ##" " ; /%#+ - &)

+A ?1).)1&7 1?16)1&72 *&&4 :%:2 !#5!

4 (

6/)1&. # # ( !# 181&)1&7 1?16)1&72 *&&4 + !

! +! - %#+ - +

! 1.&))1&7! +! -

%#+ -! %#+ -! -

1.&))1&7 &6 :

# +A ?106/)1&7 *&) %: ! (

8/)1&. # # ( !# 6&&1)1&@ # - ! ( # "

## + 2 #!

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (7) + 4 # - !

1.16)1&7 ! +! - %#+ -! -#! - !

! )11.)1)1 &8 : + +A ).7@6)1&@H' I #!

+ "# # !( ## -

# - +A &66@8)1&&GH% 9 # < I! - " "

"#!# !!

+(" - ## %# + - ! !! -# +A ).7@6 )1&@ H' I ( )11))1&7 2 *&@4 (

! !

- + ! - ( ! ( " - ##

"%#+ -

# + "# (

@/)1&. ## (!#)7&1)1&? +

! )71@)1&@! +! - %#+ - ! %#! -! - &. :

# !

# ! #!

": #I )

01 ": #

&/)1&.! +

%# ! ! : " : # (

" )

& )610)1&.C 68 (%#+ -8 ( + ! - : 8 + ! - ( ! %#

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (8) + -6@! 68%#+ -(! &?1@)1&7 &? : + ##(

(

(+A )0?61 )1&0G &@16)1&7(

# " #

(

!# !!

:, (

( ( !

(!, !

1.16)1&7 " + ! % &0 :

&.16)1&72 *&84 + ! % " - +253!

!4 &@ :

# +A @&@.)1&7H I C ( 16&1)1&7 *&.4 !

+ ! % !

&.16)1&7(

( : ! "# ! !+ + ! % !

+253!

!4)1&8 (! # 9#)1&?C (

( ! ( ! "#- !

# !

( +# -"# ! C (

1.16)1&7 ( - (# !

!# " # !"#(

&7 - 2 *&04 + ! % !

&.16)1&7 "

## + 253!

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (9) + -##C (#" ( 2 &.16)1&74 !! !

# !

( +# 3 ! ( !!#" %#! - J" !! (%

1&18)1&?!

(

)1 C #"

" - # !#! % !

1.16)1&72 *&14 ## #! !

# !"# ! )& C #!

#!#

(

# )) < !# -

!##-

(! )1&6( B # !!

!!!

+ (

( (# ##/(

( ,

!##

-#! -<!#(#- !

" - B #

" - / ## # &0 #! (#-

((

( )1&?

# &0 +253!

!4( ## " +

%# + - !

(# - !

( ! " !

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (10) )6 C##

# # !#

(# !

! " %

!## &1 -2 4 (

( ": # + - ( - - ##

)610)1&. " "# ! !+ " (# ## %#+ -! +

( (

( <

( (# - !# #-! +

((

(

" ## %#+ -# !# "#! -# !- + +A &66@8)1&& 1 ,

/5%9 )8

! #!# (## # !# - + (# - -

I # !# !

# !

( +#

B # ! # ##!" #(!

:(#- #

)61&)1&6 2 *&4

!# " !

:(##

!#&?284 +

C ! % (## (

# !

(+#"(

!! -# !

( (

( !!! # -#! -C !

# #!# ! + -

)1102@4++0@.( -0

3# -(

(

"" *

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (11) 8 3

D - -* - :+ # @"' 2 2 -

* 3 * # @"' 7"!' D 2

# @"'*

* & & 3

* 3 ? 3

* - *3 3 *

*? $ - * ? - ?3 : E5 & 6 -3 "-'* . 0 - 3

-%4"BB7"'-87')6

"BB7"@'-@(.

F G 9 G "BB@ "!' - 7!'H + "

' 3 D "

3 3 -

* ?

26 3

? ?* 3 ?:

* ?

D "

' "

' 3 3 ?3 D 3 9 $ I 6B - "3

?3 '*B-

3 *

B -3 * -3 : * B- 3 3 * $ 3 - 3

3 * 3

* B -

3 - E+ B - 3 * 3 * 3 ?

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (12) $

3 2-& 3 2 $

? H; ). < !# "

- !

# B #

" ! - . ( ! !* 7 + $ 3 3 * *3 D 6 6 -3

) 6EBB -"!' - 8H* D 3 $ "%('I J 3 *3

* * 2 2 2 D 2 -

* -

: + 3

E"# @"' 3 " "' # D /D

& *

!K L 3 "' # @ ? 3 ?

4 L *

":' * 3

4 M D * 3

D &

& J # 3 # 7"!''* * # @"' *3

D *

* 3 $ # 0 1

-)%EBB7"7'-8!H I J : ?"7 K' L

? * * -* - +L 3 3 6 ?$ D & D &

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (13) ? + * ?

4 >

"6* 3 *

D D *

4 >

* * * 'EM H )? C #!# - # (

!##

+ ,

(

( * ( %

1&18)1&? ( ! #

)81&)1&6 -

+((

( ## ! ( # + ! - ( ! " + - %#+ - : !

% # ## 2 +4 #!

! !

! (

! 1.10)1&? !

1.17)1&? " +

" !

## + !

)@1))1&6 " (

(

1&18)1&? > ( !(

## +" # ( -##C ( !

(+#2

C ! 5!

# C

4 !

)1&? % - -

+*+! -2# !## +4> #.? !!

+ ## ! #"# 6&&))1&0 ) ( +*+! -

)1&? !

: (

!# ,

1)1@)1&@

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (14) ( " %# * !!

% !

1.1?)1&7" - ## ", #!

: !! +

)81&)1&6

)11))1&8

3 ! ( ! ! " %# + - : # " * !! ( %

1&18)1&? #!

)11))1&8!!# ")1&?: ! +253!

!4 ## !##! !-

#! ! -( ## !! -!

# #!

" # ", #!

+ 253!

!4)1&0 !( !(!!# )1&7#

" #

! #

- -

# -

)0 - #!

#!#

C ##(! #(

#- (

I!# # ! #-

" 7 &) - "

(

! )7 :

##( -!

&12

42 4

2( ! ", " &) &.4 24 C+A ?1)./)1&7 *&& :%:2 !#5!

6/)1&. # # ( !# 181&)1&7

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (15) 1?16)1&. *&& + !

! + ! - %# + - +

! 1.&))1&7 ! + ! - %# + -! %#+ -! - 1.&))1&7 2"4 C+A ?106/)1&7 *&)

%: !(

8/)1&. ## (!#6&&1)1&@ # -!( #"

## +2 #!

+ 4# - !

1.16)1&7! +! - %# + -! -#! -!

! )11.1)1 2!4 C+A ).7@6)1&@ *&@ + "#(

@/)1&. ## (!#)7&1)1&? +

! )71@)1&@ ! + ! - %# + - ! %#! -! - 24 )

01 " : #

&/)1&.! + %# ! ! : " : # (

" )

& )610)1&.> 68 (%#+ -8 ( +! -:8 +! -(! %#+ -6@ 68! %#+ -( ! &?1@)1&7

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (16) 61 C #

&*)#-

" : # #!

! + 253!

!4 > ## ! 53

)1&. ( ! # )1&? : #!

! !

/ !!

! + "

1.16)1&7 % ## -

+ ! - %# + - ! : -

, 242"42!4

- - ( !

!## # (

" :

# ! !#!

(

*) )11))1&8E+253!

!4 (&? %#+ - ( + + - :

# !

( +# ! - ( (

(

6&16)1&? 2 *84 E # # ( !# # 1)17)1&? ! " ) & #

1.17)11?

# ) 2+ 4 !

## + 253!

!4 +! -:

( # &0

# ! %#+ -

( ! ## !$ !

EK# + ## 6) ! #!

+ 253!

!4K ## ! #- ! 24 2"42!4 )." >! !(

( #

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (17) " !

2 3 *&& *&) *&@4( " + ## +" ##"! -#! - !

1.16)1&7C !

" + C!

161))1&02 *@4

! #!

/ - ( ! "

+! -

(

( ! " - !# (

+ !# (

66 : " -

C ! #-

(

! 242"42!4 ). "

" - # ##(

- &./&0))1)&2 *&04" & !

&.16)1&7 2 *&84 # "# " C #!! -# 68 C # - ( "

# ! 3 " # !

++ - B # !#L -" " + #" -# (

" ' $ I ! I"# + 3#

B #

# !

+:> +

!# &?284 M

M ( # !

!## !( !

!#&?2&4&.264M B #

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (18)

M C ! %

)81&)1&62 *&4 ! #9 9

:- " !# !

# !

( +# !

"% /% ;

-<!# (## !

# !

( +# 3!# #

)0=

( +# ( # - - "

++ -( !

! !

! (M

M !! -#C # "!!

+ + - ( M

M B #

! "#

6? &# # (

+! -

6&16)1&?2 *84

% !

F: !

(+#2

C ! 5!

# C

4 !

)1&? 3 !

+*++ - !#CCC C

( " + )?1.)1&? +A 776& )1&? <# % K : % !

## ## !!

+ 253!

!4 - * 2 !

4 #"# 6&&))1&0:( #.? !!

+ 253!

!4 - * #"# 6&&))1&0 ( !!

+*+ ! - ! - ? !!

%+! - -8@ !!

- G 2 !

4( #"# 6&&))1&0,

( +:(

" +1)1@)1&@

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (19)

! #

! #!

# # ( !# &7&))1&7 " + !! +

)81&)1&6

)11))1&8

3 !( !!" %#+ - # " * !! ( %

1&18)1&? #!

)11))1&8!!# ")1&?: ! 53!

! ## ! ##! !- #! ! -( ## !! -!

# #!

" # ", #!

+ 253!

!4)1&0 !( !(!!# )1&7#

" #

! #

- -

# -

60 <!#

)11))1&8 !!# " )1&? ! + 253!

!4 > ## ! ##! ", )1&0 ! # #!

+ 253!

!4 ( !!# )1&7 6@

- ) ! +253!

!4 %#+ - " ! " + 253!

!4 " ! " (

$ - -(# #!

(

" !+253!

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (20)

I" ! E -!! "

# !#

I !

+253!

!4 - (#! !! $E+: - !# " 3 "#(

$E+ (

###!

# !! ## !

%# + - : #

# # ! "#

67 "#"

" - # ##( - &./&0))1)&2 *&04" & !

&.16)1&7 *&84 # "# " C ( !!# #

## ! / !

! !

- ! 3 "#

(# " !

# +253!

!4- 3

!! # 3 #"# !! !

(

! ! 81

!! -#

###( - &./&0))1)& 2 *&04 " & !

&.16)1&7 2 *&84 !

+253!

!4- 3

- !! #

3 #"# !! !

(

! ! ! #

, !

CWP No. 5188 of 2021 (21) !##" (

! #"

, !!( ! # 8&

# )

-.' '/ .#/" A

-/ L/ A "# L/