M/S Shivam Communications v. M/S Seth Telecom And ANR

 























 

 

 



  
  
  
 







 


!
"#$%$ &'
()(%
* +,

-%
.+$/ 0
 00(&$#

$ &%




11111223$# & 4%5

67%(%
-%
.

+
3# 0
&"
& +7


11111%2 &"& 4%5

'
'
'
'

89
.1
.


:9 89
.1
.


:9 89
.1
.


:9 89
.1
.


:9

7%& '

71
.

&
 3
.$&)+
.$"+(,
"/ #

,


! 7
+
223$# & 4%51



:9,
1 

:9,
1 

:9,
1 

:9,
1

1

+
223$# &
+ %
!$3"
+
27%&
223$#

$ &
%;$&)
)7 &
!
3 /

3
) $&%
+
<(")0&
!
#=($

3
2 %%"
$&

# 023 $&
# %
$&% $ ( "
(&"7
.# $ &
>?
!
+
) $ @3
&% 7(0& %
# ,
??

4+7$& !

7
7!77"

%,
A
# B5,
C+7@D
+
# 023 $&
!$3"
@D
+

223$# &
C %
"$%0$%%"
&"
+
##(%"
C %
#=($

"1

1

+
3$0$ "
=(% $ &
7$%$&)
! 7
# &%$"7

$ &
$&
+
27%&
27 #"$&)%
$%
C+ +7
&
3
) $&%
&
7"7
!
#=($

3
2 %%"
$&

# 023 $&
# %
(&"7
.# $ &
>?
!
+

#
# &
@
&

$&"
(&"7

+
27 /$%

.# $ &
>
!
+
7111

+
$&%

&#
!
+
# 023 $& & E
>1


+
$%%(
$%
&
3 &)7
7%
$& )7 1
&
A-%
3% $(0
A-%
3% $(0
A-%
3% $(0
A-%
3% $(0
$& &#$ 3
6%1
1
& & %;

&
 #1

.
?

*'

4>5

$& &#$ 3
6%1
1
& & %;

&
 #1

.
?

*'

4>5

$& &#$ 3
6%1
1
& & %;

&
 #1

.
?

*'

4>5

$& &#$ 3
6%1
1
& & %;

&
 #1

.
?

*'

4>5

47$0$& 35

?B 47$0$& 35

?B 47$0$& 35

?B 47$0$& 35

?B,
+
 &8@3
.(270
 (7
( + 7$

$/3D
+3"
+

# 023 $& &
$&

27 %#( $ &
(&"7
.# $ &
>?
!
+

# ,
=( 3$!$%

%

A/$# $0B
(&"7
.# $ &
4C 5
!
+
7111,
@$&)
+
27% &
C+
%(!!7%
!$& &#$ 3
3 %%
"(

+
"$%+ & (7
!

#+=(1
 &%=(& 3D,
PUNEET SACHDEVA 2025.08.05 10:26 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document Chandigarh

 

%(#+

# 023 $& &
$%
& $ 3"

2(7%(
&
3
) $&%
#=($

3
(&"7

+
27 /$%

.# $ &
>
!
+
7111,
C$ + (
+
7=($70&
!
%;$&)
%2#$ 3
3 /
(&"7
.# $ &
>?4*5
!
+
7111
*1


" 2 $&)

27 )0

$#
&"
<(% $# 7$& "
#+
&"
)($""
@D
+
27$&#$23
+

27 #"(7 3
7(3
0(%
%7/
&"
&
@% 7(#

+
# (7%
!
<(% $#,
+$%
 (7
"0%
$
227 27$



"$7#
+

+
27%&
3
@

"
%
&
( + 7$

$/3D
$&% $ ( "
(&"7
+
27 /$%

.# $ &
>
!
+
7111

1


&
/$C
!
+
( + 7$

$/
27 & (&#0&
$&
-%
3% $(0
-%
3% $(0
-%
3% $(0
-%
3% $(0
$& &#$ 38%
# %
4%(27 $& &#$ 38%
# %
4%(27 $& &#$ 38%
# %
4%(27 $& &#$ 38%
# %
4%(27 5
&"
+
/$C

;&
@D
+$%
 (7
3%
$&

















    >

>

>

>

   

$ 3"
%
 <

2
67%(%
7$&#  <

2
67%(%
7$&#  <

2
67%(%
7$&#  <

2
67%(%
7$&#
"$%2 %"
!
&

1

,
+
27%&
223$#

$ &
$%
"$%2 %"
!
C$ +

"$7# $ &
+

+
3 7&"
.%%$ &%
(")
# &#7&"
%+ 33

+
27%&
3
%
&

3
!$3"
(&"7
+
27 /$%

.# $ &
>
!
+
7111
&"
%%$)&
+
% 0

&
227 27$


 (7
! 7
"$%2 % 3
&
07$ %,
$&
## 7"

&#
C$ +
C1
1


+
# &#7&"
2233


 (7
%+ 33
27 #"

"#$"
+

3
F2"$ $ (%3D,
C$ + (
@$&)
$02""
@D
&D
"3 D
$&
!$3$&)
+

3,
$&
/$C
!
+
3) 3
2 %$ $ &
& C
#3 7$!$"
@D
+
 &8@3
2F
 (7 1
1


+
)$% 7D
$%
"$7# "

&%0$
+$%
7"7
3 &)
C$ +
# 2D
!
+
# 023 
2 27
@ ;
&"
7 (7&
+
7$ 3
 (7
7# 7",
$!
7#$/",

+
3 7&"
.%%$ &%
(")1
()(%
* ()(%
* ()(%
* ()(%
* + + + +,

,

,

,

4

:9 

:9 

:9 

:95
(&











       


G+ +7
%2 ;$&)-7 % &"

'

%-



G+ +7
72 7

@3


'

%- PUNEET SACHDEVA 2025.08.05 10:26 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document Chandigarh