High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/841/2014dismissed

Jatinder Paul Bhagi v. Hardyal Thakur

2020-03-17Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan9 pages

!"#$%$ &'()*)

!""

#$% &

"' ' +, ) -)-) ./0"12( ) *+,' -'

) ) ,+,' -' "'

....

)-)3) / "- " ' ) '01 "& " ,'

-$ "+- "'- " '2 / - '2) '"0 3405 " "#$% &67862+9'

""'-:;4:%'*+ &"<+ '"&+ $ " "'- '2' ::3+ 2'" --* " ' '2'$/ 6 &'-5+#< = ' $>$' 2*""=6)

&+''- 9&+ *'& "<) $'- '"-

",-' 6 ' ' '29 " '- $- '"26)

&*"9''& 9- '- 2' ,', '2

"'"' '2""-'2 "8'9+ '*,+ * 6)

&- ,'+ ' $ '2 *'''* '2'

, --=';

::;* >$" '- >"' *" ' '+ *" "' 2'$ ' ''- 2= 2+ '2 2' '- 9&2""9' (

= 2#$% &+ 9' '-6)

&' * 6"862 ' "' '2''& 2-' 9$'

'- "+* *"'- 9'?- '$8' 9&= - #$ % &9 9 "'- - '2*" ' " "9' +-' "' "

'2' 2""'+ #$% & , 9'* ' - '- '2+""'-* +'' '- '2-'= - '2*" '*'

'9$ "#$% &6"862 ' * ' "''&'*' '2=* '2*"$ ' '+#$% & ,& &-" 9'*"' '2+* "678% & , 2""

& &9'*" "'2 + "9 &' "- = "' '2$ 9' " 9" '2

, -''9'*"' 2= '2"2'",

2"-+' * '"

*62+9& "'2

0 @ )

2 ' "' *"" ' = 2* -*2'"'", "'=' " 2+ """*$-'2 "'=@)

* 62 & '2 ' , #'"+ +* *"2 ' $?2=" A'- '2;

::;+ ""

8"+'- * *'8"* ,'"?$*","+* " ' 8"*-''9"2

B5 *" " ' '

::;

@" "''- B5+ ' '-@,"'C'

0+ '&$ ' ""'"+ -'+ '2*"-' '-, '2 ''- "5"""

- ' '-2$, + "#$ &67862 9"22''- -' '-- ") '"0 3* ) '05,' ;

::1 ' " *2 '9 '"'-' 2"' '2*" ' 2-'- '"""," ) ' 1

"*"-?-' , '- '2+ '"'-* '2 ' "'*"2 '"D9""?2 2"

62"D +@ )

"D0"

*62"D

-+ - 2 - "+ -' '-- ") '"0 3+0 3* ) '050 05 *"-2 "+'* + $' $

2 @ '" , + '2 ' "

'*"2 ''' ?2@ 2"

62+@)

*629""' ' 2"

D '" , *" '"

)2"'- "* ') '00 +* 2 2" " " " " * ' 2 9 $ '"

' $' $ ,9-"$2 "- '" & 5- , + "?2@D2C+ @D 6"

+@D0,"

62+@D6"

62+@D3 @82)

+@D;8,62@D1 ) 2

- 2"+ ""2"" '2 > "'- -2 " 2

"'"-', " ' "'*"

(

9" '- 2', ' '- " ' & '2 "8"' 22',"

*&--

5 >$ '2+6)

&*"

2$ ", '- 6 9$ ' " '- 2 '+ '9 &' "",'$

' ,9' 9$ - '2*"

3 &$'99"', >$

B 2'+*"6)

&+* ' & '2+ $*"9' '-6)

& " '2 "+ *$+ ''-2', -'26)

&-' "9' ""' "'- "

9' "- "$'- 2',

,% ,$ "'$ " 9$ '2 '2" ' ' 9 '9- ',

, ' '"9* "2"'- '2 ' $*"""+2$D"

*62

2"'-

,9" '-'

', 2 , '

'* '' '- '2&' &'9$ -"9'*

,9$ "C'

#$% &

,D@)

*629 &'*' '2 '9"*""" 9

2'" "9" '"" " " " "2"

,9" '- ''9'' ' ,"' '- '2

?% '- " "'9',' ' 9$'"

'*'-"'9'9

? , ' "' ' , D @ 2"

62+ * ' 2 ' $ ?2 '2 " '""?2' '

' * '-"9'* '' 99'&9

; - 2" *"''""9 "

'' *"2"" '9'& " " -'+" 9 >"'', -""'- '" '"'$

?% " & ';

::;9' (

+* " '2*"-' ::;

-''-2' 2' "

"8 2- '2

, &' & '''- "'9$2', ' ) '01 -' '-" ,' 8 2'- >

52$92' 6"862

? - '' 2 '- 2 8 2 % " ,"9 "'

" "#$% &'$

'*"-9$9$1

$"+""

') '3'- A2' "9-'

* '

C' '- " '" *" "" ' "'4 "+* ' "''" " '''

5 , '"-' "9"" '

) '0'- A2' +:;0"* '- A2'', ,$""+-+ '2- " 9'"

9"2"" '

2' "'9""-

) '3'- ,$ '," $'$ '2$92- " 9'-

1 ""-" ' "-- "-''- '2& '* " ' 5 " "+ "99'""-$ ' "-- "-''- * 2 ?'">, +* "'-''9 ',

$ " ""'-2' -' $"

""- '$'"9?' "9+* 2

,9&' '"'' '' $ C''9"2 $- '- '$"'-*2' " 9 '' "'-8" 9 '' $'-2' -'$"* ' 9 $ '

', ?' *'2''-$ ) '0'- A2' +* "' -' ?'8 2

!+ "* $'-3;3$"

*" ''9$ #

'- '- -' "' 2 ,' <E"'-- *"-''* 2$ 9'2">$2'+ '9","(

" #

$ "5''-$"'' ' ) '3'- A2' '' '""$'- 1

$"- '- '-'" ,' F, ' *"+'2""'' '" ''* ' >"' 5''-$ $ $ 8 2 "" 9$ ' " 9" ' ' " ''-, ' ''-*

' ' '2 ' B5 * ' '

::;"-9 ' ' & $ ' 2 " ,'" 2" "'"

"$' 2' ' , "2 "* ' +* & ' ;

::;+B5*"' '-' $

::;

C""'"$'2' '- B & "

" ',""''"92"

,"''- * "" '-2 2'- " '' ,"' 9 ' - 9' '"'" '2''9

A '" -' "' " - ' @,"' 8 2'- "' " #

&& %%$*

* " '- " >'- " 2 "+ * ' 9-9$ )"& ,' "8 2'- >+* "2"" '

: *"'9", * ,*&9$ '+"'$*$ "'9+ ," ' 2'""9+ - " 2" "'- " , 9$ '" '+ " ',*"''""9"9+ '*"

5- 8 2-'9$ '"-' "'" 9' - "'- " " "'9", '$>"'+ ' " , '- * 2''- *"""*"9 ', 9$ ' "&' '"' *' "98 ,,'"' 9-' '2 ' ' "' " '2 - '', " " "9$'"

'*'-"'9'9

"' '"2'' " ,' " " '"+ -'"2"" ' $

)-)

()*) .$4 6..

% &"7%8 9$&/ '

%7 6..8 .