← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/907/2014dismissed

Jasvir Singh v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2015-05-05Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary11 pages

   

         

     !"# "  $%&' ++,&- (. %/'$0$

. ./ '! (  (1.*/'$ 22 /$+(1/(.$   34 

    54 

  

'/$/(. '6&(177 . '& #1%- ./'.*/ ++,&- (.

 # */ +'/$/(. ++,&- .&( 0(1/' /-.&( 89:8; 1/  '&<&( , '-/10'/:'='/%&.!#>.*/1/5;* $=//(<%/1$//?&() ,/ %/. ++/ , ) &($..*/@01)</(.1 ./1A8

+ $$/1=!.*/

/$$&($ 01)/# '&1?. -B0&..&() '/$+(1/(. $ .   .*/ -* ')/$0(1/' /-.&($8A #   '&/ -.$C*&-* '/&<+/' .&%/.1&$+$/.*/ ++,&- .&( '/'/- +&.0, ./1 $0(1/'   <+, &( (. $%&' &()* &,/1  -<+, &(. &( .*/ 0'.*&/01&-& , )&$.' ./# '&1?.# ,,/)&()-<<&$$&( /(-/0(1/' /-.&($8A #  =!'/$+(1/(.$

 . --'1&().*&<#*/C $'/$&1/(.%&,, )/ -* ?& ,

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

*//%/(&()# '0(1AEA8+<( #.*/ $(.*/-<+, &( (.C/(.0..*/*0$/(<.'-!-,/# =/,()&(). $C&(1/' &()* (1 ) (1//+ &()*#'/$&1/(.$  '&1?.C/%/'#*/1&1(.-</= -?*/< ../'C $ '/+'./1 . .*/ +,&-/  ,&-/ . &( 1 '# '&1?. ./' $/ '-*&() *&< &( .*/ %&,, )/# '/, .&($ (1 .

0=$/B0/(.,!# */ - </ . ?(C '<  $C&(1/'  ) (1//+ &()*.* .*&$$(C $$ !&().* . .%&'7 0'* 1 - ,,/1*&<.<//.&(.*//%/(&()F*/(.*/!C/'/(.*/&' C !# '/$+(1/(.  0'+'//. &()* - </ &(. .*/&' -(. -. (1.,1.* .*/C $C &.&()' (+'//. &()*#$ $.. ?/

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

"A:8;'

($./ 1,1)&() (   ) &($..*/'/$+(1/(.$ (1.' -&()0..*/=1! (+'//. &()*#.*/+,&-/'/0$/1 . . ?/ (! -.&(#C*&-* (/-/$$&. ./1 .*/ -<+, &( (. . &,/ .*/-<+, &(.*/-<+, &( (.C $ +'+/'$(#C*/'/ $# .*/'/$+(1/(.$C/'/&(,0/(.& ,+/'$($ ./''/-'1&().*/+'/,&<&( '!/%&1/(-/#'/$+(1/(. $. C/'/'1/'/1.=/$0<<(/1. -/.'& ,0(1/'

/-.&($8A #  %&1/'1/'1 ./1 "A 

 ( +0'$0 (-/  .*/ $0<<(&() '1/'# '/$+(1/(. $. * 1+0.&( ++/ ' (-/ &(-/.*//(-/0(1/'

/-.&(8A  C $/D-,0$&%/.'& =,/=!.*/0'. /$$&($# .*/- $/C $-<<&../1..*/0'. /$$&($%&1/&.$'1/' 1 ./1

" 

&(1&()+'&<  -&/- $/ ) &($.'/$+(1/(.$.

#.*/,/ '(/1.'& ,0'.-* ')/$*//./1.*/'/$+(1/(.$ . 0(1/' /-.&($8A #  %&1/'1/'1 ./1 "A  ('1/'./$. =,&$*.*/)0&,.'/$+(1/(.$.

# .*/ +'$/-0.&( &( ,, /D <&(/1 .*'// C&.(/$$/$# ( </,!#  ) (1//+ #   $%&' &()* :-<+, &( (.; F (1  $C&(1/' F8 (.*/$. ./</(.$'/-'1/10(1/' /-.&(8 8'

# '/$+(1/(. $ .  1/(&/1 ,, .*/ ,,/) .&($ (1 +,/ 1/1 .*/&'  ,$/ &<+,&- .&(  ( 1//(-/# '/$+(1/(. $ . /D <&(/1 $< (! $$/%/(C&.(/$$/$#( </,!# ,1/% F # 4 *C&1(/' &()* F# 0+&(1/' &()*F8#   $+ ,

&()*F # ,%&' &()*F"#(&,70< '0+. # (1C'&.&() (1 &()/' '&(.D+/'.FA (1 ,C&(1/' &()*F ./'*/ '&(),/ '(/1 0=,&- '$/-0.''.*/ . ./ $ C/,, $ ,/ '(/1 -0($/, ' '/$+(1/(. $ .  (1 ( ++' &$ ,/%&1/(-/#.*/.'& ,0'.'/ -*/1..*/-(-,0$&( .* . .*/ +'$/-0.&( * $  &,/1 . /$. =,&$* .*/ )0&,.  '/$+(1/(.$. #=/!(1$* 1C'/ $( =,/10=. (1 -($/B0/(.,!# -B0&../1 '&. < &()*# $%&' &()* (10'+'//.



&()*:'/$+(1/(.$. ;%&1/&<+0)(/1@01)</(.1 ./1 A8

 ))'&/%/1 =! .*/ '/$ &1 @01)</(.  -B0&.. , 1 ./1A8

#.*/-<+, &( (.* $+'//''/1.*/+'/$/(. ++/ , F/* %/*/ '1,/ '(/1-0($/,'.*/ ++,&- (. (1 )(/.*'0)*.*/'/-'1%/'!<&(0./,! 4/ '(/1 -0($/, ' .*/ ++,&- (. $0=<&.$ .* . .*/ .'& , 0'.# C&.*0. ++' &$&() .*/ /%&1/(-/ &(  -''/-. +/'$+/-.&%/#* $/''(/0$,! -B0&../1'/$+(1/(.$. # 1/$+&./ .*/  -. .* . .*/'/ C $ $0&-&/(. /%&1/(-/# &(1&- .&() .*/&' -($+&' -! C&.* / -* .*/' (1 =10-.&(    (+'//.

&()*C&.* (&(./(.&(.?&,,*&<<+, &( (. $%&' $

F * $ 0( <=&)00$,! 1/+$/1 .* . .*/'/ C $ -B0 &(. (-/  =/.C//(  (+'//. .%&' 7 0'# =/- 0$/.*/&'$.01!&()&(.*/$ </$-*, (1.* ..*/!* 1  ,,/( &( ,%/ C&.* / -* .*/'# $&(-/ , $. $/%/( !/ '$

/$+(1/(.$. C/'/(..,/' (..*/$ &1,%/  &'$# =/- 0$/ .*/ -<+, &( (. =/,()$ .  '&@ ( -<<0(&.!# C*/'/ $#'/$+(1/(.$. =/,(). . &()*-<<0(&.! (.*/ ./0,1 !&/ #'/$+(1/(.$ (18C/'/ =0$&() (1B0 ''/,,&()C&.* (+'//. &()*&(.*/+'/$/(-/  $C&(1/' &()* (1 ) (1//+ &()* (1.*/!&(-($+&' -! C&.*/ -*.*/'* 1 =10-./1 (+'//. &()*C&.* (&(./(.&( .<0'1/'*&<*/&<+0)(/1@01)</(.&$= $/1(C'()(

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

'&1?.   ('1/' . $* ../' .*/ %/'$&( .*/-<+, &( (. .* . (!,%/  &'C $ )&() ( &( =/.C//( (+'//. (1 %&.  7 0'# C*&,/ .*/! C/'/ $.01!&() .)/.*/' &( .*/ %/'(</(. -*,# -* ?& , &()*#'/$+(1/(.$. * %//D <&(/1 ,1/% &()* $F #C*$+/-&&- ,,!1/+$/1 .* .   (+'//. &()* $.01&/1 &( %/'(</(. '&< '! -*,#  -* ?& , &()*0+.8 8

 (1 .%&'7 0'* 1(/%/' $.01&/1 &( .*/&' $-*,  F4 ?*C&(1/' &()* ,$ 1/+$/1

.* ..*/( </ (+'//. &()*C $$.'0-?(  C*&,/ */ C $ $.01!&() &( .* $. (1 '1 &( /(&' /-(1 '!

-*,# -* ?& , &()*/ ,$1/+$/1($&<&, ',&(/ $ F  ,1/% &()*'/) '1&()$.01!&() %&. 7 0'/(-/# .*/ '/$ &1/%&1/(-/=/,&/$.*/%/'$&(.*/-<+, &( (.&( '/$+/-.$.01!&()*&$$( (+'//. &()*C&.* .%&'7 0' * . + '.#,/ '(/1-0($/,'.*/ ++,&- (.+, -/1 '/,& (-/(.*/,%/,/../'$ ,,/)/1,!C'&../(=! .%&'7 0'.  (+'//. &()*#< '?/1. (1.*/+*.)' +*$< '?/1 .#.$*C.* ..*/'/C $$</,%/  &'=/.C//(.*/.C

/0$ , . )&%/ $+/-&</( * (1C'&.&() =! .%&' 7 0' ,/1 . -(-,0$&( .* . .*/ '/$ &1 ,/../'$ C/'/ C'&../(=! */'   10=.#  '/0$ , &(%&./$ 1%/'$/ &(/'/(-/ ) &($. .%&' 7 0'# *C/%/'# .*/ ,/../'$ &( &.$ /(.&'/.!  $*C .* . .*/! '/ 11'/$$/1 . $</ '@ !  ( /D <&( .&(&(-*&/# .*/ -<+, &( (.:

F;< 1/ ( ../<+../$. =,&$*.* . (+'//.

&()*C $ ,$?(C( $G@ !HC/%/'#$&(-// ',&/'.*&$ 1/+$&.&( =/'/ .*/ .'& , 0'.# .*/'/ C $ ( 1-0</(. . $*C.* . (+'//. &()*C $ ,$?(C( $G@ !H#*/(-/#&. - ($ /,!=/&(/''/1.* .&.C $ 1/,&=/' ./ ../<+..-'/ ./ -(0$&( (1 '/ + ( 0(1/$/'%/1 =/(/&. =! 1+.&() $0-* 10=&0$1/%&-/*0$#.*/'/,& (-/+, -/1(.*/,/../'$1/$ (. +'%/ .* . .*/'/ C $ (! ,%/  &' =/.C//(  (+'//.

&()* (1 .%&'7 0'

 */ .*/' ')0</(.  ,/ '(/1 -0($/, ' .*/ ++,&- (..* .*/=/,()$.,C/'- $./ (1'/$+(1/(.$ . .0++/'- $./ (1.*/!C/'/(..,/' (..*/,%/  &'   (+'//. %&.  7 0' 1/$ (. *,1 C ./'# &( $<0-* $#.*/+'$/-0.&(* $ &,/1.+'%/.* ..*/'/C $ (! ,%/  &' =/.C//( .*/ .C (1 /%/( &( .*/ $. ./</(. '/-'1/10(1/' /-.&(8 8'

#'/$+(1/(.$. .? .*/+,/ .* ..*/-<+, &( (.C $ &$.'& (1&('1/'.C&(  %0'# */  -, &</1 *&<$/, . =/   @=& &?* C*&-* &$ ,.)/.*/'&(-(.' 1&-.&(.*&$/ ',&/'$. (1  1/ , C&.* .*/ .*&'1 ')0</(.  ,/ '(/1 -0($/, .* .( #.*/$(.*/-<+, &( (.#( </,!# (+'//.

&()*C $, $.,!$//(&(.*/-<+ (!'/$+(1/(.$. =!  $C&(1/' &()* (1  ) (1//+ &()*# &. C0,1 =/ (/-/$$ '!.(.&-/.*/ -.$)&%&()'&$/..*/ ++/ , (&.& ,,!#.*/-<+, &( (.).'/-'1/1 

( " C&.*.*/+,&-/'/) '1&()<&$$&()*&$$(* . :DFE;* $=//(+'%/1=!F  ,C&(1/' &()*C*&-* C $ $&)(/1 =!  ,=&' &()* F"# (/&)*=0'/'  .*/ -<+, &( (.# C* 1/+$/1 .* . */  (1  $%&' :-<+, &( (.; ++/(1/1*&$$&)( .0'/$*/-<+, &( (.C*&,/ ++/ '&() $ F< 1/1/(& ,..*/'/-'1&() (.*/ +'/<&$/ .* . */ 1&1 (. $&)( (1 (,! ++/(1/1 *&$ .*0<= &<+'/$$&(# =0. &( .*/ -'$$ /D <&( .&( */ 1<&../1 .* . */ ?(/C*C.$&)(&$ 1<&$$&( ,$&&/$*&$1/+$&.&(.* .*/

* 1 ++/(1/1*&$.*0<=&<+'/$$&((.*/ &(.*/,&)*. 1/+$&.&( 0?*1/% &()*F".* .*/ (1-<+, &( (.* 1 ++/(1/1.*/&'$&)( .0'/$&(-,0<((.*/ %/((&, 70< '0+. # (1C'&.&() (1 &()/' '&(.D+/'.:FA;) %/ *&$+&(&(.* ..*/$&)( .0'/(.*/ '/$ &1 =/,()/1. .*/-<+, &( (.%&1/(.,!#.*/&'$.%/'$&('/-'1/1.*'0)*  

$+/ ?$(,!<&$$&() (+'//. &()*#=0.C&.*0. </(.&(&() =0. .*/ $ - ,,/1 C&.(/$$/$# ( </,!#  $C&(1/'

&()* (1 ) (1//+ &()*C/%/'#&(.*/-<+, &(.#D # .*/-<+, &( (.$. ./1.* .*/- </.?(C'< $C&(1/'

&()* (1 ) (1//+ &()*#.* .&(&.& ,,!0'+'//. &()** 1 </..*/< (1.*/( '&. < &()* (1 $%&' &()*- </ ..*/ $+. (1 .*/! =0$/1 (1 B0 ''/,,/1 C&.* *&$ $( (+'//.

&()* (.*/$&<&, ',&(/$#.*/-<+, &( (.1/+$/1=/'/.*/ .'& ,0'.C/%/'# DFE1/$(.&(1</(.&(# .*/ ( </$  .*/ +/'$($ '< C*< .*/ -<+, &( (. * 1 -</.?(C =0..*/( </$ (1',/'/$+(1/(.$.

.(,!.*&$#*/.?1&/'/(.$. (1$'<.&</..&</ 6&1/ ++,&- .&(1 ./1 8:D8; 11'/$$/1. /(&'

0+/'&(./(1/(.  ,&-/# '&1?.# .*/ -<+, &( (. '/B0/$./1 ' &(&.& .&(  -.&( ) &($. .%&' 7 0'#  $%&'

'&. < &()*  C/%/'# .*/ $ </ 1/$ (. &(1</(.&( .*/ ( </0'+'//. &()*%/(&.1/$(.&(1</(.&(.*/',/  .*/ C&.(/$$/$# ( </,!#  $C&(1/' &()* (1  ) (1//+

&()*#C*&-*&$(C.*/=(/.*/-<+, &(.(.*/$&<&, '

  $*&(#  &( ++,&- .&( 1 ./1   :D ;# .*/ -<+, &( (..?.*/+,/ #C*&-*&$ 1<&../1=!*&<&(*&$-'$$ /D <&( .&(#.* .*/,1)/1.*/ '/) '1&()<&$$&()*&$ $( (1*&$<0'1/'=! '&. < &()*) &(&.1/$(.&(1 </(.&( .*/ ( </  (! C&.(/$$   0</'0$ ++,&- .&($# &(-,01&().*/C'&.+/.&.&( (1 &1 %&.#D".#< 1/. % '&0$'0<$$*C.* ..*/-<+, &( (..?1&/'/(.%/'$&( '< .&</ . .&</  /(-/# &. =/,&/$ .*/ /(.&'/ +'$/-0.&( %/'$&(  ) (1//+ &()* $  1/+$/1 .* .  (+'//.

&()* --<+ (&/1 *&< ( <.'-!-,/ C&.*  $C&(1/' (1C*/(.*/!C/'/(.*/C !#.*/!- </&(.-(. -.C&.* 0'+'//. &()*#C*$.++/1.*/&'<.'-!-,/ (1.,1.* .*/ C $,?&()' (+'//. &()* (1 ..* .+&(..&</# $%&'

&()* (1 '&. < &()*- </.*/'/ (1.? C ! (+'//.

&()*  C/%/'# .*&$ C&.(/$$ ,$ 1/+$/1 .* .  $C&(1/'

&()* .,1 *&< .* .    (+'//. &()* * 1 </. *&< ./' 8 1 !$ $C&(1/' &()* $ F81&1(../..*/,&(/.*/ +'$/-0.&( (11/+$/1/(.&'/,!1&/'/(.'<  (1 F / 1<&../1 &( -'$$ /D <&( .&( .* . 10'&() .*/ -0'$/  /(B0&'!# */ < 1/ $. ./</(. D # -0(./'$&)(/1 =!  ) (1//+ &()*# C*&-* $*C$ .* . .*/! 1&1 (. -</ &(. -(. -. C&.* (! +/'$( ( # C*/'/  (+'//. * 1+ './1C&.*.*/< C/%/'#=.* .*/ '/$ &1 C&.(/$$/$ &( .*/&' -'$$ /D <&( .&( 1/+$/1 .* . .*/! C/'/ (. &( 

 +$&.&( . )&%/ +*!$&- , ..'&=0.&(   (+'//. )/)' +*&- ,,- .&(.*/*0$/.*/-<+, &( (..,/ 1$ .-(-,01/.* .=.*.*/C&.(/$$/$1&1(.%&$&..*/*0$/ .*/-<+, &( (. (%&/C.*/ '/$ &11&$-0$$&(#C/&(1(</'&. &( .*/ ')0</(.$ ' &$/1 =! ,/ '(/1 -0($/, ' .*/ ++,&- (. --'1&(),!#.*/ ++,&- .&(<%/1'$//?&(),/ %/. ++/ , ) &($..*/@01)</(.1 ./1A8

+ $$/1=!.*/ /$$&($ 01)/# '&1?.&$1&$<&$$/1#=/&()1/%&1 (!</'&. :

 ;    !"# "  :

 ; 71