High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/880/2015dismissed

State Of Haryana v. Sheela And ORS

2016-11-07Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan,Bench- 47 pages

! "

##$%&'&()*+,&-./0%++-123$&4526(&6+42 +278,28&$& .,-$#&(06(&$&.+%2647 -6( $&-(8%+,&.+%2679 +,& +-+&23-$*-6-,-43%1&(+,&5$&4&6+-551%.-+%264&&:%6#1&-'&+25$&3&$-6 -55&-1

+%4+,&.-4&23+,&5$24&.0+%26+,-+-..04&(,&&1- 06%+- 8,2 %4 +,& 8%3& 23 .2;51-%6-6+ " -6<0 -##$%&'&( )* +,& %11%.%+ $&1-+%264,%523(&.&-4&(-'%+-8%3&23" -'%,-(8%+,.2;51-%6-6+ -6<0",-+.,&(-.$%;%6-1.2645%$-.*8%+,2+,&$+82-..04&(6-;&1* %62( %110-6(%62( -6#(--6(-11+,&+,$&&-..04&(<2%6&( +2#&+,&$-6(.2;;%++&(+,&;0$(&$23-'%+-)*41%++%6#,&$6&.:

,& ;24+ ;-+&$%-1 8%+6&44&4 -$& " .2;51-%6-6+ -6<0 ,04)-6(23-..04&(,&&1- 06%+--6(" -'%,04)-6(23(&.&-4&( -'%+- ",-4(&524&(+,-+,&$&.&%'&(-6%632$;-+%263$2;,%48%3&

,&&1-+,-+-'%+-8-43206(1*%6#(&-(26+,&3122$6&-$,&$)&(8%+,-.0+ ;-$:26,&$6&.:

&.-11&(+,&521%.&.26+$21$22;-6(5-44&(26+,& %632$;-+%26 " -'%,-44+-+&(+,-+,&8-4;-$$%&(+2-'%+-32$=*&-$4

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

,&;&(%.-1&'%(&6.&-((0.&()*+,&5$24&.0+%26+,$20#,"

$ -$06-6("?$ 0;%+%6#,-18201(4,28+,-+(&.&-4&(-'%+-,-( )&&640)<&.+&(+24&>0-1%6+&$.20$4&)&32$&,&$(&-+,-4+,&$&8-4(&+&.+%26 23 ,0;-6 4&;&6 26 '-#%6-1 48-) .211&.+&( ..04&( ,-( 4033&$&( (%4.1240$&4+-+&;&6+4 -4&(26+,&(%4.1240$&4+-+&;&6+23%62( %110 -6%$26$2(8-4$&.2'&$&(-6(26+,&)-4%423+,&(%4.1240$&4+-+&;&6+ 4033&$&( )* -..04&( ,&&1- 2)%1& 5,26& > @ -6( %; .-$( > @8&$&$&.2'&$&( =

6+,&4%(&23+,&(&3&6.&"-<8-6+%-6("!-'%+- 8&$&&>-;%6&(+2(&;264+$-+&+,-+-..04&(%62( %1108-462+-$$&4+&(

7 -+,%4$&4%(&6.& ,&+$%-1 20$+3206(+,-++,&$&8-46240)4+-6+%-1&'%(&6.&1&+ %6)*+,&5$24&.0+%26+25$2'&+,&.,-$#&41-%(-#-%64++,&; ,&$&.2'&$* 23+,&%$26$2((2&462+.266&.++,&-..04&(+2+,&.$%;& +8-4-142 2)4&$'&()*+,&+$%-1 20$++,-+$&.2'&$*23+,&;2)%1&5,26&-6(+,&%;

-$((2&462+&4+-)1%4,+,&%6'21'&;&6+23+,&-..04&(+2+,&.$%;&

&-$6&(((1

-$*-6-'&,&;&6+1*-$#0&(+,-++,&;2+%'& +2 .2;;%+ +,& .$%;& 8-4 &4+-)1%4,&( +,$20#, &'%(&6.& 23 " -'% ,04)-6(23(&.&-4&(-'%+- ,&(%4.1240$&4+-+&;&6+-6(+,&$&.2'&$*23 +,&;-+&$%-12)<&.+6-;&1*%$26$2(8201(.2$$2)2$-+&+,&'&$4%2623+,& 5$24&.0+%26+,-++,&-..04&(.2;;%++&(+,&;0$(&$ ,&+&1&5,26&.-11 (&+-%14-142.266&.++,&-..04&(+2+,&.$%;&%+8-430$+,&$40);%++&(

,&$&32$&%+%4,%440);%44%26+,-+1&-'&-4420#,+32$+25$&3&$-6-55&-1 ;-*)&#$-6+&(

,20#,$ -$&4,!0;-$('2.-+&&6+&$&(-55&-$-6.&32$ +,&$&4526(&6+4 ,&$&8-462-55&-$-6.&26+,&(-*8,&68&+22:05+,& -551%.-+%2632$,&-$%6#

"&8&6++,$20#,+,&&6+%$&.-4&3%1&%6+,&)-.:#$206(23+,& 40);%44%264;-(&)*1&-$6&(.2064&1-55&-$%6#32$+,&+-+&

"&3%6(+,-++,&$&%4;&(%.-1&'%(&6.&+24,28 +,-+ (&.&-4&(-'%+-8-440)<&.+&(+2$-5&)&32$&4,&8-4(26&+2(&-+, 0+ +,&5$24&.0+%26,-#%'&60540.,-.,-$#&-4+,&233&6.&23$-5&.201(62+ )&.266&.+&(+2+,&-..04&((0$%6#+,&.20$4&23%6'&4+%#-+%26

&+043%$4++-:&05+,&;2+%'&32$+,&.$%;&-++$%)0+&(+2+,&

9 -..04&( 3 .20$4& " -'% +,& ,04)-6( 23 (&.&-4&( -'%+- ,-4 (&524&(+,-+-..04&(,&&1-04&(+2/0-$$&18%+,-'%+--6(#%'&,&$ )&-+%6#426+,&5$&+&>++,-+-'%+-,-((&'&125&(%11%.%+$&1-+%2648%+," -6<0 +%4,%4+&4+%;26*+,-+4,&,-(;-1%.&%6,&$;%6(-6(#-'&.$%;%6-1 %6+%;%(-+%26+2.-04&(&-+,23-'%+-

,&2..0$$&6.&,-(+-:&651-.&%6+,&6%#,+237 7 + 8-4261*,&&1-8%3&23"8,2,-(5-44&(26+,&%632$;-+%26-4 $&#-$(4+,&;0$(&$23-'%+-+2,&$,04)-6("-6<0 620$.264%(&$&( '%&8%34,&8-4%6'21'&(%6+,&;0$(&$4,&8201(62+,-'&5-44&(2640., -6%632$;-+%26+2,&$,04)-6(42+,-+,&.201(-1&$+" -'%8,2,-( )&&6+2!0$0:4,&+$-+2+-:&.-$&23,%4;2+,&$ %-62&'% .015$%+8201( 62+,-'&+,20#,+23%6'%+%6#+$20)1&)*5-44%6#2640.,-6%632$;-+%26

69 7+,&321128%6#(-*23+,&2..0$$&6.&" -'% 8-4%6+&$$2#-+&()*+,&521%.&(0$%6#%6'&4+%#-+%26-6(,%44+-+&;&6+06(&$ &.+%26 $

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

= 4033&$&( )* " %4 3206( +2 )& -6 -3+&$+,20#,+ + 8201( )& ,%#,1* %;5$2)-)1&+2$&1*2640.,-40551&;&6+-$*4+-+&;&6+4033&$&()*+,&4+-$ 8%+6&44+2,21(+,-+-..04&(,-(,-$)20$&(-6%6+&6+%26+2.2;;%++,& ;0$(&$ 0$+,&$+,&$&%4622+,&$&'%(&6.&+2.2$$2)2$-+&+,&+&4+%;26*23 " -'% ,&$&32$&%620$.264%(&$&('%&8+,&;2+%'&-++$%)0+&(+2 ,&&1-)*" -'%8-462+&4+-)1%4,&()&*26($&-426-)1&(20)+

,&&'%(&6.&23"-6<0(2&462+%6-6*8-*%6(%.-+&+,& .2;51&>%+*23+,&-..04&(%6+,&.$%;&23;0$(&$23-'%+- ,&$&32$&,%4 +&4+%;26* %6 20$ .264%(&$&( '%&8 (2&4 62+ %6 -6* 8-* ,&15 +,& 5$24&.0+%26+2&4+-)1%4,+,&.,-$#&3$-;&(-#-%64++,&-..04&(

&+04628+-:&05+,&(%4.1240$&4+-+&;&6+-11&#&(1*4033&$&( )*-..04&(%62( %110 6+,&)-4%423-(;%44%)1&52$+%26> %6 +,& (%4.1240$& 4+-+&;&6+ 4033&$&( )*%62( %110 -6 %$26 $2( 8-4 -11&#&(1*$&.2'&$&(3$2;-625&68-+&$($-%6 4$%#,+1*2)4&$'&()*+,& +$%-1 20$+%$26$2(8-4-(;%++&(1*$&.2'&$&(3$2;-50)1%.51-.&8,%., 8-4-..&44%)1&+2-11 +%462+-4%3+,&%$26$2($&.2'&$&(-++,&%64+-6.&23 -..04&(%62( %1108-43206(4+-%6&(8%+,)122(-6(+,&#$20523)122( 3206(26+,&%$26$2(;-+.,&(8%+,+,&)122(23+,&(&.&-4&( &$& $&.2'&$*23%$26$2(3$2;-50)1%.51-.&(2&462+%6-6*8-*-('-6.&+,& .-4&23+,&5$24&.0+%26 0$+,&$+,&$&.2'&$*23%$26$2(3$2;-50)1%. 51-.&8,%.,-142(2&462+.26+-%6-6*)122(.-662+-+-11)&-)-4%4+2 .266&.+-..04&(%62( %110+2+,&.$%;&23;0$(&$ 620$.264%(&$&( '%&8+,&+$%-1 20$+,-4$%#,+1*(20)+&(+,&$&.2'&$*23%$26$2(420#,++2 )&5$2<&.+&()*+,&5$24&.0+%26+2%6'21'&-..04&(%62( %110+2+,&

.$%;&

&+04628+-:&05+,&+&1&5,26&.-11(&+-%145$2<&.+&()*+,& 5$24&.0+%26+2$25&%6+,&-..04&(+2+,&.$%;&23;0$(&$23-'%+- ,&$& 8-46240)4+-6+%-1&'%(&6.&+2.266&.+-..04&(%62( -6#(--6( -..04&(%62( %110+2+,&.$%;&23;0$(&$ +8-450$&1*)-4&(26+,& (%4.1240$&4+-+&;&6+4033&$&()*,&&1-+,-++,24&+82-..04&(,-()&&6 $25&(%6 45&$+,&$&.2'&$*;&;2> +,&0;)&$234-%( ;2)%1&5,26&8&$&A

=A?9-6(A

=A?= 0+-45&$ .-11(&+-%14+,&0;)&$8-4$&3&$$&(-4A

= =A?= 4 $%#,+1*52%6+&(20+)*1&-$6&(+$%-10(#&+,&0;)&$32$&'&$* ;2)%1&5,26&%4-06%/0&26& ,&60;)&$.-662+)&04&(%6-62+,&$ ;2)%1&5,26& ?

3.20$4&%+%4-11&#&()*+,&5$24&.0+%26+,-++,&-..04&(04&( ;2)%1&5,26&)&-$%6# -$(2 AAA ?=?=-6(?

?A 2

$2238-4)$20#,+26$&.2$(62$8-4-6*233%.%-13$2;+,&;2)%1&5,26& .2;5-6*&>-;%6&(+2&4+-)1%4,+,-++,24&%; -$(48&$&%440&(%6+,& 6-;&23+,&-..04&(5&$42642$%6+,&6-;&2342;&2+,&$5&$42648,2,-( .124&.266&.+%268%+,+,&-..04&( ,&$&32$&%620$.264%(&$&('%&8+,& &'%(&6.&-((0.&()*+,&5$24&.0+%26-4$&#-$(4+,&.-11(&+-%14-142(2&462+ .1%6.,%6#1*&4+-)1%4,+,-+-..04&(%62( %110-6(%62( -6#(-,-( %6+&$-.+&(8%+,-..04&(,&&1-%6.01;%6-+%2623+,&.$%;%6-1.2645%$-.* ,-+.,&()*+,&;-6(+,&.2;;26%6+&6+%26+,&*4,-$&(+2;0$(&$-'%+-

6+,&-)2'&3-.+4-6(.%$.0;4+-6.&48&3%6(+,-++,&+-+&,-4 62+.26'%6.&(04+,-++,&-./0%++-1$&.2$(&()*+,&+$%-1 20$+8-$$-6+4#$-6+

? 231&-'&+25$&3&$-6-55&-1 ,&$&32$&1&-'&+2-55&-1420#,+32$)*+,& +-+&%4(&.1%6&(

,&-551%.-+%264+-6(4(%4;%44&(-..2$(%6#1*

! "

2'&;)&$

! "

01-+% #$%&$%'%( '&)*+% #$%&$%'(%),-./0%)1 .%2