← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15134/2003allowed

Ishar Singh Walia v. State Of Pb.

2025-02-11Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri13 pages

 

        



  ! "# $%&'    "%&%(&) $%&'      

    



  !"    #

 '  *+

 ,,

, -

  *+

 ,.-,,

 $ %&' () *+(*,-. /*#  ((  $*-"- ,% ("*+.*+- .0 * (  1 + -. / #2 ,

, -

 /   4 * $** 0 # -*# * - #& /** /56 /  





! "#

$$

!



 $ 

%# &

'

(  ) !

%# &



! *$

&  +,

!!$  -

  .

/-

0 

1  0 "

 &  !!!

! #3 

0)1(020)34"%(&$ 2 *  #      #       .

+   27424874 5 94-##6 /*66+/#6+

$

  2:;  <  &  *    *+  0  /6  %&  * 

*  +#.+

/66+/#6 , $0.- *# 0 



/ 6 *0/6 - %+*6 %-4872.

99.

*  *+ = */-  *   #  

  # %6

*  * .

+ 5 9=-0*%& -##6   %+ .

 /66+/#6 .

$  -* $**  $ /0/6 -*

- **99>+!*$ $*$      =  /  *    .

+-     0*/- 

5* /- 0 + *2:?/*#6 -*

0 ./

*#  -0**##6 /66+/#6 *

*+ -% 0



/ 6 *66+/#6

-$$

*   

!

-  *

$ & !!$ 

$$



5



$



- !!$ 

$   0# "#

5* #3 @

    *  /   .

+-  *  #  +0 <  244;4872* #9

-* 5-**+ #

%&* +/66+/#6- * 6  *+-0* -*0 



/ 6 $ $66+/ *#6-%,

/*66+/#6+

$2;; <  & *.

 *+ : 0.-%/*0/6  6%*6-* / ,%/+* ,%0+#.+  > /  66+/6  6 -487= * /66 *487=  6 *6. 6@/*487= 6

5* /

  

 

          

   

    

  

 

    



 







 

  

  



 & !

67

*

&

 



'( ) *  ( +



  !

 

 

 

" 

 !

 " #   $  , 

     



  

  

" 

   - " 

 " .

 /  

 





 





 

  





%

   0  "    

,   "  

 2  3 "

  ,   &    4 4



  

  

"% &

 

 "    

"  

   .









 

 

 

"   

 

   





/  "    

   2   1 5  2 &

  &







  -

  

 

   





%

 

 3

7 ,   



( + 8 9

 " 

  

   

  

 

     

    



  

  

 

  





 

 

  

 

 

"  



  9 

 





    



     

 



  





  



 

*    !

 $

 $  & 

$$

$$ 5&

-

!!*$

8* 

 & 

$

!





8*  &  



/

! *

 





!

!

&# A 

#+ **B 9C@;49488A0 / 6%& "+ $** -0*%& -*#  *66$* .

/ 6@/*487= 6 * 0 # 0 

# 

 /.

2:;C2;;=-0*%& - 6@

-

.- .

 #.

=*/  6 -0* -66+ 0% $+

  *  

 &  < -  0  *6    %  %*  66$6-  

 6-*

%&* 66!*/*

B *6. #$#* /* . 5* /   

             

   

 



    

     

  

 

 ! "      # $    %#  

  

           

  

    

  

 &' (  )

* 

   



 $ +)*)*

     

    " 9   

* 

* 

*  5

$ !



0

95 

5

95 :

 $*

;

5$&# ,4

$$

<

# =

= 



%

&



*   

 &# 2 

*

5 $ $&  7

-

59

 

 * 5&

>!* ;

# > 

!$& $

-  *$  - !$ &  0

;

5$&

# 2 

/

* 

5 

!

%$&

  *

!* 

  ># :%

(;

 

  

 



 -

 

 .









   

  

 .









 5

 

   

 



         



 %

  %



 .



5

    5

 

   

 

    % 



 

   



   

 

  



   %(()<=)277>>=:*   )%%?>?% 7

    

  





  '

 )

  









 % 2 

 

5

   

 

 

 



 





- 



%



 

  

  

 

 

 

  

 

 

 " 

 

  

 

 

 ?>*% 3  



   

 '

 ) 

 

@ 

 

  

 

 $   A  %  

 

 







 % 1





 

 .



 2  



 

  

% 4

 



   

+

(;



    

)

3 *       

   

$   *

   

7% 4 







   2 



   %(=()<=)277 >>=:*   )%%?>?





 





     

   

$   *

   

7% 4

 



 



  

 

     %%

!

"

 !

 " #   $ / 3

7  

   

+

%%% )%%?>?

     %  

 



+ %

C

*-   6  44  /  *  487=   6

 6   5 * / #  $$ #  &

-

      



  

 

 



  

   

 

 

   

  



   

  

  % ' &

 

   5   



  -

 ,  A1A

     

 

   

 

 ,  A2A

 

 



 

 

  %

 " !!$  



5$



$$

*$ $

! 5& 5/  *

/



 &

 ? ; ;



 & ( +

 3%  * +

 3% > ) +

 3% :

@ '( +

 3% ( ' +

 3% * ( +

 3% )  +

 3%  " 

    



 

 

   

5 

  

+

  

   



%

 6* & !

= - 

!!$   $$

 $  $

 & 



!

 - &



$

$$ $ 

% !!$& 

 $$

 $  $

 & 

=

& = A B1B



- 

$5$&

!

 $

 ?

" 

 

  



 -

 

 



  



    

 

 

 

 

   

  

 



  

 

 



      



   

 



 

 

    



 -

7 *0/6 /66+/4;; <& 0 *6 44;2487:/* ##6  -0**+$*/ & *#

/*  +&0!5 " (2  %617 89 (2 ! 0.-0/6  6%*6/66+/4:;2;;

< & /#6 -*

0 $

%, 6 $ 

 8 */-  *  #   +     +%  / #  

**

 %

/66+/#6  **!*$ $*$*+&/* *+ /* #9

- *0  6&$

##6 /* # 

-0 *///+;4;44872(.-*# 6 + #  4A;C488;-*//**

. .--*/-*

 666+/#6 *$& /.+#6& - *

# *+

. 4; *.+

*#  +%& *  #     #

        *  //  *  *

    / 66+/#6 *66%

0 * * . < + / .

$D .++#6& -#.

**#  *6&##6 /#6 & *+/*+#.+

-

*  44

*+-  *  #     B 94:7C;9488:- 6 !70",:&4702:0

 17 ,101 %6 (&;0<-0* *0

#   /  .

      ;=44488:-  0 *          * #  *#  /*#  42   +  /  *  /  -  *  #   0

++   .

  6    2;44488:-  *  *

 <    / 66+/#6-* *66%

0 * * .  < +/ .

$D .+#6& -% #.

** *  6&  ##6   /    #6    &  /  *  *+

  %& #20.-*+/*# 0 #  *0/6  < 6&66+/#60 +* #  4=

*-*# ++#6 %/*"

  B

+"

 

6 +-

* * +#6  0 

# /%&=;;:488C-0* -*  +***+/*# %

 * 0/6 /2:; < & #6 * *+)0 **

, !*$ $*$*6.#/* 

5 * / C7

 

 









 



  

 @ A @





 



 

  %



  

    







   

 

  







 

%  

  









 

 , 

   

 @ A " @  @



 



 

 



 , 

5 3

 





 

  

 ,  





  

   

 

, %   

   

 

  

   



 





 ,  



%  





 

  

 

 

  

 @ A @



    

  % @  





 @ A @



 



 





  

 @ A @



 



  

 



 

 

 , 

 % C- * =

!! 

!&

$ &  /   



-$



- $

 0 

;

;< 1  0 "

=

!

 

!! 

!&

$$  

 





!$

- $



&

 

> 

 *

$  

!! 

!&   -



 $

- $

  

> 

!  

!! 

!& -$$

$

- $

- 

7 

 

 5  -$$ 

/

& 



!! 

!& 

#3

%"17 " 0!%&!1%< 0!!:4& $7 " :&061 "/17:!%("16:&$!= ":1:& 17 >":15 1:1:%&0&$:!)%&!1"0:& $1%022%>17 !0=  4@   #

6  /  #$#*    4A  /  *  #6&   44422;2@.6 -**0/6 0 # .6&*6 ;=;C4888-*

/4:;2:; < & /#6 -% /* ##6  -0**##6   # *.

+ 5 94-## $*66+/#6 * >+!*$  $*$#

6/* .6 **# * 6&##6 /* *+D.

+-/6/*66+/ #6 , $-/0* **0 / 



/ 6-*

+ ##6  *

#.

+ 5 94- ##  *66+/#6 ** >+!*$ $*$-- #/66+ 0*/- # /  *++6 

?

" !1:4:%(! 66 "6%"%(! 2 !! "!%&!@ *0 /+ 6 */- *//*# #  ) $66+/ #6 ** >+!*$ $*$-  #0*/- ** *+/+ 6/66+/#6 , $- 0 ##6 %6

66&0*6&.

99.

66+ % $ + ** >+!*$ $*$-*

*

# *+ %+/+ 6-0 *.

$ $* *-.



/ 66 0**6 ##6 /66+/#6 "1 *6

$-  !*  * %  !*  *    $*  $    (6  0

5

-*+--*

0 69# # * /  *+ 4: */-*# E 6 +-* *

+ 6& % $



/ 666 *#.

  -0* # 



 *%+. *  *+- %

 *

6 %+ $.%&** %.95 =- *  .

+  5   9=-  &  *

 6 +  *  %+

%6&,

-$$

*   

!

-  *

$ & !!$ 

$$



5



$



- !!$ 

$   0# "#

5* #3

  4A * , 

%6- 

$*/ 6 $/ *%.56. - & $$ 

%0#6 0* *  # .6& ** >+!*$  $*$0* *5

 , $B 6&-.

99.

66  *  *+  0* *  %+  /6    *    /  * +#.+

-

* -% %+.0 * *+% /

#56.  4C (.- 

  *  #   #   0  .

6&



/ 6 *6 /6 *+-* $*## $* 

66 &-% *

6 6)/



-%  + / *

#5    5 9=-*0 < * + $*# # *

< 0/6 -* %6   - %++%&* # 47 * $*  *  #   #     +  /  * 

#

/ -    %+  0  %&  *

 B -  #   +) $  

$*/ 6   $  /  * 

#  5   -       5 9=-%

 6 +) $066##6  */-* # / -0  6# # *0/6 -% **

% ## &# # *0/6 *  6



 %&*

B  48 (.-* $** # ##/ * + / +&-* $** # $-*< % $ :==:;C   4;442;4:  0    *  ,%  6  !)-

* -  *  & $    +   <

.6    *  +   /

  +&- *

* $* $

# *

 /* # # 0.-* *< +  * 2; * $**%& -* # ## */+ *# * $*9# # *0/6 -% * . 

 66+. -%



+#66&& *

#+ # %&*

B * 

#- 0*%& -*0  $*/ *##6 -% *

.

6&  / $    *  6   0  /  6 -   

< 6&  9 # #- *

< 6&/60/6  24 (.-*$ +

%&* # -* 0 $*/+ $/*487= 6 -* # 0 %6  *0/6 -#

.

+ 5 9=- 0*%& -*#  + /*

# -*0

6 $ %6# # *0/6 -% 6 

 6

*  % $**++

#

 <  6- *  6  0* *  0   /    *   +  /  *  # %6    /  * .

+

#-  # 0*-*# # + *

##6  -*

-

+##6&*# E ##6   ( -0**# E ##6  -*

#6 6& / *+

+ -*#/* # -*+ 

 */-/*6#  *#/* # -

66 +% 6%6  #*# # *%&

*

6 + **#. $#6 & 6% * +

  22 */- 6 ## ** ++

%  6.6&

$

+.*#/* # -#+#* # 6 +*

9# #  *

< 0/6 

66&*++

 0 *.

/+6/   *%& -  6 * $*/*# # 9 # # *

< 0/6 - *  $*/9 # # %+  #*%*+)/*

6 $ &

++ $/+* 6 0* *0 /* +/*/ $/ *6.##6   2=    < -  /  660 $  *  0   # -  * #  -  #/*

%,#6 -*60 /6  /*

%,#6 6&66-* .

/ * ##6  

/+66-/*  $/0/6 0* -*#  *666 %#+ # # 6

/*0/6 -*# %66*##

 #6 2@    *  #    #     %6& %  * # /+# # $ *6 0/6 - *

6 $ &    # #  * -  0*%& -  .

99.

 *  #  # -* #  - +# &+

- *



$/+*  +6/ -/ - -+

/ - *



 * # 6#  <

.6 *-0* * 0

#. $* +-0**0 6 %# # * 0/6 -*

%//*# # 

 2: *  **< 

#% 66 * +&/ 5/*66+/*#6 * *+

#%9# %&*# * #* 9 #  +&%,

$ *# /*66#6  2A  *+   6/* % -*

-66* # $##6  

- /&-

# /

*      ,

, -

  .-,,

     ).

$* 7 17 "!5 03:&4A" 0!%& $ '

 !A% 7 17 "" 5%"10<2 '

 !A%