Rita Chowdhry And ANR v. Sandeep Singh Bhatia And ORS
!
"#"$ % &
'( ) * ) +" ,"
*
%+( -$ .
# /0 ) +"1 ) %
# * 2 , /1 %
3 5" *
( ) 6 & / -$
2 + 7( " + 36 !
) * ) +" ,"
'
"#"$ "
(88 +
%9( &: * -$
;( / +
< / 1 =(+ # =((+ 5" -
) * ) +"
,"
/ 8 -
" */
/ #" //+
+ -
" "/ #" " # ( -$ * */ 33)1 %2 " 38 +1 >? &"
<<1 =(+ 1 #" " # 0( ** " "(
5" *
//( # " ( * #
+
+8
// "/ "8
"# $ * %// ( * /( +
" 8 / * $ 9 8$ 8 * @1
"
//$ (/ ( + " / + ( / + 8
"$ / 8 " (- ( " "
"$ " =(
/ + ( * $ -2
( 2" +(( 5" 8
# * " */ -( */
$
( *
"1
#
//$ 8*/
8 "
+ ?< 3:
!@ ( ) :: < 8
5 "/+$ %
" A<5 % 1 #" " # + &/ )
>?1 &"
<<1 =(+ 1 #"
2 ( $ #
(1 -( /
+ - / ::1 -
9 "
# 1 -$ 8 2 + /*" // " 5"
( * 88
"
+ (
1 -(
*/
$
"8 !
" -
" */ 8 $ 1 / / (
(88 + %9( &: #"-$ *
(88
/ ( ) ,1 @:1 @!1 @%1 !1 !1 !1 !C! <&
( ) ::% <5 %
)
" &
D(8 +"
% 1 @@! #" / " ( (88 ( ) ,1 @%1 !1 ! ! <& 5" *
- + ++ (88 + %9( &: "
" *
< * 8 1 *
**
"(+" " (/ / */$ (** -$ (8 %9( *
/ */ (8 %9( D# (-7( /$1
!1 " # *
-"
! 1 8 *
//$ :1 : 5" ) (/
"
//
8 " 8*/
//$
/
/( < - ( "
%9( & #
/ -$ *
( -/ ?<
!@ #" " # +
"
3 < - (
+(
( //$1
2 8 / %9( &
#
( " 8
3 8
DE% 1 =(+
//+ +
" 8 +8 =(+ '
//$ ) "/1 >? &"
<<1 ,/ 2 &1 ) 1 =(+ "
( ( " F (
" *
"
/ DE%
$
8 .(8 G 1 ' 0 $ & / G .= H(
) $1 #" ( + "/ I"
8 2# -(
2 8 /1 "$ *
*/ 8*/ %9( &
: 5" */ 7( " 8
(
( //$1 8 %9( & # +
-$ ;
** ) +"
7( /$1 ?< 3:
!@ # + ;
** ) +"1 #" + " +"-"
%
+
" ?<1 ;
** ) +" 0
+
$ " / * 8- / *" ( +
/ 8 8 #
?)> " 9 8
*
) * ) +" ,"
/ 8*/ ( " ?< -(
+
$ - / (
" +
?<1
+
/+
/ 8 " (/ 8 # 2 +
5" (/
"
( +(
" 8*/ %9( &
//$
/
( $ "(
" / + ( 8
" "
8
//$
/ < - ( "
+ 8 1
8 %9( & %9( & < - ( +(
9*/ " / $ /+ + %9( & #" "
!
#"
# " + 88
-$
/
+ 8 " ?-( $1 < - (
/ 8*/ %9( & (88 + %9( &:
/+ //$ -/ " * $ #(/ (/ 8 + 0( < "
" (-8 8 -$ (/
5" *$ ?< 3:
!@ + ( ) :: <5 %
2 6 &
(+"
- 7( " ( -/
?< 3:
!@ #" "
+ ;
** ) +"
" - + -$ *
# +
2 8 / ( 8
3 5" DB-/ )(*8 (
-
#" 7( " + ?< (+"
//$ " +(
" * + - (/ 8 # 2 + * / + 1 "(/ /2 8 $
+ (8
8+ + "
- 8 1 -1 # " ( (8* $ - # " / @ < * @ %9( &1 * C 8*/
*
//$ //+
@1
(/ "(
/ + ( 8
"$ 8 " (- ( " # " " *
/ / " /( -/ ** $ (8 / 1 (**/8
$ / */
" "/ -( / + "$ 2 $ +/ 8 "
/ "# *
" / + ( * $ -2 * ( 2" +(( <
" /+ 8*/ " */ #
1 -(
" */
$
5" *$
*/ 8*/ %9( 1 #" "
?8
" *( / %9( 1
**
8*/ 1 *
/ " */
#"-$
( "(
" / + ( 8 2 */
$ $ 5"(1 * */ 8*/ %9( 1
/ * @ %9( & "
2 */ D#1 "
- @ 8*/
* * I G+ ) +"1
/ " 8
2 */ 1 /
# #" " *
" 5"
// -$
/ 31 1 61
" 8*/ %9( & < * %9( &1 //+ -$
" # 8 $ */ ( $ 8
"
+ ?< 3:
!@1 + ( ) :: <5 %
( + 8 * 1 " # "
-
-$ ( 3 <* ;
+ " & 1 " )D 1 &/ )
>?1 &"
<<1 =(+
" (-
*/
/ # 8 + *( "
:
"(8- 8* (8- */ -/ 2
8* * * 5" ( 3! <* )(" .(8 1 < "
+ $- //1 ( 3 )> )(" .(8 1 $- // <* ;
+ " & 1 8 * $ #
//$ 8*/
" 8*/
- ?<
-
" 8 < * 3 %9( &1 //+
0( / -(
( 3!
" ( $
"$ *( " (8 # *
+ < * 3:
" 8*/ %9( &1
//+
( 3!1 //( #
1 (
2* " *
"( + "$ * /$ *( F
*
" 8 #" "
/ /( //+ 8 / 5"
*/
/ / ( "
" 7( /( +
/ 8*/
8 < *
" 8*/ //+
# +(/ /$ +
/ /( 8 / " */
D#1 " */
$
( <5 % < *
" 8*/
//+
" *
2 " "/ ( -$ 1 #" " # (
0( ** " "(
,
* /$ 8 8$ 8 * *
*/
/ + " 8 +8
" * * "/ " 8 5" ( * "
" / * $ 9 8$ 8 *
"(1 "$ 8
8* -/
( " "/ (
//+
88
-$ ( *1 * (
"(+ / <
3
" 8*/ //+
1 *
// "(
1 #" *
( 3!
"
/ 8
"
8 /$
2 -/$
" "/ ( -$ " 81 1 "
*
" 8 #" "
/( 8 / 5" ( 2
(-8
+ " $ D#1 + +
8 C $ "
8(
/ 8 -$ ( < * 3!
" 8*/
//+
@:1 // ( ( + "
" *
(-8
*
" 8 "#
7( D#1
( + $ (8
(
( * < 3
" 8*/ //+
:1 -
*
/$ 8 /*" // #" " #
-$ " # "$ "
#
" 8
* 1 "
8 /$ #(/ - / 8
< * + *"1 * / (* */ 8*/
%9( % %! #" " # /+ -$
( * + +
% *
*/ 8*/ %9(
1 *
3 2 $ / *
"/ *8 1 # / " 8 -$ " "#2
" "/ D#1 8 %9( & /
$ ( "
* 8 ( -$
%8
/$1 8*/ %9( & # / -$
" *
" ( * - " (
6 ! ?8 " *( /
1
**
* /$ "
"
# " 7( 1 "
" (/ # 8 -$
( * < 8
( * 8 " "// 3 9*/
8 + #
#"$1 " 8 /
8 // !
/+ *
( * 8*
0(
" / " # (//$
*/
/
+ +
$
" */ 8*/ %9( % %!1 "$ - + 8 " 8 ! < *(
3 /+ 8*/ */
8 "
2 8 / %9( & 5&1 =(+
" 8 +8 =(+ '
//$ ) "/1 >?1 &"
<<1 ,/ 2&1 ) 1 =(+ 1 ( " 8 (8 %9( &
: -$ *
3 " 88 &/ 1 =(+ # ( $
8*/ $- // 7(
" 8
( + 7( $1 ++/ # 2 * <&
/
8 / < ( 8 (
8- / *" (8- @@:!: # (
+ 8 / < ( 7( $1 (
8- / *" # ( -$ ;
** ) +"
) * ) +" ,"
7( $1 - #
//$1 ?< 3:
!@ ( ) @ <& ) :: <5 % +
&/ )
>?1 &"
<<1 =(+ ;
** ) +"
( +
1 ;
** ) +" # @ " +
$ " / * 8- / *" #" " # (
+
@
2 8 / < ( " 8
3 H1 * 8
( " 8 -( " # +
$ - / *
// %9( &!1 " (
8 "
+
%8
/$1 ;
**
) +"
/ :6: 2 + 7( " +
?< 3:
!@ / * (-8
-$ " */ " #"-$ "
+ # 8 " 8 5" *
# 8 -$
" (
1 ( * ( ** -"
" 8/$ ;
** ) +" ,"
# (
% * //
1 "
** " " ( 2 + //
?8 " *( / // %9( &! (-8
-$ " */
8 "
+ ?< 3:
!@1
" ( 8/$ <* )("
.(8 1 )< )(" .(8 <* ;
+ " & #
#
"
"
+ ?< 3:C1 #" " # +
( +
1 (
2 8 / #
" ( " -$
H1 " / / ( #" / * + (88 + %9( &:
8 " /( 1
# (
#" / " # */ ( $ * ;
** ) +"
,"
* # -9 5" / (
( " -
-
(8
//$ 8*/
;
** ) +"
,"
-
-/ " # *( -$
8*/
8 2 (
/ * $ //+
- "
" -$
*/
/
<
**
*/ 8 $ 1 * " 8/
** " # -9 I / 9 8 I "/"
%++ # /1 3
$ &(-/ 1 G+ ) +"1 #" * >
1 .
" "
= +1
/ ,)3> =(+ 1 0 )"
%/
3
/ 5/ 81 < , -1 %/
3
'
%* ) +"1 "#2 "/ #" # + + -$ ) * ) +" ,"
%
+ + "(+"
"
8 1 " + /
9 8 $ */
/ ( + " */ 8 $ < - + 1 * $
* */
#" "
- /+ -$ " 8 # " */ # "
/ 8*/
%9( & ?( "1 * %9( !
1
**
#"
3 (+"
8
( 5< % " */
( " + */$
8*/
# -$ " */ " ) * ) +" ,"
?( "1
9*/ #"$ " 2* #
+ // !
/ 8*/ %9( & ?8 " *( /
8 I G+ ) +"1
**
" 8 /+ //$ 9 8 !!1 # //+
8
$ 9 8 "
//+ ( "( + " / + ( 8 -$
5"
8 8*/
-/ " (
8 - " +"/$ -( " /$ 8*- -/ : < / +"
(8
1 (/ - /$ (
%9( & 8 /$
# " 8
"
- 8 / (/$
( # (/ 8 # 2 +
+ *
# # * "8 ( *
* / +(+ *( F
/ " *( # + ?< 3:
!@ #" " # + " 8*/
/+ -$ *
3
" 8
# **/$ 7( -$ " */ ( " D + (//$ *(
" 8*/ %9( & (+"
- 7( " ?<
!@1 (/ - /$
%9( & ( -/
?< < " / +"
( 1 "
" 8 / 8*/ %9( & - + / -$ (/ 8 # 2 +
1 *
6 ? + + 1 " *
//# 36 !
/ ) * ) +" ,"
'
"#"
$ " %9( &
(88 +
%9( &:
-$ ;( / +
<
/ 1 =(+ # =((+
// " (-7( * + +
" 7( " 7( -
1 /$ @ D#1 8 /
" -
8 "
- 8
" *(* * /
" *
/$
!
"#$%#$&'($)*+,-.&$)'/,$01 $'./ "#$%#$&&$(/&%)23$1 $'./