High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/10115/2014dismissed

Chander Pal &ANR v. State Of Haryana & ANR

2019-10-31Mr. Justice Manoj Bajaj4 pages

!! "# $ %& "& ' % (&)*# + ,-& . %,&

& /&0 1%%& "2. %,&

&3 -&%

!"#$% ! !!

&&%'

4 ,5*-6 %&* %,&3&%% &

107,-&&3 **2

1 30*-6 %&* &3 -&%

# 3%

88888 ! !!&!

, 09,%,3&%% "&-0-&1&% $:# -& "

&-0&*3&%% &,6& 09,%;0,9 "%,&309&- -&-%&- # ) # $<&=0&

)>3&-(2%,&33&%& 0%*5,&&(2%,& 33% -%&- ?

# # $ <&=0&

> - -%&- # # $ <&=0&

#>"&-(2%,&&3&%6&20-&1&% )+

--% &6-&&*,6&(&&-&-

4 ,5* &&- 0& "

%,& 3&%% & , 0(%%&-%,% &3 -&%

# 3%"&-"& 3%9% %,&3&%% &(&"

&%,&0-9%%&*4007,&%&99%,%,& 55 92&%&-" ,, 0& !

# #%@ ) -(&%& 03(2%,&0&-%

&1%% A-5 3%50&- &

)$+-%&-!

# #*0-&1&% $@*$:*$+*::*#:)*

))#*)!)*)$*$#@*$)?*! ?*# -1&% )-$ " 0(

3&%2%*+:$*

&1%% *1,,(- ,&3&%% & 95%,

%,&3& 5&&0 &-% "&% ,&25&&,9&,&&%&-0-& 1&% )#)B)$#B! ?&-5%,1&% )$ ,&%0%*6-&% C0-9&%-%&-:

# )* 6%&-%,&3&%% &-&%&&-%,&

99&6&-9%%,&&*%,&23&"&&-33&(&" &%,&--% 1& 0-9&*4007,&%5,,3&-9-C0-% , 09,%,&33% 0-&1&% )+

*3&%% &

5,&% &=&%,&"

595%&&'

> 1,40,5* 53 %&-103&%&-&%

&* &5%* 9 5%, D &3 %

-%&- !

# #*

)$+-%&-!

# #*0-&1&% $@*$:*#:)*))#*)$*$#@*$)?*! :*# "- & -&*:? %,&&E1%%&/ 019,- %,&F

(> 1,(19,*%,&%,&

*1,,(-*%% 4007,&%

6&&40*&- %(&<&&%&-> 1,,-*&-&% "G-

?*9,*%% (

12*3&%%

#%, 09,%,&33% 0-&1&% )+

*5%% 3 -0&%,&"

59- 0&%'

> &%"&- 32 " 3& &, & -%&- !

# # "2 -019,

> &%"&- 32 "33% -%&-# :

# )

> &%"&- 32 "33% -%&-#)

# #

6> &%"&- 32 " -&-%&-+ :

# !

,33% *,3&-&-%,%%,&&;0%& &6-&& 5 09,% % (&--0&- 5&-296&% %,& 0& &3&&%9,(&"

&%,&% 0%*, 5&6&*%,&&5&%,& 3 -0&- 3 6&-(&"

&%,&%

' !

) # $* %& " % 50&--%5 -&&- %,%%,&33&(& %"2-&-&- &3 & % %,& %&* &32 " 1,% 19,* &30%2 103&%&-&% "

&*1,,(- (&," "&3 -&%

5"&- %%9%,&&%,%%,&33% "%,&3&%% &"

&-9--% -&"&&&6-&&5&&-&-"%& (%9&32 "&3 -&%

3% - &3 -&%

, %,9 % - 5%, %,& "

&&% &-&%5 %3%2%,&36%& 3% 33& %,& %2* 30* &&- 0& "

&3 -&%

# 3%033 %&-%,&309&- -&-90&-%,% %,&--% &6-&&*5,,*%,&3&%% & 55,% --0&%%,& 33&%&%9&*55%,%,&7 5&-9&*-09%-*%,0*32&- - "%,&3&%% "%&,&9%,&&&- 0& "

%,&3%&*%, "-%,%%,&&9&- 0&&%

73&%,&2&# #5,&%,& 3% 5 &%&- !

# # ,& &6-&& 09,% % (& --0&-(23&%%

3&%&-% %,&- 0&%&

)$+ -%&-!

# # &,-&&-% &=&(19,*%,&%,&1 - 6&&40*&- %(&,-&"&&5%&& %2(& %&-,&&%,%%,&3 &0% 9%%,& 3%55%,-5(2 %,&1%%& + :

# !*%,0*3 &&-95&&5&5%,%,&7 5&-9&

"3&%%

-% %5 %,(&&69%,%%,&- 0&%5&& 96&% %,& 0&*5, "&-% 3 -0&%(&"

&%,&% "%&& -9%,&%%&&% "0&-0-&1&% ))

*%5 %,&0&-% --0&,-&"&&&6-&& %%,%%9&*%,&0&- 0-,6&&=3&&-,59&% --0&,&6-&& ,&&

&=3% 96& % 5,2 %,& -&"&& &6-&& 5 % --0&-

12*%,&- 0&% 09,%% (&--0&-(23&%%

3&%&-% %,&- -%,&% 0%, (&6&-%,% & "%, & - 0&%,6&&-2(&&3 -0&-&6-&&(2 3% & - 3&0 "%,&309&- -&&6&%,%%,&&(&- %,& &%33&% "%& & --%,&5 %,& 0(C&%-%- & %5%2%&"&&&(2%,

%--&-

()*'&+ , ! !!- * .

!"/0 1.*(.* 2*345* *6 7* 5 1.*(.**2()* 7* 5