High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/9251/2023allowed

Baldev Singh v. State Of Haryana And Another

2023-05-17Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj5 pages

"%&'&#(

) )

*+", 0) "!&!&#("1 2"1'3'

State of Haryana and another 0))"'4#(+"(!'

5 6 ) - -

1"'"(!

#."'/8 1 9 * : 3'/&;< +,#% !"

4"!&!&#("1) Mr. Kirpal Singh Thakur, AAG, Haryana.

1) )-) : &1#(< +,#% !"

1"'4#(+"(!

#) ) === -

7) >1 *?

('! (!

4"!&!&#( @""( $&*"+ 41 9&(.

#)B< ) ) < -"%!&#('

B 1".&'!"1"+

#*&%"

-! !&#(

&(C#1"< &'!1&%!

(%/;3* ** '3@'"A3"(!

1&'&(.

!/"1"$1#D

>(("E31"

?) A3"'!&#( 8 '

.#!

1".&'!"1"+ %#D4* &( (!1"'4#(+"(!

#) &(,"'!&. !&#( %#DD"(%"+ !/"1"#() #8","1< &(!"1,"(!&#( 1"'4"%! @*"'< $&( **9 11&,"+ '"!!*"D"(!

!/"9 1"'#*,"+ &(!"1 '"

+&'43!"< 44 1"(!

#D41#D&'"< (("E"+ (("E31"

) ( %#D41#D&'"< 4"!&!&#("1 &(,#;&(.

&(/"1"(!

4#8"1 41 9&(.

!/"'"

$3!&*"

"E"1%&'"

( !/3'< A3"'!&#( ** '3@'"A3"(!

1&'&(.

!/"1"$1#D &(!"1"'!

C3'!&%") /&'

,&+"

#1+"1 ) )

+&1"%!"+

44" 1 ** A .&'!1 !"F!1& * 1"%#1+&(.

'! !"D"(!'< %#(!"(+"+ #31!< ** A .&'!1 !"F!1& * 8 '

*'# +&1"%!"+ '"(+ 1"4#1!) 431'3 (%"

' D"< *" 1("+ -3@ &,&'&#( * 3+&%& * .&'!1 !"< : *;

'"(!

/"1 1"4#1!

) )

#31!) 7&!/ 1"4#1!

'/"

*'# (("E"+ '! !"D"(!

%#D4* &( (!1"'4#(+"(!

#) ( D"*9<

*,&1 '! !"D"(!

%%3'"+

*+", 1"%#1+"+ ) ) ) ( '! !"D"(!'< *" 1("+ -3@ &,&'&#( * 3+&%& * .&'!1 !"< : *;

%#(%*3+"+ 1"4#1!

11&,"+

8&!/#3!

(9 %#"1%&#( !/1" !

' D"

."(3&(") !

$31!/"1 D"(!&#("+ %%3'"+ 8 '

(","1 +"%* 1"+ 41#%* &D"+ #$$"(+"1)

/" 1+ *" 1("+ %#3('"* 4 1!&"'< 4"13'"+ 1"%#1+ 1"4#1!

'"(!

*" 1("+ -3@ &,&'&#( * 3+&%& * .&'!1 !"< : *; ) @ 1"

4"13' * '! !3!#19 41#,&'&#( '/#8 D ;"

#1+"1'< ("%"'' 19 .&,"

"$$"%!

(9 #1+"1 #+"

41","(!

(9 #!/"18&'"

C3'!&%")

"A3 **9 1"*", (!

%#('&+"1 !&#(< 41"'%1&@"'

41#%"+31"

%#D4#3(+&(.

(+& (

"( * #+") :""4&(.

,&"8 **"."+*9 %#DD&!!"+ $ %!

@#!/ D&% @*9 +&'43!"< 41#'"%3!&#(

$3!&*"

"E"1%&'") /"

(3D@"1 % '"'

&(%*3+&(.

1&(+"1 #!/"1'

2"1'3'

-! !"

3(C @ (#!/"1< >B?

- BBG

)-)#'/& #!/"1'

-! !"

19 ( (#!/"1 > ?

'"'

B $#**#8"+ 3**

"(%/ :3*8&(+"1 #!/"1'

2') -! !"

3(C @ (#!/"1< > ?

+" *!

41#4#'&!&#( &(,#*,"+ 41"'"(!

* 8) /"1" $!"1< & ( ,'

-! !"

3(C @ (#!/"1 > ?

'"'

$31!/"1 +" *!

&''3"

" 1*&"1 * 8 -! !"

19 ( ,'

/ C ( 6 *< -344 >?

)

B C3+.D"(!

1" +'

HB) /"

4#'&!&#( "D"1."'

@#,"

+&'%3''&#( % ( '3DD 1&'"+ !/3'

4#8"1

41#%""+&(.

%#D4* &(!

"E"1%&'"

&(/"1"(!

C31&'+&%!&#( +&'!&(%!

+&$$"1"(!

4#8"1 .&,"(

%#31!

%#D4#3(+&(.

#+") (/"1"(!

4#8"1 8&+"

4*"(&!3+"

(# '! !3!#19 *&D&! !&#( @3!

"E"1%&'"+ %%#1+ .3&+"*&("

"(.1 $!"+ 4#8"1 ,&IG >&?

C3'!&%"< >&&?

41","(!

(9 #31!) 8/ !

% '"'

4#8"1 A3 '/ 41#%""+&(.

%#D4* &(!

)) "E"1%&'"+ 8/"1"

#$$"(+"1 ,&%!&D +&'43!"

+"4"(+ $ %!'

%&1%3D'! (%"'

" %/ (# % !".#19 % ( 41"'%1&@"+) #8","1< "E"1%&'"

4#8"1< D3'!

+3"

1". 1+ .1 ,&!9 %1&D") "&(#3'

'"1&#3'

D"(! *

+"41 ,&!9 *&;"

D31+"1< 1 4"< + %#&!9< "!%) % ((#!

$&!!&(.*9 ","( !/#3./ ,&%!&D ,&%!&DJ'

$ D&*9 #$$"(+"1 +&'43!") -3%/ 1"

(#!

41&, !"

'"1&#3'

&D4 %!

'#%&"!9) -&D&* 1*9< (9 @"!8""( ,&%!&D #$$"(+"1 1"* !&#( '4"%& * '! !3!"'

*&;"

1","(!&#( #1134!&#( %!

%#DD&!!"+ 43@*&% '"1, (!'

8/&*"

8#1;&(.

% 4 %&!9< "!%G % ((#!

41#,&+"

(9 &(,#*,&(.

#$$"(%"')

% '"'

/ ,&(.

#,"18/"*D&(.*9 41"+#D&( !&(.*9 %&,&*

$* ,#31 '! (+

+&$$"1"(!

$##!&(.

4314#'"'

A3 '/&(.< 4 1!&%3* 1*9 1&'&(.

%#DD"1%& *< $&( (%& *< D"1% (!&*"< %&,&*< 4 1!("1'/&4 *&;"

!1 (' %!&#('

1&'&(.

#3!

D !1&D#(9 1"* !&(.

+#819< "!%) $ D&*9 +&'43!"'

8/"1"

81#(.

@ '&% **9 41&, !"

4"1'#( * 1"'#*,"+ "(!&1"

+&'43!") % !".#19 % '"'< A3 '/ &$ ,&"8< @"% 3'"

@"!8""( #$$"(+"1 ,&%!&D< 4#''&@&*&!9 %#(,&%!&#( 1"D#!"

@*" ;

43!

%%3'"+ .1" !

#441"''&#( 41"C3+&%"

"E!1"D"

&(C3'!&%"

% 3'"+ /&D (#!

+"'4&!"

$3** %#D4*"!"

'"!!*"D"(!

,&%!&D) #!/"1 8#1+'< D3'!

%#('&+"1 8/"!/"1 &!

3($ &1 %#(!1 19 &(!"1"'!

C3'!&%"

%#(!&(3"

41#%""+&(.

! (! D#3(!

* 8 +"'4&!"

'"!!*"D"(!

@"!8""( ,&%!&D 81#(.+#"1 8/"!/"1 C3'!&%"< &!

441#41& !"

43!

( "(+ &$ ('8"1 @#,"

A3"'!&#(>'?

$$&1D !&,"< '/ ** 8"** 8&!/&( C31&'+&%!&#( A3 '/ 41#%""+&(.)K

44*9&(.

* 8 4*"!/#1 C3+.D"(!'

#31!< &!

44 1"(!

8/"( "(!"1"+ &(!#

%#D41#D&'"< !/"( D"1"*9 ( **#8&(.

%%"4!&(.

41 9"1 4"!&!&#("1'

'"%31&(.

C3'!&%"< 41&D 1&*9 #@C"%!

*".&'* !31"

"( %!&(.

1"'3*!< $&(+'

/ (+ 'A3 1"*9 $ **'

8&!/&( D@&!

4 1 D"!"1'

C3+&%& * 41"%"+"(!'

/"(%"< #)B< ) ) < -"%!&#('

B 1".&'!"1"+

#*&%"

-! !&#(

&(C#1"< &'!1&%!

(%/;3* *#(.

%#('"A3"(!& * 1"

/"1"@9 A3 4"!&!&#("1 %#D41#D&'") ""+*"''

' 9 '/ ** 1"D &( @#3(+ !"1D'

%#(+&!&#('

'! !"D"(!'

1"%#1+"+ @"*#8)

"!&!&#( '! (+'

**#8"+)

) )

7/"!/"1 '4" ;&(.F1" '#("+

"'F# 7/"!/"1 "4#1! @*"

"'F#