High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/10130/2017allowed

Vineet Chhabra v. State Of Haryana

2018-02-20Mr. Justice Arun Palli6 pages

&'( ()*!

+ ,)(('--&.& /('')( ,(0

'&'( &1&)& / (2)3()'

(()'*

-04&&536&'(5 '-(2('')( &7' )8-,9550)7&. :(-&536&'(5 '-(;2&)&)' <<<

)'-2('')5'-(2('')(-&08-''-()() &)'2&'1.&5-(&22(-()3)8&('200&)''(8'&')

)

!3&'(3!! !!

=&'( '&') (' >5008&;5&(8)8 '-(()'-(;;) &) ()(20)-&.(0)3( (')?!

-04&&5(&)(30)( '-(2('')(50.;''-&' '-(;2&)&)'5 &7(-&)8&)3-)(2-(4@&9-&1&)85()'((3)' '4&8((;()')!> "!

>4'-'-(2('')(A;2&)1#'-08-'-( 2('')(4-'('%5 &( &22('1 &''&)3(&') ??(54'-'-(''&&;0)' (&)(';)(1 BB& -&6)8.(()((6(3.1'-(2('')()'-&'6(13&'('( 5C0&.'-'-( &8((;()' 2('-(&3&8((;()'52( 4---&6(.(()&))(D(3 &))(D0( !&)3 4'-'-(2('')5'-(&(3((3 '-(2'4&' .((D(0'(3).( ( (2'(;.(5!

>54'-&0(&)3? .'-

'-(&8((;()''&')8& 4*

E-&''-(&'3&'( '-(;2(') '-(.&8&)( '-( (D(0') &( 3((3 D(3 ) .( ( 3

(2'(;.(5 !

> ;( '-( (()( '-( 2(()' &8((;()''( ? -&' '-( ()3 2&'1 4 2&1 '-( .&&)( &;0)'

5!+

# 02(( )((4(6(@&&)3(8-'1 '-0&)3)1%' '2&'1)'-(3&1 (D(0') &( 3((3 ( B!

> -( &3 2&1;()' 4 .( ;&3( ) &36&)(5)22(((2'5()&.)8 '2&'1'(&'-( .&)9&) '()()F -6&; '((0.(&)3 '-((& '('-( '2&'14'&9( ;'-(&3.&)9 (F&-&.&3&)9 (D(0') &(3((3G -05&2('-(2('')(5 '15';(4&'-((()( '-( )'&' &)3 ()315 '-( &( 3((3 4& ' .( (D(0'(3 02) '-( ;2&)&)' &)3 - )(2-(4 2&1)8 '-( 2('')( &) &;0)'

!5+

5 ' ()&.( '-( 2('')(F- ;2&)1 ' (3((; '-( ;'8&8('-&'-&3.(()()'((3)'C0&'-(22('14'-'-(&-&.&3 &)9 ''-(&( '-(2('')('-&''-(& (&3&;0)'4& )(6( ((3'.(2&3'-;.1'-(;2&)&)'-)(2-(4&)3 (6()'0&1 '-( 3&'( (D(0') '-( &( 3((3 4& (D'()3(3 '

>54-- &')'320'(3.1(-&5(&)(30)( '-(

;2&)&)' ' 0'-('-(&( '-(2('')(5'-&'(6().1

> '-(& (&3&;0)'

5!+

4&)(6((6( ((3'.(2&3 .1'-(;2&)&)'&)3)(C0()'15'-(&(3((34&)'(D(0'(3H'-( 0'-()'()').()8;&3('-&''-08-)'&1'-(2('')(&)3'-( ;2&)&)'.'--&3(;&)(32(()'&''-( ( '-( 0.

(8'& )()(3)

>4(6(5&2('-(2('')(5'-(;2&)&)' ( ''-&' ()

> -(;2&)&)'A)'()')'-&''-( 2('')(8'-2(()(;&9(3.( ('-( 0.

(8'&) =

>5 4-((&'-(;2&)&)'4&2(()')

>'( 54'--2(()( 301;&9(3.( ('-( 0.

(8'&% -((& '(5'-(2('')('&'(3'-&6(8''4(8&)'( 0(3''-(;2&)&)'&)3-)(2-(4) "

>52('-(( -&6)8.(()&))(D(3&))(D0( >#1%4'-'-(2('') 4(2(&('&'(3'-&6(.(()86()''-(& (&3(8& )'(#.1'-(;2&)&)'&)3-)(2-(4%5.'-)!

+52( 4---&6(.(()&))(D(3&))(D0( =#1%4'-'-(2('') -((& '(5'-(&(3((3)'-&6)8.(()(D(0'(3) &60 '-(;2&)&)'&)3-)(2-(45'-(2('')(&3;''(313'-(22('1 ' )( @&D; (6 ) =

>5 63( & (8'((3 &( 3((3 #21 ))(D0( B4'-'-(2('')% -04&&5(&)(30)( '-(2('')(50.;''-&' '-(2( )3')'(D(0') '-(&(3((3) &60 '-(;2&)&)'

.()82&1;()' !5+

'()&.('-(2('')('(&'-(&) .'&)(3 ; &-&.&3 &)9 &8&)' '-( 22('1 '( 5 &)3 '-( ;2&)&)')'-&6)82&3'-(&3&;0)'5'-(&8((;()''3)0 (3 & '(

>)&)1&(5'-((.1(&6)8'-(22('10)()0;.((3 4'-'-(2('')(#'-08-;'8&8(3%'()&.(-;'(''&)1'-( 2() (-&5(&)(30)( '-(;2&)&)'5)'-('-( -&)350.;''-&' '15)'(6()&)'(4&0(3.1'-(2('')(' '-(;2&)&)' 2&1;()' '-(& (&3&;0)' !5+

&)3'-(( (54'-'-(;2&)&)'301-&6)8(;&)(32(()'.( ('-(

(8'&)

>' 0 -2&' '-()'&'5'-(2('')( -&6)83'-(22('1)C0(')';('-(2()5& &03-&.(() 2&1(302)'-(;2&)&)'&)3'-( )C0(')-&.(()('1 (8'((3&)3)(C0()'15-()'()''(3''-()')0&') '-( )() &)'2&'1.&&(&318&)'(3'-;63(&)3( '- 0'3&'(3!?

" )C0(15-4(6(5-(3()'3()1'-&') )'0;()'&6&&.(4'-'-(;2&)&)'5'-4'-&'-(-&35)

>5&'&)1';()'-((& '(5 ((3'2&1 !5+

''-(2('')(5)'(; '-(&8((;()' &7' )8- ,95 (&)(3 (20'1 36&'( ()(&5 &1&)&5))'0')50.;''-&''-((2'0)3( (') "

-&&(&31.(()0.;''(3''-(;2('()'0'.1'-()6('8&')8 &8()15&&8))8'-(2('')(&&)&0(3'-(()54'-'-(2('')( -&6)83017)(3)6('8&')&&)34-()-(4&(C0(3'5#200&)' ')'(;.&8&)'(3'-;%&)3'-(( (5'-( '&'(-&).7(')' '-(3(3&'(3!?

".()8;&3(&.0'( ')((&1')'(-(('-&'02)'-(2('')(-&6)8 &22(&(3.( ('-('&0'5-(&22(3 A(80&.&A0)3( (') ?B&(-&.(()&3;''(3')'(;.&.1'-&' 0'5 2()3)8'-( )&3('.(2&(3)'-2('')5-(&(&31.()8) )'(;.&)'-2('') (30)3( (')?+ &6)8)3((3'-(()'(;&''(5'-08-(-&-& ((302)&7038;()' '-( 02(;(0')"# $ % %& # ') @#%)!?

=) +!

"5'0.;'

'-&''-('&0') &'-03)'-&6(&3;''(3'-(2('')(')'(; .&0)3( (')?B5);12))'-&'C0(')'( ()3((3 (30)3&)'.(&0('-(2('')(403.(()''(3'.&)&)1&((6() )'-(& (&30;'&)(&-&6(.(()()0;(&'(3-(()&.6(

)('-(2(()'2(''))1)(((9)8&)'2&'1.&5 )'-)8 0'-('&'(3.1'-0')'-(;(' '-(&(54-- 403.(8)()'.1'-('&0')'-(.& (63()((3H-4(6(5 9((2)8)6(4'-(0;'&)(()0;(&'(3&.6(&)3'-( &''-&''-( 2('')(3017)(3)6('8&')& '(-(4&&3;''(3')'(;.&&)3

'-(A-&&)A-&6)8)4.(()2(()'(3''-(;2('()'0'54'-'-( 2('')(-&6)8 (3&2('')F&22&')0)3( (')?B5(( )(&)')';&9('-(3(3&'(3!?

"&.0'(5C0&'-(2(()'

2('') (30)3( (')?+5'&'0&1-&6)8.(()()3((3 ) 0'00 )(C0()'15'-(2(()'2('')&4(3&)3'-(3( 3&'(3!?

";&3(&.0'( !

( !

+ 68&8